Hi guys,
I only joined Reedsy around 4 months ago. I have been embroiled in some really crazy politics here, and I just wanted to share my opinions on some topics. First off, upvoting. Upvoting insane amounts is not good for the site, as it makes people more paranoid about their points and more willing to beg for points rather than earning them through writing. Critiques, on the other hand, are like teaching a man to fish rather than giving him a fish. Upvotes can be doled out in small amounts, and a strong sense of community should be the binding force, not a sense of protection of points. Let me make myself clear: REEDSY. IS. A. WRITING. CONTEST. Not a point contest (Zilla would totally win XD) but a contest based on good writing. It is not right to have a ton of points but very little stories and, even then, stories of questionable quality. We need to maintain the purpose of the site and stop worrying about the points. If anyone needs critiques, I'm here. Secondly, about the Marshmallows. I was one of the founders and people have come to think of them as role models and helpers of the community. However, there are other ways to do this. People argue that Marshmallows are good for people. There are other ways to make people happy, and there are certainly better ways to include someone in the community. Felicity Williams, one of my most devoted followers at the beginning of my account, did not make me happy through upvotes, but by being positive, complimenting, and giving helpful critiques. By being HELPFUL and INCLUSIVE, we can gain a better community and better collective happiness. If upvoting is your way of doing that, then you can continue. However, we are no longer an upvoting group. We are a group that makes a community and love. Lastly, the Age issue. If you are on Reedsy and are less than 18, I believe that is permitted by the rules and by my standards. However, do not expect to, even if your writing is über-awesome-amazing, win a contest. I hope you all understand that what I'm saying isn't to shut anyone down but to redirect you, to show you a better way. If you want to continue to upvote habitually, that's fine with me, I won't call you out. I'm not a cancel-culturer. However, I do implore you to see reason. Felicity Williams, an author no longer active on here, is the paragon of what I am saying. She gave me inspiration and love as a fledgling author and she complimented me. Just having her pay attention to my stories made me want to be her friend. Take her as an example. I would like to label this new idea of how to create a sense of community as inspired by Felicity Williams. Please take her example and take my and Upvoter's example. This is a consensus between me, Upvoter, and an unknown person on the leaderboard who has created the alt account of Prove me Wrong. Be a Felicity.
I love you all and wish you the best health (physical and mental) and happy writing,
Luke.
P.S. Think about what I have said
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
558 comments
HEY GoL part 6 is out how are you doing? emotionally and mentally wise??? -your caring frien :D N
Reply
Hi!! I'm doing great, Nika, I just did the Diogenes
Reply
:) That's great to hear!! and...er...whats the Diogenes??? :)
Reply
Diogenes was the founder of Cynicism in ancient Greece, and he disconnected from everything and all of his conformity and society, ceased to care what others thought, and was one with nature. XD I dunno how I know these thingsssssss
Reply
ahahah ohhhh I get it :D nice one, pulling a smart history move over a senior who just did a final on Greek history - touche touche XD
Reply
XDDDDDDDDDD
Reply
LUKE ARE YOU BACK?
Reply
I wonder... am I??
Reply
YAYAYAYAYAYAYAYAYAYYAYYA
Reply
:DDDD I won't be commenting as much thoooooooo
Reply
ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh why why
Reply
Ehhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
Reply
be a felicity. Also can we continue a book talk sometime soon?
Reply
Ofc!!
Reply
Hey, Luke! So, I am going to write a Reedsy friend cast story, and I want you to be in it. If you want to be in it as well, fill out this: Name (if you don't want it to be Luke): Power: Spirit animal: Eyes: Hair: Favorite color: Weakness: Thanks for doing this! If you don't, that's okay, too. :D Your friend, Brooke
Reply
Hey Craycray!! Name: Luke Power: Mind powers Spirit animal: Fox Eyes: Silver Hair: Brown Favorite Color: Silver Weakness: my friends
Reply
Hi! Sounds amazing! But, can you be just a bit more specific when it comes to the mind powers?
Reply
Any psychic or telekinesis!!
Reply
Sounds wonderful! :D
Reply
LUKE! YOU GET ALL SAD AND MAD AT ME FOR LEAVING, AND NOW YOU LEAVE? *cries* *dies because my body has run out of water for how much crying im doing* If you don't get back here in like thirty seconds..... I SUBMITTED MY REEDSY FRIENDS STORY. CHECK IT OUT PLZ. -Meg
Reply
I'm gonna be inactive nowwwww I just had to say byeeeee don't worry I'll be back in feb its just for personal reasons not reedsy drama
Reply
I hope everything is okayyyyyyyyyyyyyyy <3
Reply
Dude, why are you "inactive"???
Reply
Oh hiiiii siaaaaaa I just took a break bc of schoolworkkkkkk
Reply
Heyyyyyy okayyyyyy goodddd
Reply
HYELLOOOOOOO DO YOU KNOW WHY EDWARD CULLEN THINKS I'M "HARRASSING HIS GF"? Its making me legit confused and a little scared... check my new story...
Reply
Don't worry. He is just adding drama.
Reply
HIEEEE WAIT, WHAT! okiee... i going der now....
Reply
A lot of fair points made here... Thank you for this.
Reply
No prob, K!!
Reply
Hewo I think this is really meaningful Luke well done!xd
Reply
Thank youuuuuuuu hewo Cola!!
Reply
Hehe hi luke
Reply
HELLURVVVVVVVVVVVV
Reply
Do you know Chloe Ting?
Reply
Noooooo I don't
Reply
WOw. That was amazing. And eyeopening. And I see what you're saying. Thank you for writing that.
Reply
Thank you for reading it!!
Reply
Thank you for writing that :)
Reply
:D
Reply
Well said, Luke. Honestly I wouldn't have been able to put it better myself. As a writer, while I do appreciate people reading and liking my stories, the most I look out for are criticisms, as those are things I can actually use to improve my writing.
Reply
Thanks so much!! Yes, critiques are AMAZING.
Reply
This is great, Luke. It's really meaningful and I think you put into words your message really well. I think you will really inspire other Reeders. -Lily
Reply
Thank you!! I can't wait to read more of your storiessssss you're such a great authorrrrrr
Reply
Thank you so much! And also thanks for constantly liking my stories!!
Reply
You deserve it!!
Reply
😊😊😊😊
Reply
*bows to lillian*
Reply
I miss Felicity. You did a great job of writing this! Yeah, Reedsy has been kind of addictive. It went from a writing competition, and place for you to improve, grow, and learn, to a point competition. When I joined reedsy, I started off with good intentions. But then I realised the the yellow dot was the only thing I was writing for, not for my personal gain. School grades went d o w n and screen time went u p Thank you for writing this!
Reply
I KNOWWWWWW I MISS HER TOOOOOOO!!! Yeah, that's trueeeeeeeeeeee.
Reply
Yes! This is 💯 Upvotes shouldn’t matter if you’re looking to grow as a writer. I’d rather someone critique and leave no upvote (if you would like to check out my stories, please do 😀)
Reply
I totally agree. I would love to check out your stories.
Reply
Hellooooooooooo!!!
Reply
HELLOOOOOOOO
Reply
HELLOOOOOOOO
Reply
Heyyyyyyy!!! I updated my bio! (Like, a ton XD)
Reply
OOH YAY
Reply
TDR instead of Alden, and I got rid of unnecessary stuff
Reply
YASSSSSSS!!!!!
Reply
Would you like to play skribble again at 2:30? :) Megan and Riddhi are playing today.
Reply
Sure!!
Reply
Yayyy!!!
Reply
:)
Reply
Code is posted!
Reply
Where?
Reply
My bio!
Reply
I disconnected lol I’ll join next round
Reply
Okkkkkkk
Reply
XD yellow imp
Reply
Wait, Felicity isn't active anymore? Was it just the adoption thing or did something happen?
Reply
Well, she hasn't commented in a week, posted in 3 months, or changed her story of the week in 3 months.
Reply
Hmm. I feel like it's probably the adoption - something tells me she would mention it if something bigger happened. Also, I'm sorry for not reading your stories in a while - I've been very busy lately.
Reply
Yeah, prob. Oh that's totally fine, everyone has.
Reply
Luke can I join your OASIS? (it's kind of funny because oasis is a vocab word for me in social studies this week lolllll) DON'T FORGET AMONG US AT 11 -Meg
Reply
XD I won't!! Just ask Radhika
Reply
I diddddd waiting for a response :D My friend is super excited to meet u bc he's missed the last games
Reply
YAYYYYY
Reply
lolllllllllllllllllllllllll
Reply
Lollllllllllllllll so you're staying??
Reply
Hey, Luke! I will be posting an among us code at 11 am eastern time, me and my irl friend will be playing. I hope you'll join because he wants to meet you. :D He was going to join a few times before when we played but got caught up. -Meg
Reply
Ok!! I'll definitely join if I can. I'M SO HAPPY YOU'RE NOT LEAVING
Reply
Aw, Luke, this is really insightful. What's really great for me to see is people actually trying to make this a wholesome community and encouragement and critiques. I think most other online platforms get mean, fast. It's so great to see someone who is willing to keep trying to make this a place of writing growth for ALL :) :) :)
Reply
Thanks so much, Zera. That is my main goal.
Reply