Looking for updates? Subscribe to our newsletter

Steps for Putting Together a Great Anthology

Posted in: Understanding Publishing on April 12, 2019 2 Comments 💬

Known as “Spunk On A Stick,” L. Diane Wolfe is a member of the National Speakers Association. She conducts seminars on book publishing, promoting, leadership, and goal-setting, and she offers book formatting and author consultation. Wolfe is the senior editor at Dancing Lemur Press, L.L.C. and contributes to the Insecure Writer’s Support Group. For more of Wolfe's tips, check out her blog

Anthologies are great opportunities for writers, organizations, and publishers. Authors gain exposure and experience, organizations gain awareness and extra funds, and publishers make money and sample new writers. It’s a lot of work but a win for everybody.

What’s the basic process for putting one together? What do publishers and organizations, and even writers, need to know?

Here are the basic steps for an anthology:

1. Select genre, theme, word count

An anthology need to focus on one genre or it will be difficult to place the book with stores and retailers. Consider the market and the strength of the group contributing to the anthology. A theme adds a cohesiveness to the stories and allows for subgenres. There also needs to be a word count limit, both high and low, to keep the stories consistent in length.

2. Set guidelines and rules

Basic guidelines need to be set in place for story submissions. Will they be open to everyone or just members of a specific group? What type of content is or isn’t acceptable? What’s the time frame for submissions? Will the authors be compensated with either a one-time payment, royalties, or free books? Who will judge the entries? How should entries be formatted and sent? Be sure to request that writers send full contact information.

3. Announce submission opening

Start spreading the word early regarding the anthology. Announce the submission timeline and promote on social media. A graphic/ad or even the finished cover art can be used for promotions.

4. Read and check entries

Read entries as they come in to avoid a pile up if many come in at the last minute. Check for proper genre, theme, and word count. Rate each entry and take notes on what did or didn’t work.

5. Select best entries

After the submission window closes, the group and/or judges need to select and rank the best ones. Have a predetermined idea of how many will make the cut.

6. Contracts to authors

No matter who is putting together the anthology or who submitted, draw up contracts for each author. The contract needs to cover all rights, royalties, author copies, marketing, etc. Once the winning stories have been selected, send contracts to those writers. Announce the winners once all contracts are signed and the selection of authors is set in stone.

7. Cover design

The cover, if not already designed, needs to be created, keeping in mind the genre, theme, and winning stories. Always use a professional illustrator with cover experience. The book’s synopsis is crafted, and the ISBNs and release date are set at this time, too.

8. Plan marketing


The marketing plan likely began taking shape when the anthology was conceived and needs to be fine-tuned and put into action at this point. Review copies, virtual tour, advertising, graphics and ads, author appearances, target audience — all of this can be implemented while working with the authors.

10. First rounds of edits

Each story must be professionally edited and returned to the author for rewrites, often more than once or twice.

11. Book formatted


Once the stories are edited and cover art (and full wraparound, if you’re planning on printing copies) is created, the book is formatted for print and/or eBook review copies. Once it’s formatted, the price is selected, the bar code and PNC/LCCN ordered, then the title sent to printers/distributors. Be sure it’s marked “Review Copy.”

12. Review copies out

Reviewers are sent books or contacted as per submission guidelines. This is where the authors can really assist in supplying reviewers. A large list of potential reviewers should be created during the marketing planning phase.

13. More marketing

Marketing continues with social media posts — Tweets, Pinterest images, Instagram, blogging, Facebook, virtual tour stops set, live appearances set, bookstores-libraries-schools contacted, blogging, Instagram, advertising set, etc.

14. Last rounds of edits

Two months before release, the last round of edits occur, catching any typos and other areas where the stories can be tightened and polished.

15. Book finalized

A month before release, the finished book is created and sent to distributors and the printer. Copies are ordered for the author and the organization/publisher.

16. Release day and more marketing

The big day! All of the authors should play a big part in the release announcements. It doesn’t stop there though — marketing should continue for many months to come.

And that’s it. Easy? No. Simple? Yes, if you stick to the outline and plan.

It’s challenging working with so many authors, but at the same time, each person brings a fresh set of marketing ideas and a different sphere of influence — not to mention a unique set of skills and abilities. So, while it’s a lot to juggle in the production phase, the marketing part should yield some great results. A win-win for everyone!

Have any questions for L. Diane Wolfe? Leave any thoughts or feedback in the comments below!

Leave a Reply

2 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
2 Comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
C. Lee McKenzie

Dancing Lemur does a great job at putting together anthologies.

Angie Penrose

5.5 Contact the writers Email the writers and make sure the stories are still available, and that the writers still want to participate in your project. Some writers sim-sub no matter what your guidelines say, and a story you want might no longer be available. Or a writer might have changed their mind about wanting to publish with you. Or the writer might've passed away, and their heirs don't want to mess with this publishing thing. The confirmation letter is also a good place to go into detail about key contract terms you might not've included in the guidelines; that's… Read more »

Continue reading

Recommended posts from the Reedsy Blog

50 Best Writing Websites of 2019

50 Best Writing Websites of 2019

The Internet is full of writing websites and blogs to help people reach their creative goals. If you’ve always dreamt of writing your own book, but don’t know how to get there — or if …

Read article
Authors Beware: Scams and Publishing Companies to Avoid

Authors Beware: Scams and Publishing Companies to Avoid

Becoming a published author is a fantasy shared by almost all writers. And as with almost any widely-shared ambition, there are also folks out there looking to make a quick buck by exploiting those dreams …

Read article
Roundup of Writing and Publishing Resources

Roundup of Writing and Publishing Resources

Here at Reedsy, we’re fortunate that we get to work with some of the finest talent in the publishing industry — and these experts have shared their experiences and knowledge with us in the form …

Read article
BookBaby Review: Read This First (Plus Promo Codes!)

BookBaby Review: Read This First (Plus Promo Codes!)

If you’re planning to self-publish a book, you probably already know all the biggest names in the game: KDP, IngramSpark, Lulu, and of course, BookBaby. You can read about the pros and cons of each …

Read article
The Ultimate Guide to KDP: How to Succeed on Kindle Direct Publishing

The Ultimate Guide to KDP: How to Succeed on Kindle Direct Publishing

What do Andy Weir and Luke Jennings have in common? Not much — at least until self-publishing through Amazon changed their lives. Jennings, with his Booker Prize nomination, already belonged in the writerly mainstream. Weir, …

Read article
Amazon Self-Publishing Royalties and Costs: Here's What You Need to Know

Amazon Self-Publishing Royalties and Costs: Here's What You Need to Know

If you’re reading this post, you’re probably already familiar with Kindle Direct Publishing (KDP), Amazon’s self-publishing service for indie authors. But you may be somewhat less familiar with the mechanics of Amazon self-publishing royalties: how …

Read article
Looking for a professional editor?