In the year of COVID-19, what is there to be thankful for? The young college student alone in his temporary “isolation dorm” gloomily pondered that question. It was Thanksgiving, and Mark Hamels was in quarantine after testing positive with a mild case of COVID-19. Quarantine sucks, he thought.
The original plan had been for him to make the four-and-a-half-hour drive from the University of Washington in Seattle to Spokane, where his family lived, and spend a couple of days with them. That plan had been derailed when he came down with cold symptoms the week before and then got the call he was positive with the China-originated Coronavirus.
In September, Mark had returned to UW (Go Huskies!) to begin his final year of college before graduating with a bachelor’s degree in communications. Once he graduated, he was hoping to go into the field of broadcast journalism. At the moment, however, his future career was the last thing on his mind. For the first time in his life, he was alone for Thanksgiving.
For Mark, Thanksgiving had always been a family holiday and one of the highlights of the year. Usually, they traveled to their grandparent’s house in Southern California and spent the day watching football, playing touch in the street, and eating a magnificent turkey dinner around a large table filled with cousins, uncles, aunts, and a few randoms that tagged along with a family member. This year, there would be no such dinner.
How long do I microwave this thing? Mark thought as he tore open the box to his dinner: a Stouffer’s frozen roast turkey meal. He popped the tray in the microwave and pushed “start” just as his iPhone rang. In lieu of seeing each other for the holiday, the Hamels had decided to eat Thanksgiving dinner over FaceTime.
“Hey, mom and dad,” Mark said when he had answered the call.
“Hey, Mark, happy Thanksgiving!” His mom said. Her greeting was echoed by Mark’s father and his two sisters in the background.
“Happy Thanksgiving, guys.”
“How is it over there?” She asked.
“Definitely not the same,” he said, then laughed. “I can’t believe I’m eating a Stouffer’s on Thanksgiving.”
One of his sisters laughed in the background. “That’s so sad, Mark.”
After a few more minutes of chit-chat, they all sat down to eat dinner. Mark grabbed a Pepsi to drink and a few of his textbooks to prop up his phone. The local Christmas station was quietly piping in holiday jingles. This is…different, he thought.
As they ate, they talked about school, the pandemic, and the election that had happened earlier that month. The delay caused by the video call made conversation challenging at times, and the call dropped once due to bad WiFi, but they got through it; and about halfway through dinner, Mark’s dad asked them the question that had been asked around their Thanksgiving table every year for as long as any of them could remember: “name one thing you’re grateful for this year, that you weren’t grateful for last year.”
Patricia, the oldest of the two sisters, started: “Noice-cancelling headphones. I’ve certainly needed them this year.” They all laughed again.
As his family talked two-hundred miles away, Mark’s mind began to drift to one of his fondest Thanksgiving memories. He was five, and the table had been crowded as usual.
“I’m thankful for my Audible subscription,” Kate, the youngest of the three kids, said. “Sometimes, you just really need a good audiobook to get your mind off the things around you.”
That year, his grandma had accidentally used sugar instead of salt in the mashed potatoes, and no one would touch them.
“I am so very grateful for you all,” Mark’s mom said.
Instantly, the daughters protested: “you said that last year.”
When five-year-old Mark tried the sugar-mashed potatoes, he nearly gagged. “These are disgusting!” He had shouted out, much to the dismay of his parents. But that was just the beginning…
“I am thankful for FaceTime. Without it, we wouldn’t be able to talk to Mark,” Mark’s dad said. The family looked into the camera. “It’s your turn, Mark.”
Instead of answering right away, Mark said, “remember the Thanksgiving when I was five?”
“The sugar-mashed potatoes,” Patricia answered instantly.
The whole table laughed as Mark’s mom shook her head, “Don’t remind me.”
“Yeah, and remember what happened after I called them ‘disgusting’?”
They all continued laughing at the memory. Mark, the stupid five-year-old kid he was, flung a spoonful of mashed potatoes at his grandmother, who responded in kind. Of course, the uncles jumped in, and within seconds Thanksgiving dinner had turned into a war zone.
Sitting alone in his dorm, Mark picked up a spoonful of his Stouffer’s mashed potatoes, took aim, and flung it directly at the front-facing camera of his iPhone. “Food fight!” He yelled.
Then he stopped. Did I just fling mashed potatoes at my iPhone?
But his family took the bait. He watched and laughed as his family tossed turkey, ham, mashed potatoes, and dinner rolls at each other over the dining room table. Mark then took the rest of his Stouffer’s and dumped it on his iPhone. “Take that!” He said with mock anger.
In response, the rest of his family turned their artillery on their iPad, covering it with a volley of Thanksgiving food.
The whole family was bent over, crying and laughing at what they had just done. “Did we just have a food fight over FaceTime?” Kate asked through laughter. “I think we can safely say that this was the first time that has ever happened.”
Even if they couldn’t be physically together, they could still be together in spirit. They were a family, and no virus, government, or politician could ever take that away from them.
“So Mark, you never said what you were thankful for,” Mark’s mom said, laughing and beginning to clean up the colossal mess they had just created.
“I’m thankful for waterproof phone cases.” And family, Mark thought, them too.
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
Hello! Since I LOVED the last story, I was so happy you made another one! I really enjoyed this story too! I can't pick which one I liked better! Such a great job! (Plus, I loved this one so much I liked all your other stories!!) Again, have a great weekend! :)
Reply
Thanks so much for your kind words! I’ll be sure to check out a few of your stories.
Reply
Aww, thanks!
Reply
This one took me a bit. I'm gonna be honest here, the first half of this story didn't hook me at all. I couldn't quite find the conflict, and I didn't know what to expect. I'm a big believer in the power of the three Ps (promise, progress, and payoff), and that first half didn't have a promise at all. So, as a reader, I lost interest and stopped reading. But as a fellow writer, I was going to leave a comment giving you this feedback. And that's when I found Jim's comment, and he described what was my sentiment exactly. But Jim also said the story picks up after the point where I stopped reading, so I went back. And, boy, he was right!
The food fight is great! It's cute, it's warm, and it's smart. It really brings home the feeling of spending good and memorable times with your family. Awesome job there.
So, my feedback to you is this: give us some of the good stuff earlier! This one is such a short story, if it doesn't pick up after three to five paragraphs, the reader is going to lose interest.
I feel like the problem is also you are doing large amounts of telling here. A small amount of telling might be necessary, but don't overdo it. For example, you describe how usually Mark traveled to his grandparent's house and watched football. This is a good opportunity to show us that he misses it. Show us him in his room, and describe the room. Make the room ugly, uncomfortable. Make us feel bad for him. "This year, instead of spending the day with cousins and uncles and aunts in his grandparent's house watching football, Mark spent the day alone in his humid room, watching mold grow on the walls." Not the best line but now I'm the one who's thinking "quarantine sucks."
A neat trick is to use sensorial details early on. Give us a smell, or a sound, or a sensation. "The humid room." This kind of thing will pull us into the story.
So, remember, make it as interesting as you can as early as you can. Especially in a short story. The first few paragraphs, that's important real estate right there. If it wasn't for Jim's comment I wouldn't have gotten to the good part. And that was a really good part.
Keep writing! :)
Reply
Thanks for the comment. It’s so much easier writing an opening in the thriller genre where you can open up the story with a gun firing, explosion, etc. For future stories more in this vain, I’ll have to really work on the beginning. Thanks!
Reply
Yeah, the prompts of this week were really tough. I didn't write a story for any of them. I couldn't connect to the theme.
Reply
Let me know what you think. This isn't something I would normally write, so it was an interesting and fun project to tackle. Honestly, it feels kind of corny, but 🤷🏻♂️. Lmk. Thanks!
Reply
Beautiful piece.....because it features......(imaginative but) a family, and the way you created it relating with the pandemic........awesome. And yes the title is really something very interesting. Super good work👍
Would you like to read my stories? :)
Reply
I thought this was by far the hardest prompt for this weeks selection, I have been impressed by everyone who chose it. I think it terrified me because it is a story about someone watching a screen. No possibility for movement, very static. But static stories are doing very well at the moment. So I gave it a go for my latest 'man bites dog'.
I agree with Ray, this is your best story so far. I think it is because it feels more authentic. There is a truth somewhere inside it. It is not perfect but a lot of that is down to the constraints of prompt. You have to write outside of your comfort zone. I think you prefer thrillers. But you did a good job. You should take what have learnt and carry it forward. GOOD JOB
Reply
Thanks, Tom!
Reply
Hey, Antonio!
The best out of three, in my opinion. Best out of three by far.
Absolutely love this one. Heartwarming, detailed, and the way Mark's thoughts start trailing while his family members are talking about their own memories feels so accurate. Powerful memories don't wait their turn.
Great job - I'm so glad you shared it!
Reply
Thanks, Ray!
Reply
The first four paragraphs don’t quite work for me. I feel like you could have gotten us into the story right from the gate with the COVID-19 diagnosis. It seems a bit weird to be like, “So, yeah, this year and COVID sucks, right…” Exposition. “By the way, I’ve got it.” I’d probably have combined that all into a great opening line where he’s like, “The pandemic made me wonder what there would be to be thankful for at Thanksgiving, and now that I’ve got the virus, I’m at a complete loss.” Then talk about him being alone in his isolation dorm. I wouldn’t even call it a mild case, just point out that his symptoms are mild (So far he only had a slight cough and a low-grade fever…) Calling it mild before it’s over—knowing what we know about the virus—kind of lessens the looming background to it some.
The next three paragraphs following the open are just rough because they’re talking about his college plans and everything, including a typical Thanksgiving, but I think you’d be better served revealing that stuff through dialogue as you’re going forward. Like maybe:
“Hey, mom and dad,” Mark said when he had answered the call. Thanksgiving at his grandparents in warm southern California had always been a highlight to every year, but this year, he was stuck on the other end of a cold video call.
Rather than explicitly telling us he’s a journalism major, you could have him prop his phone with some of the required reading for his journalism classes.
Sooo… Here’s where things start to get really good though! When you get to him cooking dinner, that’s awesome! I love the description there, particularly in wondering how long to cook it. From there on, your story really picks up and gets super interesting!
The thing I’m really loving is that the conversation is going on sort of in the background to his thoughts as he’s remembering his five-year-old self. Taking that and turning in into his family instantly reliving that memory as well was fantastic, and the virtual food-fight was epic! This is so perfect for this ridiculous year we’ve had, and I absolutely love it! The fact that everyone on the other end of the call joined in really heightens the realism in this moment in time, that we’re all a little stir-crazy from how different our lives have been for most of 2020.
So, totally relatable, completely enjoyable story once we hit that dividing line in the fifth paragraph and things pick up reliably. In fact, I’d say aside from telling us about the COVID diagnosis, a lot of those following three paragraphs could be snuck in elsewise as suggested, or eliminated completely. You’ve got such great tempo with everything from the Stouffer’s forward that the first four paragraphs kind of drag it down a bit.
Completely ignoring that, though, this is a fantastic Thanksgiving story that has a kind of timeless quality to it in that years from now we could re-read that as anyone who went through Thanksgiving this year and be like, “Oh yeah, that was a weird year.”
Absolutely enjoyed how it built and again, what a fun twist with the food fight! That brought such a huge smile to my face!
Reply
Thanks. I’d never really written anything like this so it was a bit slow going in the beginning but I think it turned out okay.
And thanks for all of your commentary/suggestions. I really look forward to it every week.
Reply
Oh, it definitely turned out okay! Without a doubt!
Reply
Omg this story was just hilarious! I honestly loved it! It’s really heartwarming and cute. Nice job! The ending.....You nailed the ending! It was spectacular! Great job!
Reply
Thanks! I'm glad you liked it
Reply
Of course!
Reply