9 comments

Horror Mystery Funny

It’s a Saturday afternoon when Rover asks me to let him go again. Silly Rover.

“No, Rover,” I say. “I can’t let you go. The neighbours’ll complain if they see you loose.”

“Please,” he says. There’s a sheen of sweat on his brow and a hint of desperation in his voice. Well, of course there is. He’s celebrated two birthdays in this basement of mine. “Please,” he says again. “I-I won’t say anything.” His tongue darts to the corner of his mouth. His eyes glance for an exit, but there isn’t one. And even if there was, he’s chained up down here. Muzzled too. “To anyone.”

I smile. Silly old Rover. Has he forgotten? Perhaps it’s true what they say. I don’t think I’d want to remember either.

“No, Rover,” I say. “You’re not going anywhere. Not if I have anything to say about it. And—” I lean across the basement doorway “—I’m the only one here whose opinion matters.”

“Please, I’ll do anything.” His face crumples. “Just please let me go.”

My eyes go to the mattress in the corner, without a cover. Faded stains dot it, here and there. It wasn’t exactly clean when I picked it up.

My eyes dart to the window, my one weakness. I couldn’t bring myself to bricking up his only access to sunlight. And moonlight. What would happen if I cut off his access? Would it kill him? Now, I may be a lot of things, but a murder ain’t one of ‘em.

Bars on the window, though. He tried to get out, once — back when I tied him up with cable ties instead of chains. No one heard his screams. I’ve since padded it with lots of paper. It allows sunshine in but acts as a soundproofing device. Not a great one, but it’s something.

The central pillar of the cellar is sturdy. I should know, I tested it. Went at it with a full-on tackle. Damn near broke my shoulder. Rover’s gone at it. Both whilst he’s on and whilst he’s off. Not that I stick around when he’s on. But I assume he’s gone at it whilst he’s on — I mean, what else is he to do?

He did weaken it a little with the chain. Tried to wear it down with friction. He got quite far. Have to admire his sense of self-preservation. His animalistic survival instinct. Still, I reinforced it with steel afterwards. Sometimes I hear him, as he rubs his chains against it. Squeak-squeak-squeak. Like a mouse. A metal one. That keeps Rover in check.

“C’mon, man, I won’t squeal. We’ve—” he swallows, I can hear the click at the back of his throat “—we’ve built up a rapport. Yeah? I wouldn’t rat you out, man. I just wanna get out.” He glances at the window. “I just wanna be free.”

Yeah, I bet you do, Rover. I bet you do.

We’ve danced this dance a fair few times. Sometimes he’s persuasive. Sometimes he’s angry, threatening. Other times he pleads, begs. He’s cried on more than one occasion. He doesn’t scream any more. After he blew his voice box out for the fifth time he figured it was futile.

I look at the calendar on the wall. One of the many comforts I provide him. No scratching tally marks into my basement wall with his fingernails or in his blood. No, sir. Rover gets an honest-to-goodness calendar. I’ve crossed the dates off in red. Three circles around tomorrow. I know what that date signifies, and so does Rover. Not on the surface, at the top of his mind. The whatchamacallit, conscious? But I’m sure he knows on a deeper level, somewhere in his inner waters. That primal part of him.

I’ll be busy tomorrow night, as will Rover. The night will have exhausted both of us by morning. K.O. It’s a crazy time of the month for both of us. Rover burns up energy right here in the basement. And me? I’ll be patrolling the house. To be sure.

Sometimes people come by. Social services. Ambulances and paramedics. The police. I always manage to drive them away, though. I can be quite persuasive when I want to be.

The neighbours have stopped banging on the door, though. A few of them moved away. I reckon the noises scared them off. I know they drive me crazy, and I know who’s making them. I can’t imagine what it’d be like to hear those noises and not know where they’re coming from. Would be terrifying.

“I know you want me to let you go, Ro—”

“That’s not my name! My name i—”

“Shut up shut up shut up!” I put my fingers in my ears until Rover quits speaking. “I don’t wanna know your—” I swore “—name! I feed you, I water you, I keep a roof over your head, you’re Rover. You-you’re Rover!”

Rover is crying now. “I’m not your pet!”

“You’re Rover.” I nod. “You’re Rover.” I look him in the eye. “And tonight, you’re staying—” I gesture around the cellar “—right here. And every other night after that. I know what you are.” I aim my finger at him and he retreats from it as if it’s a gun. “I know what you are.”

“I’m a human being!” he says. The tears make tracks through the dirt on his cheeks.

I shake my head.

“Let me go. I-I’ll just run! I’ll run and I won’t look back! I won’t say anything, I swear. I won’t breathe a god damn word, I—”

“No. You stay here.” And with that, I leave the basement and shut the door. I can still hear him as he shouts and begs through the door. But I won’t budge. Some music will drown him out.

Of course, I know exactly why he wants me to let him go. It doesn’t take a genius to work it out. But I can’t. I can’t. I owe it to the people of this town. Of this country. Hell, I owe it to all humanity. Everyone has their lot and life, and this is mine.

So, no. I can’t let you go, Rover. Not now, not ever. But especially not today.

Because tomorrow night is a full moon.

January 23, 2021 21:30

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

9 comments

Tom .
17:37 Jan 26, 2021

I don't understand... What is rover? Nah, I'm messin'. Good take on the prompt. I love that the bad guy is the good guy. Or is he? I like to imagine that a longer take on this would be one of them just having a super over active imagination or a spell of psychosis. I would not change a thing of this though. Short and punchy. It does exactly what it says on the tin. Good Job.

Reply

13:01 Jan 28, 2021

Haha, thanks Tom! :) Yes, that's exactly what I was going for. Who is the monster? Thanks for having a read!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
K. Antonio
22:21 Jan 23, 2021

I really enjoyed this comical and yet simple take on the story. It was super easy to follow, and I was able to understand probably one third into it what Rover was (I'm not gonna give spoilers). I liked how the language was not overly complicated, yet descriptive enough that we understood exactly what had happened and what was happening. Super smooth dialogue, nice informal structure, great little hints to get the reader thinking and a wicked take on the prompt. I read it very quickly, and for a story that seemed so short, it told a lot.

Reply

13:05 Jan 26, 2021

Thanks, K! I'm glad it was so easy to read. That's a big thing that concerns me. I very much subscribe to Hemingway's "eschew obfuscation" idea. Thanks so much for having a read and leaving me a comment! :)

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Holly Fister
13:52 Jan 30, 2021

Riveting!!! It was horrifying the whole way through and I couldn’t wait to learn the truth about Rover.

Reply

13:25 Feb 01, 2021

Thanks, Holly! :) I'm really pleased you found it so engaging!

Reply

Holly Fister
14:05 Feb 01, 2021

Yeah, I loved the bitterness and attitude flowing through the narrator, and it made me think they might both be monsters, in different ways.

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Nyla N
04:06 Feb 09, 2021

Wow! I really loved this! You explained the concept really well and had descriptions but not too much. The whole time, I was really scared this guy was a complete psychopath, but the ending was nice cause you see that he's not absolutely terrible! I just learnt what magical realism is and wow, was this a great example of it!! Also, I would love if you could check out my latest story (I only started writing short stories like 3 weeks ago and I'm always looking to improve). If not, no worries! :)

Reply

Show 0 replies
Graham Kinross
01:00 Nov 23, 2021

Nice, I only just got what Rover is just before confirmation from the last line. Reminds me of a story from Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Also there was Being Human tv show, and What We Do in the Shadows. Cool story, very dark.

Reply

Show 0 replies
RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. 100% free.