Content warning: Themes of death
***
1. Tell the truth
Be gentle but honest. This is your son's first time experiencing death, his only rodeo.
He is five years old, wild-eyed and sugar-crazed and baby-toothed. A sweet boy. He doesn't complain about going to church or preschool. He picks up the toy cars in his room without being asked, lowers the seat after using the toilet. Some days you feel as though you've won the lottery.
At night, he helps you say grace. Eyes closed, hands clasped over a plate of hot dog mac and cheese, he prays for God to watch over him and you and your husband and Waffles, his favorite teddy bear, though sometimes you wonder if he means 'waffles' the food. Once, he even prayed for God to watch over your favorite music group, even though he often refers to Queen as "old people music."
If he is mature enough to have this opinion, he is mature enough to handle the truth.
2. Tell most of the truth
On the other hand, he's still the boy who cried last Easter when he caught you crouching beneath the rosebush, depositing a bright blue egg in a patch of soil.
And again, when you were both playing Chutes and Ladders and he landed on the final chute, the one that jettisoned him back to the start of the game board.
And again, last week, when he saw your husband's face plastered on a news report and proceeded to pound the TV until the screen fizzled with static because he thought his father was trapped inside.
So maybe you only need most of the truth.
Because you'd had to fib a little back then, didn't you, when you explained over cookies and milk that you were helping out the Easter bunny because one of his eggs had hatched the very moment he stepped foot on your lawn, and he had to hurry off to parent the bunny hatchling? Or when you spent six-and-a-half minutes convincing your bawling child that you'd deliberately been playing the board game backwards as a joke, and that chutes were really ladders the whole time?
Or when you finally asked him to stop hitting the television set because the problem was fixed and his father might be back any minute, and then the two of you stared at the TV, the black-and-white grains pixelating the screen, the right antenna bent like a broken wing.
3. Tell some of the truth
After you've tucked him and Waffles into bed and he asks you again where his father is, tell him your husband will be staying with God for some time. Remind your son how good of a man his father is, how skilled he is with his construction tools. Explain that he's the only one who can help Saint Peter with the noise problem they've been having up there.
It's true: You don't know for sure whether or not the Pearly Gates has a squeaky-hinge problem. But you don't not know that. You figure with the amount of new people who enter every day, there's got to be some wear and tear.
And anyway, they've got to have some decent men up there in heaven, so maybe they chose your husband instead of, say, the guy who sold you this house, the one who told you that all your dreams would come true here and you'd never have to worry about anything.
4. Lie
Your pastor would disapprove. This you know. You can picture his face—sweat-soaked, hard-mouthed, firecracker-red—as he slaps the pulpit, preaching about the Ten Commandments. Can hear the cloudburst of his words stretching across the pews, salvation falling like rainwater: "Thou shalt not bear false witness against thy neighbour." But it's your son, not a neighbour, and maybe that makes you exempt, an exception to the rule.
And anyway, who hasn't lied before?
Like the time the Campbells said they didn't have enough money for the collection plate, but you spotted them later that night at the wineshop, both of you carrying full baskets.
Or the time your pewmate Ruthie May, bless her heart, brought a vegan cake to Bible study, and you distinctly tasted butter. (You knew it was butter because you'd lied about your margarine-only diet.)
And what about those times your husband stumbled into bed after midnight and told you he was out doing some last-minute repairs for a client, and they'd invited him inside for some drinks?
Yes, if there's one thing you know by now, it's this: If you believe in something hard enough, it might stop becoming a lie.
5. Say nothing
Once, when you were a little girl, you tiptoed into the kitchen while your mother was taking a shower, threw open the freezer, and inhaled a whole six-pack of ice cream sandwiches. No real reason why. Just because you could.
When your towel-clad mother emerged from the bathroom and saw the results of your banquet—the empty Klondike box, you with one hand on your chilled stomach and one tacked to your clammy forehead—she said nothing. Took a step back, then another, until she was in the safety of her room and the door separated her from your groaning. It took fifteen minutes for you to sit up straight, half an hour before you were able to confess what you'd done, and longer than that for your mother to accept your apology.
But the thing is: That ice cream pain went away on its own. Your mother didn't have to say anything for it to vanish. All it took was some time.
Maybe that's why sometimes, when your son asks how much longer God needs your father's assistance, you say nothing. You float through the house like a poltergeist. Prepare the dinner, change the TV station, keep quiet. He's your ice cream pain, your husband. The stomachache you're waiting for time to heal.
6. Answer his questions
"Is Daddy coming back soon?" is the one you come to dread. For one thing, it's unpredictable, separated by minutes, hours, days. Sometimes, with the two of you glued together on the couch, you'll hear it four times during the span of 60 Minutes. Other times you can go a whole weekend without, thanks to the distractive power of coloring books and trips to the zoo.
For another thing, he's gotten into the habit of following this question up by reminding you that, according to your pastor, Jesus came back in just three days, so why is it taking his father so long?
You should be happy he's paying attention during the sermons at all. It's a small victory.
His other favorites include "Will he be back in time for my birthday?" and "Can we go to see him instead?" Though during dinner one night he surprises you by positioning his teddy bear in front of his face and lowering his voice to a grizzly tone and speaking for Waffles when he asks, "Will you leave me too?"
You have yet to answer a single one of his questions with yes.
7. Tell the truth (about how you feel)
Mommy is tired.
Mommy doesn't feel well.
Mommy has a headache.
Mommy is lonely.
Mommy needs five minutes of quiet time, can we please just have five minutes, please?
8. Be direct
He's carrying a basket as big as his head when you pick him up from preschool one day. It's overflowing with neon card stock—pinks, blues, reds, a rainbow collage of paper. He won't look you in the eye when you help him into his booster seat. It isn't until you've crossed the belt over his chest that you see the words on the cards, the crayon curlicue, the misspellings: "Git Wel Soone."
When you question this, he informs you that his teacher, the freckled one waving at you from the doorway now, heard the news about his father. He tells you how she made all other the kids skip nap time to write those cards while she took him to the side and told him it was okay to tell her how he really felt about losing his parent.
The door slams under the weight of your grip, a noise like a knife slicing an apple in two. You turn to do something to the teacher—what that something is you don't know, will only realize in the passion of the moment—but her back is turned, and she's already headed inside, and you're forgotten, alone.
You slide into the driver's seat. Let the engine rumble, purr. Tell your son you have a confession to make. You can only bring yourself look at him in the rearview mirror.
9. Reassure, reassure, reassure
You assure your son that none of this is his fault. Let him know that he had nothing to do with the accident or the bottles in the fridge or the fight that you and your husband had the last night either of you saw him. Let him know how much you appreciated him staying in his room, even when the vase shattered. Even when your voice grew wild with accusations. Even when your husband stormed out in his boxers and slippers, slammed his car door, sped off to who knows where.
Then, right there in the preschool parking lot, you do something you haven't done in a long time: You thank him.
For his resilience.
For being such a brave, strong boy through all this.
For that day he smacked the TV antenna and turned the screen into mush before the reporter could tell you that there'd been another woman in the car with your husband when, halfway out of town, he'd run the last redlight of his life.
10. Keep hope alive
Some days you feel as though you've lost the lottery.
The house is calm, quieter without your husband's specter haunting it.
Your son doesn't speak as much after the funeral. Maybe he doesn't trust you with answers anymore. Most days he just sits on the carpet with Waffles and glides his toy cars along the floor without making a sound. That is, except for when they hit the coffee table and flip on their side, a noise like a bomb detonating.
Sometimes, when that happens, you swoop down, a light in the darkness, and retrieve the car. Feel its weight shift in your hand. You gently guide it and its imaginary passengers to safety. Set it down somewhere and let it go where it's heading until it reaches its final destination.
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
185 comments
Congratulations Zack! This is such a remarkable story. I loved "Reassure, reassure, reassure" keeps hitting me. A well-deserved win.
Reply
Thank you, Kevin! Big praise coming from someone with your talent.
Reply
I loved this story. It made me laugh, even as it made me want to cry.
Reply
Thanks, Brenda! This was originally going to be a comedy piece, but it morphed halfway through. Glad the leftover humor worked for you.
Reply
Excellent read, Zack! Loved the format and the underbelly of dysfunction with the husband’s behavior.
Reply
Thank you very much, Emily!
Reply
Congratulations on the win, Zack!!
Reply
Thank you, Jerusalem!
Reply
Amazing piece of writing and a thoroughly deserved win, congratulations!!
Reply
Thank you, Mel, and congratulations on your shortlist as well!
Reply
Breathlessly good, Zack. This line especially resonates (and would make an amazing tattoo) "Set it down somewhere and let it go where it's heading until it reaches its final destination." CONGRATS - WELL DESERVED
Reply
Thank you, Deidra! If someone fit that whole quote on a tattoo, I'd be both honored and impressed. 😂 Appreciate the kindness!
Reply
Well earned! Congrats! :-)
Reply
Thank you, Will! Much appreciated.
Reply
Wooo hooo! Zack, Congratulations!!! Your mother should be so proud of you. This places you officially forever in Reedsy hall of fame. SO, SO happy for you! Only onwards and upwards. God bless!
Reply
Thanks as always for your never-ending kindness, Suma! Definitely planning on forwarding this one to my mom. Hopefully we go onwards and upwards and not downwards. 😂 Thanks again!
Reply
Hell of a title and it lived up to it. The emotional layers in this were very profound. The baggage left behind is really well done. “If you believe in something hard enough, it might stop becoming a lie,” should be written on the bottom of pro war propaganda next to an asterisk.
Reply
Thank you, Graham! That propaganda line would make for an interesting story itself. Might have to try that out some time.
Reply
You should. And then you should send me the link so I can read it.
Reply
Hey Zack, sorry I'm late to the party this week. At this point it feels difficult to add something new to the discourse your stories inevitably produce lol. Suffice to say the POV and list format are both effective and the story has an emotional punch. I love the subtlety of the narrator, who is flawed and uncertain, and the reveal at the end feels earned. You have this way of making your characters and therefore your stories brim with life - not just with purple prose (though you can do that too) - but also those little details about peop...
Reply
Late or early, your feedback is always helpful and appreciated, so thanks! Super experimental week here, so it's equally nice to know that the format/characterizations worked and that the Christian theming could've been weaved a little more throughout. Gives me a better understanding of how to use this tag in the future. Thanks again and good luck to you too!
Reply
Glad I could join you on the podium last week, Zack! Congrats on the win. :)
Reply
Appreciate it. Gotta be honest, though: I was definitely rooting for you, mate. Vastly preferred your story to my own. Who knows how the judging works though, right? Congrats on the shortlist, and keep writing! A new win is headed your way any day now.
Reply
Aw, you’re too kind. Your support means a lot to me!
Reply
The the structure of this! It brought out So much emotion!
Reply
Thank you! The structure was a lot of fun to try out, so I'm glad to hear that.
Reply
Zack! I really admire this piece for its strong voice and its emotional complexity. I can't add much more to what everybody else has said, but I can confirm that, yes, this is riveting, heartbreaking, thought-provoking, and so on. :-) Well done!
Reply
Thanks, Will! Definitely outside of my comfort zone a bit on this one, but I'm glad the voice came through.
Reply
Sorry no other comment: it's too real.
Reply
"Too real" is about the best comment you can receive on a fictional story, so thanks!
Reply
Where to start… First of all, I agree with Suma’s comment—that you must have a mother’s alter ego in you. This range of the mom’s emotional responses to tragedy so perfectly captures the feeling most parents probably have—that we don’t always have the right answers and often feel unqualified to handle difficult situations. The boy feels very real. He has a sense that something is wrong, but doesn’t understand death enough to even toy with the idea that that is what could have happened to his dad. I love how you described the scenes depict...
Reply
Thank you, Aeris! Was surprised (and more than a little sad) not to see a story from you this week, but I know all too well how college goes, so good on you for having your priorities together. (Now sprinkle some of those organizational skills over here.) Glad that the emotions of the characters translated to the page - such a difficult thing to intuit. Also, that Peeps comment is BEYOND relatable. Used to love them so much as a kid (even though I felt terrible about biting their heads off), but now as an adult, they are absolutely disgusti...
Reply
Aw well, thanks for noticing! I had SO much reading last week, then both kiddos got sick on Friday, so no chance to even put something together last minute. But getting started early this week 👍🏻 I will come join a strike in front of peep factories with you... I feel very strongly about this lol.. I would like to try it sometime! It’s very easy for me to write “to” someone, but it’s getting rid of that “i, me” that feels like a difficult hurdle in 2nd person. I’m just gonna keep on taking notes from successful stories like this one ;) Best...
Reply
Freaking congrats!! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Reply
Thank you, thank you! 👏🏻 (Side note: I'm selfishly waiting on a story from you tonight. No pressure or anything, right? 😉 Just kidding - happy writing, and looking forward to your next story, whenever you find the time.)
Reply
I do have one for this week, it just needs work— Every time I read back through it I am finding typos or choppy phrases, etc. so I hope to finish it without waiting until the very last possible second today 😁
Reply
Zack, as soon as I saw the title I knew I was going to love this! You are so good at getting down those complex emotions (are my comments really repetitive?). Also I really liked that you chose a 2nd person pov, I have come to actually enjoy it a lot since reading more on Reedsy. I think it works especially well in the short story format. The mothers struggle with what to tell her child is so well done. It was a great choice to make him 5 years old too, he is really at that age where he is old enough to question and have some grasp of diff...
Reply
Thanks as always, Kelsey! 2nd person POV is definitely a newfound favorite of mine, and I too have found that a shorter format can feel like the 'right amount' for it (I don't know if I could read a whole novel of it). It's funny, because the child was originally 7 years old in the first draft, but 5 just seemed like the right choice for the exact reasons you mentioned. That age really feels like the precipice of innocence, in terms of not quite knowing what death is, or how to process it. Wasn't sure if the trickling of husband-related in...
Reply
Congrats on the win Zack!!
Reply
Thanks, Kelsey!
Reply
I really enjoyed the ebb and flow of maternal justifications and tactics in this story. by the end, indecisiveness has become its own decision. Though how does one convey such a complex situation to a small child? I feel like the last paragraph captures the mother's ambivalence perfectly: for only "sometimes" does she intervene to save the toy car and its imaginary passengers.
Reply
Thanks, L.M. That's a great take on things: "Indecisiveness has become its own decision." I love it. And you caught exactly what the ending was going for, so thank you!
Reply
Zack, read this earlier, commenting now. I seriously believe you have an alter ego with a mother's soul lurking inside you. This must be the fourth one (I have read) from you that explores the pleasures and pains of being a mother. This piece clearly communicates the different stages of grief and how well or poorly the mother is able to convey/ comfort her son about a man they both loved and lost(for her, he was already lost before the accident). As per usual, the voice and the nuances of the complex relationships are on point. My fave lines...
Reply
And on a side note it's impressive how you are absolutely trumping a new genre every time!
Reply
Thank you as always, Suma! I have a lot of sympathy for my own mother (it couldn't have been easy raising my brother and me, that much I know), so I just like to imagine some of the myriad what-if scenarios and how she might've handled them. An alter ego is a fun thought, though! Nice to know which lines stood out for you. Both of those were ones I had to rework a few times, so I'm glad to see them.
Reply
I LOVE THIS. Emotional and tough, a mother fighting the storm of loss, anger, and trying to keep it from her child. Good work. So very true to the toss of emotions we go through when we're coping with death.
Reply
Thanks, Laurie! You nailed it - it seems like mothers especially have the burden of needing to be strong both for themselves and their children. Glad to hear the emotions translated to the page!
Reply
Hi Zack! I loved this story from you for a few reasons. I absolutely fell in love with the mother character and I enjoyed how most of this story was filled with debate. I also admired how this story had a “ghost side character” who was the father and really well fleshed out. I think it’d be really cool to read a story from the boy’s perspective the final night his dad was around. Nice job!
Reply
Thank you, Amanda! That's an interesting thought, writing this from the boy's perspective. Definitely gonna have to give that a try sometime and see what happens. Thanks again!
Reply
This is really sad, but I didn't cry. Its probably within the fact that I'm at Disney World right now, so maybe the "happiest place on earth" has gotten to me lol :) Anyways, I loved the fact that you named the teddy bear "Waffles". That was probably my favorite part :) *Sorry I edited this, I just kinda forgot to mention the waffles thing lol*
Reply
Thanks! Hope you enjoy your Disney World vacation!
Reply