Content warning: Themes of death
***
1. Tell the truth
Be gentle but honest. This is your son's first time experiencing death, his only rodeo.
He is five years old, wild-eyed and sugar-crazed and baby-toothed. A sweet boy. He doesn't complain about going to church or preschool. He picks up the toy cars in his room without being asked, lowers the seat after using the toilet. Some days you feel as though you've won the lottery.
At night, he helps you say grace. Eyes closed, hands clasped over a plate of hot dog mac and cheese, he prays for God to watch over him and you and your husband and Waffles, his favorite teddy bear, though sometimes you wonder if he means 'waffles' the food. Once, he even prayed for God to watch over your favorite music group, even though he often refers to Queen as "old people music."
If he is mature enough to have this opinion, he is mature enough to handle the truth.
2. Tell most of the truth
On the other hand, he's still the boy who cried last Easter when he caught you crouching beneath the rosebush, depositing a bright blue egg in a patch of soil.
And again, when you were both playing Chutes and Ladders and he landed on the final chute, the one that jettisoned him back to the start of the game board.
And again, last week, when he saw your husband's face plastered on a news report and proceeded to pound the TV until the screen fizzled with static because he thought his father was trapped inside.
So maybe you only need most of the truth.
Because you'd had to fib a little back then, didn't you, when you explained over cookies and milk that you were helping out the Easter bunny because one of his eggs had hatched the very moment he stepped foot on your lawn, and he had to hurry off to parent the bunny hatchling? Or when you spent six-and-a-half minutes convincing your bawling child that you'd deliberately been playing the board game backwards as a joke, and that chutes were really ladders the whole time?
Or when you finally asked him to stop hitting the television set because the problem was fixed and his father might be back any minute, and then the two of you stared at the TV, the black-and-white grains pixelating the screen, the right antenna bent like a broken wing.
3. Tell some of the truth
After you've tucked him and Waffles into bed and he asks you again where his father is, tell him your husband will be staying with God for some time. Remind your son how good of a man his father is, how skilled he is with his construction tools. Explain that he's the only one who can help Saint Peter with the noise problem they've been having up there.
It's true: You don't know for sure whether or not the Pearly Gates has a squeaky-hinge problem. But you don't not know that. You figure with the amount of new people who enter every day, there's got to be some wear and tear.
And anyway, they've got to have some decent men up there in heaven, so maybe they chose your husband instead of, say, the guy who sold you this house, the one who told you that all your dreams would come true here and you'd never have to worry about anything.
4. Lie
Your pastor would disapprove. This you know. You can picture his face—sweat-soaked, hard-mouthed, firecracker-red—as he slaps the pulpit, preaching about the Ten Commandments. Can hear the cloudburst of his words stretching across the pews, salvation falling like rainwater: "Thou shalt not bear false witness against thy neighbour." But it's your son, not a neighbour, and maybe that makes you exempt, an exception to the rule.
And anyway, who hasn't lied before?
Like the time the Campbells said they didn't have enough money for the collection plate, but you spotted them later that night at the wineshop, both of you carrying full baskets.
Or the time your pewmate Ruthie May, bless her heart, brought a vegan cake to Bible study, and you distinctly tasted butter. (You knew it was butter because you'd lied about your margarine-only diet.)
And what about those times your husband stumbled into bed after midnight and told you he was out doing some last-minute repairs for a client, and they'd invited him inside for some drinks?
Yes, if there's one thing you know by now, it's this: If you believe in something hard enough, it might stop becoming a lie.
5. Say nothing
Once, when you were a little girl, you tiptoed into the kitchen while your mother was taking a shower, threw open the freezer, and inhaled a whole six-pack of ice cream sandwiches. No real reason why. Just because you could.
When your towel-clad mother emerged from the bathroom and saw the results of your banquet—the empty Klondike box, you with one hand on your chilled stomach and one tacked to your clammy forehead—she said nothing. Took a step back, then another, until she was in the safety of her room and the door separated her from your groaning. It took fifteen minutes for you to sit up straight, half an hour before you were able to confess what you'd done, and longer than that for your mother to accept your apology.
But the thing is: That ice cream pain went away on its own. Your mother didn't have to say anything for it to vanish. All it took was some time.
Maybe that's why sometimes, when your son asks how much longer God needs your father's assistance, you say nothing. You float through the house like a poltergeist. Prepare the dinner, change the TV station, keep quiet. He's your ice cream pain, your husband. The stomachache you're waiting for time to heal.
6. Answer his questions
"Is Daddy coming back soon?" is the one you come to dread. For one thing, it's unpredictable, separated by minutes, hours, days. Sometimes, with the two of you glued together on the couch, you'll hear it four times during the span of 60 Minutes. Other times you can go a whole weekend without, thanks to the distractive power of coloring books and trips to the zoo.
For another thing, he's gotten into the habit of following this question up by reminding you that, according to your pastor, Jesus came back in just three days, so why is it taking his father so long?
You should be happy he's paying attention during the sermons at all. It's a small victory.
His other favorites include "Will he be back in time for my birthday?" and "Can we go to see him instead?" Though during dinner one night he surprises you by positioning his teddy bear in front of his face and lowering his voice to a grizzly tone and speaking for Waffles when he asks, "Will you leave me too?"
You have yet to answer a single one of his questions with yes.
7. Tell the truth (about how you feel)
Mommy is tired.
Mommy doesn't feel well.
Mommy has a headache.
Mommy is lonely.
Mommy needs five minutes of quiet time, can we please just have five minutes, please?
8. Be direct
He's carrying a basket as big as his head when you pick him up from preschool one day. It's overflowing with neon card stock—pinks, blues, reds, a rainbow collage of paper. He won't look you in the eye when you help him into his booster seat. It isn't until you've crossed the belt over his chest that you see the words on the cards, the crayon curlicue, the misspellings: "Git Wel Soone."
When you question this, he informs you that his teacher, the freckled one waving at you from the doorway now, heard the news about his father. He tells you how she made all other the kids skip nap time to write those cards while she took him to the side and told him it was okay to tell her how he really felt about losing his parent.
The door slams under the weight of your grip, a noise like a knife slicing an apple in two. You turn to do something to the teacher—what that something is you don't know, will only realize in the passion of the moment—but her back is turned, and she's already headed inside, and you're forgotten, alone.
You slide into the driver's seat. Let the engine rumble, purr. Tell your son you have a confession to make. You can only bring yourself look at him in the rearview mirror.
9. Reassure, reassure, reassure
You assure your son that none of this is his fault. Let him know that he had nothing to do with the accident or the bottles in the fridge or the fight that you and your husband had the last night either of you saw him. Let him know how much you appreciated him staying in his room, even when the vase shattered. Even when your voice grew wild with accusations. Even when your husband stormed out in his boxers and slippers, slammed his car door, sped off to who knows where.
Then, right there in the preschool parking lot, you do something you haven't done in a long time: You thank him.
For his resilience.
For being such a brave, strong boy through all this.
For that day he smacked the TV antenna and turned the screen into mush before the reporter could tell you that there'd been another woman in the car with your husband when, halfway out of town, he'd run the last redlight of his life.
10. Keep hope alive
Some days you feel as though you've lost the lottery.
The house is calm, quieter without your husband's specter haunting it.
Your son doesn't speak as much after the funeral. Maybe he doesn't trust you with answers anymore. Most days he just sits on the carpet with Waffles and glides his toy cars along the floor without making a sound. That is, except for when they hit the coffee table and flip on their side, a noise like a bomb detonating.
Sometimes, when that happens, you swoop down, a light in the darkness, and retrieve the car. Feel its weight shift in your hand. You gently guide it and its imaginary passengers to safety. Set it down somewhere and let it go where it's heading until it reaches its final destination.
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
I think this 'sad mother' genre might just be my favourite kind of story from you.
It's amazing how good you are at writing from a mother's perspective and capturing the emotion really well when you're very much not a mother (I am very much not a mother either so my opinion probably doesn't count for much, but I'm sure mothers will agree).
This was really good, as always, and really sad. I sympathized a lot with both the mother and the son. And I liked the complication surrounding the husband's death, I imagine that the fact that he wasn't really a good husband makes her feelings about the loss complicated, especially as they'd had a fight the last time they spoke and he was with another woman when he died.
I also couldn't help but feel sorry for both mother and son in advance. For how strained their relationship might become when the boy gets older.
The format of the story is interesting. I really liked the gradual progression (or regression?) from 1-5 from “tell the truth” to “say nothing”.
From here, “His other favorites include...” to the end of no. 6 stabbed me in the heart, makes me want to give the boy a hug. No. 7 makes me want to give the mother a hug.
The story is very well written, and there were a lot of lines that I loved, too many to mention them all but here are some:
“Explain that he's the only one who can help Saint Peter with the noise problem they've been having up there.” and the two paragraphs following it.
“Can hear the cloudburst of his words stretching across the pews, salvation falling like rainwater” LOVED this one.
“For that day he smacked the TV antenna and turned the screen into mush before the reporter could tell you that there'd been another woman in the car with your husband...”
“Some days you feel as though you've lost the lottery.” I like the flip of the first “Some days you feel as though you've won the lottery.” It really captures how much things have changed from the beginning of the story to the ending.
It's really good to see a story from you this week, and a stellar one too. Well done and good luck with the contest!
Reply
Thanks as always, Naomi! And yeah, motherhood is one of those things that I'm never going to experience myself, so I think that's why I keep coming back to that genre. Endlessly fascinating for me to try to imagine and empathize through characters.
The format was definitely an experiment here. It was an interesting challenge, taking a linear-ish story and breaking it up into different sections and still trying to have everything make sense by the end of it. (You could totally tell that I wrote 1-5 back-to-back, too.) Not sure if I'd write a story like this again, but it's probably worth a try.
Thanks not just for listing your favorite lines, but for mentioning my favorite too (the cloudburst/salvation one). Still thinking about your latest story - that twist was so good. Hope to see another from you soon!
Reply
Yess, new story! I see you're growing the list of your 2nd person ones aaand you crossed off another genre tag! (One I suspect would burn me if I touched it 😂)
Firstly, I like nuances. From the beginning, I had this feeling that personal loss really took a backseat, which, though of course "child comes first" didn't click with me until you revealed how bad this marriage was with a cheating and drunk husband through little details sprinkled in. It's not as clean cut as losing the perfect partner, it's messy and I appreciate the mess - bring on the drama! 😃
Loved the snarky line of "If he is mature enough to have this opinion, he is mature enough to handle the truth." LOL.
And OF COURSE my favourite sentence was: "Or when you finally asked him to stop hitting the television set because the problem was fixed and his father might be back any minute, and then the two of you stared at the TV, the black-and-white grains pixelating the screen, the right antenna bent like a broken wing." - love love love the "broken wing" simile.
Best of luck for this week - I'm happy to see a new story from you here and I also hope, if you picked other contests / things to submit to that's going well for you too.
Side note, there is this lit mag called "Defenestration" that you can submit funny short stories to, even reprints - in case you're interested, as you have a few?
PS: When I read "Waffles" my first thought was, you found the perfect name for their family dog. I wasn't quite right but still love the name. And waffles the food is something even I would pray for. 💯
Reply
You know you have a problem when you have more 2nd person stories than 3rd in your collection. 😂 There's something about that "You" perspective that just makes for a good writing challenge, I've found. (Side note: I thought Sci-Fi was the hardest genre to write, but we have a new winner, and its name is Christian, LOL. Very glad to get that one done and over with, because now we're down to the final five.)
I'm glad any nuances at all came through because this didn't go where I thought it would when I wrote it. This was actually supposed to be a funny piece, but then I kept writing and it developed a mind of its own. 😬 #pantser #hotmessexpress
The broken wing bit is one of those lines I felt unnecessarily proud of writing, LOL, so thank you for marking it as your favorite. No expectations for real this time; just ticking off a genre and a bucket list item with the top-10 format. Next week's prompts seem more my forte anyway.
Side note: Thank you for the heads up on the magazine! I hadn't heard of that one, and even better that they accept reprints (so few, I'm finding out too late, actually do that 😅). Definitely checking that out.
Double side note: You absolutely should send me snippets of your novel every week, just so to hold yourself accountable! I always feel bad whenever I post a story knowing that you're giving up your time to read it and I'm not reciprocating anything. Plus, reading your work always motivates me to keep going, so it's a win-win!
Reply
Tell me about it - remember when all the prompts were very godly, I came up with Selaphiel purely to avoid it😂
I cannot believe you're down to the last five..! That's incredible. (Come on, write a western with me! 🤠)
You did leave a funny line in the story that made laugh, but I wouldn't have guessed it was the original intention behind the whole piece - though the format did remind me of "Love and Chocolate in Five Easy Steps"! Maybe more just because of the title though.
Very few magazines anthologies accept reprints, frustrating, isn't it? It annoys me for sure! Not like I'm on top of my submissions by any means.
Aand on the extra side note, I cannot believe you would say it's one sided because you're not doing enough?! I'm here reading your stories (which I genuinely enjoy) but how many times did you help me edit mine? If anything I don't feel like I'm pulling my weight here! 😂 Anyhow... It's a very tempting offer and I might selfishly accept it because I couldn't wish for a better critique partner! 👀 If I can make the effort to actually write it from the beginning to the end so it makes some sense to you - at the moment it's more like "maybe I should write it backwards, like, last chapter first and so on 😱 This manuscript is the biggest mess I've gotten myself into 🤣 But if it'd motivate you, please be my guest - the dinner's uncooked but made with love LOL
I'm definitely motivated by reading your stories - makes me want to get back into the short stories ASAP - so hopefully that will push me to finish this project from hell! 🙏
Reply
😂 Imagine coming up with the basis of your short story collection solely because you didn't want to write Christian-based fiction. That's a power move right there, LOL.
Yeah, I can already tell the Western's going to be the last one. So few prompts work for that genre, and my cowboy/horse knowledge is VERY poor, so I'd be more than happy to co-write one with you (AFTER you finish your novel writing 😉). In the meantime, I've still got to do Bedtime (what even is this - I still don't know), Middle School (meh), and Horror/Thriller (you'd think I would know how to write one after reading all your spooky stories, but I don't and am banking on some good Halloween prompts for this).
😅 This was SUPPOSED to end up looking more like the Christian counterpart to "Wish You Were Here," but I'll definitely take a "Love and Chocolate" mention. I'm here for it.
And here I thought I was the only one who wrote their stories backwards! It's SO much easier to do the plotting and foreshadowing when you already have the ending written out. It's like, "Well, if I have [object/plot element/character] in the last chapter, I'm responsible for introducing them before then." Definitely keeps you accountable.
Anyway, the offer's always open if you ever want an extra set of eyes on anything! 😂 I can't guarantee I'll understand everything if it's from a later chapter, but if you give me some context, I'm good to go. It's the least I can do.
Reply
Ohh I thought some of the new prompts would be great for western OR thriller/horror - I wonder if you will get any similar ideas to what I'm thinking 👀 (and don't tell me you can't, your sci-fi was scary AF!) Also, I'm always happy to help you out of you ever wanted me to - you know where to find me.
And thanks for the extra motivation with that "AFTER" I need more of this sort of thing - what's this if not the writer equivalent of eat your vegetables first?! 😂
I completely agree about foreshadowing and setup being easier plotting backwards - unfortunately it is not what I naturally do 😅 But, I have also ran into the problem of not being able to decide which part I should start with, what should be the order of scenes - more liberal vs more flashback heavy - and though I got them somewhat organised now, I need to do a detailed plot outline with chapter summaries so I don't waste time rewriting things into the wrong place and stuff that's irrelevant (like I've done so far lol) so I figured if I do this backwards and just double check it once I got to the beginning, it should then be safe to jump back into writing... But this plotting is painful for sure! Hopefully I can get back on track soon but to be honest I'm already behind schedule! 😬
Hope you'll have fun with the new prompts!
Reply
"No expectations for real this time"...OMG! Congrats. Congrats, congrats, congrats! You know I'm cheering for you to break that record, so I'm very happy for you --- have fun celebrating you total legend!! Xx
Reply
💖 Thank you, thank you, my dear! Quite an unexpected way to start my morning. Hoping I get to break the record too.
Heads-up: It's officially an off week now (not like I had anything prepped anyway, LOL), so you won't be seeing anything new from me when you wake up tomorrow. In the meantime, hope your writing's going well, and as always, don't hesitate to ask if you need anything from me.
Reply
Hey! I see there are many comments here, and you deserve all of them, each praise! I'm a beginner and I think this is a wonderful work! Congrats for the wins, even if they are not recent! :)
Reply
hello!
this piece really touched me. your writing is truly amazing! i was wondering if i could use this piece for a prose performance at a speech & debate competition. you will be credited, of course!!
Reply
Wow. Twists and turns. Wasn't sure where it was heading at times!
I enjoyed the story, Zack.
Reply
I've been reading ur stories and i cant ever live the same. LOVE UR STORIES KEEP UP THE WORK
Reply
"there'd been another woman in the car with your husband" ouch! I can't imagine being her! Congrats on the win!
Reply
Hey Zack,
Its been awhile since you’ve been on Reedsy and I just wanted to see if you’re ok :)
Reply
That...no words. It is a good story, and it did wonders to my happiness. Thanks!!!
Reply
crying... but such a sweet story, amazing.
Reply
This story was very well written and kept me hooked until the end. I liked the format you used and the story flowed nicely.
Reply
Like life itself, coping with death - or divorce or any heart-breaking loss - is a journey. You demonstrated that so well.
Reply
Oh my heart...
This story *is* power. It hits to the bone. I can tell it won't let go of me soon.
Well done, Zach. Well done, and never stop writing.
Reply
This was heartbreaking! Why would you do this to me???
Reply
i feel like it needed more drama , but it was very outstanding
Reply
This was lovely. A great emotional story, heartbreaking. Congrats on the win.
Reply
shut up Loserr
Reply
Great piece, Zack. I'm reading this over my morning coffee and my chest has gone all tight - need to find a fun story now or I might cry! Love the way you use the 2nd person and all the details of their life together - the pastor, the school teacher, the toy truck/car, the television breaking - that appear random but of course, nothing is, everything is deliberate.
Favourite line: "If you believe in something hard enough, it might stop becoming a lie." - ouf
Catching up on some Reedsy reading this week, looking forward to more of your stuff :)
Reply
Zack, I loved this sad story and congratulations on the win. I liked the 10 steps of getting the different emotions across. Reminded me of the postcard approach in "Wish You Were Here." You are a creative writer and I enjoy your stories. I am hoping to use one of yours for another of my literary shorts group discussions in the near future. Best of everything. Cal
Reply
I can definitely see why you won-- this story is impressive. I've read some amazing things here, but this ranks top then. Never stop writing-- this is impressive.
Reply