Submitted to: Contest #56

My Best Friend Wants to Die

Written in response to: "Write a story about two people meeting during unusual circumstances and becoming fast friends."

Adventure Creative Nonfiction Drama

My best friend wants to die. It is very important as I tell you my story that you know two things: the first is the story is absolutely true and the second is I have no idea what to do. I guess it’s also important you know there are so many things that could have happened differently and if they had I would not be able to tell this story.


Young men, oftentimes, make big decisions for insignificant reasons. One such instance happened when I decided to join the military in 1988. I joined the Army but I could just have easily joined the Marines. I probably joined the army for no better reason than A came before M in the phone book. If M came before A I would not have this story to tell. 


Although I committed to the Army in September of 1988, I actually joined under a plan called the delayed entry program which pushed my actual enlistment date to the end of February, 1989. If I had not used the delayed entry option everything would have been different and I would not have this story to tell.  


Basic training sucks. You are called awful things. You are forced to do awful things and you have no control over your life. Infantry soldiers get this abuse for fourteen weeks. If you are a cook, or x-ray tech, or any other job the army offers you spend eight weeks in basic training then you get two weeks leave and you head to AIT, Advanced Individual Training. Not infantry soldiers, we get a three day pass after eight weeks then go back to the same degrading routine. I tell you this not for sympathy but because it is critical that you understand how this affects a infantry recruit’s decision making process. We crave free time: it is like air to a drowning man: it’s everything.


During infantry basic training there are a few times you are allowed to feel normal. These times come in the form of passes. Most are only for a few hours and confine you to post. While on these breaks you invariably run into other soldiers in the midst of basic training and to a man you all ask the exact same thing.  


“What week are you in?”


This question is critical because if they are in a later week they can tell your future. You pick their brains for every detail of what is to come and, if the reverse is true, they grill you.  


Unlike most basic training classes I had an extra opportunity for freedom and it was the best kind of freedom, off-base freedom. The local minor league baseball team, The Columbus Mudcats, had a military appreciation night and all uniformed soldiers were to be admitted free. Someone way above my pay grade decided all of the soldiers in basic training would be offered the chance to go to the game, unsupervised. Almost everyone did; I did. If the club hadn’t offered, if the Army hadn't allowed, or if I had rejected the offer I would not have this story to tell.  


I don’t remember much about the game. I don’t know what the stadium looked like or who won. None of that information was important enough to commit to memory. What I do remember was an incident that happened in the concession line. Because of the large number of soldiers present, the lines for refreshments were impossibly long. I didn’t care, I wanted a hot dog and a coke and in reality I couldn’t have cared less about the actual game so I took my place in line and waited my turn. Shortly after I entered the line a soldier came up and stood behind me. He had the Arctic Star, a black six point, on his shoulder signifying he was 6th Infantry, bound for Alaska. I had the same patch on my shoulder and the same ultimate destination. Neither of us knew which of the three Alaska forts would become our Army home but we both knew, regardless of which one, it would be frigid. We didn’t need an excuse to start up a conversation but the commonality made sure we did. 


He was four weeks behind me so the conversation consisted of him asking questions about what to expect and me doing my best to give him the glimpse he so desperately desired. Our talk lasted until I reached the front of the line and with my hot dog and coke in hand I wished him well and said maybe we’ll see each other in Alaska and with that I went back to my seat. If I had not wanted a hot dog, if I had gone to a different concession stand, if I had gone during a different inning I would not have this story to tell.


The real Army is only a little like basic training. You are not degraded, you are trained and you do your job. Every day just before you are released you have a squad or platoon meeting to go over the next day's plans and then you are released for the evening.  


Four weeks after I got to Alaska a new set of recruits joined my outfit. Two of those recruits were assigned to my platoon and joined us at our nightly meeting. One of these new recruits, who looked vaguely familiar, kept looking at me to the point it became uncomfortable. I’m as open minded as the next guy but I don’t like to be ogled by other men and he seemed to be doing just that. 


When the meeting was finally over and we were released to go home he walked over to me and said “You look just like...” He didn’t have time to finish his statement when I shouted, “You were the guy!” He was the soldier behind me at the ball game and not only did he end up at the same base and in the same battalion, he was in my company, my platoon, and my squad. On top of that, less than a week later we were assigned as roommates and became instant and lifelong friends.


The Army is a unique way to live your life especially when it comes to making friends. To say you put your life in each other's hands is not an exaggeration. This was especially true for Jason and I. I carried an M60 machine gun and he was my assistant gunner. The machine gun is a crew served weapon and the crew is supposed to include an ammo bearer. We didn’t have one, we split the ammo between us and prided ourselves in our ability to take the extra weight. Jason really got the worst of it though, I am stocky and built to carry a load. Jason was tall and thin but he took his fair share and at times more.  


In 1991 I was selected to represent my unit in the soldier of the month competition and Jason wasn’t going to allow me to lose. He spent every day quizzing me on the questions the military board might ask. By the time the competitions started he had me answering Jeopardy style, he would give the answer and I had to tell him the question. Well it worked, I won every level from company soldier of the month up to The United States Army Pacific Command Soldier of the year. The funny thing was I never had to tell anyone about what I had done because Jason always beat me to it. He didn’t have a hint of jealousy and reveled in my accomplishments more than I did. He taught me what a friend was, a lesson that still sticks with me to this day.  


I was the best man at his wedding and am the Godfather to his oldest son and we were each other's sympathetic ear. He and I came up with a phrase that we would do as a call and response whenever anything at work or in life was beating us down. One of us would say, “It’s only time.” and the other would immediately respond, “And time passes.”


I wish I could say we kept in close contact ever since but remember, this was in the days before social media so there were long stretches where we wouldn’t talk, but each time we did it seemed, unlike our mantra, time hadn’t passed.


Now it’s 2020, we’ve been friends for 31 years. He’s been married twice, divorced once, and widowed. He lives in Washington State and I live in Virginia. There were fifteen years where we lost touch but during that time if anyone ever asked me who my best friend was, the answer would always be “This guy named Jason.” 


 We’ve both had our ups and downs but his have mostly been downs. I got out after four years. He went to Iraq. I built a life of which I’m proud. He was a sniper and good at his job. I am the one friend who never asked what it was like to kill someone but I know he has and he is not the same as he was. He has battled addiction to pills and alcohol and he blames himself for his wife’s death. I talk to him almost every day but most days he doesn’t remember our talks. I tell him he is the best man I know, because he is, and for a few minutes he seems to feel better but it doesn’t last. For the last few weeks he has been telling me he doesn’t want to be here anymore. How am I supposed to handle that? He is my best friend and he wants to die.  


So many times in my story I could have done something different. So many times fate could have stepped in and changed my path. If any of those things had happened I would not have this story to tell. I would not have this weight on my shoulders. I would not be afraid when my phone rings. My best friend wants to die and I don’t know what to do but I do know I wouldn’t change a thing because he is my best friend and that is all that matters. 



Posted Aug 27, 2020
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

65 likes 68 comments

Zilla Babbitt
13:18 Aug 30, 2020

Well, if this is true, good job at sharing it. I like the ending lines quite a bit. If this were my piece, I'd tweak it a bit to show the degrading routine and subsequent hope for free time rather than telling it as an introduction.

Stay strong, Thom. Keep writing!

Reply

Thom With An H
14:19 Aug 30, 2020

Hey there, thanks for reading. It is 100% true which made writing it hard and easy at the same time. Once again good advice. I promise I’m not ignoring it, I just am not very good at showing. Not yet, hopefully soon.

Reply

Zilla Babbitt
14:41 Aug 30, 2020

You're welcome! I get it, hard and easy at the same time. My story "William" is like that. And showing comes with practice! :)

Reply

20:52 Aug 31, 2020

First off, I am so sorry for your struggles. I can't imagine having to deal with that. My best friend is like my sister, and I wouldn't be able to handle it. The fact that you are able to share this is inspiring. And this story also sends an amazing message. Your writing style, in general, is beautiful, but this is the best I have ever read. Ever. The first line immediately broke my heart. Your friend is very lucky to have you in his life. I hope both of you make it through.

Reply

Thom With An H
21:04 Aug 31, 2020

So much thanks for your good wishes. Most importantly he is doing better. We both know it's day by day but he's having a run of good days. Also thank you for the kind words. I love to write but more so I love to be read and comments like yours are why. Thank you!!

Reply

21:15 Aug 31, 2020

That makes me so glad to hear.
You're welcome!

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
17:43 Aug 31, 2020

This is ground control to Major Thom...
Didn't the earlier version of this story have something about you being a Giants supporter? It's okay, we all have shameful secrets 🤣

Okay, sorry, I'm done. I do have a new story when you get a moment. I enjoy your comments so much, so your opinion, as long as its honest, is always appreciated. No rush though.
Thanks.

Ground control, over and out.

Reply

Thom With An H
17:51 Aug 31, 2020

Hi my name is Thom and I'm a Giants fan. It was very hard for me to say that. :-)

I will of course check out your latest. Your stories are must see appointment kind of good. I may not have good judgement when it comes to football but I know great writing when I see it. :-)

Reply

Kristin Neubauer
19:32 Aug 28, 2020

This is a heartbreaking story, Thom....your friend is lucky that you are in his life. I have a similar friend who is ex-British Special Forces and wracked by much of what you describe. He's actually inspired me toward career change. I'm a journalist now but in grad school for social work with the aim of working with veterans. Do you mind my asking where you live in Virginia? I'm in Alexandria. And, of course, the writing in your story is so powerful. The repetition of "I would not have this story to tell" gives such a rhythm to it. I can't imagine this was easy for you to write and I thank you for writing it and sharing it with us.

Reply

Thom With An H
19:48 Aug 28, 2020

Thank you so much. This was an incredibly difficult story to write but paradoxically it was also easy because I didn't have to think I just told my story. I am south of you near Fredericksburg although for a time I worked in Falls Church so we've probably driven some common roads. I am inspired by your decision to change careers. Make no mistake I know journalists can make a difference but social workers are doing God's work. Thank you and thank you.

Reply

Kristin Neubauer
21:14 Aug 28, 2020

I'm sure your friend has investigated everything possible out there to help, but I saw this story about a year ago on 60 Minutes and it has some interesting research behind it: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/sgb-a-possible-breakthrough-treatment-for-ptsd-60-minutes-2019-06-16/. I hope your friend finds some relief at times.

Reply

Thom With An H
21:22 Aug 28, 2020

Thank you. I actually shared the story with him so he is following the comments. I know he is grateful for the well wishes.

Reply

Elle Clark
17:56 Aug 28, 2020

I think the first and obvious thing that has to be said after reading a story is that I’m really sorry that this is the thing that you’re struggling with the moment. You say at the beginning of this is absolutely true and I am taking that as reality rather than a literary device. I feel that it’s probably not a literary device though because of the raw power of the emotions. I have some experience with both suicidal friends and friends who have been successful in that and my heart goes out to you.

You have, of course, asked for my feedback so I will endeavour to give you some useful tips and thoughts.

Some grammatical thoughts. You have a great repetitive technique early on along the lines of it was running from someone who thought X, I didn’t’. In terms of punctuating this, commas aren’t the right choice because ‘I didn’t’ is a complete sentence on its own. So you’ve got a couple of options: full stops, dashes or semicolons. I think dashes would probably be best here because of the informal nature of the tagged bit but any would work.

I really like the repetitions you have in generally. The end line of ‘if I hadn’t have done X, I wouldn’t have this story to tell’ ties it together and gives it great rhythm. It’s a good way to remind the reader that what you’re saying is relevant to the overall message, too.

Your opening line - though, as I say, deeply tragic as a real life event - is a good hook that instantly grabs the reader. It’s also a good way to warn people who might find this type of story difficult.

I have some thoughts on how to make this have more of an emotional impact but as this is a real life thing that you’re still working through, it seems really inappropriate to offer authorial suggestions. If you would like this, though, let me know. I wanted to give you the choice.

The fear and sadness and desperation that you are feeling comes through very strongly in this and your conversational style works really well for this type of confessional story. The use of first person makes everything a little more immediate and distressing, especially as the reader bonds with you as you describe your experiences and wants you to be happy at the end.

Your ending of ‘if I’d made different decisions, I wouldn’t be going through this but I wouldn’t make different decisions because I’m lucky to know the guy’ is a really beautiful end message, too. Great writing, deeply tragic reason behind it. I’ll be sending you positive thoughts.

Reply

Thom With An H
18:33 Aug 28, 2020

I am so grateful for your compassion and concern. I promise you every word of this story is the unvarnished truth. In a funny way it made a very hard story to write an easy story to write because I didn't have to use my imagination only my memory. For you and anyone who takes the time to read this feedback, my friend has had four good days in a row and, fingers crossed, may have turned a corner. Last night I read him my story and we both cried, like well like best friends. Both he and I know he's not out of the woods but considering where he was when I first wrote this story on Monday, I couldn't be happier.

As for asking for stylistic feedback I feel guilty for saying this but I would like it. When I first wrote this story I didn't care. I actually wrote it just to relieve some of the burden I was feeling. The original version was less polished than the one you see now because I found that as much as I didn't want to care, I'm finding as a new writer that I do. I want to be able to share myself with my stories but I also want to share them well. I think I told you, I am not a technician. I don't know how to punctuate my sentences and truth be told I'm an awful speller. Thank you spellcheck. I also just write what comes into my head. I've been told I need to work on showing vs telling and I'm trying but it's hard because in my head I'm always just telling. I guess this is just a way too long way to try to justify asking for your help. I will say this I have limited my read requests for this story mainly because I really want feedback from people who have shown by their previous feedback that they care and you do. So I will thank you in advance for any additional feedback you have and thank you again for being someone who cares. It makes a difference.

Reply

Elle Clark
18:55 Aug 28, 2020

Four good days in a row is such good news! Sometimes things that don’t sound that much to people not dealing with things like this are everything in reality. I can honestly relate to the sheer relief and joy of having that much time off from an immediate, crushing crisis mode and so I am so happy for you both. I wish I had some advice that would improve the situation for either of you but my advice largely runs along the lines of: keeping telling him how much you love him. Other than that, there’s nothing that makes anything easier or better.

In terms of authorial advice - I completely understand your perspective. I thought that you probably would want it but ultimately, this did what you wanted it to do (helped you process some of these feelings and told us what’s happening) so it can stand as is if you wanted it to.

If you were to edit it, the main focus should be your best friend, the relationship you have with him and the emotions you are experiencing because of his situation. However in the story, you tell us a lot of background information about you which, while very interesting, doesn’t often connect to those three things. If you had spent less time on your journey to basic training and more recounting stories of your relationship and how that built, the reader would’ve been more invested in the emotional journey for both ‘characters’. At the moment, they’re invested in the ‘protagonist’ but the friend isn’t largely featured.

So, a potential structure could have been:
Opening paragraph exactly as is
One or two paragraphs describing how you got to be at the stadium
Stories of your relationship growing and evolving (the moment you first realised you had each others’ backs, holidays you went on or events you attended, the first time you met each others’ partners, the first moment you realised he had a problem, a conversation you had where you expressed your concerns, one or two stories showing his decline, etc)
Final paragraphs as is

Obviously just an idea but this puts the focus of the story on what’s actually important to you and let’s the readers get a flavour of your relationship - are you serious? Do you have lots of banter? Do you have heartfelt talks? Are you each others’ first calls? Etc.

The obvious problem with this is that because he is a real life person, stories like this could be invasive or reveal more than he’s happy with so there is that as an important consideration too.

For future writes though, my advice would be to think - before you begin - about what your core message is. Here it is that you love your best friend and you’re worried about him. Then build your narrative around that, only including things that put that message across.

Hopefully this is helpful and hasn’t overstepped. I will keep my fingers crossed for more positive days for you both.

Reply

Thom With An H
19:06 Aug 28, 2020

It's the perfect amount of assistance. As hard as this might be to believe, I've actually cut out a lot of the background that was in my original work. You are of course right, I am, as we speak, trying to think of specific events I could add to give a more complete picture of the evolution of our friendship. I have a feeling this story will be edited and added to quite a lot even after the deadline to do so on Reedsy passes. I'm hoping one day I can change the title and the ending. That is the story I really want to tell. Once again, and from the bottom of my heart, Thank You!!

Reply

Elle Clark
19:17 Aug 28, 2020

If you do, make sure you let me know - I would love to read it. And a story where you can use a different title and ending would be even better.

Reply

Thom With An H
20:30 Aug 28, 2020

Ok you asked for it. Is this any better? I haven't posted it yet.

My best friend wants to die. It is very important as I tell you my story that you know two things: the first is the story is absolutely true and the second is I have no idea what to do. I guess it’s also important you know there are so many things that could have happened differently and if they had I would not be able to tell this story.

Young men, oftentimes, make big decisions for insignificant reasons. One such instance happened when I decided to join the military in 1988. I joined the Army but I could just have easily joined the Marines. I probably joined the army for no better reason than A came before M in the phone book. If M came before A I would not have this story to tell.

Although I committed to the Army in September of 1988, I actually joined under a plan called the delayed entry program which pushed my actual enlistment date to the end of February, 1989. If I had not used the delayed entry option everything would have been different and I would not have this story to tell.

Basic training sucks. You are called awful things. You are forced to do awful things and you have no control over your life. Infantry soldiers get this abuse for fourteen weeks. If you are a cook, or x-ray tech, or any other job the army offers you spend eight weeks in basic training then you get two weeks leave and you head to AIT, Advanced Individual Training. Not infantry soldiers, we get a three day pass after eight weeks then go back to the same degrading routine. I tell you this not for sympathy but because it is critical that you understand how this affects a infantry recruit’s decision making process. We crave free time: it is like air to a drowning man: it’s everything.

During infantry basic training there are a few times you are allowed to feel normal. These times come in the form of passes most are only for a few hours and confine you to post. While on these breaks you invariably run into other soldiers in the midst of basic training and to a man you all ask the exact same thing.

“What week are you in?”

This question is critical because if they are in a later week they can tell your future. You pick their brains for every detail of what is to come and, if the reverse is true, they grill you.

Unlike most basic training classes I had an extra opportunity for freedom and it was the best kind of freedom, off-base freedom. The local minor league baseball team, The Columbus Mudcats, had a military appreciation night and all uniformed soldiers were to be admitted free. Someone way above my pay grade decided all of the soldiers in basic training would be offered the chance to go to the game, unsupervised. Almost everyone did; I did. If the club hadn’t offered, if the Army hadn't allowed, or if I had rejected the offer I would not have this story to tell.

I don’t remember much about the game. I don’t know what the stadium looked like or who won. None of that information was important enough to commit to memory. What I do remember was an incident that happened in the concession line. Because of the large number of soldiers present, the lines for refreshments were impossibly long. I didn’t care, I wanted a hot dog and a coke and in reality I couldn’t have cared less about the actual game so I took my place in line and waited my turn. Shortly after I entered the line a soldier came up and stood behind me. He had the Arctic Star, a black six point, on his shoulder signifying he was 6th Infantry, bound for Alaska. I had the same patch on my shoulder and the same ultimate destination. Neither of us knew which of the three Alaska forts would become our Army home but we both knew, regardless of which one, it would be frigid. We didn’t need an excuse to start up a conversation but the commonality made sure we did.

He was four weeks behind me so the conversation consisted of him asking questions about what to expect and me doing my best to give him the glimpse he so desperately desired. Our talk lasted until I reached the front of the line and with my hot dog and coke in hand I wished him well and said maybe we’ll see each other in Alaska and with that I went back to my seat. If I had not wanted a hot dog, if I had gone to a different concession stand, if I had gone during a different inning I would not have this story to tell.

The real Army is only a little like basic training. You are not degraded, you are trained and you do your job. Every day just before you are released you have a squad or platoon meeting to go over the next day's plans and then you are released for the evening.

Four weeks after I got to Alaska a new set of recruits joined my outfit. Two of those recruits were assigned to my platoon and joined us at our nightly meeting. One of these new recruits, who looked vaguely familiar, kept looking at me to the point it became uncomfortable. I’m as open minded as the next guy but I don’t like to be ogled by other men and he seemed to be doing just that.

When the meeting was finally over and we were released to go home he walked over to me and said “You look just like...” He didn’t have time to finish his statement when I shouted, “You were the guy!” He was the soldier behind me at the ball game and not only did he end up at the same base and in the same battalion, he was in my company, my platoon, and my squad. On top of that, less than a week later we were assigned as roommates and became instant and lifelong friends.

The Army is a unique way to live your life especially when it comes to making friends. To say you put your life in each other's hands is not an exaggeration. This was especially true for Jason and I. I carried an M60 machine gun and he was my assistant gunner. The machine gun is a crew served weapon and the crew is supposed to include an ammo bearer. We didn’t have one, we split the ammo between us and prided ourselves in our ability to take the extra weight. Jason really got the worst of it though, I am stocky and built to carry extra weight. Jason was tall and thin but he took his fair share and at times more.

In 1991 I was selected to represent my unit in the soldier of the month competition and Jason wasn’t going to allow me to lose. He spent every day quizzing me on the questions the military board might ask and by the time the competitions started he had me answering Jeopardy style, he would give the answer and I had to tell him the question. Well it worked, I won every level from company soldier of the month up to The United States Army Pacific Command Soldier of the year. The funny thing was I never had to tell anyone about what I had done because Jason always beat me to it. He didn’t have a hint of jealousy and reveled in my accomplishments more than I did. He taught me what a friend was, a lesson that still sticks with me today.

I was the best man at his wedding and the Godfather to his oldest son and we were each other's sympathetic ears when life was hard. He and I came up with a phrase that we would do as a call and response whenever anything at work or in life was beating us down. One of us would say, “It’s only time.” and the other would immediately respond, “And time passes.”

I wish I could say we kept in close contact ever since but remember, this was in the days before social media so there were long stretches where we wouldn’t talk, but each time we did it seemed that unlike our mantra, that time hadn’t passed.

Now it’s 2020, we’ve been friends for 31 years. He’s been married twice, divorced once, and widowed. He lives in Washington State and I live in Virginia. There were fifteen years where we lost touch but during that time if anyone ever asked me who my best friend was, the answer would always be “This guy named Jason.”

We’ve both had our ups and downs but his have mostly been downs. I got out after four years. He went to Iraq. I built a life of which I’m proud. He was a sniper and good at his job. I am the one friend who never asked what it was like to kill someone but I know he has and he is not the same as he was. He has battled addiction to pills and alcohol and he blames himself for his wife’s death. I talk to him almost every day but most days he doesn’t remember our talks. I tell him he is the best man I know, because he is, and for a few minutes he seems to feel better but it doesn’t last. For the last few weeks he has been telling me he doesn’t want to be here anymore. How am I supposed to handle that? He is my best friend and he wants to die.

So many times in my story I could have done something different. So many times fate could have stepped in and changed my path. If any of those things had happened I would not have this story to tell. I would not have this weight on my shoulders. I would not be afraid when my phone rings. My best friend wants to die and I don’t know what to do but I do know I wouldn’t change a thing because he is my best friend and that is all that matters.

Reply

Christina Hall
17:48 Aug 27, 2020

Great writing, again.
There were a couple parts that I really liked:
1) where he tells his friend he's the best man he knows, and it helps, but it never lasts, and
2) in the last paragraph, from where you start, "I would not have this weight on my shoulders" and continuing to the end.

I don't know if you've been through this, but trust me, you really hit the mark with these two pieces of your story.

Reply

Thom With An H
17:57 Aug 27, 2020

Thank you for taking the time to read. This is a true story that’s still unfolding. Yesterday was a good day. I hope today will be as well.

Reply

Christina Hall
19:36 Aug 27, 2020

I'm sorry to hear that, I hope your friend is able to reach out for the help he needs and find some hope for a better road ahead.
Take care of yourself. What he's living through is terrible, but its hard for you to.

Reply

Thom With An H
19:41 Aug 27, 2020

Thanks.

Reply

Pamela Saunders
18:46 Aug 30, 2020

Hi Thom and Jason, first I just want to say I am glad you've been having more good days lately and I hope you have many many more to come.
re the writing, Thom, the title drew me in as I have been where Jason is but for different reasons. Even now, some days feel extra hard and I am battling my mind's wanting to give up. I wanted to see if this story helped me to see more of what this meant to someone on the other side, who cares about me. Because for me that is a powerful incentive to keep on living. I am glad Jason has a friend like you to keep on telling him that you care and that he can confide in you. I hope that you are able to share joyfulness too and plenty of inspirational and uplifting things as I know how much those help.
I think your writing showed brilliantly the backstory and the building of the friendship. I agree with other comments that you had a good rhythm of how things developed. "If this - I would not have this story to tell" And how you ended with that you wouldn't have changed a thing, because the friendship means so much to you. The little stories showing the growth of the relationship worked extremely well. Relying on each other to stay alive in the Marines. Jason showing you off as he is so proud of you (Jason I hope you know there are not many people who do that, and it makes you extra special). Being the best man and the Godfather, those are both awesome positions of trust and responsibility and again shows strong friendship. And the little phrase that you have between you of time passes. I want to say that bad times pass too. When we are going through them they seem neverending and intolerable. Please keep on looking for the rainbows and my thing that works for me as well when I remember is "dancing in the rain" - not literally, but finding something pleasurable even in the darkness. It might just be as simple as watching a spider. Just anything to distract from the awfulness of the situation. Yes it has to be faced, but we all need rest breaks from all that work, too. And it is work. I know you are both working hard through this, and I really hope that you will find your happy ending.

Reply

Thom With An H
19:07 Aug 30, 2020

I don’t know if there enough kind words to use to thank you for this response. I wrote this as a way to help myself by putting my thoughts down on virtual paper and it worked in a way I hadn’t anticipated through the supportive thoughts of the people who have read it. I definitely don’t want to take credit for the string of good days Jason is having as they started before I shared this story with him but he did say this will be one more tool to help him on the bad days and you’re response gives me hope it may even help others. Thanks so much. More than I can say.

Reply

Pamela Saunders
19:12 Aug 30, 2020

You are so welcome, and I'm really glad you find my words helpful :)

Reply

Ru B
18:23 Aug 30, 2020

Very powerful story and well written! Your friendship is inspiring and something that most of us strive to have in our lives, typically unsuccessful I can't help but think. It was probably not easy but I'm sure it means a lot to the both of you to share this story.

Reply

Thom With An H
19:08 Aug 30, 2020

It does and thank you for your encouraging words.

Reply

Lori Colt
03:20 Aug 30, 2020

This is a gorgeous story of friendship with its struggles, sorrows, and connections. I think you did a wonderful job of building this from the ground up, telling your story in an interesting way, and putting a pit right in the middle of my heart. Stories that stir emotions are my favorite kind. Terrific job! And if it really is true, my heart goes out to Jason, I can only imagine what he is feeling.

Reply

Thom With An H
03:24 Aug 30, 2020

Thank you so much. He is real and I took a chance and sent him a link to the story. He’s been touched by the responses and he is having a run of good days. Thank you again for your time and concern. It means a lot.

Reply

Lori Colt
03:50 Aug 30, 2020

Beautiful! Glad to hear that!

Reply

Tanja Cilia
03:09 Aug 30, 2020

'I would not have this story to tell.' This is a beautiful refrain, because it is what lies beneath each thought, each link, each pent-up emotion, in this story. I, too, have had friends who told me they didn't want to be here any more... and some of them aren't. Whether or not Jason exists, he does.

Reply

Thom With An H
03:14 Aug 30, 2020

Thanks so much for the heartfelt response. He is real and he’s on a streak of good days. I hope I can eventually rewrite this story with a different title and different ending.

Reply

Tanja Cilia
09:14 Aug 30, 2020

You do all you can, and you are in the right place at the right time. When someone tells you "I am tired, I want to go..." there is nothing much you can do, except be there.

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
16:04 Aug 28, 2020

Thom, this is brilliant! The new category feature helps because the reader knows the genre beforehand, but even without 'creative non-fiction' it would've been clear this is a story based on personal experience. And because of that, it must have been very tough to write. That took courage! And, on a purely technical level, this is top-class. The tone of regret comes through from the start, and repeating how things could've been different is very powerful - it shows you've recognised the emotions you've wanted to convey and managed to highlight them.

I know for myself, writing can be a good way to work through things and heal. I hope you got a little of that here, because it's a tough situation to be in. I'm sure you know all the theory - about how you can't rescue someone in that position (I know this from experience) and you can't blame yourself. But that's theory. The reality is it hurts like hell and, again, you're very brave in writing about it.

A few small fixes - wrong not wring i think you meant early on. Off-base needs a hyphen (again, I think). And I'd drop the literally from literally shouted, because i think in that instance it takes away from the surprise you're trying to convey.

But other than that, it's an incredibly strong story. I really respect you for your writing ability and willingness to learn, and after this story, I've got even more reasons to respect you. Great writing!

Reply

Thom With An H
16:21 Aug 28, 2020

Not being a famous, wealthy, award winning writer I have no idea how those who are decide whom to thank when they win said awards. I do think if I ever accomplish that goal you just might be on my list. If you are it will be for two reasons: the first being the invaluable encouragement you give. A lot of times I hear, "great story, can you read mine." I'm never even sure if they actually read my story. You on the other hand take the time to praise specific parts and even give me constructive criticism so gently provided it still feels like encouragement. The second reason is your writing and your stories. They make me want to get better. They make me want people to think the things about my writing that I think about yours. You are professional grade. The good news is that if I ever am a famous and wealthy award winning writer, there is a good chance you'll be the one giving me the award because you'll probably have achieved those goals long before I do. Thank you, and congrats again on the shortlist this week. It was well deserved.

Reply

Thom With An H
21:01 Aug 28, 2020

Ok I am about to go above and beyond in my request. Based on feedback from Laura Clark I updated the story removing some of my back story and adding some 100% true friend stories. Can you give me a second look at a single story? I'll owe you one. :-)

Reply

Elle Clark
21:05 Aug 28, 2020

Love this!

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
06:39 Aug 29, 2020

Oh, hi Laura. Fancy bumping into you here 😊

Thom, it’s always a pleasure to read stories and more so to reread after changes – the learning value is high when that happens. I shall do so at once.

Reply

Jane Andrews
19:59 Aug 27, 2020

Hi Thom.
I think it's the sign of a good writer when you can take a real life event and tell the story so that it's just as compelling as a piece of fiction. Autobiographical writing has the power to be raw and honest in a way that fiction often lacks, and I really like the way that this piece paints a picture of your journey as a younger man through army training and a chance encounter that resulted in a friendship. A real strength of this is that you don't try to give it a Hollywood ending (eg meeting up with you makes your friend realise life is suddenly worth living) but narrate the reality of everyday: "So many times in my story, I could have done something different. So many times, fate could have stepped in and changed my path. ... My best friend wants to die and I don’t know what to do; but I do know I wouldn’t change a thing because he is my best friend and that is all that matters." It's refreshingly honest to admit that you don't have the answers and for your genuine care for your friend to shine through.

I think your writing style works well with a piece like this. If I was going to be picky (eg if I was your editor), I would remind you to use a comma after a subordinate clause at the start of a sentence eg when you start a sentence with a temporal clause such as 'So many times' or 'About three weeks later'.
You have some good use of figurative language eg "We crave free time: it is like air to a drowning man: it’s everything." (I'd replace your original commas with colons there as the second clause explains the first and the third explains the second. If you use commas, you're comma splicing. You could replace the commas with full stops (periods) rather than colons, but the colon gives a slightly shorter pause between each clause.)
I think this piece could easily be featured in a magazine - lots of publications look for 'real life' pieces like this. And well done for sharing something so personal.
PS Don't know if you want to check out my offering 'Heart Broken' which, like yours, is autobiographical - my son is now almost 17 but we went through the ordeal narrated in the story when he was a new-born.

Reply

Thom With An H
20:12 Aug 27, 2020

You are my best English friend. Thanks for both levels of feedback. It’s exactly what I needed and I’m on my way to your story right now.

Reply

Jane Andrews
20:44 Aug 27, 2020

It's always such a pleasure to critique your work - and you are exactly what every 'teacher' wants in a student: someone who won't take offence if a mistake is pointed out but will take the comments on board.

Reply

. .
09:32 Sep 03, 2020

Great story!

Reply

Thom With An H
11:19 Sep 03, 2020

Thank you!!

Reply

Jonathan Blaauw
06:42 Aug 29, 2020

With the changes, you’ve upped the emotional impact significantly. I fully agree with Laura in that not having much of the ‘bonding’ in the first draft may not have been an error as much as something that was too painful to go into detail about. Putting it in works incredibly well. It’s like, again, you’ve identified the key feelings you want to highlight and brought them through loud and clear. That probably isn’t down to planning as much as just writing from the heart, which proves that feeling is as important, if not more so, as technical stuff in writing. So you’ve taken a great story and upped it even more!

I recently watched an excellent movie called ‘The Last Full Measure’ about soldiers and PTSD. Your story has a similar feel, which is to say, a powerful one. And if your friend is keeping up with the comments, maybe he’ll be inspired to write a bit himself. Not even to show anyone, necessarily, but I find writing is an excellent way to process things. Even if it’s just for yourself. Especially if it’s just for yourself.
Reminds me of that old thing – My therapist told me to write letters to the people I don’t like and burn them. I’ve done that, and feel much better, but what do I do with all the letters now? 😊

Also, Thom, since you live in Virginia and are ex-military, you’ve obviously met Jack Reacher. Next time you see him please send my regards. And also condolences on the whole movie/Tom Cruise thing. That, I’m sure Mr. Reacher would agree, was a classic SNAFU.

Reply

Thom With An H
11:28 Aug 29, 2020

Jack says hi. He’s been in hiding since the movies. Now we know what it takes to keep a good man down.

Thank you for the added insight. It’s spot on and it’s been cathartic for both Jason and I to see the comments. And in the latest update his run of good days continues. He told me this story is something that will help on the hard days. It’s a reminder of the power of the written word. It shows me we can do more than just entertain.

Reply

Claire Lindsey
18:35 Mar 09, 2021

Firstly, how is Jason? I hope that your friendship has continued to be a place of solace and strength for him. I’ve struggled with similar thoughts before and it’s dark and scary. I’ve never told anyone actually. The fact that he talks with you about it tells so much about how close you two are and how much you mean to him. My thoughts and prayers are with you both.

Secondly, this is incredible. Very readable, engaging, and important. Easily my favorite of yours so far, it captures the complexity of friendship, how it can be a source of joy, strength and, sometimes, worry. It’s very brave to tackle a prompt with a true story, and I applaud you for that vulnerability.

As always, you’re it but take your time. I had a lot of fun writing ‘The Song of the Air Above,’ if you’d like a suggestion, but feel free to choose whichever.

Reply

Thom With An H
18:42 Mar 09, 2021

I’m glad you asked. Today Jason finished quarantine at a rehab center in Oregon. He will now be able to spend the next 90 days in treatment. His attitude is much better than I originally expected. He unfortunately had 3 DWI’s in the last two months including two that resulted in pretty severe accidents. He spent the 30 days prior to arriving at the facility in jail for his actions. Our hope is he is scared straight. He believes his life was spared because God has a purpose for him. I am choosing to believe with him. Thank you for your compassion and concern. Thank you for your kind words as well. I am definitely looking forward to your next story. You never disappoint.

Reply

Thom With An H
18:46 Mar 09, 2021

I also want to say thank you for sharing your pain as well. I hope you have someone you can talk to. That’s really what friends are for.

Reply

Claire Lindsey
20:02 Mar 09, 2021

Glad to hear he’s getting help, and that he is finding purpose. I’ll be praying for him as he begins rehab.
And thank you, I’m fine at the moment mentally but I do have people I can reach out to should the need arise.

Reply

Elle Clark
17:47 Sep 22, 2020

Thom, I’m just checking in on this story to ask how Jason is getting on. I think about you guys about once a week and been sending positive thoughts his way.

Reply

Thom With An H
18:12 Sep 22, 2020

Honestly he is doing great. He got a new job. He’s going to meetings everyday and he finally got a sponsor. He knows everyday is a new day. He always says he won’t drink today. He knows thinking further than that is a recipe for disaster. Fingers crossed he may be a success story.

Thanks for checking btw. I’ll let him know you asked. It means a lot to both of us.

Reply

Elle Clark
18:57 Sep 22, 2020

That’s amazing news! I’m so happy for him.

Reply

Paige Leppanen
20:07 Sep 03, 2020

Wow, what an emotional piece. I like the way you build suspense and show how the smallest decisions can change the course of your life. I'm so sorry your friend is in a rough way, though. It's good he has a friend who's there for him.

Reply

Isabella Montoya
21:14 Nov 24, 2024

This is really sad, Thom. I hope your friend gets the help he so desperately needs. I know that feeling of wanting to die firsthand, and it's not nice. Best thing you can have in times like this is support and knowing you're not alone. I'm glad he has a friend like you in his life. He's very lucky for that. Tell him to call/text 988 for support from professional counselors. Make sure you also take care of yourself, too. You can only support him as long as you're well. Please let me know if he's doing better or if you need anything. I hope brighter days keep coming for both of you. Thanks for sharing this story, Thom. Keep writing!

Reply

Thom, I do still check your page. I did notice that your picture changed, and I’ve read your new bio.

Right away I went and found your story about Jason, and I read it.

I know that after losing someone you love, words from others turn feeble, and can hardly give comfort. Yet I still want to offer you condolences, on behalf of myself and my mother.

My mother wants me to share this talk with you:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WJnWnN3doR4
She said it gave her comfort. There are three people in our family who have taken their own lives.

We are going to Mass tonight, and we will both pray for the repose of the soul of Jason. May he rest in peace. We will also be praying for comfort in your grief, for you and your family, and for Jason’s family.

Reply

Mary Bendickson
03:31 Nov 16, 2023

Oh, Thom. So sorry for your loss. You may not remember me but you were the first one to critique my first story on Reedsy. I so admire your writing and had no idea you were as new to writing as I was when I started here in Feb, 2023. Don't know that I have improved all that much but I do have a request to see my manuscript. I wrote about my journey in a few of my stories here. Especially 'Thank You, Killer Nashville'.
I have been crazy busy and falling behind on my reading but I happened to stop on your profile because of the new picture. Maybe it has been up for a while and I never noticed. I read about your best friend and came back to this story to read more. I only wanted to offer my condolences. May the Lord comfort you and keep you.

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.