Letters to Allegra

Written in response to: "Write a story with a person’s name in the title."

Fiction Sad Thriller

This story contains themes or mentions of suicide or self harm.

1 February 2022

Dear Allegra,

I know you have no idea who I am; if you were to list everything you know about me, all you’d come up with is a blank page. Why is it, though, that every Austen heroine rolled into a divine being would still pale in comparison to your splendour?

Right now, I watch you saunter in front of me, each stiletto-clack step tuning the pavement gold. As if from a scrupulously conceptualised film script. Your sumptuous Yves Saint-Laurent maxi dress and those perfectly coiffed burgundy waves jeté in the winter breeze, only to fall back into its properly assigned place. Your long, lithe legs float on concrete, every glide a note in the rhapsody of your radiance. You greet the newsagent with that aria of a received pronunciation-laced voice. Even the low-hanging sun insists on crowning you with its rays, just so you can rival Aphrodite herself.

Of course, whilst you play in the cinema of my mind, you will never turn your eyes on me. Why would the muse that dictates even my every breath ever hold me – wiry frame, mousy patches of hair, lips perpetually trembling with unspoken sentences --- ever spare a single thought for me?

I can only dream, I guess.

Always with you in the world of words,

M

*************

19 May 2022

Dear Allegra,

Congratulations on the Pulitzer; I knew it was as certain as letters threading themselves together to form this missive that you’d bag it.

No, I’m not surprised at all, you brilliant, intrepid travel journalist. Phileas Fogg would cower in shame at the way you have traversed the heady cosmopolitan haunts of ol’ London Town, the pristine, powder sands of the Philippines, the russet sacred lands of Outback Australia, the cacophony of sound and colour of the South American jungle --- all whilst seeming as though you walked out of a film set. Your musings on the massive stage that is the world have undeniably captivated continents of wide gazes awaiting your next voyage journal.

If that’s not enough, though, I heard that you will be starting your first novel soon. Once more, to be surprised with that news is to be blinder than Tiresias to the luminescence of your writing skill. I can not wait to nibble at every single morsel of every single syllable of that tome.

Of course, the more you step into your divinity as Calliope, the more I realise I’m but a mere mortal basking in the beacon of your splendour. Will you, one day, bestow me a smile?

Always with you in the world of words,

M

******************

16 August 2022

Dear Allegra,

Well, he’s lovely. Enjorlas’ passion meets Dorian Gray’s stellar beauty meets Colonel Brandon’s steadfast, kind heart. I’m happy for you; I truly am.

Leo Victor-George. Critically acclaimed novelist of ‘The Perfection’ Leo Victor-George. Leo Victor-George who kisses your mouth with plush lips and kisses your ear with poetry just to encapsulate your wondrous light. Even his name inks a bridge to you; Leo Tolstoy, Victor Hugo, George Elliot – authors whose tomes I’ve seen you languidly savour amongst the verdure of Green Park. The smile playing on your mulberry-painted lips is but a synopsis of the joy you feel by his side.

…a joy I can’t have. As your souls harmonise in a glorious duet with every encounter, a wailing lament rings out in mine. You and Leo get to swing into each other’s arms in technicolour; my insides submerge themselves in black and white.

But perhaps, you can string together even just a line of dialogue between you two mentioning me?

Always with you in the world of words,

M

***************

30 June 2023

Dear Allegra,

Wow, you are launching your second novel already! I know that any sentiment from me would be muffled by the acoustics in the theatre of your attention, but can I just say how proud I am of you?

Of course, it’s only fitting that the woman who could be crowned the fairest of all Olympus would celebrate her new tome’s debut in Greece. Greece, cradle of civilisation and the gods. And yet its ancient marble statues and its sprawling temple ruins were no match to your oceanic eyes in the Mediterranean sun. Even Helen of Troy would gasp at the image of you in Athens in your delicately purple silk empire dress, its ruffles transforming you into a wild iris. Your publisher might as well officially call you The Face That Launched a Thousand Shipments.

Yes, you had every reason to beam. After all, the entire time, you were next to Leo, inseparable as if your names were already inscribed in myths passed by tongue through generations. He stares at you mesmerised as you perform that ballet of press tours, sightseeing, and Sylvia Plath in the park I am miles away, begging for a single second of your bliss.

Maybe, Hermes can deliver a whispered message to you, forged by my tears?

Always with you in the world of words,

M

**************

19 October 2024

Dear Allegra,

That’s it. You’re married now. Like the end sequence of a 1950s MGM blockbuster, you kissed Leo as the sun set on New York and the minister declared you both husband and wife.

I’m not surprised he bawled as you walked down the aisle, you know. You were a vision in your lace wedding gown, fairy tale princess wedding every hero with Cupid’s arrow in their arsenal. And oh the way liquid crystal dripped down your stunning face as you stared at your besotted fiancé! Vivaldi might as well descend down from the heavens to play a melody worthy of you.

So, it’s final. It’s with Leo you’ll explore every denotation and connotation of ‘Happily Ever After’. It’s with Leo you shall cuddle on the sofa as Catherine Deneuve grins at her mother’s umbrella shop for the twelfth time on your television screen. It’s with Leo that you shall build a library of all of the titles you have collected. It’s with Leo you will write the final chapter of your story with.

Will you spare even just a line or two for me?

Always with you in the world of words,

M

*****************

28 June 2025

Allegra,

They found them! They found my letters to you! Now, they’re going to move me away, dry up the well of sentences I want to fill yours with!

What am I to do now?

M

*********************

Local Woman Found Dead in Kitchen, Suicide Suspected

5 July 2025

Pleasant, AL – Police are investigating the death of a local woman who was found by emergency services with her head in an oven. Mary Luncroft, 45, passed away due to gas inhalation. According to reports, the kitchen windows had been sealed by two layers of towels and the doors were locked when the rescue team arrived at her home.

Authorities have taken a few of Mrs. Luncroft’s belongings to aid in the investigation. Among her possessions are her journal, a ‘UK English for Dummies’ book, and a USB drive containing a novel draft written by one Allegra Victor-George, confirmed to be Mrs. Luncroft’s nom de plume by a journal entry dated 1 January 2022.

Mrs. Luncroft was due to move to the neighboring town of Lacrima next month with her family. She is survived by her husband Jeremiah, a Baptist minister, and her five children.

Posted Jul 01, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

26 likes 34 comments

Nicole Moir
22:55 Jul 04, 2025

Oh, I love this! : As if from a scrupulously conceptualised film script.
I feel for Allegra, you write characters so well!

Reply

Alexis Araneta
03:12 Jul 05, 2025

You are too kind, Nicole! Thank you! I do tend to agonise on plotting my stories!

Reply

Ralph Aldrich
01:47 Jul 17, 2025

Thanks for the like

Reply

Alexis Araneta
14:49 Jul 17, 2025

Very welcome!

Reply

Maxwell Pacilio
16:31 Jul 14, 2025

As always I am bewitched by your use of the English language. Each word feels carefully crafted to enrich your complex characters and subtle building of tension. Great work.

Reply

Alexis Araneta
16:52 Jul 14, 2025

You are beyond kind, Maxwell! Thank you so much. I do tend to be a bit agonisingly scrupulous with word choice. I'm so happy you enjoyed the buildup of tension, though. Thanks for reading!

Reply

Rebecca Hurst
15:42 Jul 07, 2025

Wow, this is so good! A brilliant subversion of the besotted stalker tale. You sure know how to stick the stilletto in when you want to !! Top marks, Alexis.

Reply

Alexis Araneta
17:12 Jul 07, 2025

Hi, Rebecca! I'm glad you liked it. For some reason, the idea of playing with the structure of my usual unrequited love stories came to mind when I came up with this. Thanks for reading!

Reply

Scott Monson
02:50 Jul 07, 2025

Loved this, Alexis! Your writing has such graceful ease that it allows the darkness to slip in quietly.

Reply

Alexis Araneta
05:44 Jul 07, 2025

Scott, that means so much! I'm glad I was able to gently nudge the darkness in like a cloud. Thank you for reading!

Reply

Derek Roberts
14:24 Jul 06, 2025

It's no surprise that she would plead for attention letters...to herself. It's a brilliant layering of the truth and fantasy, side by side. Of course we have no idea that the ending is coming. And when it does, its a breathtaking reveal. Of course, she chose the same death as Sylvia Plath, and connects perfectly to the mention earlier in the story. Such a tragedy, and yet we get to peek into the causes of the tragic end...not knowing that's what we will see and understand at the ending. Great job, Alexis.

Reply

Alexis Araneta
15:09 Jul 06, 2025

Hi, Derek! Thank you for this lovely comment, I'm happy you liked the twist. Like I said to some friends when I showed them this story, I sort of wanted to play on my usual writing about unrequited love and subvert it a bit. I'm glad you liked the way I layered elements too. Thanks for reading!

Reply

Helen A Howard
09:35 Jul 03, 2025

Beautifully done, and what a sad ending. How tragic the way the character of Mary Lunecroft becomes embedded and emotionally interwoven with her nom de plume. A lingering piece.

Reply

Alexis Araneta
11:57 Jul 03, 2025

Hi, Helen! Thank you so much! In a way, Allegra is real because she's Mary's hopes and dreams. I'm very happy you find it lingering. Thank you for reading!

Reply

Helen A Howard
12:05 Jul 03, 2025

I saw that and thought it worked well, but I wondered if Allegra was connected to mythology in some way. There were some gaps in my education and I sometimes miss things that others spot.
A good name and a great story.

Reply

Alexis Araneta
12:49 Jul 03, 2025

Actually, I named her Allegra because it means 'joy', basically the opposite of Mary (which means 'bitter'.)!

Reply

Helen A Howard
12:59 Jul 03, 2025

I googled it lol. Allegra’s a good name for a writer. I didn’t know the name Mary means bitter. Maybe a bit like olives which I love.
Fascinating the meaning of names.

Reply

Mary Bendickson
00:22 Jul 03, 2025

Your lovely literary style beams! 🤩

Reply

Alexis Araneta
01:48 Jul 03, 2025

You are too kind, Mary! Thank you!

Reply

Keba Ghardt
16:39 Jul 02, 2025

Artful intrigue; even waiting for a turn, it's an unguessable twist, but it adds a satisfying depth without feeling like a trick. Because of your craft in love and longing, it enriches rather than cheapens what we thought we knew. What a heartbreaking character!

Reply

Alexis Araneta
17:08 Jul 02, 2025

Hi, Keba! I'm beyond thrilled you liked the story. I sort of wanted to play with the idea of what seems like one of my unrequited love stories but isn't in the end. I'm happy you find the style enriches things.

Your support of my writing has always been so touching! Thank you so much. Keba! Really!

Reply

Keba Ghardt
17:22 Jul 02, 2025

It is an absolute joy to watch you play and grow :)

Reply

01:42 Jul 02, 2025

Brilliant! Bravo! Asolamente maraviglioso! Passionately raw from the place of Perks of Being a Wall. Another fav from you added to my list. Captures the essences of ideation. I say that genuinely honest. As I no longer suffer from it.

Reply

Alexis Araneta
01:50 Jul 02, 2025

Thank you so much! Merci bien (Can't speak Italian, sorry!). I'm happy I was able to capture that feeling of despair. One of my worries was that I wouldn't do it justice. I'm beyond chuffed that you're feeling better. Thank you for reading!

Reply

Colin Smith
01:04 Jul 02, 2025

I loved all of the literary allusions, Alexis! Even the ending was very Sylvia Plath. I'm going to have to read it again and Google some names to catch everything...

Reply

Alexis Araneta
01:38 Jul 02, 2025

Hi, Colin! Thank you so much! I wanted to allude to Sylvia Plath at the end. And yes! I decided to go all out on the literary and artistic references to show she truly wants to escape her situation. Thank you for reading!

Reply

Sandra Moody
22:50 Jul 01, 2025

Your luxuriant language and stylish romance makes the fall at the end such a gulper! Wonderful story telling.

Reply

Alexis Araneta
00:14 Jul 02, 2025

Oh, that means so much! I'm glad the ending hit you! Thank you for reading!

Reply

Ghost Writer
20:48 Jul 01, 2025

Might be one of your best pieces, Alexis. Written in your ever so elegant style with a captivating format and tragic twist of an ending. The name Allegra, albeit pretty, is an allergy medication. I'm not sure if you knew that or not. Overall, this is an early favorite to win, in my opinion.

Reply

Alexis Araneta
00:13 Jul 02, 2025

Oh that means so much! Thank you! I'm very happy you liked the style! As for the name Allegra, no I didn't know that because it doesn't have the same connotation in UK English. Now, if my bank would cooperate and let my payment get through. 😂 Thank you for reading.

Reply

17:47 Jul 01, 2025

Such a sad story about Mary, projecting herself as the fantasy version of herself, Allegra. So beautifully written as usual Alexis and the poignancy of Plath's despair and suicide provide a real sense of Mary's state of mind. Sylvia Plath is buried in the church yard where I live... she gets many visitors. Beautiful writing.

Reply

Alexis Araneta
00:16 Jul 02, 2025

Indeed, it is sad. I'm very happy you liked the story. I do hope I did Sylvia Plath justice. Thank you for reading!

Reply

14:49 Jul 02, 2025

You did her justice I am sure of that!

Reply

Alexis Araneta
00:58 Jul 02, 2025

For those wondering, I do want to enter this. I'm having issues with payment, though. It seems like an issue only with Reedsy because I was able to use it with no issues elsewhere. Welp. 😬

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.