My first thought about dying was the blast that filled the air at the same instant that I felt a sharp, stinging thud to my chest. I’d been shot by accident.
Blackness engulfed me. I remember that, like Alice, who fell down the rabbit hole, or someone plunged into sudden darkness, thinking, what is happening to me? Who will look after my son? Then nothing.
Gradually, I could see light, first as a glimmer at the end of a tunnel. My legs felt like lead. The light became brighter. A hazy face peered. Whose face? Then, my eyes were assailed by blinding light. Light all around me. A glow emanated from above. I looked around the room. Where am I? What light shines so radiantly from the ceiling?
I saw her. She sat on a chair beside me. A small girl. She stared at me solemnly.
“I love you, mama,” she said as her green eyes blinked and shimmered. With tears? She looked like me. How could she look like me?
I lay on a bed. Something beeped in a rhythmic pattern. A tube stuck into my arm with a clear bag full of fluid leading to it. How strange. Where on earth could I be? Curious and more curious.
I felt the pain. A dull pain in my bones and a feeling of nausea. It seemed different to the burning in my chest, which had vanished. A feeling of dread descended. A premonition that all was not well. Am I facing death all over again? The little girl and I stared at each other. I felt overcome with weariness. Should I close my eyes? . . . Why can’t I open my eyes?
How long have I been asleep? I must have nodded off. Gingerly, I open my eyes. I stare at a woman in the bed while sitting on the little girl’s chair. I close my eyes tight and reopen them. I’m still here, and she’s still there. There is a noise, but it has changed. One single, never-ending beep. I check over myself. I am a child. What is going on? Am I a ghost? Have I jumped from the skin of the woman who looks like me into the body of the girl who also looks like me?
Some people rush into the room. A woman grabs my hand and leads me out
“I’m so sorry, Victoria. She seemed so at peace. We had no idea your mummy would pass so soon. We were gone a few minutes.”
I looked up at her. She had tears in her eyes and resembled the woman in the bed. Her sister, maybe? I decided to say nothing until I could figure out what was going on, apart from that ‘mother’ had just died. I looked at the clock we walked past. 3 am; the witching hour had passed. Why am I still up?
***
I was taken back to a spacious, modern farmhouse. I spent much time in my room; I guessed it was mine. The decor suited a child. It had been a long time since childhood, but any little girl would have loved the pink girly decorations and fine furniture. The bed reminded me of a princess’s bed. All in pink with a scatter of contrasting cushions. A little girl stared back every time I looked in the mirror. I felt swallowed up in her life. This is where Victoria lived before I woke up in her body. Her mother had suffered from an illness called cancer. We lived here with my Aunty Ruth and Uncle Jack for years, and they looked after us. They loved me, Victoria Rose Trent. The next few days passed as a blur.
For the funeral, a lady named Pauline, dressed in maid’s attire, clothed me in a black satin, frilly dress and did my long black hair in a Pollyanna style.
My Aunt gave me flowers to throw on my mother’s coffin. Many stood around her grave crying. My Aunt took it worse. She clearly loved my mother, Rose. I couldn’t bring myself to shed a tear. It would have been hypocritical. I remained silent, even when others spoke to me. It was accepted as normal behavior after the shock of losing my mother. I really didn’t know what to say. I had the cuteness factor on my side, which helped. Sympathy for me poured out from everyone present.
Back at the house, they held the after-funeral party. Lots of wine flowed. Lots of fine food had been put out on tables. Many people arrived to offer their condolences - friends of my Aunt and Uncle and extended family members. Especially ones who knew my mother, Rose
“Why, Miss Victoria is the spit and image of her mother,” said one older lady I was introduced to. A great Aunt.
Someone else said, “She’s a dead ringer!”
I felt my cheeks burn as I looked down. Dead ringer? What sort of expression is that? I’m not dead, I thought.
“Haha. That’s an old expression that means very little these days,” said Uncle Jack. “In days of old, before they had modern methods to check the death of someone, they sometimes had people wake up in their coffins. To prevent the awful possibility of burying someone alive, they used to bury them with a string on one finger. The string led to outside the coffin and onto a bell. After burial, someone had the graveyard shift, waiting in case the bell rang. If it did, they would have to dig the person out. When they walked into the town, people would get such a fright, seeing someone they thought was dead and gone. They were literally called dead ringers. The phrase came to mean someone identical to anyone, even after the practice was abandoned. Modern medicine can accurately confirm if someone has died, now-a-days.”
Mmm. I am a dead ringer? A ghostly reflection. Someone who hasn’t really died. Except that this lost soul continues to find a new home.
I heard someone asking about my father. Turned out he had been in prison for many years. My mother, Rose, visited at the beginning of his sentence but had stopped seeing him years before. My Aunt and Uncle didn’t think much of him. Marcus Trent. The name meant nothing to me.
A couple of years later, it came to mean more, but not in a good way.
***
My Aunt and Uncle told me my father would visit. He had been paroled two years before the end of his sentence. They dressed me up to the nines. Not a wrinkle or a hair out of place. Like a show pony to be displayed. But to look my best? Or so that they could show off their affluent lifestyle?
The moment he walked into the room, I recognized him. Apart from when Rose, my mother, had died and I transferred to Victoria, he had always been the cause of my past deaths in one way or another. Panic gripped me, and I ran and hid behind the nearest sofa.
“My child is frightened of me?” said Marcus.
“What do you expect? She’s been through so much, with Rose dying. She doesn’t know you. You’ve hardly been in her life. After her mother died, she was an elective mute for several months. She hasn’t been the same child since her mother passed,” said Aunt Ruth.
“What did you tell her about me? Can’t I even see her?”
Aunt Ruth gently coaxed me out to present me to my father.
“We won’t force her,” said Uncle Jack.
I hung back, and when I looked up at Marcus, my body trembled, and my throat constricted. I buried my face in Aunt Ruth’s skirt.
Marcus faltered. “Thank you so much for the funeral bulletin you sent me. I can see how much my daughter looks like her mother. . . I loved Rose.”
“Was it love that got you involved in your father’s crimes again? To not be around for Rose or Victoria when they needed you?” Aunt Ruth was on the verge of tears.
Uncle Jack spoke. “We shouldn’t speak like this in front of Victoria. The visit is over. Can’t you see, she doesn’t even want to look at you.”
“She’s my daughter.”
“And she always will be, but you have nothing to offer her,” soothed my Aunt, “and for the past six years, we have been her family. She’s been traumatized by her mother’s passing. You need to leave her be.”
“Can I write to her then?”
“Yes, but keep it simple. We’ll check that any cards or letters are appropriate and show respect for her life with us.” Uncle Jack spoke firmly.
“What about when I am settled? Can I visit her then?”
“Only if she wants to see you. It should be up to her.”
Marcus stammered before he left. “I really did love Rose. You have no idea how much I regret everything that happened. I will return.”
I resolved to never see him again, though he seemed genuinely pained. Had he recognized me? Or did he simply believe that I was his daughter? After all, I am the mirror image of Rose, albeit a younger version.
***
For many years, he dutifully sent cards. Just the same message each time. Reassuring me of his love. Saying how much he missed my mother. Stating that he was working hard and keeping out of trouble. Promising me that he’d always be there for me. Most heartwarming, but I always just threw them in the trash. Ghosted him. Gradually, the cards became more and more infrequent. If he ever rang to come out for a visit, my Uncle told him I wouldn’t see him. I cherished his love for me, but I was still uncertain who he thought me to be. Keeping him in the dark kept us both safe.
I took steps to never feel helpless again. I learned kickboxing, and martial arts. They were horrified at my choice, but they respected it and realized I could never be a damsel in distress. They acknowledged that as I seemed to attract unwanted male admirers, with my focus on pursuing a career, it may be a helpful skill to protect myself from the unscrupulous. In the past, bearing children had been my doom.
My Aunt and Uncle treated me like their own precious child. I’ll always be indebted to them for the comfortable life they gave me. They saw the artist in me and sent me to study art in college, among other things. It was the first time in my life that I had pursued learning.
I arrived home one summer break to another letter from my father. From what I could see, my aunt and uncle hadn’t opened this one. They must have concluded they could trust him. I expect they reasoned I’d throw it in the rubbish.
My dear daughter Victoria,
It has been some time since I wrote. Better late than never, I guess. I trust that life is treating you well and you have been studying hard. You should have a better life than I had and make better choices.
I have moved out into the country to a house where I lived before. Before I married your dear mother and had you. I met a lady, related to the people who used to live there, and I now work for her. Genny has told me many interesting things about what happened after I left this place long ago. Do you remember the name, Laurena? It is her elderly granddaughter, Genevieve, who lives here. We have worked hard to get her ranch in good repair and be productive again.
Over the summer, a group of girls will stay here. We run a boot camp for wayward young ladies. Their parents send them here to rough it and have their harsh edges smoothed. Lots of horse trekking, gardening, and doing chores. It’s been hugely successful the last two summers and a lot of fun. I’d love you to join us. More as an example of how to behave. You could take them out sketching. The scenery here is fantastic. There’s an old ghost town nearby that used to be a little town called Clear Springs. There are lots of spectacular scenes to draw. Your folks have told me how well you are doing at Art School.
Please let me know if you would like to come for a couple of weeks this break. I know your mother would approve. I’ll arrange your travel and drive to the nearest airport to pick you up.
Your loving father, Marcus.
Also, dear daughter, please respond. If I don’t hear from you this time, I will believe you don’t wish to see me again. Please forgive me for leaving your mother and you when you were a baby. I loved your mother very much. I beg you for this chance to make amends.
Tears smarted my eyes. How I had tortured him for all those years. I sat and gaped at the letter, unable to move. He thinks my mother, Rose, would approve? Why has he mentioned about Laurena and Clear Springs? He’d feel at home working at the ranch house he lived in before. As for Clear Springs, I’ll never go there, derelict or not. It’s the place where I was shot to death all those years ago. He knew about it. Why did he mention the place to me? I can never return. Or is it a test? I could simply refuse to go there because it’s a ghost town? Too scary. It could be fun to finally see him and let him be a father. He’d have to respect my feelings at his place of work, with others around . . . I will go. Nothing can possibly go wrong. The letter has been written without any red herrings or specific comments for the eyes of Rose Trent only. I am merely her daughter. I’ll go discuss my holiday with Uncle Jack and Aunt Ruth.
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
49 comments
I loved the way you wrote this. I too would like a sequel. It has a haunting quality to it and the slow reveal worked well.
Reply
Thanks for the read and comment.
Reply
Wow, I love the detail! It's interesting and well written. Good job! Ellise :)
Reply
Thanks for the read and comment, Ellise.
Reply
Hi Kaitlyn! I do remember reading this one before! Its a great one and the mystery is brilliantly confined within the words Pleasure to revisit this one. I think it deserves a sequel :)
Reply
Haha. Thanks Derrick. It was not entered as after writing it a year ago (oops) the small print "Halloween' genre made me decide not to put it in. This time I put it in, and I knew you may recognise it. (You and Mary were the only 2 who read it last time) I deleted it from before and entered it properly this time. Just a few tweeks. A sequel? Mmm.
Reply
What a wonderfully and intricately woven tale. I thoroughly enjoyed your response to the given prompt.
Reply
Thanks for the read and comment, Cindy.
Reply
I get vibes of Shirley Jackson, which is how much I loved it. Kind of a Gothic, but much livelier and incisive. Very haunting and perfectly staged and developed. Good story for a dark and stormy night (with some pizza, of course!)😊👍
Reply
Thank you for your read and comment. I've had some lovely comments for this story. I liked it at the time but the feedback has been staggering. Some of my stories have had tons of research, moments of indecision, and extra effort to trim them down to size. They've practically done my head in while the deadline looms. I had an idea for this story, and I ran with it. It appeared in text, and I was a bit surprised. I really liked it. But I've really liked the others I've written too. Should I enter it? Mary Bendickson gave me the boost. Many ot...
Reply
If you feel it, and have the $5 bucks, enter it! I’ve really liked everything I’ve read from you. Yeah, Mary’s great — she gave me some websites I could try to write for.❤️ I’ve had to trim as much as almost 2000 words from stories, and I’ve had five or six mysteries I couldn’t cut that I’ve put in my Amazon books, which is possibly good since everything else is free here🤣. I hate to give an idea, especially if I’ve done a lot of research. The Arts Department stories require a crap-ton of research. One thing — I’ve been surprised by some of ...
Reply
This story is well written, and I love the secrecy behind it. Like how you slowly revealed more and more of the story. I must say I might be a little partial to the name Victoria, but really well done. Thank you for writing.
Reply
Thanks for the read and comment, Victoria.
Reply
Beautifully written. All praises.
Reply
Thanks, Alex.
Reply
I followed it, but I look for symbolism when I read. It was hauntingly beautiful and so terribly sad. Loved it.
Reply
Oh, also on another weird note, if you are an Ohio Wadsworth, we might be related.
Reply
Haha. I thought the Wadsworth's descended from Wordsworth the poet. I'm not from Ohio, sorry.
Reply
Reincarnation? If so, it's a very interesting twist for a ghost story. I still haven't figured out is Vic is good or bad. I want to say good, and that he really desires to reform to be the father he hadn't been. And also, congrats on making top 100 😀👍
Reply
Oh, really? What a surprise. Thanks for the read and comment. I think you mean Marcus. The father is Marcus, and Victoria is his daughter. A few have mentioned 'Vic,' so you have become confused. The consensus is that 'Vic' should not go holiday with her father. Danger and all that.
Reply
Thanks for the tip. I would not have realized I'm in the top 100.
Reply
Another, belated thought. Reincarnation is being born again as someone or something else, not necessarily remembering who one was. The modus operandi I employed in this story is a time travel type by shifting souls. No DeLorean to take her into the future. So, I used magic. This isn't made evident in the story. But the prompt allowed for strange and creepy things to happen. No problem. I tried to convey someone becoming the mother and then becoming the daughter as clearly as possible. I think it worked. In the character's own words, "This so...
Reply
Hi Kaitlyn, I really liked your storytelling. But I couldn't grasp the reason for Victoria being scared of her father. Did he kill her in her past life? If yes, then why??
Reply
Hi Shimmer. Good question, and thanks for the read. The information is inferred and stated in the story. At the beginning, we learn she has been shot in the chest by accident and died. (by who is another story) 2nd point, "Apart from when Rose, my mother, had died and I transferred to Victoria, he had always been the cause of my past deaths in one way or another." This is a quote. "One way or another." - does this hint at diverse unfortunate events? One fact not included is if Marcus held the gun that accidentally killed her or if his pre...
Reply
The depth of emotional layering, particularly as it progresses toward the end is high quality. Really grabs my attention, sucking me into the sad story, and makes me hope things finally smooth out for her.
Reply
A belated thanks for reading and commenting, thanks, Brian.
Reply
This story unfolds with a haunting elegance, delicately weaving themes of identity, unresolved grief, and reincarnation into a rich tapestry of family history and supernatural mystery. The protagonist’s surreal experience, oscillating between childlike innocence and adult consciousness, adds depth to her journey, particularly with lines like “I felt swallowed up in her life” and “I am merely her daughter,” which perfectly capture the character’s profound struggle between acceptance and denial of her past lives. The story’s gradual revelation...
Reply
Wow! Such an incredible and positive comment. Thank you. To tell the truth, I wrote this story for a Halloween time-of-year prompt over a year ago before I realised the prompt called for that specific genre. Oops. So, I kicked myself and didn't enter it into the competition. Only two read it and both said it should have been entered anyway. So, I thought it was worthwhile, but it's taken all this time to fit any sort of prompt. I think the whole theme of this week's prompts has been a great outlet for it.
Reply
Hi Kaitlyn, This short story was great; in particular, the way it all unravelled. I like the way you structure your narratives, they always flow and keep the reader wanting to know more. I loved your allusion to Alice in Wonderland, at the very beginning. My only "criticism" was the introduction of the letter. The transition from "rubbish" to "dear daughter " felt as though it could have been a bit smoother.
Reply
Haha. I love the way you put that. Maybe a bit of a jolt to you. It wasn't quite like that, though. It was the first letter given unopened. Why? Uncle Jack and Aunt Ruth had found nothing untoward in any other letters/cards. The letters hadn't been that frequent. From what he said in the letter, it sounds like Daddy lives somewhere remote. Maybe they overlooked checking it out because Victoria always binned them. Over time, people become complacent. Mmm maybe I should have elaborated on Victoria's mindset over it. Sorry, the word count got i...
Reply
Oh, by no means did it detract from the story. It was still a very enjoyable read.
Reply
Thank you. I do like a bit of 'criticism' to keep me on my toes.
Reply
ohh this was fantastic !
Reply
Thanks heaps, Henri. Will check you out soon.
Reply
great story much enjoyed sláinte x
Reply
Thanks for liking and commenting. I'm glad you enjoyed it.
Reply
I agree. Don't go Vic.
Reply
What if I said she did go? However, I don't believe taking young girls sketching at the ghost town will ever happen.
Reply
Loved this! Great as always, Kaitlyn!
Reply
Thanks, Jim. Enjoyed yours too.
Reply
Twisty ghostly memory.
Reply
I think it fits the prompt. It is a recycled story which was never entered. I think I might.
Reply
Sure, enter it. Never can predict what the powers that be like. Wish they would shortlist a few more. Say 5 maybe. Doesn't cost them anything other than a gift certificate that can't be used without spending more. Or won't be used at all.
Reply
LOL. They won't even use it to enter a story when you email them about a payment problem!
Reply
Wow!
Reply
Oooh, lots of drama here. I do advise Victoria not to go, though. For her safety. Lovely job !
Reply
Thanks for the read and comment, Alexis.
Reply
This is damn impressive!
Reply
Thanks, Kendal.
Reply