Contest #92 winner 🏆

On the Origin of Shadows

Submitted into Contest #92 in response to: Set your story in a countryside house that’s filled with shadows.... view prompt

250 comments

Drama Romance Fiction

There are two things I have always wanted you to know about the house. Ever since you picked it out, in the middle of a recession, at a heavy discount, as you put it. As if it was a carton of milk about to go out of date. For us, you said, finally away from the hustle. And there are two things I have wanted to tell you. But I didn’t know how.


1. I hate the glass door to the back garden. It’s like a wound barely held by shaggy stitches. One measly screwdriver stuck into the lock would suffice to split it open, exposing the house’s organs viable to sell on the black market. The hall like intestines, dark and humid, slapped with some nonsensical paintings you were certain would triple in value sometime. The bathroom like a liver, maroon and old-fashioned, an old bonsai fig ruling over the windowsill. You always prayed it wouldn’t just drop dead, except trees don’t do that, you know, they die standing. ‘It will be worth a fortune one day.’ At night, it cast a shadow like a mad broom that developed an evil mind of its own and wanted to sweep us under the rug when we came in for a midnight pee.

I wonder what our bedroom would be if it were a body part. The spleen comes to mind, an organ so forgotten nobody can remember what it does. I looked it up and the spleen filters bad blood as it turns out. That’s about right, more often than not, we argued in bed instead of, and then you bought the big TV. ‘Who puts a screen in their bedroom?’ I asked you. ‘Couples with,’ you replied, ‘You know.’ Or couples without. Prepositions were often missing their nouns in our relationship.

So many people turned up for the housewarming party, old neighbours and new, and your colleagues from work, remember? You were a popular man, the best of. I was carrying a big pitcher of margaritas to the back garden. I wonder if anyone actually likes those, the snot-like mixture that smells vaguely of poison, acidic dreams and delirium. 

Through the glass door, I saw the backyard, plated gold by the setting sun, and your long shadow. ‘Oh, really?’ you said and it sounded so seductive I thought you had to be talking to me. How did you know I was there? Was it that smell of tequila?

And then, a different shadow stepped into yours, and I couldn’t tell them apart anymore. I stared at the blinding concrete tiles until the shapes separated again, yours straight and simple, hers like an hourglass. No words were said. Your favourite co-worker came through and stood next to me until you split in two again as if by the hand of an invisible shadow puppeteer. No words were said.

‘Why were you hugging her?’ I asked you later that night, one of our first nights in the new bed, with lights off. 

‘She’s going through,’ you trailed off. A dreadful divorce, I know. If I’d had a nickel for every time you said that, I could have probably been able to afford a packet of condoms for you.

The sheets rustled as you turned away to sleep, and your outline became a shadow of a mountainous landscape. I guess you could only ever be straight with her, and I recalled your outline in the blinding sun, imagining stepping on it and bashing its head in.

Time seemed to flow differently in the new house, leaking into all the new rooms which didn’t quite understand their purpose, and weeks were punctuated by new purchases like semicolons, separating one arbitrary chunk of life from the other.

You brought another painting home that day and told me it would hang on the top of the stairs, and I nodded. You unwrapped it and stepped back to join me, but I wasn’t looking. There was a gold smudge on the lapel of your shirt. ‘What’s that?’ I asked. You turned your head to examine it, which gave you a double chin. ‘It’s eye shadow,’ I added, you looked away to the glass door, and your eyes drowned in light, extricating all expression I could have guessed from the size of your pupils. 

‘Yes. She was crying today. Her ex is trying to take away,’ you explained and the missing part was substituted for a vague hand wave of a prestidigitator. What? The house? The kids? The chicken pad thai?

If I’d said something then, it would have been the beginning of the end. But I didn’t, and some invisible line shifted closer towards me and I couldn’t inch away again. The shadows took on new colours every time and appeared on different parts of your wardrobe, cuffs, collars, and once, even your boxer shorts. She’d always worn a lot of makeup. I called your favourite co-worker, the one who stood by me and watched you intertwine once. ‘She is going through that divorce,’ he said, his voice flattened by the small speaker on the phone, and I didn’t cry to him. ‘Would you like me to come over?’ he asked, but his pitch didn’t rise at the end of the question, and he clicked off.

I told you I’d be working late that day, but I ended up coming home for lunch. It’d turned out, you know what, never mind. It doesn’t matter. I saw her car in the driveway, so I entered through the back door, turning the almost symbolic, meaningless key in the lock. All I really needed was a hairpin to pick it. Did you secretly want someone to break in and steal all your paintings and your hag tree, so there would be nothing left but the two of us, pumping air instead of blood in the house’s hardened veins?

I sat in the living room and waited on the desolate corner chair we couldn’t think of putting anywhere useful. You didn’t even spot me when you finally came in. I still like to think it was only because I was covered in a shadow so deep it felt like a blanket. But I know really that you couldn’t see me anymore, no more than you could see the works of art you so thoughtfully procured not for our viewing pleasure, but as a colourful investment.

We didn’t argue and you only took half the things and I didn’t argue. I wanted to keep the painting at the top of the stairs, and you didn’t argue, and you instructed me to wait for a couple more years before selling and I didn’t argue. You asked about the tree and I told you to feel free to it and I didn’t argue at all. I was relieved it wouldn’t try to get me at night anymore.

I’ve got rid of the glass door right after you’d moved out. It wasn’t cheap, but now, I can’t ever recreate that scene, the pitcher radiating cold, the concrete sparkling gold, the merging shadows staining my perfect garden floor. There’s now a wall where the door was, and the wound has closed, leaving no scar at all.

I often think about the useless rooms now, and what they are, and I think the house is one big brain, mine only to think and feel as I please. I gave the living room chair away to charity. I never wanted to sit in it again. Each room is like a lobe of my mind, and I have no photos of you up on the walls. The wallpapers underneath where they used to hang are a little lighter and fresher, and I ask people to take pictures of me when we go out, when I holiday with friends, at family events, dates. I get given new frames for Christmas and the bald wall patches disappear one by one.


2. The second thing I’ve always wanted to tell you about this house is that I’d slept with your favourite co-worker in our new bed before we ever did, and when you said it smelled used and considered returning it, that was just his sweat and mine. And when you pointed out the rash I had on my neck and breasts, that was just scratches from his five o’clock shadow.

May 05, 2021 12:09

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

250 comments

Zilla Babbitt
15:07 May 15, 2021

I always trail off on my sentences, which I need to work on, but... Anyway, really well done. You are certainly a roll and I look forward to what you have to offer in the future. You have a new follower for sure. Deserved win!

Reply

Nina Chyll
15:26 May 15, 2021

Haha, good point well made there. Thank you very much and I hope I won't disappoint!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Nathan Schaefer
13:15 May 15, 2021

Twists within twists. I'm still trying to wrap my head around it after reading it several times. Very well done!

Reply

Nina Chyll
13:39 May 15, 2021

Thank you. I'm very flattered!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
11:45 May 15, 2021

What a twist at the end. I wasn't expecting it. I wasn't sure at first if I was going to like your story, but I was hooked within a few paragraphs. The details and imagery were outstanding. I truly loved what you did with this prompt. Congratulations on the win!

Reply

Nina Chyll
13:45 May 15, 2021

I'm getting a little reader friction on this one, with some commenters saying it's not quite their type of story. I wonder whether it's down to the plotline or the style or the voice I used for the narrative - because I'm not entirely sure I like the protagonist myself. Thank you for your honesty and for the lovely comment.

Reply

16:55 May 15, 2021

I'm usually leery of letter type stories, but this one really captured my attention. Within a few paragraphs I got over that and dived deep into the story.

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Georgia Papp
11:11 May 15, 2021

Excellent. Congratulations!

Reply

Nina Chyll
13:46 May 15, 2021

Thanks a lot!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Black Swan20
08:46 May 15, 2021

😁😁 the story was hillarious. And I love the wife's cool tone when she included that oh she also cheated on him 😁

Reply

Nina Chyll
10:46 May 15, 2021

Glad you found something for yourself in there! Thank you very much for reading.

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Evi T
07:41 May 15, 2021

Congratulations! Your prose is remarkable. Very engaging story from start to finish, ingenious use of the prompt, unique metaphors and so much more I am probably forgetting. The description of the house as a living organism really hooked me and the organic addition of various types of shadows throughout the story was impressive. I believe somebody else mentioned that it felt like a theatrical monologue and I completely agree. Congratulations, again!

Reply

Nina Chyll
10:46 May 15, 2021

Thank you very much! I am glad a lot of people seem to enjoy the parts I was a little apprehensive about, the positive feedback on those themes means a lot to me. Thank you for reading and your thoughtful comment!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
R Vairagi
07:09 May 15, 2021

what a great story! its like a flow of a river. so smooth!

Reply

Nina Chyll
10:47 May 15, 2021

Thank you very much for the kind compliment.

Reply

R Vairagi
04:27 May 21, 2021

can you please give me some suggestions about short story writing !!??

Reply

Show 0 replies
R Vairagi
04:27 May 21, 2021

can you please give me some suggestions about short story writing !!??

Reply

Show 0 replies
R Vairagi
04:27 May 21, 2021

can you please give me some suggestions about short story writing !!??

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 12 replies
Show 1 reply
06:32 May 15, 2021

I read this and felt like I took a masterclass in the short story done right! The house as a body, the make up as shadow. Amazing.

Reply

Nina Chyll
10:47 May 15, 2021

Gosh, I don't know what to say! I'm so flattered - thank you.

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Alice Clements
05:54 May 15, 2021

I don't like this... I LOVE IT. The way you described the house, as it if i was alive, and the way you even described the husbands' actions even, it was beautiful! It made my stomach churn with emotions, and maybe a little bit of sickness, because i felt like this had a splash of suspense, thriller and mystery in it.

Reply

Nina Chyll
10:48 May 15, 2021

Oh I'm glad someone thought it was just that tiny bit of suspense, too, among all the drama. Thank you very much for your kind comment.

Reply

Alice Clements
11:10 May 15, 2021

Your welcome! I can see that you are a very talented writer, in fact, you could easily be able to publish something with this type of work. You definitely deserved to win, congratulations!

Reply

Nina Chyll
13:46 May 15, 2021

Wow, thank you for the kind words yet again!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Ramona Taylor
05:28 May 15, 2021

Congratulations. I loved the rhythm of the words in your story and I enjoyed reading it very much.

Reply

Nina Chyll
10:48 May 15, 2021

Thanks a lot!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Sivaprakash .
03:29 May 15, 2021

Wow! An unique style of writing! And good job with second person narrative! The descriptions were so vivid!

Reply

Nina Chyll
10:48 May 15, 2021

Thank you very much. I dabbled with second person before but it never used to come out quite right, so I'm glad this one did!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Si Guy 123
00:48 May 15, 2021

Wow nice story! second win congratulations! you deserved it! But do you always have to write sad stories? Just joking :D Loved it!

Reply

Nina Chyll
10:50 May 15, 2021

I've been told I need to flex those comedy muscles, or at least try and hit some neutral tones, but I have to say they're either atrophied beyond recognition or I just don't have them! Thanks a lot for commenting, much appreciated.

Reply

Si Guy 123
11:27 May 15, 2021

Yes, my sister (username WAIII) is the same, she can't not write about depressing events ;D

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Jacqueline Njawe
21:53 May 14, 2021

Great story Nina. Gave me chills. Congratulations on the well deserved win.

Reply

Nina Chyll
10:50 May 15, 2021

Thank you very much. I appreciate the kind feedback!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Steven Rensch
20:47 May 14, 2021

Terrific story, Nina. Short but impactful.

Reply

Nina Chyll
20:57 May 14, 2021

Thank you very much. Not sure how I resisted the temptation to ramble on!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Adam Schwartz
20:21 May 14, 2021

Congrats on the win! Great story and really great voice throughout.

Reply

Nina Chyll
20:22 May 14, 2021

Thank you very much!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Rachel Mann
19:49 May 14, 2021

I had a feeling this would win this week! Congratulations 😊

Reply

Nina Chyll
10:52 May 15, 2021

Ha! Then you certainly have a better intuition than me. Thank you very much for the comment.

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
19:44 May 14, 2021

A fabulous composition. A deserving winner. Congratulations.

Reply

Nina Chyll
20:15 May 14, 2021

Thank you very much!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Cienna Johnson
19:01 May 14, 2021

Great win!

Reply

Nina Chyll
20:15 May 14, 2021

Big cheers!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Carine Coetsee
18:48 May 14, 2021

Congratulations on the win. If I understand correctly, the shadows you are talking about are the shadows of deception and how you hide behind them if you are hiding some secret, from your partner. Clever explaining it that way. Great writing. You deserve the win.

Reply

Nina Chyll
20:18 May 14, 2021

Initially, the idea for the story had some shadow idioms interwoven in it, and I toyed with the idea of spelling it out as shadows of deception at some point, so you’ve certainly tapped into my train of thought! Thank you very much for your comment.

Reply

Carine Coetsee
22:00 May 14, 2021

If you would not mind reading my story. I would love some feedback, please.

Reply

Nina Chyll
22:33 May 14, 2021

Of course, I’ll bank it.

Reply

Carine Coetsee
22:12 May 15, 2021

Thank you very much. Looking forward to hearing from you.

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Carine Coetsee
20:47 May 14, 2021

My Pleasure

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 2 replies
Show 1 reply
Marianna Mills
18:15 May 14, 2021

ONce again you won and well deserved, beautiful piece of work. In lieu of the category deal I agree, it is sometimes hard to classify where something fits in exactly, but that's what the site wants. congrats once again Nina. Keep writing, u might make a living someday. Explore different venues.

Reply

Nina Chyll
20:20 May 14, 2021

Part of the decision to classify this story as romance was the idea of utilising the same kind of bitter sarcasm that permeates the musings of the narrator if that makes sense. I will keep writing indeed! Thank you very much for the support and right back at you.

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.