558 comments

Creative Nonfiction

Hi guys,


I only joined Reedsy around 4 months ago. I have been embroiled in some really crazy politics here, and I just wanted to share my opinions on some topics. First off, upvoting. Upvoting insane amounts is not good for the site, as it makes people more paranoid about their points and more willing to beg for points rather than earning them through writing. Critiques, on the other hand, are like teaching a man to fish rather than giving him a fish. Upvotes can be doled out in small amounts, and a strong sense of community should be the binding force, not a sense of protection of points. Let me make myself clear: REEDSY. IS. A. WRITING. CONTEST. Not a point contest (Zilla would totally win XD) but a contest based on good writing. It is not right to have a ton of points but very little stories and, even then, stories of questionable quality. We need to maintain the purpose of the site and stop worrying about the points. If anyone needs critiques, I'm here. Secondly, about the Marshmallows. I was one of the founders and people have come to think of them as role models and helpers of the community. However, there are other ways to do this. People argue that Marshmallows are good for people. There are other ways to make people happy, and there are certainly better ways to include someone in the community. Felicity Williams, one of my most devoted followers at the beginning of my account, did not make me happy through upvotes, but by being positive, complimenting, and giving helpful critiques. By being HELPFUL and INCLUSIVE, we can gain a better community and better collective happiness. If upvoting is your way of doing that, then you can continue. However, we are no longer an upvoting group. We are a group that makes a community and love. Lastly, the Age issue. If you are on Reedsy and are less than 18, I believe that is permitted by the rules and by my standards. However, do not expect to, even if your writing is über-awesome-amazing, win a contest. I hope you all understand that what I'm saying isn't to shut anyone down but to redirect you, to show you a better way. If you want to continue to upvote habitually, that's fine with me, I won't call you out. I'm not a cancel-culturer. However, I do implore you to see reason. Felicity Williams, an author no longer active on here, is the paragon of what I am saying. She gave me inspiration and love as a fledgling author and she complimented me. Just having her pay attention to my stories made me want to be her friend. Take her as an example. I would like to label this new idea of how to create a sense of community as inspired by Felicity Williams. Please take her example and take my and Upvoter's example. This is a consensus between me, Upvoter, and an unknown person on the leaderboard who has created the alt account of Prove me Wrong. Be a Felicity.


I love you all and wish you the best health (physical and mental) and happy writing,

Luke.


P.S. Think about what I have said

January 15, 2021 00:15

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

558 comments

Radhika Diksha
16:20 Jan 15, 2021

Luke, can you brainstorm ideas? Because we were going on the right path.

Reply

. .
16:26 Jan 15, 2021

I think that it isn’t necessary because the CC already does these things

Reply

Radhika Diksha
16:53 Jan 15, 2021

see actually, no one is getting my points. Yes, I do want people to give critiques for each other. All I want to do is give exposure to the unseen writers. That's it. We all have to pick a writer and a story for the week. Bill is getting massive support. What unique ideas do you want to add?

Reply

Show 0 replies
Radhika Diksha
16:53 Jan 15, 2021

see actually, no one is getting my points. Yes, I do want people to give critiques to each other. All I want to do is give exposure to the unseen writers. That's it. We all have to pick a writer and a story for the week. Bill is getting massive support. What unique ideas do you want to add?

Reply

. .
16:55 Jan 15, 2021

That's also what the critique circle does, and we can just make it a plan to shoutout some authors. I just don't see the necessity in making it such a big deal. Yes, we can shoutout writers every week, but that should be an individual thing.

Reply

Radhika Diksha
17:04 Jan 15, 2021

But if we collective people have the same bio containing the writers and stories that we recommend. THen those writers will get more exposure. Critique circle has never helped me. I myself had to ask people then I got recommendations. And sometimes due to the tight friendship between people, they don't give feedback to each other.

Reply

. .
17:25 Jan 15, 2021

Ok, well I would like to remain friends with you, but I would like to just be a Mallow.

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Radhika Diksha
17:05 Jan 15, 2021

By the way, you can read the guidelines in my bio to properly understand.

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 3 replies
Show 1 reply
Maya -
15:22 Jan 15, 2021

Can I join OASIS, if that's how it works?

Reply

. .
15:23 Jan 15, 2021

Ask Radhika and take the thing from Kate's bio!!

Reply

Maya -
15:24 Jan 15, 2021

Okay thanks!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Kate Reynolds
02:59 Jan 15, 2021

First of all: this was such a well-written message to all the authors here in Reedsy. I agree with what you said, and we really should focus more on the story quality than the amount of points. Second: YESSS be a Felicity!! That is such a good message!!! Third: don’t feel bad for being on the leaderboard, bc you really deserve it!!! Your stories are amazing (and reallyyyy emotional). You’ve also written quite a lot- (compared to me at least XD)

Reply

. .
13:22 Jan 15, 2021

:D Thanks so much, Kate. You're a great author and you do deserve to be on there.

Reply

Kate Reynolds
13:25 Jan 15, 2021

Ofc! Thank you, but I still have lots of room to improve.

Reply

. .
13:25 Jan 15, 2021

:D Well practice makes parfait

Reply

Kate Reynolds
13:28 Jan 15, 2021

Yep!

Reply

. .
13:32 Jan 15, 2021

:DDDDDDDDD

Reply

Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply

LUKE GET HERE NOW https://blog.reedsy.com/directories/comments/300606/

Reply

. .
02:20 Jan 15, 2021

It says it doesn't exist...

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Maya -
02:07 Jan 15, 2021

LUKE YOU NEED TO COME TO THE THREAD ON MEGAN'S STORY AND HELP CONVINCE HER TO STAY!!!

Reply

. .
02:22 Jan 15, 2021

I CAN'T FIND IT

Reply

Maya -
02:23 Jan 15, 2021

It was deleted. I don't know why. Make a new one!

Reply

. .
02:25 Jan 15, 2021

Yas

Reply

Maya -
02:27 Jan 15, 2021

Can you send me the link?

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Maya -
02:24 Jan 15, 2021

Her bio doesn't say she's leaving anymore... ?

Reply

. .
02:25 Jan 15, 2021

Yayyyyy

Reply

Maya -
02:26 Jan 15, 2021

Is she staying?????

Reply

Show 0 replies
Maya -
02:33 Jan 15, 2021

OMG I THINK SHE ISN'T GOING TO LEAVE!!!!!

Reply

. .
13:21 Jan 15, 2021

YASSSSS

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Show 2 replies
Show 1 reply
Show 2 replies
Show 1 reply
Mira Caplan
01:00 Jan 15, 2021

Aaaaaawwwwwww, yay! (Idk what to say, but...yay?) That last line before the P.S really did make me feel marshmallow-y. It was general, I know, but still. HAPPY WRITING, BESTIEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEe

Reply

. .
01:00 Jan 15, 2021

BESTIEEEEEEEEEEE

Reply

Mira Caplan
01:03 Jan 15, 2021

YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!!!! Btw, YOU NEED TO WRITE MALFICE ASAP!!! The worldbuilding isn't TOV or TDR level because you haven't put in the time!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I NEED TO BOARD ADYONA!!!

Reply

. .
01:11 Jan 15, 2021

XDDDDDDDDDDD FINE

Reply

Mira Caplan
01:13 Jan 15, 2021

YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Tomorrow's async, right??? WE CAN VCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC

Reply

. .
02:22 Jan 15, 2021

YASSSSS

Reply

Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
<inactive> .
04:54 Jan 20, 2021

this community is destroying itself from the inside out can't we all just take a breather and WRITE instead of debating about upvoting or downvoting? this platform was supposed to be for showcasing talent, and while that is what we're doing, we're making huge rifts along the way. i'm already getting deja vu from the dark ages of the gacha community this community is going persevere because unlike the gacha community, there are adults here and adults nearly always figure stuff out also sorry about the hot thing, i was referring to the charact...

Reply

. .
12:24 Jan 20, 2021

I agreeeeeeeeeeeeee XD

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. 100% free.