Contest #178 winner 🏆

128 comments

Christmas Crime Fiction

Squat, beige and Soviet, the Marie Antoinette Apartments stood against the stale gray Minneapolis sky. Irony of the worst kind, he thought, blandly ugly and unconscious. He would take exquisitely self-aware irony any day over this three-story architectural monstrosity, “classed up” with tacked on ionic Greek columns, harsh blue LED Christmas lights wrapped inexpertly around them, canned Christmas classics pumping through the air.


God, this place was only better than minimum security prison by a hair. But it was all he could afford now, so he’d just have to lower his eyes—and his standards—every time he approached. He tried to avoid the other people in the building, but a few of the near indigent souls, especially the family across the hall, insisted on pestering him with their lowbrow holiday cheer—the cheap gift of homemade cookies, the invitation of a seat at their dinner table on Christmas night on the flip side of a child’s crude drawing of a Christmas tree slipped under his door.


All this might have been more bearable if anyone he knew now understood why the Marie Antoinette Apartments pained his soul, filled him with righteous rage. He’d certainly never get that from his obtuse, court-appointed therapist, a small, garish woman whose office and clothing reeked of TJ Maxx. So, he amused himself by using up their fifty minutes complaining about how much he hated living there.


His fingers itched to blow the place up, her told her. To set it alight. She told him there were healthier ways to channel and examine his negative emotions so he could eventually let them go. He needed to think about what the Marie Antoinette represented to him, she told him, to look deeper, and to perhaps think about its positive attributes instead. 


This made him laugh hysterically. How much deeper can I go than living inside the damned building? Should I dive into the meaning of my laminate, faux wood floors and Formica kitchen counters, the rancid smell of old cooking that oozes from the graying, cracked walls studded with nail holes and abandoned, archeological remnants of tape from all the miserable souls who inhabited the purgatory before me? How about the rust-stained, leaking toilet and body-oil-marked tub? Should I look for Rorshachs in its grimy patterns?


That’s not what I meant, she said quietly, and you know it.


Well, I cherish my negative emotions, he said, suddenly tired. They’re the only things keeping me going these days.

~

Near morning a couple of weeks before Christmas, after one too many sleeping pills, he had a vivid dream. 


It started out of focus as he dragged himself toward the Marie Antoinette, bearing his usual cloak of heavy, gray resignation and pushed hard against the main door, as he always had to. Only this time, the door sprang open and instead of jarring, cold Christmas music, warm strains of exquisite chamber music vibrated through him. All came into focus. The entryway had grown to twice its size, the gray, non-descript industrial carpet replaced with a glowing, mahogany parquet floor. Instead of aluminum mailboxes and a frameless wall mirror on either side of the narrow space, giant gilt mirrors reflecting golden candlelight and gold and cream fleur-de-lis silk wallpaper covered the walls. The walls heaved outward until the room became what it wanted to be--a grand palace ballroom, complete with gently tinkling, candle-lit chandeliers. A ballroom for him alone.


The effect was ostentatious but stunning, the way his ex-wife had decorated their homes in the city, on the island, at the lake, near the slopes—their homes for every preposition—all gone now. He dream-prayed he had died and gone to heaven. 


But he awoke to the same ordinary life, the drab apartment, a shift at the same greasy job, and another boring session after it with his therapist, the only person he ever said more to than can-I-take-your-order-would-you-like-fries-with-that. A woman he would have sneered at, if not ignored, in his old life and would again someday when his luck turned. Would he tell her about his dream? He decided he would. It seemed safe enough, wasn’t about the past, the present, or even the future. It was just a dream.


But was it? As his workday dragged on, the customers who filed into the restaurant looked at him, smiling, with something more, it seemed to him, than mere pre-Christmas cheer. He began to wonder if the dream wasn’t a message. Maybe his luck was about to turn. He’d paid his dues after all.


That old feeling began to tingle again. 


By the time his four o’clock appointment with TJ (as he’d taken to calling her, even to her face) arrived, he’d decided he must keep the dream to himself until he knew more. He had to get through the session, get home, eat a little something and take his sleeping pills.


You seem distracted today, TJ said late in the hour. Something happen this week?


Same old, same old. Same crappy job, same crappy apartment. He shifted his gaze to the pressed board Believe! plaque near the window before she could read him, but she was astute, this small, tacky woman. Out of the corner of his eye, he saw her cock her head.


You’re not complaining like you usually do. Did something change?


Like I said, nope. Maybe I’ve adjusted to living in a shithole, I dunno. He attempted to give her an aw shucksgrin, but felt his face contorting in weird ways, so he scrambled to throw her a bone.


Have I told you about my neighbors across the way? He leaned back and sneered, coming up with an awful lie. I’d swear to god she’s killing him sometimes, and, man, I wish she’d succeed so I can get some rest. What do you think it means, doc, that I don’t care if he dies?


TJ sighed and drummed her red fingernails on her thigh. It’s clsoe four-fifty, she said. Let’s just pick this up next week. 

~

The dream started the same as before. Heavy quotidian dread as he approached the stunted building, growing excitement and wonder as it opened to a Versailles-like hall of mirrors. But this time, the hall was filled with people, giant people, people twice his height, in silken, 18th century finery, swirling and spinning around the room, wind-up dolls in white wigs with faces he recognized. His old clients, wealthy people he’d cheated and stolen from for years, people he’d fooled into being his friends. People from the life he wanted back desperately. 


He tried to speak, to get their attention, but nothing came, not even air. As he watched, the dancers grew larger. Wait, no—he grew smaller. He was shrinking, becoming more and more insignificant. An insect. A speck. Dirt.


He would always be dirt.

~

He stumbled through the rest of the week, his nights vast and dreamless. TJ seemed surprised to see him in the waiting room early but said nothing. He sat on her couch, cleared his throat. I had this dream, he said. That my building became a palace, but one I will never have access to again. His voice shook. 


She handed him the tissue box. Yes. 


He gave her a brief description of the dream.


What do you think it means? she asked. 


Isn’t that your job?


No, she said simply, and crossed her arms, waiting.


I guess…I don’t think I’ll ever again have the life I had before. I don’t think, he said, swallowed, I deserve it.


No, she said again, not clarifying what she meant, which oddly, made him feel more respect for her. 


So, what now?


That’s up to you. 


Well, a hint might be nice, he whispered, wanting to scream. He swallowed you are my damn therapist after all.


Okay. What do you miss most about your old life? Not from in here. She tapped her head. Not ego. From here. She tapped her chest. Heart. What do you really miss?


He shook his head. I dunno. Without those things on the table, nothing. I mean, I don’t have kids, my ex-wife was a money-grubbing bitch, and my friends…shit, I didn’t really have those. Maybe luck? But that’s not what you mean either. I know what you’re getting at, but you’re barking up the wrong tree.


She smiled, the first full smile he’d seen from her since they’d met, before she’d gotten to know him. I don’t think so. I think you’re getting somewhere. Maybe your dream was telling you more than you think. Like I’ve said before, dig deeper, go further. The answers are there, inside that building and inside you.


He choked back a snarky whatever Obi Wan, and nodded at her. Glancing at the clock above the door, he stood, smoothing his sweaty palms against his jeans.


Hold on. She held up a finger and smiled again. I have something for you.


He stared, not comprehending. She turned to fish something out of a paper bag then turned back, holding out a flat package wrapped in green tissue paper and red curly ribbon. Of course. Christmas was only four days away.


He stammered, cheeks reddening, I didn’t get you anything. He didn’t know why he was embarrassed, which only made him blush harder.


She laughed. I was not expecting you to. Don’t worry about it, it’s no big deal. Merry Christmas.


Merry, yeah, he said, looking down at his name, Jeb, in black marker on the paper, an inexpertly drawn holly leaf and berries below it. A feeling spread, not altogether unpleasant, replacing ungenerous thoughts about the cheesy gift she’d likely procured at TJ Maxx. 


Thank you, Geraldine, he mumbled and bumbled out the door.

~

He worked Christmas Eve day, took the bus and trudged home as the sun set again too early, the day again too short, carrying his fast-food dinner and a bottle of California pinot noir he’d splurged on. It was only four, but it felt like midnight, and his near unfurnished apartment felt more featureless and tired and depressing than prison ever had been. Because it was his choice to leave it so, he realized.


He had nowhere else to go, so he busied himself with eating and drinking, the food cold and congealed, and the wine’s mediocrity disappointing. Folding up the empty, redolent burger paper and fries’ box, he glanced at the present Geraldine had given him, still unopened on the kitchen counter. He wasn’t sure whether he’d saved it because it was his only gift, or because he didn’t really care about it. Either way, he might as well open it now.


He washed his greasy hands in the kitchen sink and poured another glass of wine. He picked up the gift and carefully untied the red ribbon, did his best not to tear the green paper as he picked at the tape, then slid the paper away. 


Not a tacky nothing after all, but a green, leatherbound book, like the ones his ex-wife had bought by the shelf load from antiquaries to decorate their homes, curated for color and size rather than content. But this wasn’t inert decoration. It was chosen for him to read. 


He snorted. Crime and Punishment. He knew the gist of the story, though he suspected he’d have to read it to get the nuances she intended. Funny, he found himself looking forward to it. 


His doorbell rang. Book in hand, still smiling with surprised respect for Geraldine, he answered the door to find the frazzled woman from across the hall. 


Hi. Jeb, right? Her grin was crooked, a little shy. Infectious. He nodded, and she said, Marissa. You never responded to our invite to dinner for tomorrow evening. Can you make it? We’d be glad to have you. We’re making turkey with all the fixings. A couple other neighbors are coming.


He considered this only a moment, tasting the oily coating of his pitiful dinner as he licked his lips. You know what, yes, Marissa. I’d be honored. Can I bring anything?


Just yourself. She grinned again. Six o’clock sharp, if that’s okay, because of the munchkins’ early bedtime.


Sure, he said, finding himself grinning in response. Six.


Great. She glanced at his book, then inside the doorway at his near bare apartment. Looks like a bookshelf is in order, hunh? Maybe even a sofa? She laughed.


He couldn’t help but laugh with her. Yes, he said. It’s time. Again, that soft, warm lightness pushing out something hard and heavy he hadn’t even known was there. What was it? 


Only later, while lying on his secondhand mattress on the floor, after he’d read the long first part of the leatherbound book about young, impoverished Raskolnikov scheming and rationalizing his decision to murder a pawnbroker for her money, did it come to him. Like Raskolnikov, he'd lost something along the way. Something essential and tender that had shriveled to a hard stone inside him once he began to drip Ponzi-scheme money. Something poor-little-rich girl Marie Antoinette likely never knew her entire tragic, gold-plated life.


That night he dreamt again, a simple dream. The Marie Antoinette Apartments remained an ugly, pedestrian building, but he entered with lightness, that warmth down to his bones. He greeted neighbors in the lobby by name, delivered groceries to the housebound old lady down the hall, went into his simply but warmly furnished apartment to make himself a nourishing meal. 


Christmas morning, he leapt out of bed. If he was lucky, he might find gifts for the children across the hall before noon.

December 24, 2022 19:14

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

128 comments

Story Time
18:44 Jan 06, 2023

"He had nowhere else to go, so he busied himself with eating and drinking, the food cold and congealed, and the wine’s mediocrity disappointing. Folding up the empty, redolent burger paper and fries’ box, he glanced at the present Geraldine had given him, still unopened on the kitchen counter." This sort of imagery put me right in the heart of the setting. I love the careful choice in what to reveal and what to leave us to fill in for ourselves as readers. Wonderful job.

Reply

Molly Kelash
19:11 Jan 06, 2023

That's always the balance, isn't it, what to leave in and what to leave out? I'm so glad it seemed to hit the mark for you and others. Thanks!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Jennifer O
18:20 Jan 06, 2023

I really enjoyed this - a well deserved win, well done!

Reply

Molly Kelash
19:09 Jan 06, 2023

Thank you!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Kate Winchester
18:06 Jan 06, 2023

I loved this! Congrats on the win, well deserved 🤗

Reply

Molly Kelash
19:09 Jan 06, 2023

Thank you!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Yanique Gayle
18:05 Jan 06, 2023

Excelente. Me encantó. This was an exceptional read. I truly enjoyed it. Love your writing skills. An awesome way of eliminating unncessary structured dialogues. Great piece. So modern and unique. Congrats.

Reply

Molly Kelash
19:09 Jan 06, 2023

Thank you1 I had fun paring down the dialogue structure, which somehow felt right with the MC's state of mind. :)

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Viga Boland
17:20 Jan 06, 2023

Given I was the judge who shortlisted your story, I’m thrilled others agreed and you won this contest! Congratulations!

Reply

Molly Kelash
19:07 Jan 06, 2023

I am so appreciative that you saw something worthwhile in this story, Viga! 2022 was a rough year for me, so winning this has given me a real boost going into 2023. :)

Reply

Viga Boland
17:10 Jan 07, 2023

Promise yourself that you’ll write more in 2023. The year will be over before you know it.

Reply

Molly Kelash
20:01 Jan 07, 2023

Will do! :)

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Diamond Star
17:05 Jan 06, 2023

Great story! Beautifully written and I love the progression of Jeb's tale.

Reply

Show 0 replies
Wendy Kaminski
17:02 Jan 06, 2023

Congratulations on your win! :)

Reply

Show 0 replies
David Dicaire
16:42 Jan 06, 2023

Excellent story. You are a natural born storyteller.

Reply

Molly Kelash
19:04 Jan 06, 2023

Many thanks!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Jay Long
15:59 Jan 06, 2023

What a great use of the prompt. Excellent. Youre really good at creating a voice.

Reply

Molly Kelash
19:03 Jan 06, 2023

Thanks, Jay. :)

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
AnneMarie Miles
15:44 Jan 06, 2023

Amazing!!! Congratulations!! 🎉🎉🎉

Reply

Molly Kelash
19:03 Jan 06, 2023

Thank you1

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
12:19 Jan 06, 2023

Enjoyed reading this, somehow the Marie Antoinette Apartments being his nemesis was v funny, and the dreams and banter with the 'court appointed counselor' gave it all the perfect amount of tension to take us to the very Christmas spirited ending.

Reply

Molly Kelash
19:03 Jan 06, 2023

Thank you! Believe it or not, the Marie Antoinette Apartments actually exist here in Minneapolis, a very tangible inspiration for me.

Reply

01:53 Jan 07, 2023

Nice, I think a lot of specific real details help make short stories more interesting. And congrats on winning the contest! I should have explored more of Minneapolis when I was growing up as we're sort of neighbors on the map, but its a really long drive from Milwaukee.

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
AnneMarie Miles
06:39 Jan 04, 2023

Hi Molly. This is my first time reading you, and I hope to read more. This was lovely. Your words were so descriptive and vivid, much like sleeping-pill induced dreams! I appreciated the voice of this grumpy Scrooge and the interweaving of the dreams certainly felt like an alternative approach to the Christmas Carol. Very modern to have a therapist in the role of the ghosties. I appreciated that. Good luck this week, and looking forward to more of your work!

Reply

Molly Kelash
18:25 Jan 04, 2023

Thank you, Anne Marie! I am so glad everyone is catching the Christmas Carol vibes--I wanted it fairly subtle, but not lost. I hope to participate a bit more in these competitions, so look forward to reading you as well!

Reply

AnneMarie Miles
18:45 Jan 04, 2023

You definitely accomplished a subtle approach. It was done in such an expertise way that one may have missed it if Christmas were not the theme. I do hope you continue on. I've found Reedsy to be the best community I've ever been apart of. Hope you find the same, too.

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Rebecca Miles
21:26 Jan 03, 2023

It's bedtime for me here in Germany so I won't write much, but just to say your imagery- for all the senses- just sparks. The descriptions of the Marie Antoinette apartment is just so wonderfully offensive! Also the dialogue, you weave it in so fluidly that this heartwarming but believable story really flows. Well done!

Reply

Molly Kelash
21:31 Jan 03, 2023

Thank you, Rebecca, especially for putting off bedtime to read this. I'm glad his offensive state of mind came through in the description of the apartment building since the building is meant to be a reflection of his psyche for sure. Sleep well!

Reply

Rebecca Miles
16:33 Jan 06, 2023

Let me be one off the first to say congratulations. Pop those corks for the second time this week🥂

Reply

Molly Kelash
19:01 Jan 06, 2023

Many thanks! Very happy indeed!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Rama Shaar
08:01 Jan 01, 2023

This was a great read! I love TJ who never gives up on Jeb, but the best thing you've captured here is the innate need wired into us to look forward even when we resist happiness! Your style is clean and engaging. Very enjoyable!

Reply

Molly Kelash
15:27 Jan 01, 2023

Thanks for taking the time to read it, Rama! I wanted this story to show a person who seems beyond redemption begin to crack and defrost a little--glad that came through.

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Viga Boland
16:28 Dec 31, 2022

So touching. Loved it. Great writing.

Reply

Molly Kelash
19:34 Dec 31, 2022

Thank you!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Unknown User
23:49 Jan 25, 2023

<removed by user>

Reply

Molly Kelash
20:42 Jan 26, 2023

Thank you! I will look back for the error!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Molly Kelash
19:12 Jan 28, 2023

Found it. So weird that I couldn't see it before. Guess it goes to show that we all need editors!

Reply

Unknown User
19:24 Jan 28, 2023

<removed by user>

Reply

Molly Kelash
19:59 Jan 28, 2023

Even advanced writers need copy editors! :)

Reply

Unknown User
21:17 Jan 28, 2023

<removed by user>

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Show 2 replies
02:02 Jan 07, 2023

I feel so blessed again in my marriage after Doctor Oku brought back my husband that separated with me for a good 3 months. Even though I have mouths all over my body, it won't be enough to thank Doctor Oku for his help in my life. My husband separated with me for 3 months and has been in pain and agony without him. So, I searched for help everywhere but nothing worked out, not until I meant Doctor Oku who I contacted online. I explained my situation to him and he promised that my husband will get back to me within 48 to 72 hours as long as ...

Reply

Show 0 replies
02:02 Jan 07, 2023

I feel so blessed again in my marriage after Doctor Oku brought back my husband that separated with me for a good 3 months. Even though I have mouths all over my body, it won't be enough to thank Doctor Oku for his help in my life. My husband separated with me for 3 months and has been in pain and agony without him. So, I searched for help everywhere but nothing worked out, not until I meant Doctor Oku who I contacted online. I explained my situation to him and he promised that my husband will get back to me within 48 to 72 hours as long as ...

Reply

Show 0 replies

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in the Reedsy Book Editor. 100% free.