The Terrifying Tale of Todd's Totally Spooky Night

Submitted into Contest #272 in response to: Write a story with the aim of scaring your reader.... view prompt

4 comments

Funny Fiction Thriller

Todd Braverman considered himself the bravest man in Cowardly Creek, which, admittedly, wasn't saying much in a town where the annual Courage Festival involved competitive hiding under blankets. But Todd was determined to prove his mettle once and for all by spending the night in the town's infamous "Murder Mansion," a dilapidated Victorian house on the hill that had been vacant since the previous owners fled screaming about a demonic Roomba.

Armed with nothing but a flashlight, a bag of cheese puffs, and his lucky rabbit's foot (which, much to the rabbit's dismay, was still attached to the rabbit), Todd approached the creaky front gate. A gust of wind moaned through the trees, causing Todd to leap three feet in the air and emit a sound usually reserved for stepped-on cats.

"Just the wind," Todd reassured himself, his voice cracking like a teenager asking someone to prom. "Nothing to be afraid of. Certainly not any ghosts or ax murderers or, worst of all, door-to-door salesmen."

Todd reminded himself that he was brave. Well, brave-ish. Okay, I’m here, aren’t I?

The town whispered tales of hauntings and mysterious disappearances, but Todd had an even scarier challenge: he was a twenty-something terrified of, well, everything—even his own shadow.

"You got this, Todd," he muttered to himself, fist-bumping his nervous reflection in the gatepost. Tonight, I prove my bravery and conquer the ominous reputation of the manor. The boys in the chess club had mocked him mercilessly when he announced his plan. He could still hear their laughter echoing in his ears—mockery that only fueled his determination, or maybe just his stubbornness.

The front door opened with a dramatic groan that seemed to say, "Turn back now, you fool!" But since Todd didn't speak Door, he missed this crucial warning. He stepped inside, his flashlight beam cutting through the darkness to reveal cobweb-covered furniture and a disturbing number of ceramic clown figurines.

"Hello?" Todd called out, immediately regretting this classic horror movie mistake. "Any bloodthirsty spirits home? I'm just here to prove I'm not a coward, so if you could maybe rattle some chains or write 'GET OUT' in blood on the walls, that'd be great. But like, not too scary, okay? I have a delicate constitution."

As if in response, a blood-curdling shriek echoed through the house. Todd's knees turned to jelly, which was unfortunate because he'd skipped leg day at the gym for the past... always.

"Who's there?" he squeaked, shining his flashlight wildly around the room. The beam landed on a mirror, causing Todd to scream at his own reflection. Oh, it's just me, he sighed in relief, then frowned. Wait, when did I put on this hockey mask and start holding a chainsaw?

Before Todd could ponder this choice further, his entire body tingled and vibrated, sending him into a scared jump. Oh, dang phone. “Hello?”

On the other end, an automated voice responded, “Hello, I’m calling to remind you that the warranty on your 2004 Ford Crown Victoria is about to expire.”

Frustrated, and a bit embarrassed, Todd hung up and shoved the phone deep into his pocket. Immediately afterward, a loud “POP” sound rang out. His eyes flicked to a red balloon floating up the stairs. Well, this is floating up nicely. Oh no, it's not Pennywise, is it? So this is where I run upstairs to follow the balloon, right?

The floorboards behind him creaked ominously. He spun around to find himself face-to-face with a hovering, translucent figure. Suddenly, the room felt colder than the reception at his last family reunion.

"Boo," said the ghost, in the least enthusiastic tone possible.

Todd unleashed a scream that could have shattered windows, if the house had any left. He backpedaled furiously, tripped over his own feet, and landed in an old, dusty armchair that suddenly reclined with a mechanical groan, trapping him like an evil La-Z-Boy. "Release me, foul contraption!" Todd shrieked, struggling as the chair vibrated gently in 'relaxation mode.'

The ghost sighed heavily. "Great. Another one. Look, Charlie, can we just skip to the part where you run away screaming? I've got a union-mandated break in ten minutes."

But Todd, in a surprising display of bravery (or perhaps just extreme confusion), stood his ground. "N-n-no!" he stammered. "My name is Todd and I'm here to prove I'm not afraid of anything!"

The ghost raised an ethereal eyebrow. "Really? Honey, you're currently using a throw pillow as a shield and I'm pretty sure you've wet yourself."

Todd glanced down. "That's... that's ectoplasm! Yeah, that's my story and I'm sticking to it."

The ghost rolled its eyes, a feat made more impressive by the fact that they were just glowing orbs of light. "Fine, Jimmy. You want scary? I'll give you some scary." It floated over to a dusty old record player and put on a vinyl record. The room filled with the opening notes of "Baby Shark."

"Dear god, no!" Todd cried, covering his ears. "Anything but that!"

"Do do do do do do," the ghost sang along monotonously.

Todd broke into a cold sweat. "Okay, okay! You win! This is terrifying!"

The ghost allowed itself a small smile of satisfaction. "And for my next trick, Fred..." It pulled out a stack of papers. "Your tax returns. Unfinished. And it's April 14th."

Todd's face went pale. "No... it can't be..."

"Oh, but it is," the ghost cackled. "And look, Jeremy, a letter from the IRS about an audit!"

That did it. With a wail of pure terror, Todd bolted from the room, the rabbit still clutched in his white-knuckled grip. He tossed one more remark over his shoulder as he left. “Again, my name is Todd!”

In the kitchen, Todd opened a cabinet and was bombarded by mismatched Tupperware lids that flew out and attacked him. "Where do these lids even come from?" he screamed, batting them away like blood-sucking bats.

He opened the refrigerator, hoping for a cold drink, but instead there was a talking expired yogurt. "I've been here since 1992," it moaned, lurching toward him. "I’m broccoli flavored, too. Eat me if you dare!"

He ran out of the kitchen searching for a safe room. The ghost hovered in a depressed manner. “I hate to break it to you, Johnny, but your little midnight adventure is about as exciting as burnt toast.” Rolling his spectral eyes he continued. “I’ve been doing this for ten centuries, and I tell you, Brian, I’m burnt out.”

Todd jumped, eyes widening. The ghost floated before him—translucent and decidedly over it, with tattered chains draped around its translucent form. “I’m Mortimer, but I have long since given up answering to such a boring moniker.”

“So, like... you don’t want to scare me?” Todd asked tentatively as he held the flashlight beam in Mortimer’s face.

“Sweetheart, I would love nothing more than to scare you senseless. But at this point, I’d be boring myself. Get that damn light out of my face.” With a wave of his arms Mortimer caused candles throughout the house to spontaneously light.

Mortimer floated closer, an air of indifference hanging around him like a tattered cloak. “Why should I even bother anymore, Greg? I could be watching Netflix. Do you know how many foggy nights I’ve worked through? All those jump scares, gnashing teeth, eerie moans—ZZZZzzz… I’m practically asleep on my feet!”

Todd blinked, caught off guard. “So, you… kind of just want to quit?”

“Right! Who came up with this October tradition anyway?” Mortimer flipped through the air, forming a casual ghostly shrug. “Come on, Larry, do you have any idea how boring it is to hover around endlessly? People don’t even scream anymore; they just whip out their phones! ‘Ooh, look at the haunted ghost!’”

“Honestly, I’m not really all that brave,” Todd confessed, finding a bit of camaraderie with the burnt-out ghost. “I just wanted to show everyone I could do this. Prove I’m not afraid of my own shadow.”

Mortimer looked genuinely perplexed. “You’re scared of your own shadow? Dude, you’re missing the point! The only thing scary around here is the fact that no one even knows true haunting anymore! They prefer lame parties with ‘The Monster Mash’ on repeat.”

Todd's nerves were wound tighter than a rubber band ball made by someone with too much time on their hands. He puffed out his chest, which deflated almost immediately, much like his courage.

A voice echoed from a closed-off room beneath the stairwell. A shrill old biddy-like voice, dripping with mockery: "You left the oven on, moron!"

Mortimer threw his hands on his hips and glared upward in exasperation. "Shut up in there, you flea-bitten bag of bones!" he bellowed, his voice cracking with frustration.

Todd mustered his courage to open the door and enter the dreary room. The air smelled like a mix between grandma’s attic and a sock that had given up on life. The candlelight cast an eerie shadow onto an ornate four-poster bed with a tattered silk canopy.

He stepped in to get a closer look and saw deep gashes in the wood, as if someone held on for dear life while being dragged into the pits of hell. That’s enough. You’re letting your imagination run wild, and that doesn’t make you brave at all.

The voice screeched at him once again. “Nice haircut, Jethro Bodine! You need to put the cereal bowl back in the kitchen, loser.”

Todd steadied himself on the corner bedpost, using his flashlight to find the source of the voice. It came from a large black iron cage tethered by a chain to the ceiling. A parrot skeleton sat on a perch eating bird seed that fell through its mouth and trickled down its ribcage. The birdseed played a tune as it touched each rib. The simple, repetitive piano melody of Halloween, instantly unsettling, created an ominous atmosphere.

Todd's eyes bulged out like a pair of ping-pong balls. They looked as if they would pop out, take a lap around the room, and report back on what they saw.

The parrot screeched at Todd, then recited a rhyme:

Shadows creep and whispers grow,

In the dark, where none should go.

Eyes that watch, but never see,

Hide beneath the crooked tree.

Footsteps fall where none have tread,

In the night, where fear is fed.

Todd had seen enough and backed out of the room to find the safety of Mortimer’s company again.

So, dear contest judges, are you frightened yet? I can add more spooky clowns if needed. I bet you want me to go upstairs now? Okay, here goes nothing.

Making his way to the top of the stairs, he saw it lined with dusty photos. It felt like the walls had eyes, and not the polite kind—more like the kind that judges you for wearing Crocs in public. He leaned to look closer at a portrait. An eerie wind blew through the house, but instead of a haunting wail, it hummed the theme from Jaws. A portrait coughed and sneezed, blowing cobwebs onto Todd’s face.

The thought of a spider crawling through his hair freaked Todd out, and he sprinted to the top landing, frantically clawing at the cobwebs.

“We’re in here,” said a voice, filled with an exaggerated sigh. Mortimer, no doubt.

Todd stumbled into a grand room where a group of skeletons were having a tea party. They clinked their cups politely, and one of them looked up. "More tea, old chap?" the skeleton offered in a disturbingly chipper tone.

Todd stared at the scene, his mouth hanging open like a rusty screen door nobody bothered to fix. As they sat together—one man terrified of literally everything and one ghost exhausted from a century of fright—an idea sparked in Todd’s mind, igniting the atmosphere with a wild energy. “What if we throw a party? Something fun and scary. Please? Let’s make it hilarious. I mean, come on, a ghost and a scaredy-cat teaming up? That’s a new twist!”

Mortimer lifted his gauzy eyebrow. “A party, huh? Now you’re talking! I can be the ghost that tells bad puns while dressed in a toga—ghost toga…so ancient Grecian!”

As laughter erupted between them, the haunted house transformed from a place of dread to a quirky realm of slapstick fright. Mortimer and the other ghosts, no longer intent on scaring Todd, decided a party was in order. Bowls of popcorn magically appeared, floating in the air before being flung at each other like confetti. Todd joined in, laughing uncontrollably as kernels bounced off his head, raining down like spooky snowflakes. They created choreographed "scare dances," moving to the rhythm of eerie tunes like the Barney & Friends theme song, each ghost twirling and dipping with exaggerated flair as Todd fumbled his way through the steps, tripping over his own feet but grinning from ear to ear.

Howls of glee, not fear, filled the house, reverberating off the walls. Shadows on the walls flickered and waved, joining in the ghostly conga line. Every corner of the room danced with vibrant energy. Mortimer pulled out a vintage projector and started playing classic horror films—films that were apparently hilarious to the undead. The group shrieked with laughter as the supposedly terrifying scenes played out, Todd clutching his sides as a ghost did impressions of Frankenstein’s monster attempting the moonwalk.

But from the outside, none of this joyous chaos could be seen. For any poor soul walking by, the house was a different scene altogether. The only visible sign of life was a single beam of light—a lonely flashlight casting erratic shadows across the walls and ceiling. The light flickered wildly, bouncing as if it had a mind of its own, illuminating the peeling wallpaper and dusty cobwebs. From the street, all one could hear was the sound of Todd’s manic laughter—laughter that echoed into the night, chilling the spine of any passerby. To them, it wasn’t the sound of someone enjoying a whimsical bash—it was the eerie, unhinged cackle of a man slowly losing his grip on reality.

Inside, Todd danced and spun in circles, throwing his arms up like he was at the greatest party of his life, while outside, the house remained a cold, silent tomb, save for the unsettling light and the haunting sound of laughter floating into the wind.

The group partied into the night, and as the sun rose, the skeletons disappeared and the house went dark. Mortimer, no longer depressed, floated over to Todd. “You know, Michael, you’re not half bad.”

“Mortimer, thank you for not giving me the heebie-jeebies. I can’t wait to tell the guys about you.”

Mortimer faded away with a smile.

Todd ran downstairs, and as the gate closed behind him, he heard a shriek from inside the "Murder Mansion."

“Happy Halloween, Todd!” Mortimer’s voice trailed off as a whisper on the wind.

Todd ran through the town, screaming about the horrors he'd witnessed, eventually collapsing in front of the local diner.

The next day, the townspeople of Cowardly Creek gathered to hear Todd's tale of terror. He regaled them with stories of the monstrous apparition, carefully omitting the parts about his less-than-heroic reactions.

"And then," Todd concluded dramatically, "the ghost tried to force me to do math!"

A collective gasp arose from the crowd. Several people fainted.

"You're the bravest man in Cowardly Creek!" the mayor declared, pinning a medal to Todd's chest. The medal read "Participated" in small letters.

And so, Todd Braverman became a local legend. The Murder Mansion was torn down and replaced with a bunny petting zoo (much to the relief of Todd's emotional support rabbit). Todd went on to write a bestselling book titled "I Ain't Afraid of No Ghost (But I Am Terrified of Their Taste in Music)."

As for Mortimer, he retired to Florida, where he now spends his days scaring retirees by reminding them about their cholesterol levels and the dangers of mixing medications. And Cowardly Creek lived happily, and fearfully, ever after.

###

October 14, 2024 10:48

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

4 comments

Cameron Snider
07:28 Oct 24, 2024

After reading through quite a few other short stories from the fright contest, this felt so refreshing! You made me laugh a few times, and the descriptive details were great. I wasn't expecting to feel some joy mixed among all the dreaded and spooky tales, thank you for a different take.

Reply

Tina Harden
19:42 Oct 25, 2024

Ha! Thanks for reading and enjoying it. That's a "win" in itself. When I saw the prompts this go around the concept of spoof came to mind. Thanks for taking the time to read my work and share your opinion.

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Shannon McLean
21:25 Oct 20, 2024

The descriptions you wrote were detailed. I especially liked how you described the characters, the house, and the wind. You even added a little bit of poetry! This story was funny, and I laughed at some parts. I enjoyed reading your story.

Reply

Tina Harden
19:45 Oct 25, 2024

Ha! I appreciate the time you took to read it and share your opinion. That made my day. I'm glad you enjoyed it and found the humor. Thank you, Tina

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. 100% free.