Emma's Dinner

Submitted into Contest #283 in response to: Write a story that ends with a huge twist.... view prompt

2 comments

Suspense Thriller Drama

  In small towns, secrets are as rare as glowing stars; everyone knows everything because they see everything. Everyone said that in Ivyblue Creek, a small town perched on a chilly mountaintop, offering breathtaking views of the mysterious lands below. Every other night, after the sunset and the day's labor faded, the warm glow of Emma's Diner became the light for the townsfolk. Inside, the air was filled with the aroma of home-cooked meals and the laughter that mingled with heartfelt conversations. It was a cozy haven where dreams were shared, and friendships were strengthened.

It was another night filled with the familiar hum of conversation and laughter, a portrait of encounters waiting to be painted with new stories. As Emma waltzed through the cozy, dimly lit room, her tray loaded with drinks for the locals, she caught sight of a figure entering through the door. She halted, captivated, as she took in the stranger.

Draped in a long, dark coat that seemed to swallow them, the figure moved with an air of mystery like a bear roaming through the snowy landscape. A thick, woolly, texture fluffy hat topped its head as protection from the brutal chill that howled outside. Each step the stranger took echoed through the establishment, the heavy thud of their boots creating a rhythm against the wooden floor.

Emma swiftly grabbed a chair from a nearby table with a warm smile and a cheerful wave. She dragged it across and held the tray with one hand, the legs scraping softly against the floor. Her heart raced with curiosity as she approached the newcomer and promptly placed a drink before them, eager to welcome this unexpected guest into their stories.

No words were exchanged between them; a simple hand lift as a gesture of gratitude, that was all. Emma topped the drink again, her eyes sparkling warmly, while the stranger set the money on the table—a brief interaction, nothing more. This went on for several days, days that turned into weeks, and weeks that became months.

The stranger slowly acclimated to the quaint town and its welcoming folks. Initially, they acknowledged the friendly greetings with a reserved hand lift, but gradually, that small gesture became a wave, embracing the warmth of the community. Eventually, a soft “hello” emerged from her lips, with sweetness and shyness.

With each passing day, the thick layers began to shed. The heavy clothing transitioned into a cozy, vibrant sweater and thick pants, revealing a tall, slender figure. The woman’s wild red hair dropped freely behind her and over her shoulders, framing her freckled face, which glowed with a newfound confidence and connection. The stranger was no longer an outsider; she became a cherished part of the town.

She slowly moved forward, getting closer to the center tables. As she began to speak, the townspeople gathered around her. The hello became a sentence and then slowly an adventure, the adventures coming from the uncharted lands below. Emma became intrigued by the new stranger. She provided something no one had offered: a connection she had never felt. They often spent their days walking around the dinner table, talking about the lands below, the sun, and the warm sands of the beach.

One evening, as they strolled through the dense woods near the diner, Emma took in the crisp, earthy scent of the forest. Her gaze was toward the uncharted lands below, where the stranger had claimed to wander. As thoughts of sunlit beaches and warm sands danced through her mind, she offered the stranger a soft smile.

Yet, when they reached a clearing, a sudden chill embraced them. The vibrant hues of the setting sun stayed behind the towering trees, casting shadows that deepened the forest's secrets. Emma felt an unsettling shift in the atmosphere, and the stranger grew eerily quiet. Emma noticed the shadows swirling in the stranger's eyes, darkening with a weight she couldn't quite decipher, leaving them with an unspoken tension.

The stranger turned to Emma, her voice low and somber as if sadness was cascading with each letter she spoke. “Emma, there’s something you need to know.” The stranger swiftly revealed a badge, the glint of metal catching the fading light. Emma barely had time to read the word "investigator" stamped on it. “I am here investigating the mysterious disappearances of numerous people. Everyone who sets foot in this town seems to vanish, Emma. I’ve narrowed down a few suspects and may have a possible culprit in mind, but reinforcements are on their way. I need you to get as far from here as you can. I don’t want them coming after you. Would you come with me?”

A whirlwind of confusion and disbelief swirled within Emma, her gaze dropping to her feet as her heart raced in her chest. “Come after me? Why would you involve anyone else? Who are you? What have we done to you?” The stranger paused, hesitation flickering across her face as her confidence wavered. “I am just investigating, doing my job, Emma. There’s something deeply unsettling about the people in this town. Have you ever stopped to wonder where they vanish during the day? Why do you only see them when they come to your diner every other night?” She gently grasped Emma’s hand, leading her to the rocky edge of the mountain, where the vast uncharted lands unfolded beneath them. “What lies below is a world filled with cities and towns, rushing with life and overflowing with buildings. Up here, we see dense forests and the shadows of trees. But, Emma, trust me, I come from down there. I have seen it with my own eyes. I know what exists beyond this mountain, forest, and shadows.”

Emma stumbled back, her hands trembling at her sides, her gaze fixed intently on the stranger, a mix of fear and curiosity swirling in her eyes. “Please, let me get you out before they hurt you too,” she pleaded, her voice barely above a whisper. Turning away from the stranger, Emma’s breath faltered, transforming into a soft whimper. “Where will I go? What will you do with me?” The stranger's hand fell softly on Emma's shoulders, wrapping around her in a gentle embrace, offering warm reassurance against the cold mountain air. “I will take you far away to a place where the sun kisses the shore, where the sands are white and soft beneath your feet.”

A heavy sigh escaped Emma’s lips, her chest rising and falling as she struggled to absorb the stranger's words. “And how will we get there?” The stranger tilted her head slightly, a curious glint in her eyes as she turned Emma to face her. Emma's eyes became vacant as though staring into an endless void. Her lips pressed together, forming a thin, straight line. “I will… We will… my car is…” Her voice trailed off as she scanned the surroundings; standing in the mist in the thick forest, the blanket of snow, and the darkness enveloping Emma’s Diner like an imminent shadow, she noticed nothing else. “How will you leave?" As her gaze returned to Emma, the stranger saw a slow smile creep across her face, tinted with darkness. "I never let my playthings go.”

December 31, 2024 19:50

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

2 comments

Carolyn O'B
18:11 Jan 09, 2025

Nice. Although I had an inkling that Emma was a predator, the ending was certainly unexpected.

Reply

Catalina Felix
12:14 Jan 11, 2025

Thank you.

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. 100% free.