Submitted to: Contest #323

The Lantern Keeper's Bride

Written in response to: "Write a story that includes the line "I don’t know how to fix this" or "I can't undo it.""

Fantasy Fiction Romance

The world ended in soft light, not flame.

Each evening, as the sun dropped behind the peaks, Lysandra climbed the path to the cliffside lanterns and lit them. The glass orbs shimmered with starlight, drawing on drifting sea magic. The lanterns, it was said, steadied the veil between worlds—without them, night would engulf the coast and drowned spirits would rise.

She was the last Lantern Keeper of Arathen’s Reach, and she was alone.

Until he came.

Cael arrived one stormy night, half-drowned and furious at the sea for letting him live. Lysandra found him tangled in kelp near the shore, his skin pale as driftwood, his pulse a thin flutter. When he opened his eyes, they glowed faintly, like someone who had seen beyond the veil and returned marked by it.

She dragged him to the Keeper’s cottage and tended to him through the night. He barely spoke for days. But when he did, it was of strange places — kingdoms buried beneath the tides, cities of bone, promises made to the dead.

“I shouldn’t have survived,” he said once, voice ragged as he stared into her lantern light. His hands trembled in his lap. “The sea wanted me.”

“The sea doesn’t get to decide,” she told him softly.

She lit the lanterns; he walked beside her, silent but for boots on stone. He had once been a scholar, hunting lost relics. He ventured too deep into the catacombs, chasing the Heart of Tides—a crystal said to rule the boundary between life and death. He found it, and the sea turned on him.

She should have been afraid. She wasn’t.

Maybe it was loneliness. Maybe it was the way he watched her, not with hunger, but with awe. Her nights stopped being just work. They became theirs, filled with laughter, shared meals, and the brush of fingers in the lamplight.

Sometimes, when the wind rose and the waves clawed at the cliffs, he would wake in terror and whisper names that belonged to no one living. Lysandra would hold him until he stilled.

“I think something followed me back,” he confessed once.

“Then we’ll keep the lanterns burning,” she said. “Light drives the dark away.”

For a while, it did.

The first sign of change came with the red tide. The sea bled itself onto the shore, staining the rocks. The air grew thick. Lanterns flickered, no matter how carefully she fed their magic. Villagers below began leaving offerings at the cliff path: salt, bread, bits of silver. They muttered about curses. They muttered about omens.

Lysandra pressed her fist to her chest and tried not to listen. She wanted—achingly—to believe love was enough to quiet the sea.

Then, one night, as she climbed to the highest lantern, she saw movement in the water. Something vast and pale swam just beneath the surface, trailing ribbons of light. Cael was standing at the edge, barefoot, eyes open and distant.

“Don’t go closer,” she called.

He turned to her with a smile too calm to be his.

“It’s calling me, Lysandra. I can feel it again. The Heart. It isn’t done.”

A cold spike of fear stabbed through her; her breath caught painfully.

“You said you left it below. You said it was lost.”

“I thought it was.” He touched his chest. “But it isn’t. I can hear it in me.”

That night, she dreamt of the sea splitting open like a wound, of Cael walking into the depths without looking back.

The days blurred. Cael weakened, his skin gleaming faintly like scales. His breath misted, and his touch ran cold. The transformation was an ancient curse for disturbing the Heart of Tides, marking them forever for the sea.

“Tell me what you need,” she begged. “Tell me how to stop this.”

He only shook his head.

“You can’t stop the sea. I brought its heart back with me, and it wants to return.”

“Then I’ll go with you,” she said.

But he smiled, the same soft, broken smile that had undone her the night she first kissed him.

“You don’t belong to the dark, Lysandra.”

She woke with a gasp—his side of the bed was cold. She was alone.

The door was open, the lanterns still unlit, and the wind smelled of salt and sorrow. On the table lay a single note, damp at the edges.

Forgive me. If I return it, the sea will rest. You must keep the light burning until dawn.

She ran.

By the time she reached the cliffs, the waves were wild and black. Far below, she saw him wading into the surf, the water glowing around him. She shouted his name until her voice broke, but he didn’t turn.

Then, just as the first light of morning touched the horizon, he vanished beneath the surface.

The sea went still.

For three days, the sea lay calm. The lanterns burned on. Lysandra waited, every heartbeat knotted with hope and dread.

On the fourth night, she saw someone standing by the shore.

Cael.

Or something that wore his shape.

The moon hung low when Lysandra reached him.

She first thought it was Cael: hair dripping, eyes shining. When she touched his arm, her fingers met a cold that burned. His pulse was gone. Light in him pulsed with the tides, not his heart.

He smiled at her as though nothing had changed.

“Lysandra,” he said softly. “You kept the lights burning.”

She nearly collapsed against him, desperate to believe, but her voice broke into a whisper.

“What are you?”

“I came back.” His words trembled like a reflection on water. “The sea gave me back.”

The lanterns above them flickered, and the shadows seemed to breathe. She saw, just for a moment, something move behind his eyes — a ripple of silver, a tide surging where his soul should be.

“You shouldn’t have,” she said.

His hand cupped her cheek, and for an instant, she felt warmth again, the ghost of who he had been.

“I told you the Heart wasn’t done. It isn’t just an artifact. It’s alive. It wanted a vessel. I think that’s what I’ve become.”

She stepped back.

“Then we can free you. We’ll find a way to take it out.”

But his expression changed, sorrow darkening the edges of his smile.

“You don’t understand. It doesn’t want to leave me. It loves you, too.”

The wind rose, carrying the scent of salt and something older: rot, memory, longing. From the sea came a low hum, almost like a heartbeat echoing through the cliffs.

He took another step forward. “I feel it, Lysandra. It wants to keep you safe. It wants to bring you where I am.”

She shook her head. “That isn’t love.”

“Then what is?” His voice cracked. “If love isn’t wanting to never let go?”

The ground quivered beneath them. A wave crashed against the cliffs, spraying them both. In the salt spray, she saw faces: blurred, weeping, pleading. The drowned souls the lanterns had always held at bay.

“Cael,” she whispered. “You’re letting them through.”

“I can’t stop it anymore,” he said, and for a heartbeat his voice was truly his own again, raw and terrified. “The Heart keeps opening. Every breath I take is another crack in the veil.”

She reached for him. “Then let me help. Let me take it from you.”

“You’d die.”

“Then we’ll die together.”

Something flickered in his expression, a longing so fierce it hurt to see. Then the light inside him flared, and his body convulsed. He fell to his knees, clutching his chest as seawater spilled from his mouth.

“Lysandra,” he gasped. “Run.”

But she didn’t. She knelt beside him, pressing her palm to his heart. The magic burned, but she forced herself closer, whispering the words her mother once taught her—the old Keeper’s prayer meant to seal breaches and bind the lost.

“Light to dark, shore to sea, keeper’s hand, return to me.”

For a moment, she thought it was working. The tide withdrew, the lanterns steadied. His breathing slowed.

Then the light in his chest burst open like a wound.

A torrent of spectral water surged from him, hitting her square in the chest. It wasn’t cold; it was filled with memory. She saw flashes of everything he’d endured: the catacombs, the drowning, the endless dark. She saw the Heart itself — a crystal pulsing in a cavern beneath the sea, alive, aware, whispering promises of eternal love.

When the vision faded, she was shaking. He lay before her, his body still but his eyes open.

“Lysandra,” he said faintly. “It’s inside you now.”

Nausea twisted her gut. She could feel it—a pulse under her ribs, echoing the sea, relentless and foreign.

“No.” She pressed her hand against her chest as if she could claw it out. “No, I didn’t want—”

“You tried to save me.” He looked up at her with wonder and grief tangled together. “It’s what it wanted all along.”

“What are you saying?”

He pushed himself up with trembling arms. “It wanted you. It used me to find you. The lanterns, the light — they’re fragments of its power, but you were the only one strong enough to bind it.”

The wind screamed through the cliffs, and the sea began to churn again. The lanterns flared, then dimmed one by one.

Lysandra felt her magic unravel as she stood among the glowing lights. The lanterns bent toward her chest, drawn by the Heart inside. Her magic seemed to flow into it, intertwining with its ancient, tempestuous currents.

She staggered back, horrified. “Cael, it’s killing me.”

He reached for her, eyes full of tears that did not fall. “If you let it, it will remake you instead.”

“Into what?”

He didn’t answer.

The waves rose higher, glowing faintly with the same light that now pulsed beneath her skin. The spirits of the drowned gathered at the base of the cliffs, their shapes shimmering through the mist. They began to chant, a low, rhythmic call: the same words she had spoken moments ago, twisted and broken.

Light to dark. Shore to sea. Keeper’s hand. Return to me.

She felt it pulling her forward, inch by inch, toward the edge. Cael stood between her and the drop, shaking his head.

“No. Not like this. I thought it would free me, not bind you.”

“Then help me,” she said, her voice cracking. “Please. I can’t hold it back much longer.”

He looked at her, truly looked, as if memorizing her face one last time. Then he whispered, “I can’t undo it.”

The words shattered something inside her.

Before she could speak, he placed his hand over her heart. His touch burned, but it was the ache of love, not pain. The light flared again, and she realized he was pushing the Heart back into himself, forcing it away from her.

“Cael, stop! You’ll—”

“I’m already gone,” he said. “Let me do one thing right.”

The sea howled. The light swallowed them both.

When it faded, she was alone on the cliff.

The lanterns were all extinguished. The sea was calm again.

And Cael was gone, not drowned this time, but vanished, as though he had never been.

For three days, Lysandra did not light the lanterns. The villagers whispered below that the Keeper had lost her faith, that the dead would soon come walking. But when she finally rose from her bed and looked at the sea, she saw something glimmering in the water: a single lantern, burning beneath the waves.

She knew it was him.

That night, she lit every lantern again. Each one flickered with that same strange light, colder now, but still beautiful. She whispered his name into every flame.

And though the world above slept, the sea whispered back.

The lanterns burned weakly as dawn crept across the cliffs. Lysandra knelt by the highest light, her hands trembling as they hovered above the flame. It was smaller than it had ever been, barely a whisper of warmth, but it pulsed with something she recognized: Cael.

The villagers below had stopped leaving offerings. They whispered her name with fear now, calling her the Keeper of Shadows, the girl who had loved a spirit and survived. Whenever she ventured into the village, their wary glances lingered in her mind, a reminder of the life she was tethered to by the sea.

Every night since that moment, she had seen him in the waves. Sometimes, a shadow danced just beneath the surface, glinting like silver. Sometimes, the water reflected his face in fragments, breaking with the tide. Each time, she reached for him, and each time he vanished.

It had been weeks. Weeks of longing, of light burning against the impossible.

And still she tried.

Tonight, the sea was different. The water roiled, not with ghostly calm, but with hunger. The moon hung low and red, casting a bruised hue over the world. Lysandra climbed the cliff path, lighting lantern after lantern, trying to weave the magic that would reach him, even if she didn’t fully understand how.

Then she saw him.

Or what he had become.

He stood at the edge of the cliffs, dripping with seawater that shimmered silver and black. His eyes glowed faintly, as if the moon had claimed them. He raised a hand. The wind carried a voice that was his and not his at the same time.

“Lysandra,” he said, and the sound echoed like a bell through the night.

Her legs refused to move. She wanted to run and hide, to flee from the creature she loved, but something in her heart compelled her to stay.

“Cael,” she whispered. “Please, come back.”

He shook his head slowly. The water licked the cliffs at his feet, rising, curling around his ankles, as though the sea itself were pulling him into a crown of power she could never reach.

“I can’t come back,” he said. His voice trembled, full of sorrow and love. “Not really. I am too much of the sea now. Too much of the Heart. And yet…” He stepped closer, and Lysandra felt the pulse of his presence in her chest, the same light she had tried to keep at bay. “…I wanted to see you one last time.”

Her fingers brushed the lantern’s rim, and the flame flared to life, burning bright against the cold of the night.

“I can fix this,” she said, voice quivering. “We can—”

“You can’t,” he interrupted, his eyes glimmering with tears that reflected the red moon. “You tried once. You gave everything. You tried to save me and almost lost yourself. I cannot let that happen again.”

Her chest ached. Every beat felt hollow, echoing in the emptiness he left behind. “Then what do I do?”

He stepped closer. His hand reached for hers, and for a moment, she could feel warmth, memory, love. Then it passed, like a wave breaking against the cliffs.

“You keep the light burning,” he said. His lips trembled against the wind. “You do what only you can do. Protect the world from what I became. But… know this. Every pulse of magic in the lanterns, every shimmer of starlight you capture, every whisper of wind you hear: that is me, in some small way. Always with you.”

Lysandra pressed her palms to her face. “I can’t lose you again.”

“You already have,” he said, voice breaking. “And yet… I am here in all the ways that matter.”

The tide surged. Water shot up in pillars around him, glowing, shimmering, alive. The lanterns flared in response, some shattering from the raw force. Lysandra fell to her knees.

“Please,” she begged. “Come back. Let me hold you. Let me fix this!”

He shook his head, a sorrowful smile tugging at his lips. “I can’t undo it. I tried once, and it nearly destroyed you. You must live. You must shine. You must let me go.”

A wave lifted him, carrying him out over the edge of the cliffs. He did not scream. He did not call. He simply looked at her, eyes full of longing and love and regret, and then the water swallowed him.

She ran to the edge, shouting his name until her throat burned. The sea answered only with silence and the faint glimmer of the broken lanterns.

For a long time, she sat there, her knees pressed to her chest, rocking slightly. The lanterns flickered in the wind, some glowing weakly, some dead, but all holding a trace of his light.

The villagers whispered she had gone mad, lost herself to the sea. But she did not care. She had known love that transcended death, and even in despair, she would not trade it.

At dusk, she lit the lanterns again. Each flicker carried his memory. Each flame told the story of a love that would endure in the smallest ways.

She whispered his name to the light. The wind carried it across the cliffs. Somewhere in the depths of the sea, she imagined him hearing her. Somewhere in the vastness, he must have been waiting.

And though her heart felt hollow, though the world had shifted and left her alone, she repeated the words that would haunt her forever:

“I can’t undo it.”

The lanterns burned through the night.

The sea remained calm.

And she remained, a keeper of light and memory, changed by the whisper of the Heart. Though her love would never return, the Heart had left her with more than memories; it had altered something deep inside, binding her to the sea’s call.

Posted Oct 04, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

2 likes 1 comment

David Sweet
20:10 Oct 13, 2025

Tahlia, what a great piece of lore! Even though some of the ideas are cliche, you take them and blend a new narrative that is completely original. You did a good job of immersing us in this world without too much exposition or depth of backstory. It was a narrative that could stand completely on its own. As most stories from mythology and folklore do, it became a moral lesson and, of course, the lovers could not be together. The explanation of spirits lost at sea creating the horrible storms is a wonderful idea. Thanks for sharing. Keep it up.

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.