Submitted to: Contest #271

The Bench

Written in response to: "Write a story that includes the line “Have we met before?”"

🏆 Contest #271 Winner!

Drama Sad Fiction

The elderly lady shuffled the few remaining steps to the park bench and sat down, happy to catch her breath and rest for a moment. The autumn sunshine was warm, but the nip in the air made her glad of her warm coat. She placed her handbag neatly on her knee.

“Good morning,” said the silver-haired gentleman at the other end of the bench. “Beautiful day.”

Elsie smiled. “Yes, it is. Cold, but lovely.”

The man folded his newspaper and returned the smile. “I’m George.”

“Hello, George. I’m Elsie.” She re-arranged her scarf, her gnarled fingers struggling in the cold.

They sat for a few moments quietly, looking over the city. “I’ve always loved this view.” 

“Pardon?”

“The view,” George repeated. “I’ve been coming here since I was a boy. I used to watch the trains.”

Elsie looked to where George was pointing, down the hill towards the city. 

“I liked the steam trains. Do you see?” He added. 

“Yes, I can see. No more steam trains now, though, I’m afraid. It was different, then.”

George nodded. “It was. I’d travel the country. My folks had no idea where I was half the time. It wasn’t like it is today.” He paused. “Do you have children?”

“Yes, two. And grandchildren, now.”

“Then you’re blessed. What are their names?” George turned to look at Elsie, noticing her careworn face, the long, white plait that rested over her shoulder.

“Timothy, is the eldest. He has two little ones of his own now.” Elsie said, proudly. “Well, not so little now. They’ve grown and gone, too. I don’t get to see them as much as I’d like.”

“I’ve always liked the name Timothy.”

Elsie smiled. “And then there’s Ellen. She got married, finally, last year. She’s nearly sixty! She finally took the plunge.”

“Well that’s lovely!”

“It is. It was. She looked beautiful.”

George sat back. “I always wanted children.”

Another few moments passed by, quietly. 

Elsie looked over. “You can read your newspaper, George. I don’t mind.”

“No, no. It’s okay. I don’t often get chance to chat. Especially with a beautiful woman.” He said, with a wink. 

Elsie chuckled. “Charmer. I bet you broke some hearts.”

“I don’t know about that!”

“Did you grow up around here, then?”

“Yes,” replied George. “Not far. And I went to school here, too. Calder… Calder something.” He shook his head. “I forget.”

“Age does that to us, doesn’t it?” Elsie asked, softly.

George shrugged. “I guess it does.”

She sighed. “It takes away the most precious things. Our bodies, our minds, our memories.” 

They fell into quiet again, both looking at the city sprawled out before them, lost in their own thoughts.

“May I ask you something, George?” 

He turned to look at her again. “Of course!”

“Have you ever married?”

George shook his head. “No, I never married. There was a girl I knew… once. I forget her name. Have you?”

“Yes. I was lucky enough to marry my best friend. The love of my life.”

“Well that’s wonderful!”

“Yes. It was wonderful. I’ve… lost him now. And it’s lonely. Terribly, terribly lonely.” Elsie looked down at her lap.

George reached over and took her hand, tenderly. “I’m very sorry for your loss. How long ago?” 

“Around five years ago. Nothing has been the same since.” Tears filled her once, bright blue eyes. They were cloudy now; age and sorrow had faded their beauty. 

George frowned. “That’s such a shame. Do you have anyone close?”

Elsie shook her head. “They have their own lives. Timothy is in Chester, Ellen in Manchester. And I feel like all I do is cross names out of my address book.” She paused. “All of my friends… They’re all gone.” 

George reached into his pocket for his handkerchief and offered it to her. “There, now. It’s okay.”

Elsie managed a small smile. “Thank you.” She wiped her eyes. “It’s silly. You must think I’m an old fool, sitting on a bench, crying.”

“Not at all.”

“Well I feel like an old fool. I should be glad of what I have. I’m still here, my children are happy and healthy. You were right, I have been blessed.”

George looked puzzled. “What?”

“A minute ago, you said I was blessed. For having my children.”

“Oh, that’s right.” He shook his head. “I’m more forgetful, the older I get.”

Elsie tried to pass the handkerchief back but George refused. “Keep it, I have plenty.”

“Okay, I will. Thank you.” She opened her handbag and tucked the handkerchief inside. She snapped it shut again. “It’s a funny old life, George, don’t you think?”

He tilted his head, not understanding. “In what way?”

“I just… can’t believe I’m here. At the end of my life. And what do I really have to show for it?”

George didn’t reply. 

“I don’t feel any different than I did ten years ago. Twenty years ago, even. And now when I look in the mirror, an old woman looks back.” She sighed. “It all feels so… pointless.”

George cleared his throat. “I don’t know how to help you with that one, I’m afraid,” he said, a little uncomfortably.

“I know, George. I don’t expect answers. I just wanted to say it out loud.”

Quiet fell again. 

“I used to take the trains, you know. All around the country.”

“Yes. You said.”

George laughed. “I did?” 

Elsie smiled, indulgently. “Yes. And your parents didn’t know.”

“Not a clue. Not like today.”

“No, George. It isn’t like today at all.”

George turned to look at her. “Do you know, you seem really familiar. Have we met before?”

Elsie sighed. “Yes. We have met.”

George frowned. 

“And it’s time we went home. This cold is getting right to my bones.”

George continued to frown. 

“Come on. I’ve got a casserole in the oven. And then it’s time for the racing. You like the racing.” She stood, stiffly, then held her hand out. She smiled, encouragingly. “Come on, George. Home time.”

George stood, still frowning. “Home?”

“Yes, sweetheart. Home. And we can ring Tim later and see him on the screen. Remember?”

George nodded slightly and stood. 

“Don’t forget your paper.”

The elderly couple walked away from the park bench where they had sat every Sunday morning for the past fifty years, hand in hand, back to the house where they had raised their children. Empty now, thought Elsie as she lead her husband back through the park. Entirely empty.

Posted Oct 06, 2024
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

234 likes 203 comments

Carrie Backer
22:36 Jan 03, 2025

Truly excellent.

Reply

Louise Paterson
23:06 Dec 09, 2024

What a beautiful short story. I loved Elsie’s patience and understanding towards her sweetheart. Dementia is such a difficult illness for surrounding family but this story gently unwinds revealing a wife’s undeniable love for her husband. ❤️

Reply

Janice Dewar
21:45 Dec 04, 2024

Brilliant and real.

Reply

Martin Killips
04:02 Nov 22, 2024

A very lovely story. A little bleak if we imagine that it is what we all have to look forward to. But truth always carries a momentum of its own, and once I started reading, the dialogue swept me through to the end.

Reply

Kate Simkins
09:01 Nov 22, 2024

Thank you for taking the time to read and comment. I think I was feeling a little melancholic at the time of writing and this seeped through a little into the story. I'm glad you liked it ☺️

Reply

Katie Mobley
16:04 Nov 08, 2024

This was a very good, very amazing story, the ending surprised me in a happy, sad way. Wish i could write with such power in storytelling!

Reply

Jennie Mika
11:00 Nov 07, 2024

I love this. The twist was really well done. It moved me ♡

Reply

Mason -
20:04 Nov 05, 2024

Very powerful. Simple, but done so well.

Reply

Kate Simkins
20:15 Nov 05, 2024

Thank you 😊

Reply

Tawana Burgan
17:39 Nov 05, 2024

I am in tears! This is so beautifully written. I love the dialogue, fell in love with the couple. I have read some of your comments about your father and your grandfather, I had a writing teacher many years ago tell me that the best stories come from people we know and life experiences, he was so right. My own father had dementia and it is a fear I have because I am getting older. In fact, I can see the situation reversed and my husband and I on that park bench. :-) One of the best shorts I have read so far. Congrats.

Reply

Kate Simkins
17:58 Nov 05, 2024

That's such a lovely comment, thank you! It really was a special story and I agree that writing from experience makes the story all the more relatable. It definitely makes it feel more real🙏

Reply

Tom Skye
11:53 Nov 05, 2024

This was amazing dialogue. I have read stories about Alzheimer's before but the back and forth between the characters here was so immersive, the reality of the situation didn't occur to me until the reveal. I also enjoyed that Elsie's state of mind was less sentimental and more accepting, maybe even resentful in the end. I imagine partners going through this situation experience a world of emotions.

Amazing work. I can see why it won.

Reply

Kate Simkins
12:39 Nov 05, 2024

Thank you! My father has dementia so this one was close to my heart. I appreciate you taking the time to read and comment 🙏

Reply

SOPHIE SIMMONS
04:03 Nov 05, 2024

Wow. I love how this story left the reader with a sense of wonder throughout, and that it wasn't entirely clear what was going on until the end. Beautiful story about grieving a loved one with dementia/memory loss. Very well deserved win.

Reply

Kate Simkins
07:59 Nov 05, 2024

Thank you! I appreciate you taking the time to read and leave a comment 🙏

Reply

Henna Shah
03:32 Nov 04, 2024

This story is breathtaking! It has a sense of sorrow, but it is beautifully written to explain the effect of Alzheimer’s. It tests the emotion of readers, starting out as a sweet conversation between two elderly individuals, but morphing into the tranquil story of a woman, forgotten by her husband. (I hope this makes sense, and that what I interpreted is what you were going for!)

Reply

Kate Simkins
08:40 Nov 04, 2024

Thank you! It's is exactly what I was going for. I appreciate you taking the time to read and leave a comment 🙏

Reply

Mallory Jones
23:26 Nov 03, 2024

Beautiful. ❤️

Reply

Willie Tee
12:42 Nov 02, 2024

Loved it.

Reply

Kate Simkins
13:44 Nov 02, 2024

Thanks!

Reply

Elena Balaguer
12:27 Nov 01, 2024

It all felt so real and the conversations were so seamlessly put together. A pleasure to read!

Reply

Kate Simkins
17:12 Nov 01, 2024

Thank you! I appreciate you taking the time to read and comment 😌

Reply

Angela Ewing
13:15 Oct 30, 2024

Made me cry. So lovely, and I'm 86, so I know the feeling of getting old. Well done. Thank you.

Reply

Kate Simkins
13:41 Oct 30, 2024

I'm glad you liked it, but I'm sorry it made you cry! My father is 77 and has dementia so this story was special to write. Thank you for taking the time to read and comment - I very much appreciate it.

Reply

JoAnne Burgess
11:43 Oct 29, 2024

This was beautifully done. The way you touch your readers, by allowing us to feel like we are standing there looking in, is a great talent!

Reply

Kate Simkins
12:12 Oct 29, 2024

Thank you! I appreciate you taking the time to read and comment :-)

Reply

Donavyn Haley
04:36 Oct 29, 2024

I really enjoyed this read. It reminded me of the short film The Wait (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EuRHHmXbzYs). I especially liked how natural the dialogue felt. Having it take place between an elderly couple added a level of relatability.

Reply

Cathy Ro
23:18 Oct 27, 2024

This was such a beautiful and touching story. I know it was also sad but the beauty of it and the fact that the love was still there even if the memory wasn't. The fact that they didn't 100% lose each other was so sweet and touching. Really loved this one.

Reply

Olive Silirus
16:57 Oct 26, 2024

This is the kind of short story we all hope to write someday. Splendid work.

Reply

Kate Simkins
17:06 Oct 26, 2024

That's a truly lovely thing to say! Thank you 😊

Reply

Donna Fontenot
06:54 Oct 26, 2024

So well-written. You had my attention immediately. I could relate to that couple on so many levels. It is a well-deserved honor and you have my admiration.

Reply

Kate Simkins
07:40 Oct 26, 2024

Thank you! I'm glad you liked it. It was a story close to my heart. 🙏

Reply