Submitted to: Contest #303

It Won't Mind the Fire

Written in response to: "Write about a character who becomes the villain in another character’s story."

Historical Fiction Sad

This story contains sensitive content

SENSITIVE CONTENT - WAR RELATED TRAUMA AND DEATH



Part 1 – Captain Charles Miller


They moved at dawn because that’s when an army moves best: when the light is clean, the air is cold, and men are quiet. No time for talking. No time for second thoughts. The road was soft from the night’s rain and the men cursed their boots, but they marched anyway, shoulders bowed, rifles at rest. The fields to their left were thick with tall, dying corn, dry enough to go up with a single torch. Captain Charles Miller rode ahead, coat unbuttoned, hat pulled low against the glare.


He didn’t like riding. It made him feel separate. But his knee had turned bad many months and many miles ago, and the surgeon said if he marched on it much longer, it would go stiff and stay that way. So he rode, and the men said nothing.


They were headed for a plantation called Wexley Hollow. Intelligence said it had two wells, thirty hogs, six barrels of cornmeal, and a family that had refused to evacuate. That was enough to earn a visit. The orders were clear. Deny the enemy subsistence. Break the back of the rebellion.


He’d long stopped asking if it was right. Only if it worked. You don’t always need a bullet to do the job. Just take their food, take their roof, take their firewood. That was the part no one liked to say out loud. But it ended wars faster than sermons or treaties. It was pressure, applied until something broke.


The trees thinned as they neared the estate. No pickets. No sentries. No cannon. Just a large white house with wide porches and empty rocking chairs, and outbuildings spread like ribs from a spine. Slaves had once worked here. Now the fields were half-harvested and abandoned. Maybe the Confederates had called them to the fight. Maybe they’d scattered before the army got within a day’s ride.


One of his lieutenants, Farris, came up beside him. “Sir? Want us to spoil the wells?”


Miller shook his head. “No. We’re not poisoning the South. Just starving it.”


Farris pointed at the barn. “Dry roof. Should catch easy.”


Miller didn’t bother looking. “We’ll take the stores. Burn the rest.”


He didn’t raise his voice. He didn’t need to. The men moved out, disciplined. No whoops. No laughter. The new recruits had learned by now not to cheer when the flames came. The veteran soldiers worked quickly, collecting flour, salt, dried meat. A sergeant broke open the smokehouse with a prybar and gave the all-clear.


A woman watched them from the porch. Not yet forty, but the war had aged her face faster than the seasons could. Her graying hair was pulled back tight, like it was the only thing she could still control. A boy stood beside her, maybe eight, wearing shoes with broken laces, dust-caked and too small. They didn’t speak.


Miller approached the house slowly. He stopped short of the steps, removed his hat.


“You’ve been given time to leave,” he said. “We’ve no quarrel with civilians. But the buildings go. All of them.”


The woman stared at him like he was already a ghost. “This land’s older than your war.”


Miller wasn’t in the mood to argue. “Then it won’t mind the fire.”


She didn’t answer. The boy looked like he might run forward, or maybe cry, but he did neither. Just stood there, shaking with rage, or cold, or both.


Miller turned away before she could say anything else. He didn’t like watching them beg, and he liked it even less when they didn’t.


By midday, the barn was cinders. The smokehouse went next. The wind shifted, and ash drifted across the yard like snow. One of the younger privates tossed a broken toy onto the pile — a wooden horse with one wheel missing. It caught quick. Flames climbed its painted legs.


Farris came back again. “The woman and boy still haven’t left.”


Miller nodded. “Let them be.”


He moved past the hog pens. Empty. Someone had already taken the animals. Confederates, most likely. Or deserters. Or the family, slaughtering what they could before the army came. He saw the boy’s eyes again. They were still. Children were supposed to cry. But this one just burned cold.


Miller stopped at the edge of the field. The corn rustled in the wind like it was whispering something. He pulled a match from his coat, lit it on his saddle stirrup, and dropped it.


The stalks took fire fast.


Miller didn’t watch them burn. He turned his horse and started back toward the road.


The smoke rose behind him, thick and furious. Like something old had broken loose. He didn’t look back. He never did.



*****



Part 2 – The Boy


I don’t remember when they came. Just that they were there when I opened the door.


The sky was still waking up, and the yard smelled like dirt and old wood. I thought maybe it was going to rain, but it didn’t. It was quiet. Not peaceful quiet. Just the kind before something bad.


There were a lot of them. All dressed the same. Guns on their backs. Faces like they were heading somewhere worse than this.


Mama told me to stand still. So I did. My shoes didn’t fit right that day. They pinched at the heel, but I didn’t move.


The man in front didn’t yell or wave his arms. He wasn’t big, but everyone looked at him before they did anything. His coat was darker than the others, and his face didn't move. It was like nothing behind it was still alive.


They talked, him and Mama. I couldn’t hear much. Her hands stayed clasped like she was holding something she didn’t want to drop.


They took things. Then they lit the barn. Then the field.


It didn’t roar. It ate. You could feel it chewing the air, like it wanted your breath too.


I wanted to run and tell Papa, but Papa was gone. He left with his horse, his saber, and a carbine when I was six. Said he had to head for Tennessee, where the real fighting was. I think he really believed he was doing the right thing.


After they left, I went behind the smokehouse to be sick. It wasn’t even a choice. My stomach turned inside out and I dropped to my knees in the dirt. The ground was warm from the fire still smoldering. I tried not to cry, but it was like my body didn’t know the difference.


It smelled like ash and meat and something worse. That’s when I started to understand. Not just that they were gone, but that they could come back. That they could do it again somewhere else. That nobody could stop them.


My hands shook. I wiped them on my shirt, then sat there for a long time, trying to breathe without tasting smoke.


Later I walked back to the yard. The barn was gone. The field looked like the sun had been buried in it, and the burn left a scar. I found where the ashes had buried my toys. The ones I left near the porch, where Papa said they’d trip someone one day. I tried to dig one out, a carved horse with a chipped leg, but it crumbled in my hand. Fell apart like dry bread.


I didn’t cry then. Not because I was brave. Just because there was nothing left in me.


We left that afternoon, walking toward Uncle Silas’s place three miles west. Slept under a hickory tree that night with smoke still in our clothes.


Uncle Silas’s place was smaller. No one bothered to burn it. Not since he went off to war and his girls took the wagon north.


We let ourselves into the house. It was cold and quiet, but the walls still stood and the wind stayed out. Mama sat at the kitchen table that night without saying anything. She looked like she was waiting for someone to say it was over.


That winter was long. The cold got into the house, then into her. She stopped talking sometime in January. I buried her before spring, in the back field, where the ground was soft and no one would step on her.


I told myself I’d find the man in the dark coat one day. Make him look at what he did.


But I never saw him again.


I still think about his face. How he didn’t look angry. How he didn’t look anything at all.


And how that made it worse.



Posted May 23, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

16 likes 17 comments

08:59 May 26, 2025

Compelling read. I like how you've humanised the soldier, made him a real character with his bad knee and no longer questioning. The boy too, is a strong character and the story leaves you hoping that his future will not be consumed by hate. Pawns in a war that was not of their making. Great read!

Reply

Scott Monson
18:30 May 27, 2025

Thank you, Penelope! I really appreciate you picking up on those elements. Humanizing the soldier and showing how both he and the boy are caught in something far larger than themselves were central to what I hoped to convey. He wants to protect his men and bring an end to a war meant to confront America’s original sin, even as he carries out terrible acts in the process. The boy, though innocent of that legacy, is left to suffer its consequences. I'm truly grateful for your thoughtful reading.

Reply

Rebecca Detti
12:25 May 27, 2025

Really compelling!

Reply

Scott Monson
18:36 May 27, 2025

Thank you, Rebecca! I’m really grateful you took the time to give it a read. I appreciate the kind words.

Reply

Silent Zinnia
19:39 May 26, 2025

This one was really cool, nice read👌

Reply

Scott Monson
18:34 May 27, 2025

Thanks, Yasmine! I really appreciate you reading and leaving such a nice comment!

Reply

Silent Zinnia
20:07 May 27, 2025

anytime man

Reply

Rebecca Hurst
09:28 May 26, 2025

Wonderful work, Scott.

Reply

Scott Monson
18:33 May 27, 2025

Thank you so much, Rebecca! I always appreciate your support and the time you take to read my work.

Reply

Rebecca Hurst
18:36 May 27, 2025

You're welcome. You are a pleasure to read.

Reply

Alexis Araneta
14:42 May 25, 2025

Such compelling writing! I love the characterisations in this one. Incredible work !

Reply

Scott Monson
23:31 May 25, 2025

Thank you so much, Alexis! I love to hear that. I put a lot of effort into building the characters, and it was really thoughtful of you to share your impressions like that.

Reply

Lisa Cornell
06:19 May 25, 2025

I was reluctant to read this, war stories always make me feel so sad.
But, I skimmed the start and couldn't stop reading.
Very compelling and felt an immediate attachment to the characters.
A story that left me thinking after I finished reading it.
I always think about how young 17 and 18 year olds look and the thoughts of war always saddens me. Maybe the boy's revenge would be a vow of never going War himself so he doesn't have to be someone's villian 😄

Reply

Scott Monson
22:37 May 25, 2025

Thank you, Lisa! I completely understand the hesitation with war stories. They can weigh heavy. You're exactly right about the boy’s possible vow. I actually wrote this with a strong anti-war undercurrent in mind. The Civil War was one of the few truly necessary wars in history, and even then, it was brutal and tragic. That’s exactly what makes it such a powerful lens for understanding why armed conflict should be reserved for when there is no other choice. Thank you again for reading it with such care!

Reply

Greta McMullen
23:06 May 24, 2025

This story is amazing, I love your writing!

Reply

Scott Monson
02:00 May 25, 2025

Thanks so much, Greta! I really appreciate that. Very kind of you.

Reply

Thomas Wetzel
02:57 Jun 25, 2025

This was fantastic. I really liked the narrative structure, showing both sides of the conflict from very different perspectives. Great story-telling and you did a nice job of capturing the language of the times. Was this based on Sherman's March to the Sea?

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.