Mom works. She never picks me up from school, and two miles is too close for a bus pickup, which is fine by me because I like cutting through the woods. Especially on autumn days, when the air is cool, and the flies and mosquitos are gone, and basketball practice hasn’t begun. I like the quiet. I like the wordlessness of the walk.
A pretty sugar maple dressed in vivid orange frills beckons me off the path. I stand to look at her. I sound like a weirdo, I know. A sixteen-year-old boy calling a sugar maple pretty. It was Dad that taught me to appreciate trees before he hung himself from one. I love ‘em even more, now, Dad and trees. Did you know the oldest maple is five hundred years old? They call it the Comfort Tree. Dad said all trees are comfort trees.
I search the sugar maple for a perfect orange leaf - I think I’ll press the leaf between two sheets of waxed paper like I did when I was a kid – but I can’t find a perfect orange leaf. It doesn’t matter. We don’t even have waxed paper at home. We don’t save things at home.
I follow a line of golden, round-leaved aspens to the creek, a grove of clone trees grown from the root system of the male. “Aspis means shield in Greek,” Dad said. “Aspens are protectors and inspire courage.” Brave aspens. Magic aspens. I wonder, Dad, did it take courage to kill yourself? Did you care about leaving me?
“Depression is a villain,” the therapist said. “That villain convinced your father the world was better off without him.”
I could have slayed the villain. If I had only told Dad how much I needed him.
I sigh. I try to take a deeper breath. I inhale the dank smell of cold dirt and dropped leaves. I smell Dad, the amalgam of decomposition and old blood. I didn’t know what the smell was when I was a kid. I didn’t know what a medical examiner did. The smell was a thick smell and sweet. I knew, only, that the smell was my dad. I’ve got a friend, Jimmy, who likes the smell of skunks.
My backpack is light, no books, not much homework. With it being the end of the semester and the week before Thanksgiving, teachers don’t add to their piles of ungraded papers. I drop my bag at a willow. I strip a branch of its leaves. I sit on a rock. I pretend to fish.
“Knock. Knock,” I say. “Who’s there?”
“Fish on a hook out of water.”
“Dad? Is that you?”
I reach to unhook him, but he slips through my fingers. How did I let my dad slip through my fingers?
“It wasn’t your fault. There was nothing you could do.” The therapist said it. Mom said it, but I know Mom doesn’t feel that way.
I keep photographs of Dad in a tackle box. His eyes look sad even as his face smiles. In a birthday photo, we wear matching red hats on our heads, the paper cone kind with the elastic bands that dig under our chins. His body leans into me. His arms hug me enthusiastically. He looks at me. I look at the cake. My mouth is open in the ready position to blow out six candles. I am happy. We were happy. But I see his sadness captured by the photograph. Maybe because his smile looks a little like the same fake smile, I make in all my school pictures. Maybe because his lips are dry and look a little too stretched over his teeth. Or because the corners of his mouth don’t go up into his cheeks in an easy way.
I am seven years too late for more knock, knock, jokes. I am seven years too late to make him laugh, seven years too late to make him happier, seven years too late to give him reasons to stay. I should have made him not want to leave us.
I want to tell Mom that I walk through the woods, but she worries. “Apples and trees,” I heard her say. “I will spend my life trying to keep him alive.” She means me. She means keep me alive. I want to tell her that her burden makes me angry, that it crushes me, that it flattens me. I want to tell her not to worry about me, but I’m scared. I’m scared as if her thought is a premonition.
I pick up my backpack and I follow the creek that leads to the oak tree in the yard, to the black scar on its trunk from where a thick limb once reached upward. I sit on a branch that spreads over the ground. All the oak’s branches have turned toward the ground. “Dad?” I smell decomposition and old blood. I smell the vanilla in the old oak’s tree bark, the smell Dad taught me to notice. I feel the strength in the old oak’s trunk.
In the kitchen I see the bowl full of apples, a white oak bowl full of red apples. It hits me why the bowl is there. Seven years of apples in a white oak bowl sitting on the kitchen countertop and I only, now, see why my mom puts them there. “Apples and trees. I will spend my life trying to keep him alive.” The white oak is Dad. The apples are me.
I pull each apple from the bowl. I line them up on the countertop. Seven apples. Seven years. I inspect each apple for bruises and blemishes. Not a single bruise on any of the apples. It’s a sign, my sign. I am an apple from only the best parts of the tree. I feel taller. I am sure. I’ve slayed the villain that was hiding inside me.
“Mom,” I say, when she walks into the kitchen. “You don’t have to worry about me.”
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
138 comments
The imagery in this coupled with the honest simplicity is very moving; the symbolism of the unblemished seven apples a beautiful metaphor for childhood. They say fruit never falls far from the tree; I'm so glad your narrator rolled away from that fatal oak. This story is sad, but I found it ultimately uplifting too. A well deserved win.
Reply
Thank you Rebecca! I’m happy to hear the imagery and voice worked together to move you as a reader.
Reply
So much emotion in this one! Great work.
Reply
Thank you Daniel! Much appreciated.
Reply
I see my sis and I fishing as kids, fishing off the bridge close to our grandparents' cabin. You see your father and you at the comfort tree, perfect branches with perfect orange leaves. Both left this earth, hung by their own dragons, As if autumn blew them off, each a leaf, crushed up as compost under a once strong tree. Why didn't we say what we needed to make them stay? Were their smiles ever happy, really happy, unfaked? Now that I'm half-grown, bruised, delicate-delicious, I know fishing with my sis is a message, a bridge between ...
Reply
Many of us relate to how a suicide affected us. We feel guilt. We grow, we learn, we come to know each has a unique story-- happiness, depression. Yet some truths are universal.
Reply
So true. Thanks so much for sharing Deanna.
Reply
I loved how in just a few words, you let the narrator go through a round of sad emotions and how he came out all strong. Amazing work, indeed.
Reply
Thank you Maliha. I’m glad you enjoyed it.
Reply
Oh my gosh! Wasn’t expecting this win, I am thrilled the story touched many of you. Thank you for your feedback and support!
Reply
Yep. I came back looking at the recommended stories. There's 13 I found so far. I just had to read the first sentence or two and the rest of your story was completely memorable. Big claps
Reply
Thank you Tommy!
Reply
No worries. When you autograph my book (that you wrote) could you leave a blank spot where my name should go. I'm going to bet on the resale value.
Reply
A bitter sweet story of death, strength and endurance. The tree and apple analogies are thoughtful and touching. Beautiful symbolism, loved it!!
Reply
Thank you Matthew. I’m so happy you enjoyed the story.
Reply
A very nice story. I read it twice. I think it will be memorable.
Reply
this story is kind of sad i cried a little bit but im good
Reply
Such a simple and heartbreaking story! I love how you describe the feelings of the narrator. Congratulations!!!😊😊
Reply
I like this honestly its really misterious
Reply
Hello, Lisa! I would like to say that I enjoyed this. And I did. But, If I have to be honest, at some paragraphs, I felt myself losing interest quickly, and at some points, even feeling myself scrolling through this faster then I could read. But, to be more positive, the writing was really great. And I did love the way you conveyed the main character's emotion throughout the story, and loved even more the way you painted a picture in our minds via imagery.
Reply
Great job buddy! I really liked what you wrote!
Reply
It Do Feel Depression
Reply
Very readable, although I feel like you should try and put some metaphors within the passage, I liked it, I've been writing a little less than a year now, and I'm hoping to get better at my writing s I comment on other writers work, so this is my feedback: Its very readable as I said at the beginning, and it uses a lot of imagery, its a fantastic story, but i feel like it should be just a tad more expression, for example " I search the sugar maple for a perfect orange leaf - I think I’ll press the leaf between two sheets of waxed pape...
Reply
Beautiful! Congratulations on your win!
Reply
Why didn't she come and pick you up from school in the evening Lisa Lange
Reply
Read Up My Story Today as my story is a very special and unique one as is not like the numerous advert you always see online and also I want to be 100% sincere and truthful to you that there can never be any other online spell caster that can help you bring back your EX BACK to you other than DR HUNTER ALVIN as he alone is 100% effective,dynamic and very reliable as 99.9% of other spell casters are not for real and can never help you solve your problems at all instead they will complicate your present condition OK SO BE WISE AND ALSO BE WARN...
Reply
I live this story. It's sad and sweet at the same time. It speaks to me. I just enjoyed it. Thank you.
Reply
I feel like this is a sad story but It Is really good. I enjoyed it. I haven't read something like that In a long time. You should think about writhing a book one of thesis day's
Reply