Submitted to: Contest #298

The Silence Between the Notes

Written in response to: "Center your story around someone finding acceptance."

Contemporary Fantasy Fiction

It was always there. The music flowing like a river beneath the streets. It drifted through alleyways, curled around lampposts, soaked into cobblestones like rain. The city pulsed with a thousand private symphonies, flutes of joy, strings of longing, brass heavy with sorrow. Mira felt them all, not through ears, but through the marrow of her bones.

But she didn't belong to it.

To Mira, emotion wasn't a sound. It was vibration. Pressure. Texture. Like brushing fingertips across a stranger's soul. The world around her hummed, but she could never quite join the chorus. No one understood her gift, not her teachers, not her friends, not even her parents, who had long since grown frustrated with her abstract, unquantifiable passion. Music was a thing they could measure, something they could hear and grade and shape into conventional forms. But what Mira experienced was different. It wasn't normal.

She stepped from her crooked doorway onto the street, the hem of her coat catching on the rusted hinge. Morning light spilled over slate roofs, illuminating passersby whose music tangled in the air like colored smoke. A woman in red glided past, trailing notes so sharp they stung Mira's skin. Regret, maybe. Or bitterness. A man followed, his tune warm and full, honey-thick with affection.

Mira pulled her scarf tighter around her neck. It wasn't just for warmth, it dulled sensation, blunted the world's constant thrum. Each step she took vibrated beneath her boots, rhythm stitched into the world itself. And yet, it never belonged to her.

She couldn't remember the last time someone met her eyes for longer than a glance. To them, she was silent. Broken. Without music. But none of them knew she heard too much. Too much to share. Too much to give voice to.

Her fingers twitched, aching for keys. Her flat waited, the old piano yawning in the corner like an unfinished sentence. It was her only companion in a world too loud to listen.

The music in her apartment was her own, composed from memory, shaped by touch. She didn't hear it, but she felt it humming in her blood as she played. Fingers danced across the ivory, chasing a melody only her soul recognized. The piece was jagged, unresolved. As if always reaching for something just beyond her grasp.

She stared at the final measure she'd written the night before. A single note, C sharp, hung alone on the page. Wrong. She crossed it out and pressed her forehead to the wood, heart rattling behind her ribs like a misplayed chord.

She wasn't composing for anyone. No one listened. No one could.

Her parents' words echoed in her mind, as they had countless times before, "You could be great, Mira, if you'd just try harder." Her mother's voice, soft but persistent, reminding her of how she should be more like the others, more like the musicians whose work could be measured and dissected. Her father's disappointed sigh whenever she tried to explain how she experienced music, not as notes on a page, but as waves coursing through her body. Mira wanted to be understood, to prove that her music could matter. But what if her way wasn't enough, what if she had to conform to rigid standards of what music should be?

It was just another Thursday morning when Mira passed the cafe with the chipped window where a handwritten sign read: Open Mic Thursdays.

Through the glass, a girl played a ukulele. Not skillfully, but with abandon, music spilling out like laughter, unguarded and free.

The cafe manager, a tall man with kind eyes, waved to Mira through the door. "You should come play sometime!"

Mira nodded and kept walking. Her scarf tightened like a noose around her throat.

They wouldn't feel it. Not like she did.

They'd hear nothing but silence.

Applause rose behind her, muffled but bright. She didn't look back.

It was in the park when she first noticed him.

Adrian.

He sat on a bench with his elbows on his knees, watching ducks trail across a pond dappled in gray light. Mira wasn't sure why she stopped. Maybe it was the stillness. Not in his body, he shifted now and then, rubbed his thumb over a folded corner of paper in his pocket, but in the surrounding air.

She felt nothing.

No thrumming. No pressure on her chest. No stinging notes. Just silence.

Not absence, exactly. Something deeper. Like the hush between breaths. A silence that meant something.

She stared.

And he looked up.

For a moment, she nearly stepped back. People never noticed her, not really. But Adrian's gaze caught hers and held it, unflinching. Curious. There was no flash of pity or surprise, no subtle lean away. Just presence.

He raised one hand in greeting.

Her own lifted, as if by reflex.

They met again, by chance, or maybe not. Mira wasn't sure she believed in chance anymore.

The second time, she brought a notebook. She wrote: Do you always sit in silence?

He took the pencil and wrote back, neat and slow: It's not silence to me.

She frowned. You don't have a song. Everyone has a song.

He hesitated. Then: Not everyone.

Days folded into weeks. They met in the park, on street corners, in the back of the music shop, where no one went anymore. Mira began to play for him, setting her notebook beside the piano. Adrian would close his eyes, and she could see in the way his breath shifted, that he was feeling something. Not just the notes, her intention behind them.

"Tell me what this feels like," she signed once, fingers moving with care.

He paused. Then signed back, clumsy but clear: Like a place I forgot I missed.

Mira found herself smiling more.

She showed him how to compose, not with traditional theory, but with emotion, simple shared moments, the sweetness of burnt toast, the stillness before a storm, the pressure of her fingers curled around his. She gave him fragments of music, and he built something quiet, aching, and beautiful. She'd never known music like it. No jagged edges. No striving or reaching. Just being.

One afternoon, Mira sat cross-legged on the grass beside him, notebook open but untouched. Wind rippled the pond like breath through a reed.

“What's the point of writing music no one can hear?” she signed.

Adrian didn't answer right away. He pulled a blade of grass between his fingers, twisting it slowly.

Then he signed, "You don't need everyone to hear you, just the right ones."

Mira blinked. Her pencil stilled.

He looked at her then, eyes calm. "If one person feels it, really feels it, is that less real than applause?"

She didn't answer.

But that night, she played differently.

And still, the question haunted her.

“Why is your music silent?” she signed to him one evening, when the clouds hung low, and the world felt like a held breath.

Adrian watched her for a long moment. Then, slowly, he unrolled a weathered page from his coat pocket. It was old, its edges frayed. Mira ran her fingers over the ink, an ancient notation. Melodies she didn't recognize but somehow knew.

"I helped write the first songs," he signed. "Back when music was meant to reflect, not define."

Her breath caught.

He continued, "But people stopped listening. They started judging. Measuring each other by what their songs sounded like instead of what they meant. So, I stopped playing."

Mira's fingers curled around the edge of the page. "You chose silence."

He nodded. "Peace is a kind of song, too. Perhaps one we had forgotten how to hear."

The words settled into Mira like stones dropped into still water, ripples expanding outward. She thought of all the times she'd hidden her music, afraid of judgment, of misunderstanding. Of all the times she'd silenced herself.

That Thursday, Mira stepped into the cafe.

The open mic night was already underway. The girl with the ukulele waved. The manager gave her an encouraging nod.

Mira's scarf felt heavy in her hands. She hesitated, then unwound it from her neck, feeling exposed, vulnerable. But for the first time, she wanted to be. Not for applause or validation, but because this was who she was, a creator of music beyond sound.

She sat at the piano.

And played.

Her fingers moved through truth and trembling, doubt and longing. She poured herself into the melody, unapologetic, exposed. This was her song, full of vibration, of ache, of everything she'd never signed.

When she finished, silence held the room.

No applause. No reaction.

Someone coughed. A chair scraped the floor. A whispered, confused, "Did something happen?"

The manager offered a polite thank-you and turned to the next act.

Mira stood.

The silence crushed over her, louder than any roar of approval ever could.

She walked out into the night, throat tight.

At the edge of the pond, she finally let herself crumble.

Why had she done it? She knew how it would end. She wasn't like them. Her music wasn't made to impress or entertain.

But wasn't that the point?

Wasn't that the question?

Did she create to be accepted, or because it was who she truly was?

She sat there for hours, scarf pooled in her lap, the cold kissing her bare neck.

When Adrian arrived, he didn't ask what had happened. He simply took her hand and pressed something into her palm.

It was the last note she'd crossed out from her page: C sharp.

She stared at it.

Then, slowly, she smiled.

That night, in her apartment thick with twilight, Mira laid the note beside her on the piano bench. She sat before the keys, bare-necked and unguarded, and let her fingers move. Not reaching. Not questioning.

The music that rose wasn't jagged or broken. It was steady. Gentle. Whole.

When she finished, Adrian touched her wrist and signed, now you hear it too.

And she did.

Across the hall, through the thin apartment walls, a neighbor paused mid-argument. Mira could feel it, the shift. A slowing. A softening. The tension in their music unwinding like thread from a spool.

On the street below, a boy walking his dog stopped, head tilted, as if trying to catch a scent carried in the wind. His song, usually hurried and distracted, grew quieter, more attentive.

And in a cafe four blocks away, the girl with the ukulele looked up from her latte, fingers tapping softly on the table, feeling a melody she couldn't explain but that resonated through her bones.

Mira stood up, a smile spreading across her face. For so long, she had craved acceptance from others, validation that her different way of experiencing music was real, was valuable. But now she understood. True acceptance began with herself, embracing the unique gift that allowed her to touch souls in ways others couldn't.

She walked into the park, this time with a sense of peace, knowing that her music had found its place, not in the loudest applause, but in the quiet hearts that truly understood. And in that understanding, that authentic connection, lay the acceptance she had always looked for.

Posted Apr 14, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

6 likes 0 comments

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.