NOT THE PROMPT!
Dhwani Jain's Challenge
"Write a story with a curtain as the MC/important character or item."
The Fourth Wall
Even when I stand on my tip-toes, the peephole in the heavy blue curtains is too high for me to see through. A murmuring reaches my ears: the audience. I remember coming here when I was younger, seeing these same curtains ripple and sway between scenes. I was just another watcher then, glimpsing the hidden world, leaving once the performance was over.
Now I am on the inside, a part of the magic, an actor among many, no longer a watcher, alone.
Others are crowding to peer through the peephole, others who are tall enough to see through it, so I move away. Turning my back to the curtains, I examine the set.
A large window occupies the back of center stage. Flanking it are white-painted wooden panels, with a pattern of blue and yellow stars near the top. This play is Peter Pan, and this is the Darlingsβ nursery, so Wendyβs, Johnβs, and Michaelβs beds are on stage as well.
The performance will be starting soon. One of the adults comes, scolding the other kids not to pull on the curtains, then sending them backstage to look for Peter, Tinker Bell, and the three young Darlings.
As I leave the stage, I take one last look at the swaying curtains, recalling again the times I saw them from the outside. They donβt look that different on the inside, really.
ο»ΏCurtain
The Legend of Saint Agnes
Feast Day January 21
Agnes is one of the best-loved Saints of the Catholic Church, with many churches bearing her name. She is also one of the six women named in the Eucharistic Prayer One. Saint Jerome penned, βBy the writings and the tongues of all nations, particularly in the churches, hath St. Agnes been praised, who overcame both the tenderness of her age and the cruelty of the tyrant and sanctified the honor of her chastity with the glory of martyrdom.β
According to tradition, Agnes was born of wealthy Roman patricians, nobles of high rank, on January 28, 291 A.D. Many accounts say that they were Christians, though some say they were pagans. However, the story concerning Saint Emerentiana and her mother makes it more likely that Saint Agnesβ parents were Christians.
Emerentianaβs mother was a slave belonging to Saint Agnesβ parents, who tasked her with being Agnesβ wet nurse and nanny. Inspired by the example of virtue in her masters, the slave-womanβs daughter Emerentiana began receiving instruction in the Christian faith from her milk-sister Agnes.
Agnes was a lovely girl to behold, and when she reached the age of 12, the customary age at which wealthy Roman girls married, many suitors asked for her hand. Since she had already vowed perpetual virginity and pledged herself to Christ as his spiritual spouse, she informed the young men that she was already engaged.
One young man, Procopius, son of Symphronius, governor of Rome, sent her a rich gift, evidence of his ardent desire for their espousal. When she gave him her usual answer of being already pledged to another, he doggedly continued in his advances. Agnes finally told him: βBegone from me, thou food for death! I am already engaged to another and a far better spouse. He is the King of Heaven, to whom I have consecrated my entire being.β Puzzled by her response, angry at her refusal, and suspecting her of being an adherent to the forbidden religion of Christianity, Procopius asked his father to speak with Agnes, hoping that his status as governor of Rome would influence a change of mind.
When Agnes entered the governorβs presence, he asked her why she would turn down so advantageous a match. She told him that she had a divine spouse, far better than his son. Now Symphronius was puzzled, too. One of his aides, hearing Agnesβ words, told the governor that Agnes was a Christian, and the βdivine spouseβ she was speaking about was the God of the Christians.
Upon hearing this, Symphronius urged Agnes to leave her faith and accept marriage to his son, or face torture and death, for to be a Christian was unlawful. He then offered her twenty-four hours to consider her answer. Agnes replied that she needed no time for consideration, for she had already resolved to have no other spouse than Jesus Christ, and fearing neither pain nor death, was most anxious to lay down her life for him.
Symphronius threatened to send her to a brothel, but Agnes said, βMy confidence is placed in Jesus Christ, my spouse, who is omnipotent - he will defend me from all outrage.β The irate governor ordered her to be bound with chains, dragged before idols, and ordered to offer incense to test whether or not she was truly a Christian. Agnes fearlessly made the sign of the cross, professing that only her Crucified Spouse should be adored. Now having proved beyond doubt that she was a Christian, she was stripped of her clothing and imprisoned in a brothel. Miraculously, her hair immediately grew longer, until there was enough to completely cover the young girlβs body, thus protecting her modesty.
Several young men approached Agnes, intending to violate her virginity, but were all miraculously struck blind. Finally, Procopius himself appeared, determined to have his way with the young girl by whom he had been jilted. He, too, was struck blind, and fell down as if dead, whereupon his companions begged Agnes to pray to her God for her would-be attacker. Upon her doing so, Procopius instantly revived, and his sight was restored.
Symphronius now wanted to release the young girl, but several pagan priests cried out against this, claiming the miraculous happenings were due to witchcraft, and stirred up the crowds to demand her death. The governor, fearing a riot if he did not comply, yet not willing to put the young girl to death, handed the case over to his lieutenant Aspasius.
Aspasius suffered no such qualms, and sentenced Agnes to be burned to death. When the flames were kindled, they would not touch Agnes, miraculously parting around her and instead killing those who had lit the fire. The pagan priests and the crowds with them continued to call for the young virginβs death, insisting she was a witch. Accordingly, Aspasius ordered that she be beheaded. The trembling executioner, abhorring his grisly task, was reluctant to touch her, but Agnes encouraged him, saying βHaste thee to destroy this my body, which could give pleasure to others, to the offending of my divine Spouse. Fear not to give me that death which shall be to me the commencement of eternal life.β Then raising her eyes to heaven and beseeching Jesus Christ to receive her soul, she died. The day was January 21, 304, on which day we now celebrate her feast day.
One night as Agnesβ parents were visiting her grave, they beheld a vision of their daughter accompanied by many other virgins. She told them, βFather and Mother, weep not for me as though I were dead; for now these virgins and I live together in Him whose love was my whole life upon earth.β
Bibliography
De Liguori, Alphonsus, βVictories of the Martyrsβ
Ruffin, C. Bernard, βThe Days of the Martyrsβ
https://www.franciscanmedia.org/saint-of-the-day/saint-agnes
https://saintagnes.com/who-was-saint-agnes/
https://www.britannica.com/biography/Saint-Agnes
https://www.catholic.org/saints/saint.php?saint_id=106
https://www.traditioninaction.org/SOD/j290sdEmerentiana_01_23.htm
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
I like that you chose an actor to make a curtain important. It makes perfect sense but I wouldnβt have thought of it.
Ah, theyβre kids?
291 AC or BC?
Why was 12 ever considered an acceptable age to get married? Far too young.
Marry my son or die? Great options. Thatβs bound to lead to a happy marriage. What a time to have lived in.
Is Saint Agnes the origin of the Rapunzel idea? Hair as a magical power?
Witchcraft, the age old way to put down a women who sticks out from what society wants.
Interesting end. I think Star Wars lifted heavily from the bible as well with Force Ghosts, people seeing those who have died but lived a good life and returned to share knowledge or give peace.
Reply
A collection of stories is a great idea! I love how they remain separate, but are equally important. The Fourth Wall really portrayed the nervousness/excitement of being on stage and performing. The Legend of Saint Agnes was really cool to learn about! It's really awesome how God protected her life to spread his own good news to those around her.
Although, while The Fourth Wall seemed more like a story, The Legend of Saint Agnes seemed more like a history report (which is fine, just a little bland).
Not really any critique, really astounding job!
~LB
Reply
Thank you for reading!
You are discerning correctly when you say that TLOSA seems like a history report - that was the intention with that one.
Hope to see more comments from you soon!
Reply
Ah, I understand.
I shall try my best :)
Also: π
Reply
Oh yes thank you!
Reply
:D
Reply
This is a great story and I loved reading every bit of it. Well done :))
Reply
Thank you for reading it!
Are you going to put up a bio?
How are you doing?
Reply
No worries :))
Yes I will eventually
I am good, hbu?
Reply
I am doing well. Working on a slightly longer project. What's the most recent time someone was randomly nice to you?
Reply
Ummmmmmm well, it would be when someone helped me with something that I didn't ask for but I really needed.
Reply
Hi Guadalupe - I hope you are well. Here is what I found for notes.
I did like 'The Fourth Wall'. It's short with a captivating style. I like the beginning of it the most, the start is strong and sets the scene well. I only found one comment for feedback on my second read.
[One of the adults comes], scolding the other kids not to pull on the curtains, -You could possibly shorten this to 'One adult comes', then modify it to be more descriptive, 'One adult walks by,' or 'An adult steps by'
Curtain - Great closing line with the italics
For 'The Legend of Saint Agnes':
Inspired by the example of virtue in her masters, the slave-womanβs daughter Emerentiana began [recieving] - recieving is misspelt here. It should be 'receiving'
Agnes was a lovely girl to behold - this being a story, unless your intention is a history report, you could show more here and tell less. What makes/made Agnes a 'lovely girl to behold'? Did she tend to flower gardens, or go horseback riding, or whatever hobby is considered lovely in 291?
One young man, Procopius, son of Symphronius, governor of Rome, sent her a rich gift, evidence of his ardent desire for their espousal. -Once again, I'd change this to be more fitting of a story. To me it reads a lot like a history report(Which, if it is your intention, that's ok, but I'm assuming it's written to be a story)
I'd write it something like this
>
A young man, Procopius, son of the governor of Rome, sent her a rich gift. A bottle of wine and a bouquet of flowers (Something rich. I don't know what gifts were considered rich back then, but it'd add good imagery & show your research to put it into words!)
I'm not going to point out every spot since I'd take you got the idea, but if you want it to feel more like a story, I'd recommend trying to show more and tell less. I hope this doesn't come off as rude - I do think you're on to something here! I'd love to learn more about Christianity's history and the stories revolving around it - it is a big part of the world with many stories to tell.
You've done your research, and it shows, but I feel like I'm reading a summary of what happened rather than a short story on Agnes, Procopius, and Symphronius. I'd recommend taking this story and writing it more like 'New Arrival' or 'Tour Guide', if that makes sense. I'd personally find that to be really interesting, learning about Christianity(something I know very little about) in a short story format that could showcase your talent(not to say this is bad by any means, just not my style)
I hope this feedback is helpful! I don't mean it to sound discouraging in any way. I look forward to your next story. π
Reply
Thank you so much, Alex!
You are right on the dot when you say that this reads like a history book summary. I meant this particular piece to be like that. I wrote it for the feast day (anniversary of death) of Saint Agnes. I was possibly going to read it aloud at a dinner at my church on Jan. 21. Didn't end up doing that, though. Then I decided to post it on Reedsy.
I fixed the typo. Thank you for pointing it out!
My first story for Reedsy, From Ashes to Hope, is a historical fiction story about the early Christians.
I'm working on writing more about the early church. Hopefully I'll post more on Reedsy soon!
Reply
very very interesting! I liked how you kinda showed her faith through her life story, and it's very remarkable what God can do to promote His name :)
I liked both stories overall, awesome job :D
Reply
Thanks!
Did you read Genesis #44?
Reply
:)
yup, just now actually.
Reply
Hey Wolf, how are you?
Reply
Doing alright, how about you?
Reply
Good! How's your family?
I've got a question for you.
I'm writing a story in which the POV is focused on the character, C1, whose story it is. The character who the third-person POV is focusing on, C2, is the protagonist, but C1 is also the protagonist. However, it's kind of important to the story that you don't know C1's thoughts until he reveals them. He needs to be scary and dangerous, and part of what makes him strange is the fact that you don't understand his motivations.
Does this justify not focusing on protagonist 1? Or do you think I still need to focus the POV on the person the story is mainly about?
Reply
New comment thread, replying to "oof."
Sorry, that was a weird question.
Do you read non-fiction about wolves?
Reply
Itβs fine.
Yeah I do, mostly stories on here though.
Reply
If you're interested in reading about the wolves of Yellowstone, I recommend Nate Blakeslee's book American Wolf, as well as Rick McIntyre's Wolves of Yellowstone series.
Reply
Thanks for the recommendations :)
Reply
Ooh you're on! What's up with you today?
Reply
New comment thread, replying to
yeah i suppose so.
niceee
Mr. O'Brien wrote in his novel Island of the World
Can a dwelling place without books ever truly be a home?
I highly recommend his books!
Reply
that's a nice quote, a true one too.
cool
Reply
What have you been reading lately?
Reply
I've been reading Till We Have Faces by C.S. Lewis. how about you?
Reply
I have not heard of that one, I'll have to check it out.
I'm reading Doctor Dolittle's Circus for the second time, Heretics by G. K. Chesterton, The Father's Tale by Michael D. O'Brien, Joan of Arc by Mark Twain, and more XD
I'm think I'm currently in the midst of more than half a dozen books.
I also just finished O'Brien's Voyage to Alpha Centauri yesterday.
Reply
FOR THE CHALLENGE STORY:~
Well I read it, Guadalupe.
It was nice, short and cute.
It was impressive, how you expressed the views of the narrator in such a less amount of words, and yet leave the reader thinking about the backstory/future story.
Here is my review:
-> TITLE ~ I couldn't see any title?
-> STORY ~ As I said before, it was a pleasant read.
-> CHARACTERS ~ The MC was interesting. It somewhat remined me of a movie I watched. It's a bollywood movie, Dhoom 3.
-> ANY ERRORS/ MISTAKES ~ I found just this one mistake:
1. Now I am on the inside, a part of the magic, an actor among many, no longer a watcher, alone.
IT SHOULD BE SOMEWHA LIKE THIS: "NOW I AM ON THE INSIDE, A PART OF THE MAGIC, AN ACTOR AMONG MANY; NO LONGER A WATCHER, ALONE"
-> CONCLUDING REVIEW ~Pretty well done! Albeit, as I said in the previous comment, it would have been better if you uploaded it as a Reedsy story so that other people (except comment-readers...Hello!)can read/like/comment on it too.
FOR THE SAINT AGNES' STORY :~
Whoa!!
It was a really nice story!
Although I must say one thing: This is quite similar to a story I know, a story from the Hindu epic, Mahabharat....and a similar Jain stry too, if you want, I can tell you more about it.....
Very well written
Reply
Thanks!
Reply
=D
Reply
Given the review already...amazing stories!!!!!!!!!
=D
Reply
Would you mind copy-and-pasting it here? Just so everyone can see it. :)
Reply
I don't mind....
Reply
Thanks!
Reply
Hi, Tricia.
I've been watching you write stories for a while. I think that the first one of yours that I read might have been the one about Bob the monster under Juanitaβs bed.
[Maisie and Craig had been dating for a couple of years, and now they were getting married β tomorrow!]
The spaces on either side of the emdash are unnecessary. Remove them.
[Everything was ready β she was on top of it all.]
[Maisie dropped her hands, and backed away.]
I think this would read better without the comma in the middle.
[She looked at him. βYouβre eating our wedding cake!β]
I think [She looked at him.] can be cut. I already know that she must be looking at him incredulously.
[He looked from Maisie to the wedding cake.
βThatβs our wedding cake? I didnβt know.β]
It feels bumpy when I read the words [wedding cake] in two sentences in a row. I would combine them, to make it punchier.
{He looked from Maisie to the counter. "That's our wedding cake?"
[Maisieβs friend Jenna always raved about Maisieβs pies and cakes. She said they were the best she had ever eaten. The crusts on the pies were light and fluffy, the cake moist and delicious, the cookies chewy and soft.]
I really like this paragraph. I think all of it is helpful in the telling of the story. You tell me how much Maisie's friend loves Maisie's baking. Then you give a brief list of a few baked goods and how well Maisie makes them (using the rule of odds: if you're displaying something, it's more attractive to see one, three, five, seven, or another odd number of objects). Your descriptions make me want to have some!
[And she asked Maisie to make the cakes and pies and petit fours and cookies β everything β for the party.]
Again, you can remove the spaces on either side of the em dashes.
[When she told Craig all about it, he was almost as excited as Maisie β but for completely different reasons β Maisieβs delicious, irresistible baking would be available.]
This sentence reads awkwardly. I would write it as
{When she told Craig all about it, he was almost as excited as Masie, but for a completely different reason. Maisie's delicious, irresistable baking would be available.}
[βCross my heart, hope to die,β he said literally crossing his heart. βI will not even look at the cake!β]
Oh dear. I see a bunch of loopholes.
[Because she was also a guest she had to drop off the pastries and set up the dessert table, and still have time to get back home to get ready.]
I would add one more comma to this sentence, after [guest]
[βCraig!β she yelled marching through the house, carrying the box. βCraig!β]
I would make this
{"Craig!" she yelled as she marched through the house, carrying the box. "Craig!"}
[βExplain how, after you promised you wouldnβt eat any of the desserts, you ate a dozen β any entire dozen β cookies?β]
Remove the spaces on either side of the em dashes. Also, I believe [any] is supposed to be {an}
[In that moment, Maisie knew that she could commit murder.]
HMMM. A forshadowing?
[In fact, she had more customers she knew what do with, especially around the holidays.]
You're missing the word {than} after [customers]
[One man who had been referred to Maisie by Jenna (the missing dozen cookies notwithstanding), had wanted to surprise his partner on Valentineβs Day.]
I don't think you need the comma after [cookies (notwithstanding),]
[In the years that she had been baking commercially, there had been too many times that Craig had decided that he deserved the baking more than the customer did.]
I don't think you need two of the [that]s here. I would make this
{In the years that she had been baking commercially, there had been too many times when Craig had decided he deserved the baking more than the customer did.}
[She counted the chocolate covered strawberries β twelve. Perfect. Then the truffles β twelve as well. When she opened the box that held the cake, her face fell.]
Remove the spaces next to the em dashes.
[To look at it, you couldnβt tell based on height, but heβd messed up the icing hearts that encircled the cake β there was half a heart instead of a full heart.]
Remove the spaces on both sides of the em dashes.
This reads a little awkwardly. I would make it
{Looking at it, you couldn't tell based on height, but he'd messed up the iced hearts encircling the cakeβthere was half a heart instead of a full heart.}
[Maisie put down the cake, and stomped upstairs where she found Craig watching something stupid on television.]
I would move the comma. Instead of putting it after [cake] put it after [upstairs]
[βThis is the last time that I am going to have you sabotage my work.]
I don't think you need the word [that] here. I used to use the word [that] a lot, but some people pointed out to me that it wasn't necessary to use it quite so much.
[So, Maisie, why do you think that this isnβt going to work?β]
Again, [that] isn't necessary here.
[Maisie turned to look at Craig before she returned to look at Dr. Peters.]
This could be more interesting if you reworked it a little. It's a bit bland with just the [look] twice. Maybe instead
{Maisie glanced at Craig, then focused on Dr. Peters again.}
[He crossed his arms across his chest.]
I would make this
{He crossed his arms on his chest.}
[but once he got a look at her face β her angry face β he switched his gaze back to the therapist.]
Remove the spaces next to the em dashes.
[Maisie took a big, deep, breath before she started to talk, centring herself, trying to regain her calm.]
I think you should remove the comma after [deep]. Also, [centring] is a typo. If you're doing American English, it should be {centering} and if it's UK English it should be {centreing}
[First off, baking is my job β JOB!]
Remove the spaces next to the em dash.
[βItβs like I only get the not-good-enough treats β the seconds.]
Remove the spaces next to the em dash.
[Thatβs the reason that we separated β not your eating the desserts I prepared for others,]
Remove the spaces on both sides of the em dashes.
[βWe are β¦ were separated.]
Delete the space before and after the [β¦]
[βCan you explain to me how Mr. Wright happened to be in your work kitchen.]
A would put a question mark at the end of this, not a period. It's a question.
[There was Craig, laying on the floor]
[laying] should be {lying}
[βWhat was Craig allergic to, specifically?β Waits asked, pointing to the EpiPen?β]
At the end of this line, there should be a period, not [?"]
[βHer finger prints werenβt of the glass pie cover.β]
I believe [of] is supposed to be {on} here.
[like she tampered with the EpiPen.]
I would add {if} after [like]
My goodness, what a case.
Reply
Reply
Haha! I was wondering if that was purposeful . . . Thank you.
How is your editing of Genesis going?
Reply
Reply
Would you like me to go through them and do edits, or not? I stopped doing edit comments because I just wanted to read the story as fast as I could.
Reply
Reply
Yes, I know! Just thought I would check. Godspeed on your editing!
Reply
I have a new prayer request at the top of my bio.
Reply
Opening scene from Metanoia
Location: a gathering room adjacent to a conference room, Allied Space Territory.
Various species are milling about talking quietly, mostly in same-species groups.
A hush sweeps the room as a new species enter: forgs. One 6'7" with dark brown scales, the other light gray and more than 7' tall. The latter moves slowly, gazing boldly about himself as he stalks across the room. On reaching the far wall, he leans against it, crosses his arms, and glares, making and holding eye contact with anyone who looks his way, waiting for them to break it.
Reply
Reply
I guess now is the time to say this: No part of Metanoia, whether character, setting, technology, etc. is in any way a fanfic, copy, or inspired by Rune/Genesis. I have had these ideas since before I read your story. There is going to be a black forg, but I had the idea to make a big, tall, strong, black-colored alien character years ago. Just a disclaimer. ;)
Glad you like it so far!
Reply