Recipe for the Perfect Love Match

Submitted into Contest #270 in response to: Write a story in the form of a recipe.... view prompt

2 comments

Romance Contemporary Fantasy

Ingredients:

  • 1 Client (a man, heart bruised but still open)
  • 1 Matchmaker (a woman with more intuition than she knows what to do with)
  • 2 Pinches of undeniable chemistry
  • 1 Scoop of shared secrets
  • A handful of longing
  • 1 Brush of fingers (start slow, increase heat as needed)
  • 1 Unexpected late-night conversation
  • 1 Cup of vulnerability (heaping)
  • 2 Scoops of self-discovery
  • A sprinkle of laughter
  • A generous serving of trust (to bind the ingredients)
  • 1 Slow-burning romance
  • 1 Intimate weekend
  • A dash of risk (optional, but recommended for maximum flavor)
  • 1 Bold confession
  • Garnish with future promises and hope.

Instructions:

  1. Preheat the Heart: Begin with a man who, despite his bravado, is a little weary from love. Our client, Elliot, enters the matchmaker’s office with guarded hope. His past relationships haven’t satisfied the deep craving inside him—the kind of longing for a connection that goes beyond the surface. He has high expectations, but he doesn’t quite know how to articulate them. That’s where she comes in.
  2. Add the Matchmaker: Valarie Cupid—a woman with an air of casual elegance, her smile as warm as a hearth. She’s the type of matchmaker who doesn’t just take notes; she observes body language, catches the flicker in her client’s eyes when they speak of love lost or dreams deferred. As she sits across from Elliot, pen poised, she listens to more than his words.

"You’re not looking for just anyone," she says, her tone teasing yet knowing. "You want the one who makes your pulse race in all the right ways, don’t you?"

Elliot chuckles, a bit nervously. "Yeah, that’d be nice."

Valarie jots something down, her lips curving. "We’ll find him."

  1. Mix in the First Layer of Chemistry: Over the next few weeks, they meet several times. Valarie’s process is deliberate—no rushing through bios or hastily arranged dates. She watches Elliot as she suggests potential matches, noting the ones that light his interest and the ones that fall flat. But something else stirs in their conversations. It starts innocently enough—a lingering glance, a smile that lingers too long to be strictly professional.

"I think I’ve got someone for you," Valarie says one evening, standing by her desk after their latest session. Elliot looks at her, the soft lighting casting a halo around her dark hair. There’s something in the air between them, a quiet, humming electricity.

"I’m trusting you," Elliot says, a note of something deeper in his voice. "I need this to be right."

And for a moment, Valarie wonders if he’s really talking about the match—or something else entirely.

  1. Add a Pinch of Late-Night Texts: The matchmaker-client dynamic should always be professional, but sometimes lines blur. Valarie finds herself texting him after hours, sending snippets of thoughts that feel far too personal. “I think I’ve found someone. I’ll tell you more tomorrow,” followed by a winking emoji. His reply comes minutes later: “Don’t leave me hanging like that.”

Their texts become a slow burn, each message pulling them closer together, though neither admits it aloud. She sends him little teasers about the men she’s found, but somehow, the focus always shifts back to them—how was your day, did you get home okay, what’s your favorite drink? Small things that, over time, feel monumental.

  1. Stir in Vulnerability: As Valarie prepares to introduce Elliot to his first match, she feels an odd flutter in her chest—a strange sense of reluctance. It’s irrational, of course. This is her job. And yet…

They meet one evening in a café, not for a date, but for a check-in. Elliot walks in, and Valarie’s breath catches. The way he looks at her—like he’s been waiting for her all day—makes her stomach flip. As they talk about his upcoming date, Valarie finds herself sharing more about her life than she usually does. She talks about the clients she’s matched before, the ones who have made her question whether love can be so easily arranged.

"And you?" Elliot asks, eyes searching hers. "Do you believe in all of this? In finding the perfect match?"

She hesitates, then smiles, soft and a little sad. "I believe in chemistry. The rest… depends."

  1. Increase the Heat: The first touch is accidental—or so it seems. As they leave the café, their hands brush, sending a jolt up her spine. It’s brief, but enough to leave her wondering. Later that night, as she lies in bed, Valarie stares at her phone, debating whether to send another message. But before she can decide, her phone buzzes.

"I don’t think I’m ready for tomorrow," Elliot’s text reads. "Not for the match, at least."

Her heart skips. She types out a quick reply: "What are you ready for?"

His answer comes moments later, simple and devastatingly honest: "Something real."

  1. Add Laughter, Slowly Mix in Trust: The night of the match arrives, but Elliot cancels at the last minute. Instead, he invites Valarie out, though the context is clear—this isn’t about work anymore. They meet at a quiet bar, where the conversation flows easily, peppered with laughter and teasing. There’s no mention of other men, no talk of matchmaking. Just them.

"You’re trouble, you know that?" Valarie says, sipping her drink. "This wasn’t supposed to happen."

Elliot leans in, his eyes dark and focused. "What wasn’t supposed to happen?"

She doesn’t answer, but they both know.

  1. Turn Up the Heat: The first kiss is inevitable. It happens after a few more drinks and an even longer conversation. Outside the bar, the air is cool, but her skin is flushed. He leans in, tentative at first, but when their lips finally touch, it’s like everything falls into place. It’s a kiss that’s been building since their first meeting, a culmination of every glance, every shared moment, every unspoken word.

When they finally pull away, breathless, Valarie grins, feeling a warmth she hasn’t felt in years. "So, does this mean you’re not interested in any of my matches?"

Elliot chuckles, his hand sliding around her waist. "I think I’ve already found my match."

  1. Let it Simmer: Over the next few days, the connection between them grows stronger. They spend a weekend away—nothing extravagant, just a cozy bed-and-breakfast. It’s there, in the quiet moments between conversations and touches, that they both realize what’s happening is more than just an unexpected romance. It’s something deeper. Valarie wasn’t looking to fall for a client, and Elliot certainly wasn’t expecting to find his perfect match in his matchmaker, but here they are.
  2. Garnish with a Bold Confession: One night, as they lie together, bodies intertwined, Elliot breaks the silence. "You’re more than I ever thought I deserved," he whispers, his voice thick with emotion. "I didn’t know I was looking for you, but now that I’ve found you, I can’t imagine anyone else."

Valarie smiles, her heart full. "I guess we’re both good at finding what we need when we least expect it."

October 04, 2024 23:34

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

2 comments

Alexis Araneta
15:50 Oct 05, 2024

Jax, the romantic in me swooned at all of this. Your romance from meeting to the confession was such a sweet dish ! Amazing stuff !

Reply

Jax Wilder
02:04 Oct 06, 2024

Awe shucks. Thank you so much for reading. I really appreciate it!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. 100% free.