Submitted to: Contest #315

The Day I Met the Wrong Person at Exactly the Right Time

Written in response to: "Your character meets someone who changes their life forever."

Contemporary Funny Romance

He didn’t rescue me. He didn’t stay. But he left me with no way back to who I was.

I was sitting on the cold metal bench outside the train station—the one with the gum stuck underneath that’s been there since the ’90s—waiting for a train I had no intention of boarding. I wasn’t going anywhere. That was the whole point.

I’d been there for over an hour, watching people with places to be and lives to live, while my coffee went from hot to lukewarm to that perfect bacterial petri-dish temperature.

I’d been invisible all day. Which was exactly what I wanted—until it wasn’t. There’s a dangerous point where invisibility stops being peaceful and starts feeling like a dress rehearsal for your own obituary. That’s where I was.

My phone was off. My hair was in that special “I don’t give a fuck” knot that somehow requires more effort than an actual hairstyle. I was wearing my oldest hoodie—the one with the bleach stain shaped like Australia—because if you’re going to have a breakdown in public, you might as well look like someone who’s just shopping for cat litter.

That’s when he showed up.

Not the love-of-my-life type of “he.” No. More like the wrong person at exactly the right time kind of “he.” The kind who doesn’t smell like cologne but like rain and cigarettes and trouble.

He stopped right in front of me and stared. Not the casual glance people give when they’re deciding whether you’re homeless or just eccentric. This was a full-body scan, like he was trying to read the fine print on my soul.

“You’re in the wrong place,” he said.

I snorted. “Thanks, Sherlock. Did the trench coat give you that clue?”

He sat down next to me, uninvited, knees jiggling in that restless way that says either caffeine overload or an overactive brain that hasn’t slept in three days.

“I mean,” he said, “you’re not going to get on a train. So why are you here?”

I wanted to tell him to mind his own business. Instead, what came out was: “Because the alternative was staying home and staring at my ceiling until the existential dread ate me alive.”

He grinned like I’d just given the correct answer to a question he’d been waiting years to ask.

“Good,” he said. “Means you’re not dead yet.”

And just like that, I hated him. And needed him. Both at once.

---

We didn’t introduce ourselves. We didn’t need names. He just started talking—like he’d been saving up words for months and I was the first unlucky bastard to sit still long enough to hear them.

He told me about the time he faked an asthma attack to get out of a date, about the job he quit in the middle of a meeting because someone used the word “synergy” unironically, and about how he used to get high just to feel like he deserved food.

I should have walked away. Instead, I found myself talking too. About the way my legs hurt in the mornings before I even stood up. About the marriage that looked perfect in pictures but came with enough silence to fill a cathedral. About the fact that I’d been carrying around a list of reasons to stay alive, and lately, the list felt more like homework than hope.

“You think too much,” he said finally.

“Thanks, Doctor Freud.”

“No, seriously. You’re busy making lists and what-ifs, when you should be making messes.”

I wanted to argue. Instead, I asked, “And what exactly is the cure for chronic overthinking, oh wise one?”

He leaned in, and for a second I thought he was going to say something poetic. Instead, he said:

“Start by doing one thing today you’ll regret tomorrow. It’s the fastest way to remind yourself you’re alive.”

---

We ended up in a bar. Not the nice kind with craft cocktails and ironic Edison bulbs. The kind with sticky floors, toilets that flush when they feel like it, and a jukebox stuck on ’90s alt-rock.

I hadn’t been in a place like that in years. My drinks had evolved into overpriced wine with tasting notes. This was… different. Here, beer was beer, served by a guy with tattoos that looked like they’d been done in a prison laundry room.

We drank. We didn’t toast. We didn’t take selfies. We didn’t pretend it was a moment worth documenting. It wasn’t romantic. It wasn’t inspiring. It was loud, messy, and exactly what I didn’t know I needed.

At one point, he lit a cigarette and looked at me like he was studying the weather. “You’re not as broken as you think,” he said.

I laughed so hard beer almost came out of my nose. “Oh, sweetie, I’m broken in places you haven’t even heard of.”

“Good,” he said. “Means there’s more to fix.”

---

Somewhere between beer four and bad karaoke, I realized he was right about one thing: I wasn’t dead yet. I wasn’t fixed. I wasn’t even close. But I was… awake. Awake in a way I hadn’t been in years.

And that scared the shit out of me.

Because being awake meant feeling things. And feeling things meant I might have to start doing things. And doing things meant I couldn’t keep hiding in the safe, suffocating little bubble I’d built around myself.

---

When the night ended, he walked me back to the station. The same bench. The same gum still stuck underneath.

“This is where I leave you,” he said.

“That’s it? No grand goodbye? No promise to change each other’s lives forever?” I tried to make it sound like a joke. It came out like a plea.

He shook his head. “I already did.”

And then he walked away. No number. No name. Just… gone.

---

It’s been two years. I still don’t know his name. I never saw him again. But I started doing one thing a day I might regret tomorrow.

Some days it’s small—telling someone what I really think instead of what they want to hear. Some days it’s big—quitting a job without a backup plan.

And yeah—sometimes it hurts. Sometimes I fuck up spectacularly. But every time I do, I think about that bench, that beer, that stranger who told me I wasn’t dead yet.

And he was right.

I’m not.

Posted Aug 08, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

17 likes 15 comments

Rebecca Hurst
11:37 Aug 18, 2025

This is great, Jelena. Speaking as a person who deliberately seeks out the very worst bars and makes myself at home, I understand the interactions we must make to burst our bubbles. Good work!

Reply

Jelena Jelly
16:16 Aug 18, 2025

Cheers, Rebecca! Worst bars are where God sends his rejects to swap trauma stories over flat beer — perfect breeding ground for bubbles to burst.

Reply

Derek Roberts
13:55 Aug 15, 2025

"There’s a dangerous point where invisibility stops being peaceful and starts feeling like a dress rehearsal for your own obituary." - WOW! You swing from one powerful image to another.
"But I was… awake. Awake in a way I hadn’t been in years.
And that scared the shit out of me." Absolutely. Misery not only love company but it thrives on routine.
"It’s been two years. I still don’t know his name. I never saw him again. But I started doing one thing a day I might regret tomorrow." It's good to be uncomfortable while chasing a better life/mind/heart.
This story reads like a key to unlock our sense of grief and loss and failure. It's really beautiful.

Reply

Jelena Jelly
18:15 Aug 15, 2025

Derek, when I saw your like without a comment, I honestly got scared it didn’t land. Reading this now is such a relief. Thank you for catching exactly what I wanted to convey — it means more than you know.🫂

Reply

Derek Roberts
19:14 Aug 15, 2025

Sometimes, I read a a story and give it a like just to help boost it up the chart, but I usually go back and write review...but especially for you.

Reply

Jelena Jelly
21:10 Aug 15, 2025

That honestly means the world, Derek. Knowing you’d do that for me really touched my heart… and yes, I’m smiling right now, so mission accomplished.🙃

Reply

14:04 Aug 13, 2025

"The kind who doesn’t smell like cologne but like rain and cigarettes and trouble."

Love this. Sounds like just the right kind of guy!

Inspired work. Challenging the reader to step out of their comfort zone and do something a bit more edgy.

Great piece of writing!

Reply

Jelena Jelly
11:22 Aug 14, 2025

Penelope, you’re my official confidence dealer. Thank you for always finding a way to make me think that maybe, just maybe, I actually know what I’m doing when I write.🫂

Reply

14:51 Aug 14, 2025

You absolutely do! Keep on producing the brilliant work! 😀

Reply

Jelena Jelly
17:21 Aug 14, 2025

🥰🥰

Reply

Saffron Roxanne
05:08 Aug 12, 2025

I feel like this story spoke to me too much… like I might be in trouble by tomorrow. (I’ll blame you for the chaos to come)

Ha! But I love this. So short but so enough! Hm, like a sort of dirty magic.

Thanks for sharing.

Reply

Jelena Jelly
13:10 Aug 12, 2025

Chaos is my love language.
If tomorrow gets you into trouble, at least you'll have a good story to tell… and I’ll happily take the blame. 😉
Glad the dirty magic worked on you.

Reply

Saffron Roxanne
23:49 Aug 12, 2025

😆🥰

Reply

Aaron Kennedy
03:31 Aug 23, 2025

What a fantastic snippet of life. I love how gritty and real this is. Thank you for letting us read it.

Reply

Jelena Jelly
16:51 Aug 23, 2025

Thank you so much, Aaron. Life’s gritty bits are usually the ones worth telling – glad it came across that way. Appreciate you taking the time to read and comment.

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.