Submitted to: Contest #299

The Asphalt Buccaneers

Written in response to: "Center your story around a comedian, clown, street performer, or magician."

Fiction Funny Inspirational

Ahoy, ye landlubbers! Gather ‘round your glowing screens and lend yer ears to the tale of Captain “Spectacular Steve” Sullivan and his motley crew aboard The Rusty Hatchback. ‘Twas a day so hot the asphalt be bubbling like the Devil’s own jacuzzi when our story unfurled its metaphorical sails...

In the urban seas of downtown sailed a peculiar vessel—a 1997 Dodge Caravan with more rust than paint, a peeling magnetic sign reading “THE ASPHALT BUCCANEERS: ENTERTAINMENT OR YOUR DOUBLOONS BACK,” and festooned with a rubber chicken wearing a tiny pirate hat as a hood ornament. This weathered craft carried the most fearsome crew of street entertainers this side of the Municipal Parking Enforcement Division.

At the helm stood Captain “Spectacular Steve” Sullivan, a magician whose sleight of hand was matched only by his delusions of pirate grandeur. With his discount store tricorn hat and deck of cards, the Captain navigated the treacherous waters of city ordinances with equal parts bravado and desperate improvisation.

“Swab the anchors and raise the poop deck, ye scurvy dogs!” Captain Steve bellowed as he parked illegally in a loading zone. “We’ve prime plunderin’ to do before the dreaded meter maids make their rounds!”

His loyal First Mate, Penelope, rolled her heavily made-up eyes. With a theater degree and six figures of student loan debt, the mime found herself second-in-command of this dubious enterprise.

“Captain,” she said wearily, “for the hundredth time, you can’t raise a poop deck—it’s a fixed part of the ship. And one doesn’t ‘swab’ anchors.”

“Belay that educated talk, First Mate!” the Captain retorted. “No audience ever paid gold doubloons to see proper seafaring protocol!”

From the sliding door emerged Guiomar “The Navigator” Segura, a juggler whose capacity for keeping objects airborne was surpassed only by his superstitious nature. Clutching his smartphone like a sacred sextant, he consulted three different weather apps and his horoscope.

“The digital stars be ominous today, Captain,” he muttered nervously. “Mercury’s in retrograde, and Yelp predicts a seventeen percent decrease in downtown foot traffic.”

“Nonsense!” Captain Steve declared. “Fortune favors the bold!”

The final crew member stumbled from the back of the van, nearly tripping over an untied shoelace. Jamie “Cabin Boy” Pembroke had joined the crew just two weeks prior, answering a Craigslist ad promising “ADVENTURE, FORTUNE, AND FLEXIBLE HOURS (no benefits).” With no discernible talents and crushing anxiety, Jamie had been assigned the crucial roles of equipment carrier, hat-passer, and occasional distraction during technical difficulties.

“Pardon, Captain,” Jamie said, struggling with an ancient speaker system, “but there’s another crew already set up at Fountain Square.”

The crew peered around the corner to behold their nemeses—The Queen Anne’s Restraining Order, led by the infamous “Black Jack” Jackson, a former cruise ship magician with a penchant for expensive leather vests. Their equipment gleamed in the sun, and a crowd had gathered to watch their slick performance.

“Those corporate corsairs!” Captain Steve hissed. “Sailing into our waters without so much as a by-your-leave!”

“I heard they got sponsorship,” First Mate Penelope announced. “From that new energy drink company.”

As they watched, Black Jack executed a flawless illusion involving a volunteer’s smartphone and a miniature drone. The crowd erupted in applause and a flurry of digital transactions.

“We’re sunk,” Jamie grumbled.

But Captain Steve Sullivan hadn’t survived fifteen years in street performance by admitting defeat. From his pocket, he produced a crumpled flyer. The crew huddled around as he smoothed it against the van.

“ANNUAL STREET PERFORMANCE FESTIVAL,” it proclaimed. “NEW THIS YEAR: GRAND COMPETITION! WINNER RECEIVES EXCLUSIVE YEAR-LONG PERMIT FOR PREMIUM PERFORMANCE LOCATION AT HARBOR FRONT PLAZA.”

“Harbor Front!” Penelope gasped. “That’s—”

“The most lucrative plunderin’ grounds in the city,” the Captain finished. “Thousands of tourist doubloons ripe for the takin’.”

“But Captain,” Jamie interjected, “isn’t the festival just two weeks away? And doesn’t it cost money to enter?”

“Details, mere details.” Captain Steve waved dismissively. “We shall devise a show so spectacular that victory shall be assured!”

With renewed purpose, the Asphalt Buccaneers set up on a smaller corner (“Skull Island” in the Captain’s ever-expanding mental map). As Jamie arranged their tip hat, the Captain gathered his crew.

“Remember, me hearties,” he said solemnly, “we be pirates of the pavement, buccaneers of the boulevard! Every smile we plunder brings us closer to our dream – health insurance and possibly a van with air conditioning!”

And with that stirring declaration, the crew set about filling their metaphorical treasure chest with the day’s meager earnings (a grand total of $37.42, two Canadian quarters, and what appeared to be a counterfeit arcade token). That evening, huddled around a sticky table at Denny’s (“The Captain’s Quarters,” according to Steve’s elaborate mental map of the city), they pooled their doubloons to pay the festival entry fee and plotted their path to glory with the gravity of naval officers planning an invasion.

Navigator Rodrigo sketched costume designs on napkins while First Mate Penelope listed potential routines that wouldn’t require actual talent. Jamie, meanwhile, was tasked with the vital mission of securing “authentic pirate provisions,” which mostly involved refilling their coffee cups and preventing the Captain from stealing sugar packets.

The following fortnight saw the Asphalt Buccaneers preparing with all the organization of a drunken parrot attempting calculus. Captain Steve, convinced that victory required “authentic pirate spectacle,” had devised a routine combining magic, mime, juggling, and what he described as “nautical derring-do.”

Their rehearsals occurred in Navigator Guiomar’s uncle’s garage, a space just large enough for the desperate performers practicing what First Mate Penelope termed “choreographed chaos.”

“No, NO!” Captain Steve bellowed after their seventeenth run-through ended with Jamie accidentally setting Guiomar’s beard afire. “The pyrotechnics come AFTER the card manipulation!”

“Perhaps,” First Mate Penelope suggested, extinguishing the last smoldering hairs, “we should simplify. The greatest pirates succeeded through boldness and simplicity, not... whatever this is.”

“Simplify? SIMPLIFY?” the Captain sputtered. “Did Blackbeard ‘simplify’ when confronted with the Royal Navy?”

“He died fighting them and had his head displayed as a trophy,” Jamie pointed out, earning a withering glare.

“Details, Cabin Boy! ‘Tis the spirit of the man that matters, not the specific manner of his demise! Now back to the rehearsal before I make YOUR head a warning to others!”

A series of calamities further hindered their preparations. The Rusty Hatchback’s transmission died with all the drama of a Shakespearean actor in their final bow—smoke, grinding noises, and what sounded like the mechanical equivalent of “Et tu, Brute?” Jamie developed a mysterious rash, and their rehearsal space was rendered unusable after Captain Steve’s “smoke illusion” triggered the building’s sprinkler system.

But the final blow came three days before the festival when First Mate Penelope arrived with a face more solemn than a funeral director’s LinkedIn profile.

“I’ve been approached,” she announced, “by The Queen Anne’s Restraining Order.”

Captain Steve dropped his trick deck. “Mutiny!”

Penelope held up a hand. “Not mutiny. I’ve declined their offer. But Black Jack showed me his festival routine. It’s like nothing I’ve ever seen.”

“Speak plainly,” Guiomar urged, clutching his lucky juggling balls.

“They’ve got drones, projection mapping, and a live DJ. Their whole performance is synchronized to an original music track, with lighting effects that would make Broadway weep. And they’ve hired actual dancers from the city ballet.”

“Then we’re doomed,” Guiomar said. “We cannot compete with corporate backing.”

Captain Steve paced, his discount tricorn hat brushing against the low ceiling. For once, the bombastic leader seemed at a loss.

It was Jamie who broke the silence. “Captain, why did you start performing in the first place?”

Steve stopped, looking momentarily thrown. “For the treasure, of course! The doubloons, the—”

“No,” Jamie interrupted with unexpected boldness. “The real reason.”

The Captain’s shoulders slumped, his perpetual performance dropping. “I was eight at the county fair,” he said quietly. “A magician picked me from the crowd. Made a silver dollar appear from behind my ear. It wasn’t the trick that got me – I could see how he did it. It was how he made me feel. Like I was part of something magical, even if we both knew it wasn’t real magic.”

He looked around at his crew. “That’s what we do. Not fancy drones or corporate-sponsored spectacle. We create moments – ridiculous, imperfect, human moments.”

Navigator Guiomar nodded. “Like when that tourist figured out my juggling pattern but still laughed when I pretended to drop a ball on his foot.”

“Or when I mimicked that arguing couple,” Penelope added, “and they stopped fighting to laugh at themselves.”

Captain Steve straightened his hat with renewed purpose. “We may not have drones or projection mapping,” he declared, his pirate persona returning, “but we have something those corporate corsairs will never understand – the true spirit of performance piracy!”

“Which is?” Guiomar asked.

“Making magic from nothing, stealing laughs with nothing but our wits, and never, EVER admitting that we don’t know what we’re doing!”

Now more determined than ever, the Buccaneers abandoned their complicated routine and returned to what they knew best – improvisation, audience interaction, and the fine art of looking like failures on purpose rather than by accident.

As the fateful day of the festival approached, the crew spent their final hours not in frantic rehearsal but in what Captain Steve grandly termed “strategic psychological warfare preparation,” which mostly involved stitching loose sequins back onto costumes and consuming alarming quantities of gas station coffee.

By dawn’s first light, they had loaded their meager props into Jamie’s mother’s borrowed AMC Pacer and set sail for City Park, their confidence bolstered by Rodrigo’s insistence that he’d spotted three red-tailed hawks that morning—a sign of certain victory, or possibly impending rainfall.

The festival grounds at City Park had been transformed into a bustling marketplace of entertainment. Jugglers, musicians, acrobats, and performers of every description competed for attention and a spot in the grand competition.

The Asphalt Buccaneers arrived, their revised props consisting mainly of items acquired from the dollar store. Captain Steve had insisted on maintaining their pirate aesthetic, though the eye patches and inflatable parrots looked even more absurd in the harsh light of day.

“Steady as she goes, me hearties,” the Captain murmured as they surveyed the competition. “Remember our code – we may not be the most polished crew, but we be the most persistent!”

Their spirits fell when they spotted The Queen Anne’s Restraining Order’s setup – a stage complete with lighting rigs, sound equipment from the future, and a team of stagehands wearing matching sponsor shirts.

Black Jack himself stood directing operations like a field marshal. Spotting the Buccaneers, he sauntered over, his smile as genuine as a three-dollar bill.

“Steve! You actually showed up. And in... costume, I see.” His gaze swept over them. “Adorable. Very... community theater.”

“We be here to claim what’s rightfully ours,” Captain Steve replied, drawing himself up to his full height (which, at five-foot-eight, was less impressive than his tone suggested).

Before Black Jack responded, a festival organizer approached. “Bad news, performers. Due to a permitting issue, we’ve reduced competition slots from ten to five. Preliminary rounds start in thirty minutes.”

As he walked away, Black Jack’s smile turned predatory. “Well, well. Seems the competition just got fiercer.”

The preliminary round was grueling. The Buccaneers performed their revamped routine – a blend of Captain Steve’s card tricks, Penelope’s mime work, Guiomar’s juggling, and Jamie’s surprisingly effective slapstick – for a modestly enthusiastic crowd.

When the results were announced, Navigator Guiomar’s knees almost buckled. Against all odds—and probably several laws of probability—the Asphalt Buccaneers had secured the fifth and final slot in the competition. To no one’s astonishment, The Queen Anne's Restraining Order had claimed the coveted closing position.

“We made it by the skin of our teeth,” First Mate Penelope observed. “But Black Jack’s crew will blow everyone away with their production value.”

Captain Steve stared at their rivals’ technical rehearsal. The drones formed patterns while projections transformed the stage – a stark contrast to the Buccaneers’ hand-painted backdrop depicting what might generously be called a pirate ship.

“We’ve no chance of competing with that,” he admitted.

“Then we don’t,” Jamie said suddenly. When the crew stared, the cabin boy flushed but continued. “I mean, we don’t try to beat them at their game. We play a different one entirely.”

“Go on, Cabin Boy” the Captain encouraged.

“They’re doing this perfectly choreographed, high-tech show, right? Everything rehearsed down to the second. But what happens if something goes wrong?”

A slow grin spread across Captain Steve’s face. “Chaos. Beautiful, magnificent chaos.”

“And who thrives in chaos?” First Mate Penelope asked.

“Pirates!” Guiomar exclaimed.

For the next hour, the Asphalt Buccaneers hatched a plan that even Captain Steve acknowledged was “madness bordering on mutiny, but in the best possible way.”

The competition began with the first three finalists delivering impressive performances. An acrobatic troupe, a one-man band, and break-dancers all received enthusiastic applause. But the anticipation built for the final two acts – the mysterious Asphalt Buccaneers and the heavily promoted Queen Anne’s Restraining Order.

When their turn came, Captain Steve led his crew onstage with all the confidence of a man who either had a brilliant plan or was about to commit career suicide.

“Ladies and gentlemen,” he announced, “we be the Asphalt Buccaneers, humble pirates of the concrete seas! We’ve no fancy gadgets or corporate backing – just four fools with a dream and possibly undiagnosed concussions.”

This earned a ripple of laughter, encouraging him to continue.

“We’d planned to show ye a routine of middling skill, but instead... we’re going to tell ye a story. A true tale of modern piracy!”

What followed was unlike anything the festival had seen. Using minimal props and maximum charisma, the Buccaneers enacted the story of their own misadventures – from their first meeting to their rivalry with The Queen Anne’s Restraining Order, portrayed by Penelope with a devastatingly accurate mimicry of Black Jack that had the audience howling.

They incorporated audience members, improvised scenes based on shouts from the crowd, and revealed the genuine humanity behind their pirate personas. Jamie, usually relegated to the background, shone in depicting their disastrous rehearsals, displaying unexpected talent for physical comedy.

As they reached the climax, a commotion erupted. The Queen Anne’s Restraining Order was beginning their technical setup early, their drones humming to life above the audience.

Captain Steve incorporated this interruption seamlessly. “Ah! Right on cue! The dread technologically advanced rivals appear on the horizon!”

Black Jack, realizing he was being mocked, signaled his crew to accelerate. One drone swooped low over the Buccaneers’ space.

“Cannonball!” Captain Steve shouted, and the crew turned the interruption into part of their show, diving behind props and “returning fire” with foam balls.

The audience, realizing they were witnessing not just a performance but an actual rivalry, became fully invested in the underdog pirates. When one of Black Jack’s drones suddenly malfunctioned – spinning wildly before crashing into the sound equipment with a shower of sparks – the crowd gasped.

Black Jack’s crew rushed to salvage their showcase, but the damage was spreading. The projection system glitched, displaying error messages. The sound system emitted a high-pitched whine.

“Technical difficulties, me hearties!” Captain Steve called out. “But fear not – the Asphalt Buccaneers specialize in navigating treacherous waters!”

The Buccaneers transformed the technical disaster into an interactive moment. Penelope mime-created an invisible wall between the malfunctioning equipment and the audience. Guiomar juggled to distract frightened children. Captain Steve performed magic tricks that made the glitches appear almost intentional.

And Jamie, spotting an opportunity, grabbed the microphone that had rolled from Black Jack’s stage.

“Ladies and gentlemen,” the Cabin Boy announced with unexpected confidence, “what you’re witnessing is the difference between performance that depends on technology and performance that depends on heart. When the gadgets fail, pirates adapt!”

The audience erupted in cheers as the Buccaneers took a bow, while Black Jack’s crew struggled to reboot their system.

When the judges’ decision was announced, the Asphalt Buccaneers had been awarded the Harbor Front permit for having “demonstrated extraordinary adaptability, audience connection, and the true spirit of street performance.”

Black Jack approached Captain Steve with grudging respect. “You sabotaged our equipment, didn’t you?”

Captain Steve placed a hand over his heart. “On my honor as a pirate of the pavement, we did nothing of the sort. The sea of technology be dangerous, and ye placed too much faith in favorable winds.”

After a moment, Black Jack nodded. “This isn’t over, Sullivan. We’ll be back next year with a routine so foolproof that not even your chaos can derail it.”

“Looking forward to it,” the Captain said with a genuine smile. “Make sure ye purchase the extended warranty on yer contraptions next time, savvy? Though if ye need any lessons in the ancient art of not catching fire mid-performance, the Asphalt Buccaneers offer very reasonable rates!”

The Asphalt Buccaneers celebrated at Denny’s. Captain Steve raised his coffee mug in a toast.

“To the finest crew a captain ever had the privilege to lead! May our coffers overflow with Harbor Front booty, and may The Rusty Hatchback survive at least until winter!”

“To adaptation in the face of adversity,” First Mate Penelope added.

“To signs and portents that actually came true,” Guiomar contributed.

Jamie, now promoted from Cabin Boy to “Powder Monkey,” raised a mug of hot chocolate. “To finding treasure that isn’t gold or jewels.”

Captain Steve nodded. “Indeed, for the greatest plunder is not that which fills our pockets, but that which fills our—”

“If you say ‘hearts,’ I will mime vomiting on your pancakes,” Penelope warned.

The Captain grinned. “I was going to say ‘stomachs,’ actually. Pass the syrup, ye scurvy dog!”

And so the Asphalt Buccaneers continued their adventures on the concrete seas, proving that with sufficient audacity, questionable fashion choices, and genuine connection, even the most unlikely pirates can find their treasure in the modern world.

Posted Apr 23, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

3 likes 3 comments

Dennis C
23:38 Apr 28, 2025

The festival scene was such a great payoff, with the crowd getting swept up in the Buccaneers’ improvisation. You guys nailed that underdog moment where they find their strength in being themselves.

Reply

20:45 Apr 25, 2025

Thanks Kristi! I had fun writing the story, really had to channel my inner swashbuckler!

Reply

Kristi Gott
23:29 Apr 23, 2025

Lol, funny, clever, witty, and great pirate language. Very creative answer to the prompt. A fun read!

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.