American Fantasy Horror

"For what is a man profited, if he shall gain the whole world, and lose his own soul? or what shall a man give in exchange for his soul?"

Matthew 16:26

Los Angeles in 1925 was no place for the faint of heart. It was a city of mirages, painted desert backdrops, and endless opportunity—provided you were willing to play by rules no one ever wrote down and to pay prices no one ever mentioned.

Celia Hart had been in the city for eighteen months, and she still hadn’t made it past playing “third flapper from the left” or “girl in the crowd.” Her dark curls and bright eyes earned her compliments from every photographer in town, but compliments didn’t pay for rent on her little room above a bakery on Olive Street. Her feet ached from waitressing at Musso & Frank’s by day, and her dignity ached from begging casting directors for a chance by night.

She thought she’d tried everything. Until she met him.

It was at the corner of Sunset and Gower, on a night when the fog curled low over the streetlamps and the palms rustled like gossiping ghosts. Celia had just left another humiliating audition, this one for a serial called Jungle Hearts, where they asked her to screech and faint on cue. She’d tripped on her own skirt and the producer had laughed so hard he nearly choked on his cigar.

She’d ducked into an alley to cry, clutching the sides of her cheap fur wrap and trying not to let her mascara run down her cheeks.

“You’ve got quite a face,” came a voice from the shadows.

She spun around. A man stepped into the light—or what passed for a man. His suit was white, but not the kind of white that clothes ever came in; it shimmered faintly, like moonlight on water. His smile was polite but knowing. And his eyes—they were the most peculiar part—gray as smoke, with flecks of gold that sparkled as he studied her.

“You startled me,” Celia managed, pressing a hand to her chest.

“I do that sometimes,” he said smoothly. “Forgive me. I couldn’t help but notice your… predicament.”

Her laugh was bitter. “If you’re looking for a date, mister, you can keep walking. I’m not that kind of girl.”

He chuckled, low and soft, and Celia shivered at the sound.

“No,” he said. “Not that kind of proposition. I can help you, Miss Hart. I help many. I open doors.”

He extended his hand. She stared at it. Long, elegant fingers. A perfect manicure. Celia hesitated, then shook it. His touch was cool, dry, almost electric.

“Who are you?” she whispered.

“You may call me the Angel,” he said.

That night, Celia found herself sitting at a table at the Biltmore with the director of Jungle Hearts and three casting agents. She didn’t quite remember how she’d gotten there, except that the Angel had told her to smile and follow his lead.

When she spoke, her words seemed to charm everyone. When she laughed, the whole table laughed with her. Before dessert arrived, they offered her the lead in the serial.

Over the next weeks, her name started appearing in trade papers. A gossip columnist called her “the brightest new face in the silent era,” and fan letters began arriving at the bakery where she still lived. Women asked for beauty tips; men asked for signed photographs.

The Angel was always nearby. Sometimes he appeared at her door in the evening, wearing that otherworldly suit. Sometimes he was just a voice in her ear, whispering what to say to the studio bosses or which reporters to flatter.

At first, she felt like she was dreaming. Then she began to feel something else: watched.

By midsummer, Jungle Hearts had made her a star. The studio gave her a new name—Celia Starling—and a bungalow in Beverly Hills. At twenty-two, she had her own chauffeur, her own dressing room, her own telephone line.

The Angel never asked her for anything. Not yet.

But things began to happen.

During the filming of a scene where she swung across a jungle ravine on a vine, the stuntman fell thirty feet to his death, and everyone said it was just an accident—except that she could still hear him screaming in her sleep.

A fan broke into her house one night, raving that she was an angel herself. He cut his own throat on her marble steps.

Every time she looked in the mirror now, she thought she saw something behind her. A dark silhouette with faint, golden eyes.

One night she confronted the Angel as he leaned in her doorway.

“Why are these things happening?” she demanded. “People keep getting hurt.”

He gave her that same polite smile.

“Fame always leaves casualties,” he murmured. “Did you really think it would be different for you?”

She swallowed hard. “But… I didn’t ask for anyone to die.”

“No,” he agreed. “But you asked to shine. And when a star shines… others burn.”

A year later, she was the queen of Hollywood.

Jungle Hearts had made her famous; her follow-up, a lavish romantic epic called The Prince’s Bride, made her a legend. Theaters sold out. Fans screamed her name on the street. Paparazzi lay in wait outside restaurants.

And she hated every minute of it.

She couldn’t sleep anymore. The walls of her house seemed to whisper. Her skin sometimes crawled with invisible hands. At parties, men tried to touch her and flinched away as if she were made of ice. Other actresses looked at her with envy that quickly soured into fear.

Her mother stopped returning her letters. The priest at St. Vibiana’s refused her confession.

And always, always, the Angel was there—watching her from some quiet corner, smiling faintly as if he knew something she didn’t.

The night it all came to a head, she was hosting a gala at her home. The house was full of laughter, music, the smell of champagne. But Celia stood alone at the window, staring out at the moonlit garden, and saw a shape standing on the lawn.

It was the Angel, waiting.

She went out to him barefoot, her silk gown whispering against the stones.

“I want it to stop,” she said bluntly.

“Stop?” he echoed, with a mild tilt of his head.

“All of it. I don’t want any more of it. The movies, the cameras, the parties. The blood. I want my old life back.”

For the first time, his smile widened enough to show teeth.

“I’m afraid,” he said softly, “that’s not possible. My dear girl… you signed the contract.”

“I never signed anything,” she shot back, though her voice wavered.

He laughed then—not cruelly, but like a teacher laughing at a naïve child.

“You said yes to me, Miss Hart. That was enough. Words are binding, more than ink.”

Her breath came fast. “So what happens now? Are you going to kill me?”

He shook his head.

“Oh no,” he said. “You belong to me now. You’ll go on shining, brighter and brighter, until you burn out. And then—”

“What?” she demanded.

He leaned close, his breath cold against her ear.

“And then,” he whispered, “you come home with me.”

That winter, her films began to take on a strange quality. Reviewers said she was “hypnotic,” that her eyes seemed to follow you even after you left the theater. Audiences packed the seats, but they left unsettled, murmuring about nightmares and shadows.

One critic wrote:

"Celia Starling’s beauty is like staring at the sun. You can’t look away, but you feel something in you dying when you do."

More accidents happened. A lighting rig collapsed on set, killing two cameramen. A co-star drowned in his pool under mysterious circumstances.

Her dreams grew darker. Sometimes she woke to find scratches on her skin, though her bedroom door was locked from the inside. Sometimes she thought she heard voices chanting her name outside the window.

And sometimes, when she stood in front of the mirror, her reflection would smile before she did.

On the opening night of her biggest picture yet—Heaven’s Kiss—she stood backstage at Grauman’s Chinese Theatre, staring at the enormous crowd that had come to worship her. The marquee blazed her name in gold:

CELIA STARLING

HEAVEN’S KISS

She could hear them chanting it outside: Celia, Celia, Celia…

And above it all, she heard his voice again.

“You’ve done beautifully,” the Angel murmured.

He was leaning against the curtain, immaculate as ever.

“But it’s time,” he added.

She spun to face him. “Time? Time for what?”

“For you to come with me.”

Her heart pounded in her chest. “No. No! I won’t!”

His expression never changed. But his gray eyes glimmered gold as he stepped toward her.

“Oh, Celia,” he sighed. “You already did.”

They say she fainted that night. Some say she had a nervous breakdown. Some say she disappeared entirely.

Her body was never found.

But sometimes, if you walk down Sunset Boulevard just after midnight, you can see her. Standing on the corner of Gower, dressed in a white gown, her curls perfect, her lips curved in a smile that doesn’t quite reach her eyes.

And if you listen closely, you can hear her whisper:

"For what is a woman profited, if she shall gain the whole world, and lose her own soul?"

Behind her, in the shadows, you might also see the faint outline of a man in white, watching with golden eyes.

Still smiling.

The Angel of Sunset Boulevard never left.

Some say he still offers deals to starry-eyed dreamers who think fame is worth any price.

And some say Celia Starling is still out there, her soul bound to the city that devoured her.

If you ever find yourself in an alley near Gower Street on a foggy night, and you see a man in white smiling at you, remember:

Not all angels come from heaven.

And not all fame is worth the cost.

Posted Jul 05, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

1 like 1 comment

Jonathan Page
22:13 Jul 06, 2025

Wonderful storytelling Jethro! This is a great premise and well carried out!

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.