0 comments

Adventure American Drama

Sarah always thought her worst nightmare would be spiders, or heights, or maybe even public speaking. She was wrong. Her worst nightmare turned out to be herself – or rather, the version of herself she saw in the mirror that night.

It started with a text message from an unknown number: "Look in the mirror at midnight. See who you really are." She'd dismissed it as spam, deleted it without a second thought. But as midnight approached, she found herself drawn to the full-length mirror in her bedroom, the one she'd inherited from her grandmother.

The mirror had always been peculiar, with its ornate bronze frame and slight discoloration around the edges. Tonight, it seemed different. The glass appeared deeper somehow, as if it extended beyond the wall behind it. Sarah checked her phone: 11:59 PM.

"This is ridiculous," she muttered, but her heart was already racing. The rational part of her brain screamed to walk away, to go to bed and forget about cryptic text messages and ancient mirrors. Instead, she stepped closer.

Midnight struck.

At first, nothing happened. Sarah let out a nervous laugh, relief washing over her. Then she saw it – a slight movement in the mirror that didn't match her own. Her reflection's eyes met hers, but they weren't moving in sync anymore. The reflection smiled, a cold, calculating expression Sarah had never worn in her life.

"Hello, Sarah," her reflection said. Sarah's mouth hadn't moved. "Shall we talk about what you've been hiding?"

Sarah stumbled backward, but the reflection stepped forward, maintaining the same distance between them. "This isn't real," Sarah whispered. "I'm dreaming. I must be dreaming."

"Oh, you're very much awake," her reflection replied. "And we have so much to discuss. Let's start with what happened to Dad."

Sarah's blood ran cold. "Stop."

"You told everyone it was an accident," the reflection continued, its voice dripping with contempt. "That you didn't see him fall. That you tried to catch him. But we both know that's not true, don't we?"

"I was seven," Sarah said, her voice breaking. "I didn't mean to—"

"Didn't mean to what? Push him? Or didn't mean to lie about it for twenty years?" The reflection's face twisted into something cruel and familiar. "You've gotten so good at lying, Sarah. To Mom, to your therapists, to yourself. But you can't lie to me. I'm every dark thought you've ever had, every secret you've buried, every moment of weakness you've tried to forget."

Sarah's legs gave out, and she sank to the floor. The reflection remained standing, looking down at her with those cold, knowing eyes. "What do you want from me?"

"The truth," it said simply. "Stop running from who you are. Stop pretending to be this perfect, put-together person who never makes mistakes, who never hurts anyone. You're not fooling anyone but yourself."

"I'm not pretending," Sarah protested, but even as she said it, she felt the familiar weight of deception on her tongue.

The reflection laughed, a harsh, brittle sound. "Really? Should we talk about Michael then? About how you knew he was married when you started seeing him? Or about Claire, your 'best friend' who you secretly hate because she got the promotion you wanted? Or maybe we should discuss the real reason you never visit Mom in the nursing home?"

Each accusation hit like a physical blow. Sarah pressed her hands against her ears, trying to block out the words, but they seemed to come from inside her own head now.

"Stop it, stop it, stop it!"

"You can't stop the truth, Sarah. It lives in here, in every reflection, in every quiet moment when you're alone with your thoughts. You can run from it, bury it, deny it, but it will always find you."

Sarah forced herself to look up, to meet those merciless eyes that were somehow her own. "What's your point? That I'm a terrible person? That I don't deserve forgiveness? Fine. You win. Is that what you wanted to hear?"

The reflection's expression softened, just slightly. "No, Sarah. What I want is for you to stop being afraid of who you are. All these years, you've been running from your own shadow, terrified of what might happen if people saw the real you. But look at me – really look. What do you see?"

Sarah forced herself to study the reflection, really study it. Beyond the cruel smile and cold eyes, she saw something else: pain, fear, loneliness. She saw a scared little girl who'd made a terrible mistake and spent her whole life trying to make up for it. She saw every bad decision, every moment of weakness, every flaw and imperfection that made her human.

"I see... me," she whispered.

"Yes," the reflection said. "Not a monster, not a villain, just you. Flawed, complicated, human you. The sooner you accept that, the sooner you can stop living in fear of your own shadow."

Sarah stood up slowly, her legs shaking but holding. She stepped closer to the mirror, close enough to fog the glass with her breath. The reflection did the same, their movements finally in sync.

"What do I do now?" Sarah asked.

"You tell the truth," the reflection said. "Maybe not all at once, and maybe not to everyone. But start with yourself. Stop pretending the darkness isn't there. Acknowledge it. Own it. Only then can you begin to change it."

Sarah pressed her hand against the cool glass. Her reflection did the same, and for a moment, she thought she felt warmth on the other side.

"It won't be easy," she said.

"No," the reflection agreed. "But it will be real. And that's what you've been afraid of all along, isn't it? Being real means being vulnerable. Being vulnerable means risking pain, rejection, judgment. But it also means having a chance at genuine connection, at real love and acceptance – not for the person you pretend to be, but for who you actually are."

Sarah took a deep breath, then another. She thought about her mother in the nursing home, waiting for visits that rarely came. She thought about the guilt she'd carried for twenty years, the weight of unspoken truths.

"Tomorrow," she said. "I'll visit Mom tomorrow. And I'll tell her... everything."

The reflection smiled, and this time it wasn't cruel at all. It was sad and scared and hopeful, all at once. It was real.

"Good," it said. "That's a start."

The clock on Sarah's phone clicked over to 12:01 AM. When she looked back at the mirror, she saw only herself – her ordinary, everyday reflection. But something had changed. The weight she'd carried for so long felt different now, not lighter exactly, but more balanced. More bearable.

She reached out and touched the mirror one last time, tracing the outline of her own face. "Thank you," she whispered, though she wasn't sure who she was thanking – the mirror, the mysterious text sender, or perhaps some part of herself that had finally decided it was time to stop running.

That night, for the first time in twenty years, Sarah slept without nightmares. In her dreams, she saw herself clearly, completely, and wasn't afraid.

The next morning, she would wake up and begin the hard work of becoming real. But for now, in the quiet darkness of her bedroom, she stood before the mirror and finally, truly, saw herself. All of herself. And somehow, that was both the most terrifying and most liberating thing of all.

December 03, 2024 18:09

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

0 comments

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. 100% free.