(Not What I Was) Expecting

Submitted into Contest #275 in response to: Write a story that includes the line “Better late than never.”... view prompt

39 comments

Fiction Funny High School

“You’re not the weed girl,” I said as I stood in the second-floor girls’ bathroom with my brows stitching together. It was my usual third period trip to the bathroom on a Thursday to pick up my weed, and instead of seeing Miranda, I was staring at what looked to be a senior with mascara running down her cheeks. I was a junior, so just from her face I couldn’t place her name. She was blonde and tall and looked like her perfume was called “Bubblegum Kiss” or something like that. I immediately wanted nothing to do with her, or her teary eyes, but then she was walking toward me. And then I noticed the pregnancy test in her perfectly manicured hand. (With hot pink nails filed to a point).

“Does this look positive to you?” She sputtered out, holding out the little white stick with the pink cap, her bottom lip trembling. Part of me wanted to turn around and shamelessly pretend I’d never seen her, but then her pathetic blue eyes snagged on my grey ones, and I sighed. Let me see, I said back, and my tone was a bit more exasperated than I intended. She didn’t seem to mind and handed me the stick she’d just peed on.

It was clear as day, the two lines. I’d seen picture books that were harder to read. From her smeared makeup, I could tell she was losing her shit over this, but I wasn’t about to lie to the poor girl.

“If you pissed on this, you’re definitely pregnant.”

Immediate sobbing, while I was still holding the little stick in my hand. God, where’s the weed girl when you need her? I sucked in another breath and stood there rocking back on the heels of my Doc Martens, grinding my teeth as this blonde girl continued to sob into her hands. I’d never been really great at comforting people, but there was something that sort of stung me about seeing her look so broken. She was so perfect, so beautiful. The picture of femininity and youth—the antithesis of me and my smudged eyeliner and hand-me-down t-shirt. It was a shame to watch her in pieces like this. So, I reached out and brought her into an awkward kind of hug. It’s alright, I’d muttered. An unconvincing and definitely untrue statement. 

As soon as I touched her, she was clinging to me, sobbing, shaking in my arms as she buried her face in my shoulder. I tried to remind myself that this was probably better than being in chem lab… probably. For a moment we just stood there, and I held this girl against me while she seemed to let a few years’ worth of tears pour out of her eyes. When she finally seemed to be calming down, with my hand still stroking her back I said: wanna tell me your name?

“Bridgette,” the blonde choked out, stepping back from me to wipe her snotty nose on the sleeve of her pink cardigan. I grimaced subtly and nodded, now putting a few pieces together. She was a cheerleader, and a senior, as I had originally thought. Bridgette Anderson was dating everyone’s favorite ejacu-loser, Ryan Sutherland. I could completely understand her sobbing now. God, had that man put a baby into me I’d have set the whole school on fire. 

“Is it Ryan’s then?” I asked tentatively, not wanting to set her off again. I felt like I was in a hostage situation and was somehow the hostage and the negotiator all in one. While the girl was in the dirty bathroom mirror trying to wipe at her makeup with a crumpled piece of toilet paper, my mind wandered to Miranda and my weed again. Where the fuck was she?

Bridgette answered me after a moment, going on some tangent about how she and Ryan were already on the rocks, and this would be the nail in the coffin. This meaning the baby inside of her, though I couldn’t help but wonder why she would want to deal with two babies instead of just one. Cutting Ryan out of the equation would do nothing but simplify things. I didn’t realize I was speaking these thoughts out loud until Bridgette was turned to me with her mouth agape. I smiled sheepishly and tucked a strand of my bottle-black hair behind my ear. Before I could do any damage control though, the blonde spoke again.

“You really think I’d be better off?”

“He’s a dick, Bridgette.”

It’s like I had been the first person to ever say that to her. Maybe I was. I wasn’t going to defend him when I knew how he treated girls… mostly because he and I had had a fling a few summers ago. No, I wasn’t his type, you’re exactly right. I’d wanted us to be more than bathroom stall sex, but the thought of being seen with me in public was enough to make him ghost me less than 24 hours after saying he really cared about me. Guys love saying things like that when they’re inside of you, and then you stand face to face with all your clothes on and the tune changes. From wedding bells to funeral hymns.

Then Bridgette said something even sadder: you think I can do it alone? Have this baby? It was the first time during the exchange that I had smiled. I was smiling because it surprised me how little she thought of herself. It was like when you smile right before you cry, because you just felt your heart exhale. The girl at school who every other girl wanted to be, or be with, and she was doubting her abilities. Of course you can do it, I’d said, you’ll be a great mom, Bridgette.

And she was crying again, but this time with a smile on her face. We were both smiling, and I was uncharacteristically reaching out to wipe at one of her tears with the pad of my thumb. Her cheek was warm, and the chipped back nail polish on my fingernails matched the streaks of makeup still left behind on her tanned skin. Her ocean blue eyes fluttered open and shut as the tears fell, but she didn’t pull away from me. I was surprised by that, and the way my chest tightened just a bit. I wanted to cry with her. I wasn’t sure why. What’s your name, she asked softly, her words finally able to breathe, no longer strangled with emotion. 

“Leah,” I replied, my hand still comfortably resting on the girl’s cheek. She was leaning her face against my palm. I felt unexplainably warm, holding Bridgette’s face in one hand and her positive pregnancy test in my other. Then she took a half-step forward and her hand brushed the pregnancy test, and a second later we were holding hands around the plastic stick. We were far too close, I had thought, and somehow far too far away, as well. I watched still as her wet lashes fluttered themselves dry, and her lips glistened with tears. My mouth felt dry. Then I heard my name again and was snapped from my haze when I turned and saw Miranda standing just by the bathroom door, looking at us.

“And where the fuck were you?” I asked her, breaking every connection I had to Bridgette, as I felt my cheeks flush. What had happened in that bathroom would follow me, I could already tell. Miranda gave me a little smirk and pulled a few little plastic baggies of weed out of her hoodie pocket. Better late than never, she told me while I was trying to gather a singular coherent thought that wasn’t about Bridgette. (An Impossibility because she was still standing there, just an arms’ reach away.)

(Why was I thinking about touching her again?)

I nabbed two bags of weed, double the amount we had agreed upon, and handed over my usual wad of cash which was only enough to pay for one. I shot Miranda a look that said something like you owe me, because she did. Because then I walked back to class wondering when I was going to see Bridgette again, and how soon I could get high enough to maybe forget about her. (Though that was unlikely.)    

November 02, 2024 21:13

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

39 comments

Alex V. Mortis
13:30 Nov 11, 2024

Beautifully written. All praises.

Reply

Brynn Helena
14:37 Nov 11, 2024

thank you! :)

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
KA James
22:59 Nov 09, 2024

Hey Brynn, Seems like you've really touched a few nerves with this one, and that may be the best feedback you can get overall. Writing that makes people think is almost always the best kind. And you're managing to churn out all these really good stories at 22!

Reply

Brynn Helena
23:02 Nov 09, 2024

thank you so much!! i always enjoy writing that makes me think best, too. nothing better than a novel that stays with you! :)

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Mary Bendickson
20:44 Nov 04, 2024

Sorry, don't see the humor in this situation. Thanks for liking 'Much Ado About Nothing'.

Reply

Brynn Helena
01:46 Nov 05, 2024

oh! any particular reason?

Reply

Mary Bendickson
06:13 Nov 05, 2024

Oh...a fifteen year old was hoping to score weed; found a girl in distress over a pregnancy; thought about scoring with the distressed girl. Not humorous to me.

Reply

Brynn Helena
12:23 Nov 05, 2024

well, a few things! leah is 16-17... it was stated she was a junior. yes, bridgette is definitely distressed but leah is quite comforting, at least she tries to be. 'scoring' has quite a connotation that i don't think applies here at all. leah was experiencing an emotional connection, at least that's how i wrote it. (i would say both the girls were, it was a charged moment. 'scoring' is inherently sexual... there was no mention of sex between them or even an implication?) overall, the piece is somewhat humorous, yes, but it wasn't meant to b...

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Keba Ghardt
03:54 Nov 04, 2024

"because you just felt your heart exhale" was particularly good. Great comedic pacing, while still taking the emotion seriously

Reply

Brynn Helena
04:11 Nov 04, 2024

thank you so much!! :)

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Susan O'REILLY
12:55 Nov 12, 2024

great read much enjoyed sláinte

Reply

Brynn Helena
13:54 Nov 12, 2024

thank you! glad you enjoyed :)

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Carol Stewart
16:18 Nov 11, 2024

Love the voice, so honest and real.

Reply

Brynn Helena
17:07 Nov 11, 2024

thank you! :)

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Mary Butler
23:15 Nov 09, 2024

Your story captured an emotionally charged moment with an authenticity that’s both raw and beautifully complex. Lines like “The picture of femininity and youth—the antithesis of me and my smudged eyeliner and hand-me-down t-shirt" perfectly contrast Leah’s hardened exterior and Bridgette’s fragile idealism, setting up their unexpected connection. And your description of their hand holding the pregnancy test, a symbol of shock and support intertwined, was poignantly vivid: "We were far too close, I had thought, and somehow far too far away, a...

Reply

Brynn Helena
23:44 Nov 09, 2024

thank you!! :)

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Eden Penfold
23:09 Nov 09, 2024

I like your style of humour! From "ejacu-loser" to "wedding bells to funeral hymns", there were lots of clever little lines in this. Life is not one faceted, there's humour to be found even in the darkest of situations, it's often how we humans cope. Strong tone of voice throughout, you captured the high school feeling well. :) I think a few of the comments are a little overcritical, and I think you do so well at taking them on board with grace! Just because you don't personally connect with the subject matter (underage drug use and sex), d...

Reply

Brynn Helena
23:44 Nov 09, 2024

thank you so much! i appreciate the read and comment a ton :)

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
20:35 Nov 09, 2024

Hi Brynn, you have been faithfully reading my stories of late. Here's the thing: You didn't comment, or I would have replied before. A belated thanks. I have been busy. I have another writing project going on at the moment and haven't been faithfully reading everyone else's stories. Please don't take my following reservation as judgment. I glanced at your bio and decided to give reading a miss. Probably for the same reason those people walked out of the theatre at Cannes. Trust me, we are very different from each other. I loved this story....

Reply

Brynn Helena
21:28 Nov 09, 2024

hello kaitlyn! i really appreciate your lengthy comment, and your giving my stories a chance! the thing about me not commenting-- i often read a lot on here and don't comment. i guess you could say i have a bit of a complex about it. i find i'm quite young amongst the people on this site and sometimes i think i should sit back and allow myself to receive criticism from the more experienced rather than trying to dish that out myself. (i'm only 22 after all, i don't think i know a singular thing about anything, really.) (also, i was inferring...

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Tom Skye
20:22 Nov 09, 2024

Some irreverent humour here, and the MC is morally ambiguous. Quite a fresh take on a difficult situation. Well written and entertaining. Thanks for sharing

Reply

Brynn Helena
20:23 Nov 09, 2024

thank you! :)

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Heidi Fedore
15:27 Nov 09, 2024

Loved "looked like her perfume was called “Bubblegum Kiss” or something like that," and "pathetic blue eyes snagged on my grey ones." Your tone of detachment, yet awkward compassion is perfection! Leah's character arc and emotions take the reader from humorous cynicism to reluctant kindness. The "better late than never" line was a creative spin on this prompt. Well done!

Reply

Brynn Helena
17:47 Nov 09, 2024

thank you so much!! :)

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Joe Smallwood
20:16 Nov 06, 2024

Hi Brynn, I like the way you write and there were some really good lines in this one, but I didn't like it. Your last story that I read of yours was about a boy who decided to commit suicide. That one was extremely well written, although if you remember, it seemed to treat suicide like a spectator would. Like it is a part of life and something to be accepted. You strive to be realistic and in touch with how young people really feel. That's great, no problem there. But might you consider incorporating a view of what life should be for everyon...

Reply

Brynn Helena
20:42 Nov 06, 2024

hi! i greatly appreciate your lengthy comment. i always love receiving feedback. i think what has struck me about what you said is -- "what life should be for everyone". you suspected wrong, i don't really believe that exists. i think life looks like a different thing for everyone. what a meaningful life means to me is probably drastically different than what it means to you. most of the time i think my writing takes a spectator's view because i feel like a spectator even in my own world. i'm watching things through my eyes yes, but i'm stil...

Reply

Joe Smallwood
20:52 Nov 06, 2024

Thanks for setting me straight! And replying like you did, explaining yourself so well, I might add. Yes, I actually thought you might reply like you did, having discussed this very topic with so many people over the course of my life. I should let you have the last word (there's that dreaded S word again) But can we really escape how things should be? Don't we get caught to saying that we shouldn't say shouldn't? I won't reply to what you write next, out of respect!

Reply

Brynn Helena
21:24 Nov 06, 2024

i also find philosophical type questions such as these very fun, so i'm always excited when one is poised for me to answer. i think that's one of the best things about being a writer/being around writers: we're all so introspective by nature! lots of great conversations to be had, should we choose to. i suppose you have a point, like when people say never say never. i fear Shakespeare may have gotten me when he wrote 'to be or not to be—that is the question' because it seems i see life that way! i've never quite been concerned with expecta...

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Trudy Jas
10:57 Nov 04, 2024

I enjoyed the combination of sarcasm, dry humor, confusion and insights from the fifteen-year-old Leah. :-) Thanks for reading my stories.

Reply

Brynn Helena
12:24 Nov 05, 2024

leah is probably about 16-17 seeing as she's a junior!! but i'm so glad you enjoyed :)

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Alexis Araneta
17:42 Nov 03, 2024

Brynn, this is stunning. Great way of showcasing emotions. The imagery here is also spot on. Lovely work here !

Reply

Brynn Helena
17:55 Nov 03, 2024

thank you so much!! :)

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Thomas Wetzel
22:13 Nov 02, 2024

This was great. You write beautifully. Very real and a great mix of drama and humor. I loved this. Also, I bought my first pair of black Doc Martens at a little shop called "Trash Vaudeville" on the Lower East Side when I was 17. After I laced them up I looked over at the guy sitting next to me and it was Matt Dillon. He was buying the same pair of boots. Only one weed purchase per week?

Reply

Brynn Helena
23:59 Nov 02, 2024

matt dillon!! what a story! and i think one weed purchase for per week makes sense for the high schooler budget, at least it did for my friends (i was never into it but i observed)! thanks for reading, and sharing :) i got my first pair at 17 too, but no celebrities were involved... bummer

Reply

Thomas Wetzel
02:42 Nov 03, 2024

The cool thing about living in NYC is you never know who you might see. I shared a taxi with James Hetfield one time. You ever see "The House That Jack Built", by Lars von Trier? If you like really twisted films its worth watching. (Content Warning: It contains almost every disturbing thing imaginable, just like all Lars von Trier movies. Half the audience walked out of the theater at Cannes.) Matt Dillon was great in the serial killer role. Kind of reluctant about taking his victims. Like he didn't really want to. He just had to.

Reply

Brynn Helena
03:31 Nov 03, 2024

ah i see!! i've lived in rural PA my whole life, nobody out here! and yes i actually have seen the house that jack built. i AM a lover of twisted films. i quite adore antichrist actually, which i know is another one people either love or hate! if you have letterboxd, you should follow me! my user is brynnhelena, same as on here :)

Reply

Thomas Wetzel
05:02 Nov 03, 2024

Antichrist was so fucked! That scene with the little kid tumbling out the window... Melancholia was also really good. Not on letterboxd but will check it out and follow you. I appreciate your interest in my stories and I look forward to reading more of yours. I like your style.

Reply

Brynn Helena
12:53 Nov 03, 2024

melancholia i have not yet seen! i will have to check it out. if ur into movies letterboxd is actually quite fun! thanks a million for reading my stuff :)

Reply

Show 0 replies
Tom Skye
20:26 Nov 09, 2024

Melancholia is one of my favourite films.

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 2 replies
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. 100% free.