18 comments

Horror Mystery

This story contains themes or mentions of physical violence, gore, or abuse.

When I come through the door, Amy is laying on the couch, the news lighting up the living room, weeping into one of Jason's shirts.


I do my best to ignore her, ignore the grief welling in my own throat, and head to the kitchen. I reach in my bag as I start to lay out all the ingredients that I brought. I glance up at the television, Jason's missing person picture and information flashes across the screen. Amy lets out a strangled cry.


Frustration bubbles up in my chest. If she would just put in an effort to find him, he was her son after all.


I push it down. She was my sister, and she was in pain. Right now, all I needed to do was cook her a pan of lasagna. I reach my hand in the bag for the last ingredient, and find the bag empty.


No ground beef.


Shit.


"Amy." I say tenderly. She peeks her head over the couch. "Do you have any ground beef?"


She stops crying, resorting to rapid sniffling long enough to nod and let out a strangled response.


"In the freezer."


"Alright." I say softly.


She retreats behind the back of the couch, her weeping returning, though it seems like its starting to slow. She might actually cry herself to sleep. I've seen a lot of things, but I have never seen a grown woman cry herself to sleep.


I retreat to the garage of her house, the white rectangular block of a freezer was tucked into the corner. I walk over to it, opening it and searching through the bags of frozen soup, homemade tomato sauce stored for a rainy day, just below a bag so full with food that its hard to pick up, lies an unlabeled bag of what appears to be ground beef.


There's seven other bags with equally strange cuts of meat, some ground, some strips. I stop digging halfway down the freezer, glancing at the bag of meat with a frown.


Screw it. She never labels her bags, if it isn't ground beef then it's some other form of meat that she trusted to someday ingest. She probably won't eat this anyway. I return everything but the bag of 'ground beef' to the freezer and shut the lid, dragging my feet as I reach the garage door, and enter back into the house.


Amy moved. She's sitting at the kitchen table, straight left of the kitchen, she still stares at the television, her eyes dull and red with crying. I do my best to ignore her as I put the bag of meat in the sink, running hot water over the frozen meat.


As I gather the rest of the ingredients, getting ready to start making the food, Amy falls asleep. Her head leaning on the table, wrapped in a blanket that she dragged from the couch. I sigh quietly, taking the bag from under the water and bringing it over to the pan that I'd warmed up. I put the still half-frozen meat in the warming pan.


Amy snored on the table as I watched frost leap off the odd meat, slowly, it defrosted enough to cook. Then it started to hiss from its place in the pan, browning. It smelt... different. The closest thing I could come up with was pork being grilled over charcoal.


---------------------------------------------


When I'd finished layering the pasta noodles, the sauce, and the strange meat. I slipped it into the oven, then I began to clean up.


I went to grab the plastic bag that had held the meat, I grabbed it, heading towards the trash, when a slip of paper fell out of the bag. I stop, bending down to pick it up. Amy's handwriting was a messy scrawl, it spelled out a date, and a few words.


4/12/13

Left arm


April the twelfth. That was the day before she reported Jason missing.


I put the empty bag on the counter, slipping the paper into my pocket. I glanced at Amy, she was still asleep, quietly, I slipped into the garage, curiosity, but more importantly dread.


I had miscounted, there were eight other bags. Not seven, slowly, I opened each one. They all had the same date. Each one labeled a different part of a body.


A human body.


One of them had a time recorded as well. Forty-two minutes before Amy called in Jason as missing, she put a human heart in a bag, a human heart small enough to belong to a missing boy. Small enough to belong to Jason.


I gape at the assortment before me, shakily, I stand up. Quickly. I re-bag all the organs, shoving the pieces of paper in my pocket, and stuff them back in the freezer, shutting it quickly. I move swiftly towards the door, my breath shaking.


When I open it, I turn to walk out of the house. Ready to run. Amy stands in front of me, blocking my way past her. She holds the empty bag that I'd set back down.


"Are you alright?" Amy asks. "You look like you've seen a ghost."


She cocks her head, not a bit of concern on her face. My heart is beating so quickly I think it will explode.


"Yes." I breathe. "I just wanted to grab something out of my car."


I make a move towards the door, Amy grabs my arm, stepping in front of me.


"Of course." She said detachedly. Then she glanced the direction of the garage. "What were you doing in there CeeCee?"


I cringe at the nickname. "Nothing." I say shortly.


Amy smiles at me. "Nothing?"


"Nope."


"Then why." She began, cocking an eyebrow. "Do you have one of my little labels in your pocket?"


---------------------------------------------


Police report

Reporting officer: Flint Jaseon, badge number 173

Amy Wren Chillron called the county police station at 1422, she reported that she was eating lasagna when she heard a thud in her garage, when she went to investigate, she found her sister, Celine Iris Chillron, brutally murdered, there was a hold carved into the garage door, allowing the murderer access from outside.. Amy has been eliminated as a suspect from the case, further investigation to follow.

October 04, 2024 17:08

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

18 comments

Chris Sage
19:25 Oct 10, 2024

Ooh creepy! I got a little hint from the pork grilled over charcoal it wasn't going to be a nice ending! By the way, did you mean 'a hole carved in the garage door '?

Reply

Cedar Barkwood
02:51 Oct 12, 2024

Thank you! I wasn't sure if that would be clear, I meant that someone carved a hole from outside. The metal side of the garage that would open, the hole was carved there, allowing a 'criminal' (Amy covered her tracks) to get into the garage and murder Celine.

Reply

Chris Sage
10:05 Oct 12, 2024

I got the idea - just that it says "hold"! Probably an autocarrot?

Reply

Cedar Barkwood
12:26 Oct 12, 2024

Oooh, I guess. Missed it in proofreading, thank you!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
FJJ Austin
05:45 Oct 10, 2024

Great story that twists and turns with dark themes and gore. Great stuff. Clear and suspenseful, I enjoyed it. Won’t look at ground beef in my freezer the same way ever again, though!

Reply

Cedar Barkwood
13:05 Oct 10, 2024

Thank you! I'm really glad you enjoyed it, and so long as you don't have any homicidal sisters you should be safe with the ground beef. :)

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Amber Claire
11:43 Oct 13, 2024

Eek! I was a little puzzled about the pork detail, then as time went on I started to connect the dots just in time. And she was eating the lasagna knowing what was in it! Great, suspenseful read. Good job!

Reply

Cedar Barkwood
11:52 Oct 13, 2024

Hi Amber! Thank you for your praise, and I have to imagine that it can’t taste that good. I’m glad you enjoyed it!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Mary Bendickson
21:38 Oct 05, 2024

Well, you did warn! Horrible is right. Writing is well done.

Reply

Cedar Barkwood
14:40 Oct 06, 2024

Thank you!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Alexis Araneta
09:13 Oct 05, 2024

EEEK !!! I just about gasped when I realised what the meat was. Great work !

Reply

Cedar Barkwood
18:05 Oct 05, 2024

Thank you! My poor search history, turns out human flesh does smell like pork when cooked. 🙃

Reply

Alexis Araneta
00:10 Oct 06, 2024

Hahahaha ! I have strange search history items too. Writing. 😂

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Amber Claire
20:18 Oct 04, 2024

Wow! I loved this story, it was suspenseful and the shock at the end was so well hidden throughout the majority of the story. The police report at the end really brought it together. Good job!

Reply

Cedar Barkwood
23:16 Oct 04, 2024

Thank you! I'm really glad you enjoyed it, I always love writing a plot twist. The police report was fun too, glad you enjoyed it!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Cedar Barkwood
17:15 Oct 04, 2024

Hello! Thank you for reading my story, any suggestions or problems you noticed are greatly appreciated. Have a wonderful day!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Isabella Montoya
00:35 Oct 06, 2024

This was sooooooo suspenseful! I really enjoyed it. I was reading this while doing something else I needed to work on and told myself I would read only halfway through and then finish what I was working on, but the suspense kept me wanting to read more. You really have a great talent at writing these types of stories that include suspense and mystery. Poor CeeCee, she saw what she shouldn't have and paid for it. Great job, Cedar!

Reply

Cedar Barkwood
14:38 Oct 06, 2024

Hi Isabella! I’m really glad you enjoyed it! I’ve always loved a good suspense story. CeeCee had quite an unlucky end. Thank you for reading!

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. 100% free.