Submitted to: Contest #294

Buttons and Banter

Written in response to: "Write a story in which the first and last sentence are the same."

Fiction Mystery Romance

The journal was flat on the table.

In a small, cluttered room filled with odd trinkets and the faint smell of burnt toast, Detective Jack and Professor Emily were deep in discussion about their latest adventure. The last case had left them with more questions than answers, and the objects before them seemed to hold the key to solving the mystery.

“Let’s start with the journal,” Jack said, flipping it open to a page filled with hasty, scribbled notes. “It says here that the treasure is buried beneath the old oak tree in the park. And look! There’s a map!” He pointed excitedly at a crude drawing that resembled a stick figure attempting to dig up a garden gnome.

Emily squinted at the map, then at Jack. “Are you sure that’s a map? It looks more like a toddler’s interpretation of a treasure hunt.”

“Hey, don’t underestimate the genius of toddlers,” Jack replied, puffing out his chest. “They can be surprisingly crafty!”

As they poured over the journal, the locket on top caught Emily’s eye. “What’s this? A locket? It looks fancy.” She picked it up, and as she opened it, a small cloud of dust puffed out, causing her to sneeze. “Ugh! Maybe it’s cursed.”

“Or maybe it just needs a good cleaning,” Jack quipped, taking the locket from her. “But if it’s cursed, we might want to avoid wearing it during our treasure hunt. You know, just in case it turns us into frogs or something.”

Emily rolled her eyes. “Great, because being transformed into a frog is exactly what I need right now. But what about the compass? It’s just spinning in circles!”

Jack grabbed the compass, watching the needle dance around like it was auditioning for a musical. “Maybe it’s trying to tell us something! Like, ‘Hey, you two are hopeless!’”

“Or it’s just broken,” Emily suggested, crossing her arms. “We’re not going to find any treasure if your tools are defective.”

“Maybe we need to believe in the compass!” Jack exclaimed dramatically. “It’s not just a tool; it’s a symbol of our journey! It represents—”

“Your inability to read a map?” Emily interrupted, smirking.

“Okay, fine, but it’s also a reminder that we can find our way if we just follow our instincts!” Jack insisted, flipping the journal’s pages again. “And according to this, our instincts say we should head to the park immediately!”

With newfound determination, they gathered the journal, locket, and compass. As they headed out the door, Jack turned back to the table and grinned. “Let’s do this!”

The park was bustling with activity, from children squealing on the swings to joggers panting as they raced past. Jack and Emily arrived, armed with the journal, locket, and spinning compass, looking decidedly out of place among the picnickers and dog walkers.

“Alright, the journal says the treasure is buried beneath the old oak tree,” Jack declared, pointing dramatically toward a massive oak that seemed to have been standing since the dawn of time. “That’s our destination! But first, we must navigate the treacherous terrain of the park.”

Emily squinted at the compass, which was still spinning wildly. “You mean we’re going to get lost in a straight line? I think the only treasure we’ll find is a hot dog stand.”

“Hey, a hot dog could be a treasure in its own right! Especially if it’s loaded with mustard!” Jack replied, rubbing his stomach. “But let’s focus. We must be vigilant! Who knows what dangers lurk in the underbrush?”

“Right, like a rogue squirrel might challenge us to a duel,” Emily laughed, glancing around as a particularly bold squirrel approached them, eyeing their snacks. “Look, that one’s plotting something! I can almost hear him saying, ‘Give me your lunch or face my wrath!’”

“Maybe he’s the guardian of the treasure!” Jack said, pretending to bow to the squirrel. “Oh great Squirrel King, we come seeking the treasure of the ancient oak! Will you grant us safe passage?”

The squirrel twitched its tail and scampered off, leaving Emily in stitches. “I think he just said, ‘Get lost, humans!’”

Finally reaching the old oak, Jack dropped to his knees, dramatically pulling out a tiny gardening trowel from his backpack. “Time to dig for glory!” he shouted, as a few nearby picnickers turned to watch, amusement dancing in their eyes. “If I find a treasure chest, I’m expecting a lifetime supply of chocolate!”

Emily rolled her eyes, but she couldn’t help but smile. “And if you find a chest full of socks, then you’ll know you’ve truly struck out!”

As Jack began to dig, each scoop of dirt unearthed more laughter than treasure. “Look! I found a bottle cap! Maybe it’s a message from the past!” he exclaimed, holding it up like a trophy.

“Congratulations! You’ve uncovered the legendary Cap of Lost Beverages!” Emily teased, pretending to take notes. “This will surely go down in history as the greatest archaeological find of the century!”

Just as Jack was about to retort, his trowel hit something hard. “Wait! I think I’ve actually found something!” He dug frantically, revealing a small, rusted box. “This is it! The treasure!”

Emily leaned closer, her eyes wide with excitement. “If it’s full of socks, I’m going to laugh so hard I might just faint!”

With a dramatic flourish, Jack opened the box, only to reveal a collection of old, dusty buttons. “Well, it’s not chocolate, but it’s definitely… something,” he said, trying to hide his disappointment.

Emily burst out laughing. “You know what they say—one man’s treasure is another man’s button collection! We’ve officially gone from ‘Indiana Jones’ to ‘Button Bandits!’”

Jack sighed, shaking his head with an exaggerated expression of defeat. “Next time, we’re going to a hot dog stand instead. At least they don’t require a treasure map!”

As they both doubled over in laughter, they realized that sometimes the journey—and the ridiculous moments they shared—were worth more than any treasure they could find.

As they finished their hotdogs, laughter bubbled between Jack and Emily, the day’s absurdities fading into fond memories. The sun dipped below the horizon, casting a warm glow over the park, and the distant sounds of children playing felt like a perfect soundtrack to their adventure. Jack leaned back, a satisfied grin on his face, while Emily recounted their comedic missteps, each story more ridiculous than the last. With their hearts full and their bellies satisfied, they both knew that the treasure they sought had been found in their shared laughter and camaraderie.

The journal was flat on the table.

Posted Mar 15, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

12 likes 2 comments

15:17 Mar 23, 2025

Very sweet and charming story; good title! It isn't entirely clear who Emily and Jack "are" to each other but by the end we assume this was maybe a date? Like the use of the treasure hunt and clues to build a sense of their senses of humor and willingness to engage in playful behavior. Also like knowing that Emily recaps the adventure, wonder what that would have been like as a scene?

Reply

Joe Miller
12:43 Mar 24, 2025

Thanks for your kind comment, Anne. I'm glad you liked my story. Have a great Springtime!! All the best, Joe.

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.