Mystery

The Price of Truth

Ashwood’s Hero

The Weight of a Name

Kelly Largent had grown up in the long shadow of her father’s reputation. In Ashwood, the name Bryan Largent wasn’t just respected — it was revered. To the townsfolk, he was the man who had saved hundreds during the fire that nearly gutted the manufacturing district three decades ago. His face adorned murals. His name echoed at parades. His bronze likeness stood in the town square with eyes turned toward the horizon, forever noble.

Kelly learned early to smile when strangers told her how lucky she was to be Bryan Largent's daughter. But at home, her father was different. Quiet, brooding, his silences heavier than his words. She assumed this was the price of being a hero- carrying the ghosts of those he couldn’t save.

She didn’t know then how many ghosts there were.

The Letter

At seventeen, curiosity drove her to the attic. Between yellowed photographs and medals she found a scorched letter-

We can’t keep this quiet forever. If inspectors dig too deep, they’ll find everything. You need to decide what story you want them to hear.

Signed, M.

Kelly read it again and again, her hands trembling. It hinted at something hidden, something shameful. That night, she told herself it was nothing. But the thought burrowed deep- what if the hero wasn’t who he seemed?

Ashwood’s Funeral

Years later, Bryan Largent died. The entire town poured into the square. The mayor called him “the greatest man our city has ever known.” Veterans saluted. Children left flowers. Ashwood wept.

Kelly wept too, but her grief was complicated. She mourned his absence, but she also mourned the chance she had lost to ask him what was true.

And so, she resolved to dig. If he had taken his secrets to the grave, she would drag them back out.

Smoke and Ashes

The Records

At town hall, Kelly requested fire department reports. The clerk handed them over with a reverent smile, calling them “her father’s legacy.” But as she read, Kelly's stomach turned. The fire had started in her father’s office. The door had been locked from the inside. Inspectors mentioned accelerants, unstable storage, negligence. Workers had filed complaints of chemical sickness in the months leading up to the fire.

The reports didn’t name Bryan Largent as the cause. But they didn’t have to.

Survivors

Kelly began to track down survivors. Mr. Johnson, an old machinist, remembered Bryan carrying him through flames. He called him a savior. But Lydia Hejney was bitter- “Your father wasn’t saving lives. He was covering his sins. My husband died choking on smoke he caused.”

Each visit chipped away at Kelly's faith. Her father was a man of contradictions — savior to some, monster to others. Truth lived in the space between their stories.

A Dangerous Curiosity

The deeper she dug, the more resistance she faced. Records disappeared from archives. A stranger began following her home. Anonymous notes arrived, warning her to “leave the past buried.” Someone else didn’t want Bryan's truth uncovered. Kelly realized she wasn’t just piecing together history — she was stirring up enemies who had survived it.

The Hero’s Mask

Allies and Enemies

Not everyone wanted Kelly silenced. Don Blake, a local journalist with a reputation for chasing uncomfortable stories, reached out to her after hearing whispers of her investigation. He offered his resources, his contacts at the paper, and his determination to print the truth.

But Don wasn’t universally trusted. Some accused him of exploiting pain for headlines. Others whispered he had his own vendetta against the Largent name. Kelly hesitated — ally or opportunist? Still, she needed help.

Meanwhile, Kelly's best friend, Barbara, urged her to stop. Barbara's father had been among those saved by Bryan, and she feared Kelly's search would destroy not just the town’s pride but their friendship. “What good comes from tearing down a dead man?” she demanded. Their bond strained under the weight of Kelly's obsession.

M.

The signature on the letter haunted Kelly. After weeks of searching, she discovered old company rosters. Among the names was Matt McClard, her father’s closest friend and foreman. If anyone knew the truth, it was him.

McClard was dying, frail in a hospice bed. He confessed- Bryan had ordered the destruction of documents proving illegal dumping. They had used fire to cover their tracks. “But your father — he couldn’t live with it. That’s why he ran back inside. He carried people out. He tried to make it right.”

The words tore Kelly apart. Her father had been both executioner and rescuer. His heroism was real. So was his guilt.

A Town Divided

As Don began publishing fragments of Kelly's findings, Ashwood split in two. Protests filled the streets. Some demanded the statue be torn down; others defended it with fists. Businesses took sides. Friendships broke apart. Even the mayor, who had built his career on Bryan's legend, called Kelly a liar. Barbara refused to speak to her.

Kelly had become both a pariah and a prophet, depending on whom she asked.

The Price

Betrayal

When Kelly learned that Don had printed details she hadn’t approved — details that endangered surviving families — she felt betrayed. He claimed the public had a right to know everything, but she realized he cared more for headlines than healing. The rift left her more alone than ever. Even her allies were unreliable.

The Decision

She gathered the evidence — reports, testimonies, the letter, McClard's confession — and faced her choice. To stay silent would mean peace but complicity. To speak would destroy the myth and fracture the town. She thought of Lydia Hejney, of Mr. Johnson, of the workers whose bodies never left the factory. She thought of her father’s silence, his distance, the heaviness in his eyes. He had carried the truth alone, and it had devoured him.

She would not carry it with him.

Ashwood Square

On a bright Sunday morning, she walked to the statue with her bag of evidence. Families bustled, children played, and Bryan Largent's bronze eyes stared heavenward. Kelly knelt, unzipped her bag, and placed the documents at his feet. Wind tugged the pages. People stopped. Gasps spread through the crowd. Whispers became shouts.

Kelly rose and walked away. The weight lifted from her shoulders, though her heart ached. Truth had been set loose, and it could not be caged again.

Aftermath

By the next morning, the flowers were gone. Some cursed Kelly's name, others demanded investigations, and a few thanked her quietly. Ashwood fractured, its identity splintered. The statue still stood, but now people looked at it differently — some with pride, some with rage, and some with doubt.

Barbara left town, unable to reconcile her memories with the truth. Don printed a book, profiting off the chaos. But Kelly remained. She stayed because Ashwood wasn’t her father’s anymore — it was hers, scarred and imperfect, but honest.

At home, Kelly sat alone, her father’s picture on the mantle. She touched the frame. “You were a hero,” she whispered. “And you were a liar. I won’t forgive you. But I won’t forget you, either.”

For the first time in years, she felt free. The truth had burned away the legend, leaving only what was real. And what was real, however painful, was hers to keep.

Because the truth always has a price — and Kelly had finally paid it.

Posted Aug 16, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

2 likes 1 comment

Mary Bendickson
21:38 Aug 17, 2025

Setting the record straight.

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.