Submitted to: Contest #311

The Shadows That Promised to Return - A Callum Reed Mystery

Written in response to: "Write a story that includes the words “they would be back…”"

Crime Mystery Suspense

This story contains themes or mentions of physical violence, gore, or abuse.

The Shadows That Promised to Return

A Chilling Murder Mystery

The sky over the sleepy coastal town of Ravenshade was heavy with the threat of rain, its clouds bruised and swollen, promising a storm before midnight. The city was accustomed to such brooding evenings, when the world outside seemed to whisper secrets to those who dared to listen. It was on one such night—in the waning hours before dawn—that the peace of Ravenshade was shattered by a brutal murder.

The body was found on the windswept cliffs behind the old Hargrove manor, a decaying Victorian sprawl half-swallowed by ivy and rumour. The victim was Eleanor Langley, the young and vivacious owner of Ravenshade’s only bookshop. She had been the heart of the town, always quick with a smile or a recommendation, her laughter ringing out on market days. She was found lying on the slick grass, eyes wide in silent accusation, a single crimson wound beneath her ribs.

The news travelled through Ravenshade with the restless wind, slipping under doors and between shutters, until every soul in town awoke uneasily, as if the storm had found its way not only into the sky but into their bones. By dawn, a crowd had gathered at the manor’s edge, their faces pale in the thin grey light, each person nursing their theories and a growing sense of dread.

Detective Inspector Calum Reed arrived just as the first drops of rain fell. He moved through the cluster of townsfolk, his expression unreadable, the brim of his old felt hat casting a shadow over his eyes. The scene was already cordoned off with yellow tape that fluttered in the stiffening breeze. Reed knelt beside Eleanor, careful not to disturb the grass slicked with dew and something darker, studying the pattern of her fall and the way the ivy seemed to clutch at her ankles.

Nothing was stolen, nor were there any signs of a struggle—just that one fatal wound. In her hand, she clutched a torn scrap of parchment, its edges stained with rain and blood. Reed pried it gently from her stiff fingers. The writing was smudged but legible: “They always return when the shadows grow long.”

The detective stood, scanning the manor’s battered silhouette, its windows like watching eyes. Behind them, secrets flickered and hid, waiting for the storm to pass.

Detective Inspector Calum Reed lingered at the edge of the scene, his eyes tracing the waltz of wind-swept ivy, the brooding manor, the arc of the cliffs. Most would look for footprints, for fingerprints, for the clumsy evidence of violence; Reed let his mind move sideways, slipping between the obvious and the overlooked.

He reviewed the details—Eleanor, beloved, and vibrant, felled by a single, precise wound; the absence of theft or struggle; the cryptic scrap in her hand. “They always return when the shadows grow long.” It was not a scream, but a clue. Not a story’s end, but it’s the beginning. Reed turned the parchment over in his gloved hand. It was torn from something older, the paper a shade that spoke of library stacks and secrets best left undisturbed.

Most would ask who hated Eleanor. Reed asked, "Who loved her stories?" Who spent hours in her bookshop, poring over forgotten texts and local legends? Who would know the hidden places behind the Hargrove manor, where the wind sang through broken glass and rain-slicked grass?

He called for a list of Eleanor’s recent customers, especially those who’d shown interest in Ravenshade’s history. Among the names, one stood out: Arthur Hargrove, heir to the crumbling manor, a recluse obsessed with the past. Reed remembered seeing Arthur hovering at the fringe of the crowd, rain clinging to his coat.

Reed sought him out, finding Arthur in the dim library of the manor, surrounded by tomes as battered as the house itself. “You know why I’m here,” Reed said. Arthur’s hands trembled on the spines of the books. “I—I never meant for her to get hurt. She was only supposed to listen.”

“Listen to what?” Reed pressed.

Arthur pulled out an old, dust-choked volume—the twin of Eleanor’s parchment. The book chronicled a centuries-old feud, a tale of betrayal and hidden gold, of Hargroves and Langley’s and a promise that ‘shadows would return’ to claim what was lost.

“She found the last clue,” Arthur whispered, “and wanted to publish it. But if the town knew—if the shadows returned—they’d tear my family apart.”

Reed’s mind leapt: The murder was not born of greed or hatred, but of desperation and fear. Arthur had lured Eleanor here to beg her silence, brandishing the old dagger as a threat. In the chaos of their quarrel, he had lost control—the fatal wound was not premeditated, but an accident, panicked and irreversible.

Eleanor’s dying act was not to accuse, but to warn. Her note, torn from history, became her legacy.

Reed stood, the pieces sliding together like rain on glass. He called for backup, but as he watched Arthur sob into the brittle pages, Reed wondered which haunted Ravenshade more: the shadows that promised to return, or those that never truly left.

Outside, the storm had exhausted its rage, leaving the world raw and dripping. Reed stepped into the manor’s corridor, the hush broken only by the distant, mournful toll of the church bell. He watched the constables lead Arthur away, their footsteps echoing down the tiled hall, the old house itself seeming to sigh in relief or sorrow—he could not tell which.

Rain pooled in the ruts of the drive. Reed paused beneath the weathered portico, glancing back at the shuttered windows where secrets had festered for generations. Ravenshade had been built with walls thick enough to hold a thousand whispers, but not strong enough to contain the weight of grief.

He took the parchment from his pocket, the ink now blurred at the corners by Eleanor’s touch. In her last moments, she had chosen not vengeance but guardianship—one last silent story, entrusted to a detective drawn to the space between facts and phantoms.

Reed wondered if the town would ever learn the truth, or if this chapter, too, would retreat into legend. Already, he could imagine the stories taking root: of Eleanor’s courage, of shadows moving behind rain-misted glass, and of a family’s curse finally spent.

As he made his way back toward the waiting car, Reed glanced over his shoulder at the manor. For the first time that night, the clouds parted, letting a thin blade of moonlight slip across the broken stones. The shadows might always return, as the note had warned, but for now, Ravenshade belonged to the quiet, and to those willing to remember.

Posted Jul 13, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

5 likes 2 comments

Carolyn X
20:53 Jul 19, 2025

Reed stood, the pieces sliding together like rain on glass. Great metaphor.

Reply

Andrew Hixson
14:13 Jul 23, 2025

Thank you for your kind words

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.