Submitted to: Contest #303

What She Hid From Me

Written in response to: "Write a story with the line “I didn’t have a choice.” "

Contemporary Romance

This story contains sensitive content

This story explores adult themes, including explicit content and psychological conflict.

The glow of the laptop screen cast long shadows across the kitchen table. Thomas hadn’t meant to snoop. He really hadn’t. But her email had popped open automatically, and the subject line had grabbed him by the throat.

Re: Club Vespera - Membership Renewal

His wife didn’t go to clubs. At least, not the kind that needed renewals. Or passwords. Or encrypted replies.

He hovered his finger over the trackpad. One click. Just one. A trembling breath escaped his chest as the message opened.

There were attachments.

One was a scanned form—signed.

Her name, neat and familiar, stood out in a sea of clinical, anonymous type. But it was the second file, the video, that made his hand tremble as he clicked download.

He wasn’t sure what he expected.

But it wasn’t this.

The image loaded slowly, frame by frame. She was there. Unmistakably her. Reclining on a velvet couch in crimson lingerie, legs parted now, no longer crossed. Her face was composed, almost defiant. Around her, the men were no longer just present, they were touching her. Possessing her.

One was between her thighs, moving with purpose. Another stood over her, his hips angled toward her mouth. There was no mistaking what was happening. No ambiguity left.

It wasn’t just sex. It was performance. Submission. Power. Pleasure.

All without him.

He watched, breathless, as her body moved, opened, welcomed.

Something fractured inside him. A jagged silence that echoed louder than any moan from the screen.

Who the hell was this woman?

Because she wasn’t the wife he thought he knew?

Delete

It was the soft clink of a teaspoon that caught his attention first.

She had been stirring her coffee like it held a secret. Focused. Poised. The world moved quickly around her, phones ringing, voices rising, doors slamming, but she seemed to move at her own frequency, undisturbed.

Thomas had been in Brussels for a conference. Three days of suits, polite applause, and bland hotel bars. That café had been his escape. She, his unexpected sanctuary.

She looked up from her cup, met his gaze, and smiled. Not the kind of smile you give a stranger. The kind that makes you feel remembered, even if you’re meeting for the first time.

They spoke for three hours.

She was an interpreter, she said. Multilingual, cultured, curious. A lover of maps, red wine, and old poetry. He had never been good with words, but she made him feel like every clumsy sentence he spoke had weight. Meaning.

She hadn’t mentioned secrets. Or clubs. Or shadows behind her eyes.

That day, she’d worn a cream coat and a tiny gold pendant, so gentle, so composed. Not the woman moaning beneath strangers on a screen.

She had looked safe. And Thomas, tired, lonely, craving permanence, had believed her.

He should’ve stopped watching the video the moment he recognised her laugh.

But his hand stayed on the mouse, frozen. Eyes locked to the screen.

She was on her knees this time. The men wore no masks. No edits. Just raw, unscripted lust.

The woman he’d toasted at their wedding. The one he still kissed on the forehead when she pretended to be asleep.

Now, she was moaning, shameless, hungry, taking them like it was the most natural thing in the world.

Thomas’s stomach twisted.

He felt betrayed. Disgusted.

But underneath the nausea… a throb. Low. Reluctant. Primal.

He hated himself for it.

She was nothing like the soft-spoken woman who’d curled against him at night, tracing circles on his chest. The woman in the video was confident. Commanding. Addicted to being watched, to being taken.

And he was watching.

His pulse raced, his breath uneven. He wanted to close the window. Smash the laptop. But instead, he rewound, needed to hear that sound again, the way she whispered “yes” like sin itself.

What did that say about him?

Was he just hurt… or something darker? Something he hadn’t let himself feel until now?

The screen glowed coldly in the dark room, and Thomas stared, caught between revulsion and desire, unable to move.

Delete

She was on the couch when he found her.

Cross-legged, scrolling her phone, one leg bouncing lazily. Calm. Like she hadn’t just detonated everything.

Thomas stood there, shaking, breath ragged. She looked up, tilted her head, her lips parting to say something…

But he didn’t let her.

He was on her in two strides, ripping the phone from her hand and shoving her down into the cushions like the breath in his chest was no longer his own. His mouth crashed against hers, not tender, not seeking, claiming. It wasn’t love. It wasn’t even lust. It was a storm of betrayal and heat, shame and ownership, all boiling over in one violent surge.

“Thomas…” she gasped, lips bruised, half-laughing in disbelief. “Wow, what’s gotten into you?”

She didn’t push him away.

She pulled him closer.

He didn’t answer. He couldn’t. Words would break him. So instead, he grabbed at her, shoving her shorts down, his own jeans dragged just low enough to free himself. His hands were clumsy, rough. His body knew exactly what it wanted, even if his mind screamed confusion.

She arched into him as he entered, deep, hard, a single, punishing thrust. It wasn’t slow. It wasn’t soft. It was a claim. A protest. A last attempt to feel like she still belonged to him.

Her laughter faded. Her breath hitched. Her nails dug into his back, anchoring herself against the storm. And then she moved with him, thrust for thrust, gasp for gasp, matching the rawness he gave her, taking it all like it wasn’t the first time he’d broken this way.

He buried his face in her neck, biting down to keep from shouting. The shame. The desire. The grief.

When he came inside her, he didn’t pull away.

Instead, he stayed, panting, forehead pressed to hers, the weight of his body pinning her down as if that might keep everything from slipping further.

Her hand curled behind his neck. Fingertips gentle, almost soothing.

“…What was that about?” she whispered.

He pulled back just enough to see her eyes. And finally, he said it.

“I saw the video.”

Silence.

Then, slowly, her lips curled, not with shame, not with fear, but something darker. “Which video? What are you talking about?”

He pulled back, out of her, the physical connection severed as suddenly as it had begun. She reached for him, confused, but he was already rising to his feet, adjusting his jeans with trembling hands.

He didn’t look at her when he said it.

“Go check your inbox.”

Her smile faded.

Thomas didn’t wait for her reaction. He needed to get out. His own skin felt foreign, like he was wearing someone else’s body, someone cruel, someone lost. He grabbed his jacket off the chair and walked out without another word.

The cold hit him hard outside.

The arousal was gone. Evaporated, like steam after a fire dies.

What was left was hollow. Numb. He couldn’t tell if he wanted to scream or cry—or both. The worst part wasn’t the betrayal.

It was the part of him that still wanted her.

And now hated himself for it.

Delete

He sat alone at a bar he didn’t recognize, a half-empty glass of something smoky and sharp in his hand. The burn in his throat was nothing compared to the one hollowing out his chest.

His phone lit up again. Her name. Again.

Calls. Then texts. A flood of them.

He couldn’t bring himself to read them. Not yet. Maybe not ever.

It felt like the woman waiting for him at home wasn’t his wife anymore. That home wasn’t even his. The air they used to breathe together now felt borrowed, tainted.

The lie. The betrayal. It had stripped her bare in ways he hadn’t asked for. She wasn’t his anymore.

Worse, maybe she never had been.

The videos had done more than reveal her body to strangers. They’d shown Thomas a version of her he’d never known existed. One that laughed, moaned, begged for others. A woman who opened herself completely… but never to him.

He pressed the glass to his lips again but didn’t drink. Just held it there.

He knew answering her would mean facing the end of something.

But right now, he wasn’t ready for the end of his life as he knew it.

That’s when he felt it, a hand on his shoulder.

He didn’t need to look. He would’ve known that touch anywhere. Even after everything, even now, he could recognise her. Her presence moved through him like muscle memory.

He froze. Fingers tightening around his glass until the ice cracked. The bar melted away, voices, music, laughter, all receding into a hush that existed only between the two of them.

“Thomas,” she said, her voice barely above the hum of neon. “We need to talk.”

Slowly, deliberately, he turned. The amber swirl in his glass caught the light one last time before he set it down. She stood just behind him—coat half-buttoned, eyes swollen and shimmering, cheeks pink with cold… or panic.

“How did you even find me?” His voice was hoarse, scraped raw from everything he hadn’t said.

She hesitated. “Our phones are still synced. I saw you were gone. When you didn’t answer… I panicked.”

A humourless sound left his throat. Not quite a laugh. More like something broken rattling loose.

“Figures,” he muttered. “You can betray someone, but still track them like a lost suitcase.”

“Thomas, it’s not what you think.”

He lifted a hand. Not to silence her, just to stop the room from spinning.

She reached for him. Reflexively. Instinctively. Like maybe her hand could stitch together what her silence had torn.

He stepped back. Not violently. Just enough. Enough to let the space between them ache.

“Don’t,” he said, his voice low, splintered. “Not while I can still feel you in my skin, and wonder who else did too.”

Her breath caught, like she’d been slapped with a truth she wasn’t ready to face.

He wasn’t done. His jaw worked once, twice, before he added, quieter but just as cutting:

“You didn’t just sleep with them. You filmed it. You signed it. You archived the betrayal like it deserved a damn label.”

The words landed hard. Her expression faltered, chin trembling as she blinked the sting from her eyes.

He dropped a few bills on the counter and rose. She flinched as he passed, brushing her shoulder.

“I can explain...”

“Don’t,” he interrupted. This time, the word was gentler. Frayed at the edges. Not angry, just emptied out. “Not here. Not in front of strangers.”

She nodded. One small motion. She suddenly looked nothing like the woman in the video. No crimson lingerie. No throne of kneeling shadows. Just a person he used to trust, shivering under too much truth.

But still her.

And somehow… still his.

He jerked his chin toward the door, the silent gesture of a man not ready to forgive, but willing to listen.

They stepped into the cold night, where the air was sharp, the silence louder, and every breath between them carried the weight of what they hadn’t said.

Delete

The car hummed beneath them, smooth and oblivious to the wreckage in the passenger seat.

Ana drove, while Thomas stared out the window, watching the lights smear across the glass like they were trying to outrun the thoughts clawing through my head. Silence filled the car. Not the peaceful kind. The kind that feels like it has a pulse. That heavy, choking kind, thick with all the things they weren’t saying.

Every few minutes, his mind betrayed him. Flashbacks, like little landmines:

Ana barefoot in the kitchen, laughing as pancake batter hit the wall.

Ana curled on the sofa, mouth slightly open, a blanket tucked up to her chin, tucked by me.

Ana in white, standing in front of me on a warm afternoon, promising forever.

He clenched my jaw. Those moments felt like they belonged to a different couple. A different timeline. Before the images. Before the video. Before he realised, he didn’t even know the shape of the shadows inside the woman I married.

The air between them was cold. Not angry, just distant. Like they were already drifting into different orbits.

Delete

We stepped inside. Coats off. The door clicked shut with finality. He dropped his keys into the bowl by the door. The sound was small, but it landed with weight.

Ana didn’t sit. She paced, then stopped and turned to face me. Her cheeks were still pink from the cold. Or maybe from the shame. Her eyes were glassy, like she’d cried on the way here and thought he wouldn’t notice.

“I need to tell you everything now,” she said, voice thin and trembling. “You deserve that.”

He didn’t respond. Just stood there. Letting her speak.

“It was… before I met you. Not long before,” she began. “That part of my life, what you saw, it wasn’t who I am now. It was a phase. A chaotic, confusing time. I was experimenting. I didn’t know what I needed, so I tried everything.”

Her voice cracked. She swallowed and went on.

“But when I met you, Thomas… that part of me faded. It didn’t matter anymore. You made it easy to leave it behind. I never looked back. I haven’t been with anyone else since you. Not physically. Not emotionally. You were it for me.”

She paused. Her eyes searched for his, looking for mercy, maybe. Bracing herself.

“I didn’t tell you because I was ashamed,” she whispered. “And scared. That you’d see me differently. That you’d love me less.”

She looked down, voice barely above a whisper. “I didn’t have a choice.”

That hit him harder than the video. The way she said it, like it explained everything. Like it absolved her.

His chest tightened.

“You didn’t have a choice?” he echoed, sharp. “When we were sharing stories on that balcony in Valencia, confessing the worst versions of ourselves, that wasn’t a choice?”

“I was terrified,” she said. “That you’d leave. That you’d love me less.”

He stepped back. Not to hurt her. Just to breathe.

“So instead, you gave me half the truth,” he said. “Let me build a life with someone I didn’t really know.”

“I’m still me, Thomas,” she said. Pleading. Fragile.

He looked at her. He wanted to scream. To hold her. To shake her. To ask what else she hadn’t said.

But what came out was quieter. Tired. From some hollow place in my chest.

“No,” he said. “You’re just someone I loved… with half the truth.”

He turned. Not to leave. Just to breathe. To get a second away from the weight of everything pressing on me.

Behind him, he heard her collapse onto the sofa. And the silence returned, different this time. Sadder. Older.

And somehow… even with everything out in the open, it still didn’t feel like enough. He used to think love was a promise. Turns out, it’s just another story we tell ourselves until the truth speaks louder.

Posted May 20, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

4 likes 0 comments

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.