The Fairytale that Never Happened

Submitted into Contest #283 in response to: Write a story with the line “I wasn’t expecting that.”... view prompt

2 comments

American Romance Drama

Chapter 1: The Illusion of Perfection



Amelia James was your average millennial—sold dreams and delusions of equality and happiness. She figured that if she followed her dreams, everything in her life would be great. Amelia believed in college and a great career afterward, only to be marred with debt and low-paying jobs after graduation. Academics always came easy to her, but she didn’t really know what it is that she wanted to do with her life. The only thing for sure that she knew that she was ever good at was helping others, but she quickly learned in life that “no good deed goes unpunished.” So, Amelia was confused, navigating the world with blinders and figuring it out day by day. She had it all—a good college education, a decent career in education, a nice home, a fancy car to everyone else—she had it all. Yet, despite the glittering facade, Amelia felt an emptiness gnawing at her.


She often scrolled through Instagram, watching her friends flaunt their perfect lives: elaborate weddings, exotic vacations, and adorable babies. Each double-tap on a photo was a reminder of what she lacked, or rather, what she had thrown away. Everyone was happy all the while she was wiping the noses of sniffling brats day in and day out and dealing with bullshit from her miserable “Ms. Trunchbull” comparable boss and miserable co-workers. Amelia hated her life.


Amelia’s void grew only from the poor choices that she made in lovers. She always sought out what she wanted and not what she needed. Her first poor choice came wrapped in charm and charisma—his name was Ryan. He was everything she thought she wanted: adventurous, spontaneous, and a little reckless. They met at a rooftop party, the city skyline casting a magical glow over their budding romance. A whirlwind of passion ensued, and before she knew it, they were navigating the tumultuous waters of a relationship that felt like a fairytale, albeit a chaotic one.


Chapter 2: The Spark That Burned Out


When she found out she was pregnant, Amelia was terrified. Ryan, blissfully unaware of the weight of fatherhood, was more interested in planning his next wild escapade. “Get rid of it,” he said, his carefree tone only adding to her anxiety.


Amelia chose to go it alone without him. Ryan would return, but with only more stress to add to her life. When her son Jack was born, the reality of fatherhood hit the two like a freight train. Amelia was left with the responsibility. After months of trying to make it work and a half-assed proposal of marriage and months of poorly executed wedding plans, Amelia decided it was time to leave. She left holding the pieces to a life she had never intended to build alone.


Her career began to crumble as well. Juggling late-night feedings, endless diaper changes, and the task of raising other people’s children over her own, Amelia began to fall apart under the demands of her life. Amelia began to drown in her depression and under the pressure of life’s demands. The bright future she had envisioned now appeared dim and distant.


Chapter 3: The Cycle of Regret


Days turned into weeks, and weeks into months. Amelia found herself stuck in a cycle of poor choices. She dated men who were just as lost as she was, seeking validation in fleeting connections. Each relationship ended in disappointment, leaving her feeling more hollow than before.


“Why can’t I just be happy?” she whispered to herself, staring at the reflection in the mirror. The woman looking back seemed like a stranger. A far cry from the ambitious woman she once was, she felt like a caricature of herself, lost in a life she hadn’t planned.


One fateful night, she met Derek at a local bar. He was charming, with a quick wit that made her laugh, and for a moment, she felt light. They shared drinks and stories, and after a few too many cocktails, they ended up at his apartment. It was a mistake, one she would come to regret. Derek was fun, but he was also selfish and emotionally unavailable. After a few months of dating, he abandoned her, leaving Amelia to pick up the pieces yet again. Amelia had given up. She resigned herself to the possibility that she may never find love or the happiness that she needed in life. But one thing was certain: if that “love” and “happiness” would be the price of her time being wasted, she would be happy to be alone.


Chapter 4: The Moment of Clarity


As the seasons changed, so did Amelia’s perspective. One chilly autumn day, she took Jack to the park. Watching her son giggle as he chased the leaves, Amelia realized that she had been searching for happiness in all the wrong places.


That evening, she sat down and made a list of what brought her joy, what she wanted for her life, and how to achieve it. It was a simple exercise, but it sparked something inside her. She was tired of being a hapless millennial woman who threw away happiness with both hands.


In the weeks that followed, she started to focus on herself. She enrolled in online courses and was done raising children that did not belong to her. Instead, she used her heart and her love to help others and decided to pursue social work instead. She began volunteering at a local community center, finding fulfillment in helping others. Slowly but surely, she was reclaiming her life.


Chapter 5: A New Beginning


Months later, Amelia was sitting in a coffee shop working on her portfolio when she heard the door chime. She looked up to see a handsome man, entrenched with her deadlines and work; she paid him no mind until…


“Hello,” he said, a sheepish smile spreading across his face. “I am sorry to interrupt you; you look busy, but do you have a moment?”


Her heart raced. A mix of emotions instantly covered her; confusion, fear, happiness, and longing flooded her veins. “What do you want?” she asked, trying to keep her voice steady.


“I’m sorry,” he said, his sincerity palpable. “I just thought that you were the most beautiful woman that I had come across in a long time.”


Amelia laughed, “Does that bullshit pickup line work on every woman you meet in coffee shops?”

Shocked at Amelia’s cold response, the man steps back and apologizes once more. Realizing that her response was a bit harsh, Amelia responds, “I’m sorry, I didn’t get your name.” “It’s Thomas; nice to meet you,” as Thomas extends his hand to greet her. “Amelia,” she replied. Two would converse for hours in the confines of that coffee shop.

Chapter 6: The Choice


Over the next few weeks, Amelia grappled with her feelings. Thomas made an effort to connect, spending time with her and showing genuine interest in her life. It was a stark contrast to the men who had once left her behind.


But the thought of opening herself up again was terrifying. What if he leaves? What if she ended up in the same cycle of despair?


One evening, as Jack played in the backyard, Amelia found herself in deep contemplation. What did she truly want? A fairytale life? A partner? Or was happiness something she had to define for herself, independent of anyone else?


After several sleepless nights, she decided to meet Thomas again. They sat on her porch, the sunset casting a golden hue around them.


“I need to know you’re committed, Thomas,” she said, her voice steady. “I can’t go through that pain again.”


“I want to be here for you and Jack,” he replied, his voice earnest.

Amelia felt a flicker of hope. But would she be risking it all again?


Chapter 7: The Unexpected Twist


As they talked, she could see glimpses of the men she once loved. But just as she began to feel a sense of comfort, her phone buzzed. It was a notification.


Her heart sank as she opened the message. It was from another woman, claiming to be Thomas’s wife.


Stunned, she felt the breath leave her body. How could this be happening? Just as she was beginning to feel whole, the ground was pulled from under her.


“I wasn’t expecting that,” she muttered, her voice barely a whisper.


Thomas reached for her hand, but she pulled away, feeling the weight of her choices crashing down on her.


Chapter 8: The Road Ahead


As the days unfolded, Amelia faced the reality of her situation. She had to dig deep, not just for herself but for Jack. The loss of her relationship felt like an anchor dragging her down, but she refused to let it.


She went back into herself. With renewed determination, she applied for new positions, networked, and even started a nonprofit project that fueled her social work passions.


Months passed, and slowly, life began to stabilize. She found the solace and strength that she needed as a single mother.


Chapter 9: A New Perspective


As she stood in her new office, overlooking the city, Amelia couldn’t help but smile. She had fought for her happiness, clawed her way through despair, and emerged stronger.


One evening, as she tucked Jack into bed, she felt a wave of gratitude wash over her. She had built a life she was proud of, one filled with love, laughter, and resilience.


As she turned to leave the room, Jack called out, “Mommy, are we going to be okay?”


Amilia smiled, her heart swelling with love. “Yes, sweetheart. We’re going to be just fine.”


Epilogue: The Unexpected Journey


Years later, as she sat in a cozy café reflecting on her journey, Amelia realized that life had unfolded in ways she never could have imagined. She had learned to embrace the unexpected, to find beauty in chaos, and to love fiercely despite the risks.


Her heart was full, and she knew that while life would always be unpredictable, she was more than ready for whatever came next.


And as she sipped her coffee, she chuckled to herself, remembering the twists and turns that led her here.


“I wasn’t expecting that.”


January 03, 2025 01:10

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

2 comments

Cliff Mansfield
23:00 Jan 08, 2025

Wow! Lots of emotion, fast moving and easy to read. Good job of building characters quickly. Nice post.

Reply

Show 0 replies
Jo Freitag
22:39 Jan 08, 2025

I did enjoy this story, Amelia! I felt as if I were on the roller coaster with her! So many near solutions that faded until, with the benefit of hindsight, the unexpected happy conclusion was reached.

Reply

Show 0 replies
RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. 100% free.