Submitted to: Contest #306

The Very Best Meal I Ever Ate In LA

Written in response to: "Write a story in the form of a recipe, menu, grocery list, or product description."

⭐️ Contest #306 Shortlist!

Fiction Romance Sad

Los Angeles is a foodie’s haven. Mecca for anyone with a gold-plated tongue and diamond-dusted tastebuds. The choices are beyond abundant and available around the clock. Whether you crave comfort food, the elegance of fine-dining, or the thrilling adventure of a vegan kosher taco truck, LA has got you covered. I lived in the City of Angels for a decade, and while I was spoiled by all sorts of gourmet experiences, here is my recipe for the best meal I ever ate.

What you will need:

basil (freshly plucked from my friend Mick’s backyard)

cherry tomatoes (ditto)

cheap crackers, any brand will do

mustard (I like Dijon, but French’s is just fine)

a time machine

Directions:

1. Live in LA in the early 90s. Or use the time machine. Set it for June, 1991.

2. Be the type of flirty chick who gets invited to places like Spago and Le Dome. Try to be impressed by the towering salads and the bone marrow with the persnickety spoons, and the way every waiter introduces himself to you and gives you a little backstory. “Hi, my name is Chad?” Always with a question mark. “I’m originally from a town in Texas you’ve probably never heard of, but I’m actually an actor…” just in case you might be someone who could give Chad his big break.

3. Randomly meet a man named Mick who used to be a drug dealer in the heady, coke-infused days of the 80s, but now has reinvented himself as a type of guy-Friday. He is just scratching by, but he’s doing it honestly. Meet a lot of men in LA, but never meet anyone like Mick.

4. Get to know Mick slowly. He’s a friend of a friend of a friend, and he drives a convertible and keeps nothing in it so he can park with the roof down and never be robbed. He has a large personality that hides a shy side. You like the way he dresses in plaid shirts and jeans, so different from the Miami Vice-inspired, Easter-egg-colored blazers on most of the other men. There’s nothing artificial about Mick. It’s like he survived something dangerous, and now he is forever chill. He doesn’t talk about his past.

5. Date the men who think they’ll impress you with the size of their Rolodex, but always go over to Mick’s house after. Bring him your leftovers. Dish about the date. Mick’s place is in constant disarray because he’s trying to remodel the old bungalow himself. This means there is a pool, but no water. A kitchen with no floor. A hot plate. A tiny fridge. And yet you always feel comfortable and welcome. He doesn’t care if you put your feet up anywhere. He is happy to see you, and he makes you happy to be seen.

6. Go to Patina. Have the lobster bisque. Order pear liquor as the after-dinner drink and decide that it tastes exactly like you imagine furniture polish would taste. Make this comment to your date who doesn’t think you’re funny at all, especially because that drink cost a pretty penny, little lady. Tell the story to Mick later, over beers. Out of the bottle, of course. He says, “I know exactly what you mean.” And you know he does. “Did he really call you ‘little lady’?”

7. Realize one night while you’re getting dressed for dinner that you do not want to go to the new hip place. The new big gig. The five-star anything. You don’t want to go to City or Maple Drive or Ivy by the Shore. You do not want to be arm candy or leg candy. Or any kind of candy at all. Realize you’re tired of listening to tonight’s specials because they sound as if someone made them up: frou-frou with a side of splitz-ditz under a generous squelch of wilted pick-up-sticks. Realize that you’ve had all the carpaccio a person can eat in a lifetime. What’s so special about raw fish in lime?

8. Call Mick and ask if you can come over. He says, “I don't have anything but crackers and mustard.” Tell him you’ll bring over some wine—a bottle somebody left at your apartment after a party—and you’ll be by in forty-five. Take off the dumb dress with the big bow. Put on ripped jeans and a concert tee. Show up at Mick’s feeling a little giddy.

9. Mick has lit candles on mismatched thrift-store tables in his backyard. He says, “There’s basil and tomatoes growing,” and points to the tiny garden you’ve never even noticed because it’s more weeds than garden.

10. Pluck fresh basil and crush a tiny bit between your thumb and finger. Breathe in that scent that takes you back to some other time, some other lifetime, maybe. Ancient and mystical. Pick a handful of tiny cherry tomatoes. Revel in their scent. Is there anything in the world as beautifully rustic as the scent of fresh tomatoes right off the vine?

11. Sit at Mick’s side on the deck around the empty pool. Let him make you tomato-and-basil cracker sandwiches with a little dash of mustard. With a jolt, understand that every bite is better than any bite you’ve ever had of any meal you’ve ever eaten.

12. Lean back against Mick as the sky changes color from dark moody blue to an inky black. Feel his arms around you. Relax against his chest. Listen as he whisper words in your ear. “Hi, my name is Chad? And I’ll be your…” Laugh and roll over to face him.

13. He brushes the hair out of your eyes. He kisses you. You kiss him.

You need the time machine, because there is no going back. Because Mick’s timeline ended in the 90s, way too young. Way too soon. But every time you have a little bite of tomato and basil on any type of cracker with any sort of mustard, you are in the canyons of LA. In the backyard of a rundown bungalow. With a man who was turning his life around. One cherry tomato at a time.

Posted Jun 07, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

29 likes 21 comments

Shauna Bowling
20:31 Jun 23, 2025

I really enjoyed this story, Annalisa. Mick and his simple life touched my hippie heart. I, too, grow cherry tomatoes and basil. Now I think I'll have a snack of tomatoes, basil, salt and pepper!

Congrats on making the shortlist. You definitely earned it!

Reply

23:21 Jul 05, 2025

Thank you very much. I appreciate you taking the time to write.

Reply

Story Time
19:38 Jun 23, 2025

I think it was great to use this format to tell the story. I think the last few bullet points could be expanded if you wanted to continue working on the story. When the story ends, it feels like there's more to explore, and speaking as reader, I'd be happy to keep going alongside you.

Reply

09:58 Jun 23, 2025

Great story! Congrasts on short list on first entry! :)

Reply

15:12 Jun 24, 2025

Thank you so much! I found the prompt inspiring!

Reply

Helen A Howard
13:57 Aug 03, 2025

Such a great way of bringing the past to life! Nice approach and very readable. Congratulations.

Reply

Philip Ebuluofor
20:20 Jun 25, 2025

Inventive and educative. Fine work. Congrats.

Reply

Marilyn Flower
04:18 Jun 22, 2025

Ah, magical. Click your cherry tomatoes together three times and whisper, there's no place like basil, there's no place like basil, there's no place like basil, and voila! You're home! But would you even have recognized it without the pear wine and lobster bisque? Only Chad knows, and he's not telling! Now that you're warmed up our appetites, Grey Poupon and I are off to see the mustard! Bravo and Congratulations, Annalisa!

Reply

16:40 Jun 22, 2025

Thank you so much! I'm so glad you liked my piece. I still think about the pear liquor from time to time.

Reply

Jenn Chapman
23:05 Jun 20, 2025

Wistful...and full of what's really important. Love it!

Reply

16:40 Jun 22, 2025

Thank you so much! I've never tried to write a story in recipe format before.

Reply

Avery Sparks
21:08 Jun 20, 2025

So much I love about this. It's evocative, poignant, a real capturing of people, time and place, circling back to those cheap crackers. And I'm completely with you when it comes to tomatoes on the vine. Lovely.

Reply

16:41 Jun 22, 2025

My middle kiddo works at a Sephora and told me that there is now a perfume that smells like tomatoes. I'm not sure if this is a good thing or a bad thing. Thank you for the lovely comment!

Reply

Alexis Araneta
17:53 Jun 20, 2025

Absolutely fun! Well-deserved shortlist placement!

Reply

Mary Bendickson
16:42 Jun 20, 2025

Congrats on shortlist. Will read later.🎉

Reply

Nicole Moir
15:41 Jun 20, 2025

Congratulations!

Reply

Iris Silverman
11:19 Jun 17, 2025

This was an incredible story. I loved your take on the prompt. This had such incredible nostalgia and weaved in the ingredients of the recipe so beautifully. Slowly, I learned the backstory behind this unusual recipe, and it was incredible.

Reply

16:43 Jun 22, 2025

Thank you so much! Yours was the first comment and made me feel very happy someone liked my piece enough to respond. I really appreciate that.

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.