Submitted to: Contest #311

Here Comes The Judge

Written in response to: "Write a story about an unlikely criminal or accidental lawbreaker."

Christian Crime Kids

Here Comes The Judge

The judge banged his gavel repeatedly. “Order! Order in the court, I say!”

The unruly din continued for another minute or two until the command took root. A woman shrieked loudly and ran across the courtroom. Giggles were heard in the gallery as peanuts get passed around. Playful hand clapping rhythms drummed out. Someone sang 'Baa, Baa, black sheep. Have you any wool?' The prosecutor adjusted his ill fitting suit and emitted a low growl.

The gavel pounded again. A kind of hush fell all over the room.

The owly judge pronounced, “All right, Mrs. Farmer, the mice have been chased out of the area. You can turn over the carving knife to the bailiff.”

“What do you want me to do with their tails?”

“Give them to the officer, also. Thank you for saving us all from those blind justice seekers. Now back to the case at hand.

“Mr. Prosecutor, Mr. Wolfe, correct? You were in the middle of questioning the witness, I believe. Proceed, please. And we will have no more outbursts such as that again, understand? Or I will be forced to clear the court.”

The prosecutor cleared his throat, “Gr-r, gr-um. Um, you were saying, Miss Marm.”

“My name is not 'Marm'. That is what I am. A school marm.”

“Sorry. A school marm named Miss Mary?”

“No. Mary is a student. My name is unrecorded.”

“Okay, Miss Unrecorded. You are on record saying the perpetrator, the accused, broke the rules. Is that correct?”

“Yes. That is correct.”

“Can you identify this rule breaker? Are they present in the courtroom today?”

“Well, it is hard to say exactly because there are so many gathered here that resemble the culprit, but I believe that is the one at that table there.”

“Let the record show Miss Unrecorded is pointing at the defendant at the defendant's table. How sure are you that is the one, Miss Unrecorded?”

“Nearly 100 percent, Sir. Like I said there are many in attendance that look very much the same, though. It's fleece is white as snow sort of like your suit and like over in the jury box.”

“Those are peers deciding if the party is guilty of the charge. Is there any other way we could use to definitely identify the rule breaker?”

“Oh, I don't know for sure but I suppose if it follows the student Mary every where she goes it might be a clue.” Assured the young marm.

“And why is that, I wonder?” Wondered Mr Wolfe, as he readjusted his slipping suit.

“That's how it arrived at school. It followed Mary. It's rumored it follows her where ever she goes.”

“Your Honor, I request the student Mary seated next to the defendant walk across the room to see if she will be followed by the perpetrator.” Mr. Wolfe suggested.

“If you please, Young Lady, rise and walk across the room.” The judge directs.

When she did, the little lamb next to her did indeed follow her across the room and back to the table.

“I believe that proves the defendant is the animal in question. And exactly what rules were broken by this devious character, Miss Unrecorded?”

“Your Honor, I must object.” The defense attorney spoke softly. “Counselor is leading the witness by defaming the character of the accused.”

“Sustained. Disregard the description offered by the prosecutor. You may answer the question.” The judge instructs.

“What was the question again?”

“What rules were broken?”

“Well, it is against the rules to have a lamb, or any animal for that matter, at school.”

“Your Honor, I object!” Mr. Shepherd, counselor for the defense speaks up once more.

“State your objection, Counselor.” The judge grants permission.

“As we have recently witnessed, animals such as those mice that got loose are allowed at school.”

“How do you justify that, Miss Unrecorded?” Asks the bench.

“Those are used for educational purposes. Mostly scientific research.”

“Objection overruled. You may proceed, Mr. Wolfe.”

“And why is there such a rule regarding non-scientific animals in school?”

“It can be very disruptive to a classroom. The students can't learn.”

“Why is that?”

“It makes the children laugh and play. Laughing and playing, you understand, doesn't allow room for learning.”

More giggles erupted from the gallery above.

“Order.” Demanded the judge once more banging his gavel.

“And, therefore, Miss School Marm. What did you do to take care of the problem?”

“Let's see. Oh, yes, I turned it out, yes, Sir, I turned it out. But still it lingered near.”

“Then what happened, in your own words.”

“It waited patiently, patiently until Mary did appear.”

“Was that the end of the fiasco?”

“So far. Mary must have contained it so it wouldn't follow her to school again.”

“To sum up. We have a wayward lamb identified as the defendant that broke the rules by interrupting your classroom time stealing valuable learning time from all of your students. Is that a fair assessment?”

“Yes, I believe you are correct.”

“Your Honor, I rest my case. I recommend further incarceration for the defendant so such a travesty never happens in Nursery Rhyme Village again. Just so you know, I gladly offer my services to take the perpetrator into custody and render justice.

“I'm sure that won't be necessary, Mr. Wolfe.” The judge avows. “You may step down, Miss Unrecorded. Now it is the defense's turn to state their case. Mr. Shepherd, the floor is yours.”

The kindly looking attorney in white robe and sandals stands and lifts the defendant into his arms and carries it before the bench.

“Your Honor, this is one of My lost sheep. It did stray. It was lost but now it is found. It loved Mary as she loved it. That is why it follows her everywhere much like Mary follows Me. I have paid the price of its transgressions. It is forgiven. Therefore, you should forgive it, also. When a lost sheep is found and repents of straying I provide for all its needs and return it to the sheepfold. It has provided a valuable lesson to all the children at school and in the peanut gallery today.”

“How does the jury find the defendant?” Asks the judge.

“Not guilty!” They shout in unison and spill out to surround the Good Mr. Shepherd.

“Case dismissed!” Declares the judge.

Posted Jul 18, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

15 likes 26 comments

16:36 Jul 23, 2025

Really clever and brilliant use of the prompt. Love how you've come up with this... great imagination! Loved the ending!

Reply

Mary Bendickson
22:20 Jul 23, 2025

😊

Reply

Rebecca Hurst
13:17 Jul 23, 2025

Wonderful allegorical tale (or tail). Loved it!

Reply

Mary Bendickson
13:55 Jul 23, 2025

😁

Reply

Jack Kimball
19:38 Jul 22, 2025

Well, I have a rule. Anytime the word "din" is used in a story I'm hooked, immediately, do not pass go.

Mary, Mary, who now has 10,431 Reedsy points, an example for us all. Who else could take a nursery rhyme and turn it into courtroom drama?

Favorite section:
The prosecutor cleared his throat, “Gr-r, gr-um. Um, you were saying, Miss Marm.”
“My name is not 'Marm'. That is what I am. A school marm.”
“Sorry. A school marm named Miss Mary?”
“No. Mary is a student. My name is unrecorded.”
“Okay, Miss Unrecorded

Reply

Mary Bendickson
20:13 Jul 22, 2025

😆Thanks.
Nice new picture!

Reply

Helen A Howard
16:40 Jul 22, 2025

What fun, Mary.
It reminded me of a friend whose dog used to follow her to school and disrupted the lessons.
I enjoyed the blend of courtroom drama, childish play, and nursery rhyme characters.
Excellent “tail.” Unique.

Reply

Mary Bendickson
18:38 Jul 22, 2025

So pleased it pleased you.😊

Reply

James Scott
03:23 Jul 22, 2025

Lots of fun and a clever reimagining of a nursery rhyme!

Reply

Mary Bendickson
05:14 Jul 22, 2025

Glad you liked it.😊

Reply

Mary Butler
23:57 Jul 21, 2025

What a brilliantly whimsical courtroom scene! You had me grinning from the first gavel bang to the final “Case dismissed!” I especially loved the line: “It loved Mary as she loved it. That is why it follows her everywhere much like Mary follows Me.” That added such a sweet, spiritual note to an otherwise hilariously chaotic tale. The mix of nursery rhyme and courtroom drama was inspired — mice being chased, peanuts in the gallery, and a sheep on trial? Genius. Mr. Wolfe’s serious prosecutorial tone cracked me up, especially in contrast with the utterly absurd case. And that closing argument by Mr. Shepherd? A perfect blend of heart and humor. Thanks for the delightful ride through Nursery Rhyme Village justice!

Reply

Mary Bendickson
00:48 Jul 22, 2025

And thank you for the delightful comment. Glad you enjoyed the drama.😁

Reply

J.R. Geiger
14:18 Jul 21, 2025

Now this was a cute story.

Well done.

I love the nursery rhyme characters and the courtroom situation.

You have got to put them into a contemporary scenario like Mr. Wolfe as a NASCAR driver and the sheep his pit crew. 😆

Reply

Mary Bendickson
15:32 Jul 21, 2025

How do you come up with your ideas? 🤔😂

Reply

J.R. Geiger
17:10 Jul 21, 2025

I just think of... What if...?

Whatever outrageous idea comes to mind, I go for it....

Mr. Wolfe, despite his predatory instincts, harbored a secret passion: NASCAR. He roared onto the track in a custom-painted #99 "Big Bad Wolf" Chevrolet, much to the bewilderment of his fellow drivers. His pit crew, however, was the real head-scratcher. A motley crew of sheep, led by the surprisingly competent Dolly, scrambled to change tires and refuel. During one particularly intense race, Mr. Wolfe's tire blew out on the final lap. "Faster, you woolly nincompoops!" he howled over the radio, eyeing a rival car gaining on him.
Dolly, unflustered, calmly directed her team. One sheep, Baa-rbara, fumbled with the lug nuts, while another, Shaun, got tangled in the air hose. Yet, with surprising coordination (and a few well-placed headbutts from Dolly), they managed a lightning-fast stop. Mr. Wolfe peeled out of the pit, just narrowly beating his competitor to the finish line. As he celebrated his improbable victory, he couldn't help but think, "Maybe these sheep aren't so baa-d after all."

Reply

Mary Bendickson
17:45 Jul 21, 2025

👏👏👏

Reply

Derek Roberts
00:57 Jul 21, 2025

Nursery Rhyme + Alice in Wonderland x Inherit the Wind = This truly brilliant story. How much fun did you have writing this? I had a lot of fun reading it.

Reply

Mary Bendickson
01:03 Jul 21, 2025

Thanks! Started Friday at noon. Finished about 5pm. Easiest one I've ever writen, I think. Hardest part was getting an idea of what to write which is true all the time for me.😆

Reply

Derek Roberts
01:14 Jul 21, 2025

Well good stories always start with a good premise. I loved the premise of this story.

Reply

Rebecca Lewis
15:33 Jul 20, 2025

The idea is super creative! Turning Mary Had a Little Lamb into a courtroom drama? That’s brilliant and fun. The humor worked well the little chaotic touches like the peanut gallery, people singing, and the judge trying to keep control. That made me smile. The ending with the Good Shepherd was a nice twist. It gave the story a heartwarming finish and a deeper meaning beyond the comedy. It’s a super fun, whimsical piece that works on two levels- funny and meaningful.

Reply

Mary Bendickson
19:58 Jul 20, 2025

I really appreciate your comment. Thank you.😊

Reply

Thomas Wetzel
21:03 Jul 19, 2025

This was really clever. I liked the prosecutor (wolf in sheep's clothing). Nicely done. I suspect that's the first time anyone has ever used the combination of those three categories here on Reedsy.

Reply

Mary Bendickson
23:06 Jul 19, 2025

I hope so!😆Thanks for liking.

Reply

Alexis Araneta
16:42 Jul 19, 2025

Hahahaha! Adorable one, Mary! Lovely work!

Reply

Jo Freitag
03:18 Jul 19, 2025

I love this story, Mary and especially the ending!

Reply

Mary Bendickson
04:40 Jul 19, 2025

Thank you so much!

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.