Content warning: emotional abuse, pregnancy loss.
Some things don’t disappear when they’re gone. They wait.
The tide always came home. Maren never quite managed to.
Most mornings she found herself here again, though she couldn’t have said why. Maybe the sea remembered her. Maybe that was enough. The road ran until it forgot itself and became water; each dawn she stood at that seam, stone loosening into tide, and watched the ocean retreat as if it had somewhere better to be.
She had started coming the week she turned fifty, when she woke with smoke in her hair from a fire she hadn’t lit. The bell on the headland cleared its throat into the fog and let the day begin without asking her permission. Drizzle threaded the air the way grief threaded a life: quiet, constant, and unwilling to leave.
The bay was pewter this morning, soft and bruised-looking, the kind that showed every fingerprint. She always thought of it like that—something that remembered being touched.
She took the jar from its place in the stone niche along the wall. Old jam glass, green-tinted, leaning slightly at the seam like it had survived a hard life. She tapped the lid. That click had become a ritual, a way to start again.
“Alright, love?” called Gwen from above, hunched over her garden wall in a cardigan the colour of old tea.
“Morning,” Maren said.
“You’ll catch your death out there. Air’s got teeth today.”
“So does the sea,” Maren said. “Worse boundaries than any man I’ve met.”
Gwen huffed, amused. “Bring back something pretty. I’ll pretend I don’t know it’s rubbish.”
They shared a glance that held years in it—the silent knowledge of two people who had once saved each other by accident.
Then Maren stepped onto the tidal road, slick with sand and sea-sheen. Wind lifted her hair in warning. The air tasted like iron and salt. She walked slowly, eyes lowered. Foragers walked like this. So did people carrying quiet guilt.
The sea kept a daily inventory: rope, driftwood, one yellow boot, never two. Bottle caps. Feathers. The broken spine of an umbrella. And glass. Always glass.
That was why she came.
The morning after the bonfire, she’d found a shard near the verge—green, sea-worn silky with time. She had taken it home without understanding why. The next day there were two. Then more. She kept them, though she didn’t know for what. Some things arrive before their purpose.
The first piece she spotted today was green again, soft oval, edges patient from years of sanding against tide and stone. She turned it in her fingers. In the grey morning, it flashed briefly, like a signal someone had given up sending.
Green meant permission. Once, she had refused it.
The smell of iron arrived before the thought. Suddenly she was back at the kitchen table, years ago, staring at a letter like it might bite if opened.
Marseille Residency Program – six months. Studio access. Full scholarship.
Her hands trembled as she lifted the page. “It’s real,” she whispered, because saying a thing aloud gave it weight.
“Six months,” Rowan said from the doorway. He leaned there like he already owned the room, mug in hand, chipped at the rim where it tapped his teeth. “We’ve only just got serious. Long distance kills people, love. You’ll leave and meet some bloke who likes oil paint and mess.”
She had laughed back then—the kind of laugh meant to keep peace, the kind that cost more than it looked. But he wasn’t always unkind. Once, he stayed awake beside her all night while she worked on a canvas that had scared her to begin. At four a.m., he made her coffee and said he believed in her hands. It is always harder to leave a man who is capable of kindness.
“Stay,” he said now, softer. Like a hand offered—but palm up or palm down, she couldn’t tell.
She packed anyway. She folded loose brushes into cloth. Wrapped her palette like a child. Folded courage into a ticket with a foreign city written on it. Before dawn she stood at the platform, rails shining like something that had been waiting for her.
The ticket trembled in her fist. Freedom didn’t always feel light; sometimes it felt like jumping with no guarantee of landing.
Rowan’s voice lived under her collarbone: Six months apart will kill us.
She tore the ticket in four neat pieces—quarters of a life. The train arrived. Steam hissed across her wrist, hot and unkind. That night he kissed the burn and called it love.
She had mistaken ownership for devotion for years.
The wind snapped her back to now. She dropped the green shard into the jar.
A few steps on she saw the next piece—blue, the colour of a sky she no longer trusted. She held it to the grim morning light and watched a square of blue dance faintly across her palm, as if a ceiling somewhere remembered her.
Memory didn’t announce itself; it arrived uninvited.
The flat above the bakery had skylights—she loved it for that. “Sky inside,” she’d said, rolling paint before they had furniture.
Rowan had leaned against the doorway.
“Leave it white,” he said. “White keeps a place honest.”
“Blue makes it kinder,” she said, and climbed the ladder with a brush between her teeth.
She painted until her shoulders ached and the whole room felt like a softened summer. She slept proud under that new sky.
By morning it was white again.
The paint tin sat by the sink, lid crushed on and dotted with fingerprints like bruises. Rowan had opened every window, air sharp and punishing.
“It made me dizzy,” he said simply. “You know I can’t sleep in chemical air.”
She scraped her beautiful sky into the bin without speaking. That day she learned a dangerous truth: you don’t have to break a woman to erase her. You can just repaint her.
She swallowed the memory. Dropped the blue shard into the jar.
Near the wrack line, something warm flickered against the cold morning—a glow of amber half-buried in sand. When she lifted it, light moved through it slowly, like honey that remembered fire.
Amber was a dangerous colour: soft at first, then burning.
The quay had been crowded that Saturday years ago, full of fishmongers and wet nets and shouting men who pretended the sea was something that could be bargained with. Rowan’s voice had carried over the stalls—rich, confident, familiar enough to draw eyes. He had loved an audience the way some people loved prayer.
The vendor, wrapping their cockles, told Maren he liked her scarf. Rowan laughed first.
“She’d wear sackcloth if I didn’t dress her.”
Everyone laughed the easy laugh people give handsome men who sound sure of themselves. Maren laughed too, though she didn’t feel it. Survival sometimes sounds like agreement.
On the walk home, Rowan slung the cockle bag over his shoulder like a prize. He threaded a casual finger through one of her belt loops, guiding her—not roughly, just with ownership. She had learned by then: gentle control is still control.
In the present, the amber shard pulsed, as if it still carried applause from somewhere she’d worked hard to forget. She turned it in her palm once, felt the past try to sweeten itself again. Then she dropped it into the jar before it could lie to her.
The tide was sliding back in. She quickened her pace.
The next shard was white, tender as bone—the sort of glass that once had been clear but turned milk-soft after years in the sea. Light slid through it in a way that made the world around it too sharp: clean, merciless.
White was the colour of hospitals. Of almost.
The letter had come tucked between a café menu and a bill. A professor she admired had written to invite her to exhibit: small residency, northern coast, travel covered, stipend included. He had seen one of her earlier canvases and wrote four words that had nearly undone her: Your work knows silence.
She had hidden the letter under a tea towel as if hope needed shelter to survive in her home.
That night, their kitchen filled with neighbours, steam, and too much wine. Rowan liked a table full of people—he told stories better when he had witnesses. Halfway through dinner, his grin widened like someone about to unwrap a trick.
“Good news,” he announced, raising his glass. “We’re having a baby.”
The room cheered. Maren stared at him. The room blurred.
He leaned to her ear. “Finally painting something useful,” he murmured, and pressed his thumb into her waist where nobody could see.
Weeks later, the doctor apologized with a gentle voice and practiced eyes. “Common. Nothing you did.”
She left with nothing but an empty shape inside her and a folded piece of paper with the word loss printed where a heartbeat should have been. At home, she placed the ultrasound in a drawer. She didn’t cry. She sat at the table and stared at her hands, waiting to feel like a person again. Rowan stood in the doorway, arms crossed, unreadable.
He didn’t blame her. He didn’t hold her. He just didn’t speak to her for three days.
That was when she realized something cruel: there are wounds the world lets you grieve, and there are wounds you must bury alone.
She placed the white shard back into the water, not the jar. Some memories were never hers to hold in the first place.
A wind shift cut through her coat. She walked until the shore grew feral—tangles of kelp, broken crab shells, gulls wheeling low.
The brown shard lay wedged between two stones, dull as disappointment. Brown was the colour of rot disguised as earth.
A dinner party. Six guests. Wine poured like apology. Rowan retold a story about her—one she hated, one he knew she hated—about the time she lost a canvas she had been working on for weeks. He performed it like comedy, twisting truth into humiliation with perfect timing. The table laughed, grateful not to be the target. She smiled too, because the alternative would’ve been worse: exposing the violence no one else could see.
Later that night he kissed her knuckles like a peace offering. “You’re too sensitive, Maren. People laugh because they like you.”
Translation: I decide how people see you.
He didn’t raise his voice. He didn’t swear. He never needed to. Control doesn’t always slam doors; sometimes it just edits you until you fit.
Back on the shore, she turned the brown shard over. Her reflection came back warped. Honest. She put it into the jar.
Then she saw it—the grey piece. Dark, smoke-struck glass, sharper than the rest, half-buried like something that didn’t want to be found. She knew before she touched it what memory it held. This one had teeth.
The shed had smelled like turpentine and rain. Her favourite canvas leaned against the wall—too raw to show, too true to destroy. She had painted it during a winter she didn’t think she’d survive. The horizon line in it looked like a prayer said from the inside of a locked room.
“That old thing?” Rowan had said when he found her looking at it. “You’re not still chasing that storm.” He said storm like sickness.
That night, from the kitchen, she saw light outside. Not warm light. Firelight.
No one else would have noticed the canvas in the flames—one more broken frame, another scrap in a bonfire. But she knew its shape even in silhouette.
By the time she ran outside, the paint was already bubbling, burning in colours no one would ever see again.
A piece of her life went up that night and did not return.
Rowan stood beside the fire, palms out to the heat as though he hadn’t lit it to begin with.
“Must’ve been rotten,” he said. “Things that matter don’t burn that fast.”
He didn’t look at her as he said it.
She didn’t scream. She didn’t beg for the painting. She learned in that moment that grief could be quiet: sharp as glass, clean as winter.
Now, holding the grey shard, she let herself feel the weight of it—the part of her life she hadn’t known how to bury. The night the sea began speaking to her because there was nowhere else to take her rage.
She put the shard in the jar.
Rain began, not a storm, just steady intention. The kind that decides things. The kind that makes you finish what you came to do.
She reached the end of the tidal road where the sea began to take itself seriously. She set the jar on a flat rock. The waves breathed in and waited.
She unscrewed the lid and laid the pieces out in a line: a small, wordless accounting.
Green – permission refused.
Blue – sky taken from her hands.
Amber – applause that cost her a self.
White – grief that did not get a funeral.
Brown – humiliation disguised as love.
Grey – the hardest thing to forgive.
Salt wind slicked her hair to her face. She didn’t wipe it away. For the first time in years, she wanted to feel everything.
She stared at the pieces. They looked harmless now, soft-edged, worn down. Proof that time didn’t erase what had happened; it only made it safe to hold.
She thought of Rowan—not the cartoon villain people imagine when they hear the word damage, but the real thing. The slow erasure. The pretty cage. The ache you start calling normal. Some men don’t have to raise a hand to break you; they just teach you to hold the knife yourself.
She looked out at the tide. The seam between road and sea blurred under rain.
The jar had never been about collecting. It had always been about returning.
She picked up the green shard and threw it into the waves. Then the blue. Then the amber. The white and brown followed. Each one vanished in a widening circle, swallowed by something larger than memory.
She held the last piece—the grey one—until her hand shook. This one was hardest because it still wanted to be true.
She closed her fist around it. The glass did not cut her. She had already done the cutting herself long ago.
A storm lived behind her ribs, but it didn’t scare her anymore.
She let the shard go.
The grey glass struck the water with a sound so small it felt holy: a tap on skin. No drama. No redemption. Just truth.
The circle widened. Dissolved. Took nothing from her that she needed.
She stood very still. Then something inside her, something small and stubborn, opened like a window. Not joy. Not relief. Just room. She had not known she’d been running out of room.
Behind her, Gwen’s voice carried over the rain.
“You done, love?”
“Nearly,” Maren said.
She put the lid back on the empty jar. It weighed almost nothing. For a moment she wanted to keep it—to fill it again with proof of what she had survived. But strength wasn’t carrying the weight; strength was knowing when to set it down.
The tide sloshed over the road, reclaiming it. The sea didn’t care what had been done here. But it had witnessed it, and that was enough.
She tucked the empty jar under her arm and walked back toward the world that waited, plain as bread and as complicated as love.
Gwen met her halfway down the lane, scarf wild in the wind.
“You’re soaked,” Gwen said.
“Better soaked than still,” Maren answered.
“Tea, then?”
“Always.”
Inside Gwen’s kitchen, the windows fogged with warmth and steam. Life clattered around the room in spoons and teacups—the quiet proof that people keep going even when they don’t know how.
Gwen cleaned the cut on Maren’s palm without asking about it. Love, the real kind, rarely requires explanation.
When the rain settled into mist, Maren stood.
“Will you bring that thing back?” Gwen asked, tapping the jar.
“For the niche,” Maren said. “Someone else will need it.”
“Someone always does.”
The walk home was short and salt-scented. The sky had begun to lift at the edges, pulling light through like thread. Maren’s front door still hung slightly crooked—a leftover joke from Rowan’s hands—but it no longer felt like a relic. Just a door. She opened it.
Inside, the mantel held a single pale stripe where other jars had once stood. She let the emptiness remain. Not everything needed filling.
On the windowsill lay a paintbrush, bristles splayed, waiting. She picked it up. It balanced in her grip like something that had been waiting for her too.
She opened the window. Air moved through the room—clean, salt-laced, awake.
The sea hummed in the distance, tireless and ancient. It had taken pieces of her life, returned others, and carried the rest without judgment. It was not kind. But it was honest. And honesty was its own form of mercy.
She set the brush beside a fresh canvas.
Somewhere beyond sight, Rowan still lived—alive enough to haunt, gone enough to free her. She no longer needed to choose between forgetting and remembering. Salt does not forget; it keeps shape long after the wound closes.
So did she.
She touched the blank canvas. It did not ask anything of her. It only waited.
Outside, the bell tolled once—not warning, just time keeping its promise.
The tide always came home. And now, finally, so did she.
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
I came here from your story The Left Shoe First, which was vividly and beautifully wrought, with strong extended metaphor, vibrant imagery and sense of place, a believable character who had a moving internal conflict, and a timeless message to top it off. It was so good I had to come for more, and this did not disappoint on any of those fronts. I really felt like I was with Maren and Gwen staring out at the wild grey tides (which, to be fair, isn't too difficult as I'm currently living by the sea!)
Maren herself was a likeable character whose personal ambitions are crushed by a charming but controlling man, whose hubris is invisible to all-- even Maren at first. This concept, as well as her deeply human desires for self-expression and artistic brilliance, made it an intensely relatable story that I think will resonate with many.
Maren's relationship with Gwen was lovely; quiet and tender, and it serves as the perfect antithesis to the abusive relationship controlled by Rowan. I would, however, liked to have heard more about how Maren and Gwen 'once saved each other by accident.' I also want to know how exactly the relationship with Rowan ended: did Gwen inadvertently give her an out? We assume it was straight after the burning of the painting, but it isn't clear. You leave me feeling as though there is more to the story I'm not privy to. It's all so wonderful--so give us more to work with PLEASE!!!
I also really liked the tinted glass shards as metaphors (which to me, are symbolic of how emotion warps memories) and the idea of throwing them all away in order to heal. The extra glass jars on the mantle hinting at more trauma in Maren's life was also very clever.
The one part I didn't like was when you spelt out what each shard represented; I assume you meant it to give the story more structure, but it felt like patronising the reader. In my opinion, the whole list is redundant; it's aesthetically displeasing, unnecessarily spells out what is happening, and is also devoid of the poetic links you made between the stones and the memories within the narrative. It doesn't give clarity but rather feels clumsily expositional. Summarising the stories like this also robs them of their depth and trivialises Maren's struggle imo. One additional small mistake you might not have noticed while editing was that the white shard wasn't actually in the jar, as she cast it away already.
The only other part that took me out of the story a little was the character of Rowan: he's a remarkabky well-written villain at first (I especially liked the pregnancy story and the indoor sky vignette- this one *SHONE*!!!) but he becomes totally unrealistic by the end, flying in the face of the intended message that abuse doesnt always come in the form of cartoon villains. The idea that the worst thing for her is the destruction of her art is excellent, and this becomes a potent symbol of their relationship as a whole, but there is no buildup to this specific moment at all and as a result it feels like hollow cartoon villainry. He is not angry, nor burning it for any manipulative end I can see. It's an action that, while representative of the core tension in their relationship, doesn't work in his favour as a rational decision, and there is no indication that he is thinking less rationally than usual. It comes literally out of nowhere. Of course, this is not a major problem for the story, and all it requires is a little fleshing out to show why he does it, but I get why you might be nervous about either humanising him too much or giving him some sort of wild temper. I think these effects are easily avoidable with careful thought, though.
Anyway, you obviously don't have to listen to this random stranger because you're always the expert on your own work and you might have good reasons for these choices, but those are the things that stood out to me as a reader. Overall I loved it and think you're an incredible writer from the two stories I've read, and can only offer words of encouragement- don't let any Rowans go burning your paintings; you've got a real talent, and it shouldn't be thrown away!!!
Reply
A gut punch of a first sentence, and a story that backed it up and fulfilled its promise. Love it, Sonia. Well done!
Reply
This was a beautiful story with a brilliant extended metaphor. In collecting the glass shards, she was "picking up the pieces" that were taken from her. Like glass shards, the painful memories were jagged around the edges and no two were the same. The commentary about what villains are really like in the non-fantasy world was brilliant. It's a fantastic reminder for us to remember to believe those who are victims of domestic violence. What looks okay on the outside may certainly not be.
Beautiful story. thank you for sharing
Reply
Thank you for this beautiful comment. The way you unpacked the glass shards - how each piece mirrored memory, pain, and survival and connected it to the quiet reality of domestic abuse means so much. You understood the heart of what I was trying to say: that not all villains are loud, and not all wounds are visible. I wrote this story hoping someone would see that truth beneath the metaphor, and you did. That metaphor came from a very quiet, personal place, so seeing you reflect on it with such empathy means more than I can say.
Reply
You. Girlfriend, are very talented. This speaks volumes softly.
Reply
Mary, you’re so kind! that made me smile. Thank you for reading and for saying that. I’m really touched you felt something in it. 💕
Reply
Just absolutely incredible.
Reply
That’s so kind of you, thank you! I’m really grateful you took the time to read it.
Reply
Sonia, you are a painter of words. Oh my goodness! I love how each shard represented a way for Rowan to control Maren. It's soft, quiet, but full of sharpness too. Incredible work!
Reply
You have no idea how much this means. I poured so much into that balance of softness and sharpness🥹 thank you for seeing it so clearly. Your words honestly made me night.
Reply
Beautifully written! I felt every word.
Reply
Aw, thank you so much!
Reply
This is absolutely breathtaking and masterful. Reading this piece, I felt like I was walking alongside Maren— the imagery transported me to the edge of the tide. Every emotion evoked by the symbolism lingers long after the final line. I appreciate how the ending isn’t loud, but rather honest and full of breath. Stunning work.
Reply
This comment made me tear up a little. Thank you for reading with so much heart - I can feel the care in your words. I’m beyond grateful that Maren’s story stayed with you.
Reply
Amazing read!
Reply
Thank you, truly! I’m really happy you enjoyed it.
Reply