I. Description: Handwritten school assignment, dated March 4, 2024, by Timmy Reed, Age 7, single sheet of lined paper, submitted by Ms. Evelyn Porter (Lincoln Elementary School, 2nd Grade) to King County Sheriff’s Office, collected from classroom on March 18, 2024, Volunteer Park Incident Investigation.
The Mushroom Guardians
Sam is a gnome that was in my Mom’s garden. He’s old and chipped, with a pointy red hat. There used to be mushrooms growing around him, little white ones, but Mom pulled them out last summer. Sam didn’t like that. He looked mad without his mushrooms. So I rescued him. Now he stares out my bedroom window at night. Me, Joey, Ben, and Lila made a club called the Mushroom Guardians. Joey wrote our club rules on his notepad. Ben’s the Sergeant of Arms and Lila’s our lookout. See, in Volunteer Park, there’s a magic mushroom garden. It’s a real Fairy Circle, and it’s secret. We found it hiding by the trees near the water tower. It’s ours. The bad men from the road company want to dig it up for a stupid street. We said no way and made our club to stop them. We’re four kids, and a gnome, against the bad men. We’ll figure something out. Do you have any ideas what we can do, Ms. Porter?
II. Description: Handwritten school assignment, dated March 4, 2024, by Lila Brooks, Age 7, single sheet of lined paper, submitted by Ms. Evelyn Porter (Lincoln Elementary School, 2nd Grade) to King County Sheriff’s Office, collected from classroom on March 18, 2024, Volunteer Park Incident Investigation.
The Fairy Circle and Me
My name’s Lila and our new club is called “The Mushroom Guardians.” Timmy’s our leader, and he says he can hear his gnome. Sam is telling him how to save the fairy circle! It’s this secret spot where we feel like we can do anything, like fairies are watching us. These terrible men want to tear it out to build a stupid road! My job is to be the lookout ‘cause I’m the smallest and sneakiest. I can hide behind trees super easy and I don’t wear glasses like the boys do. I think Sam’s funny looking. His little feet are stuck together, so I dunno how he's supposed to move. Anyway, I really love fairies, and I’ll do almost anything to keep them safe! As long as I’m home by 7:00 because that’s when my Mom fixes dinner every night.
III. Description: Printed news clipping, dated March 6, 2024, Seattle Times, page A3, submitted to King County Sheriff’s Office, collected from public records on March 18, 2024, Volunteer Park Incident Investigation.
Volunteer Park Road Expansion Draws Ire, Vandalism
Seattle, WA—Apex Corporation’s plan to widen Park Drive through Volunteer Park’s eastern edge has sparked backlash from residents, with protests growing over the loss of green space. Last night, vandals struck, slashing tires on three Apex trucks parked near the site. Witnesses reported small shadows fleeing. "It looked like kids pulling a cruel stunt," said jogger Lisa Tran. The project, set to begin in April, promises faster commutes but will uproot trees and disrupt trails near the water tower. "It’s frustrating, but we’re pressing on," said foreman Jim Kessler. "Not everyone lives in a fairyland. This road will ease traffic." Police are investigating the tire damage as petty vandalism, though Kessler insists there’s no need for violence. "The road’s for everyone," he added. Community groups plan a rally this weekend to oppose the expansion.
IV. Description: Email, dated March 7, 2024, from Ms. Evelyn Porter (Lincoln Elementary School, 2nd Grade) to Mr. and Mrs. Reed, submitted to King County Sheriff’s Office, collected from school email records on March 18, 2024, Volunteer Park Incident Investigation.
Subject: Concern About Timmy—Can We Meet?
Dear Mr. and Mrs. Reed,
Left you a voicemail today—following up here. Timmy’s been a bright, engaged student this year, which makes his recent shift stand out. His latest writing assignment (snapshot attached) dwells on “mean men” threatening a park and mentions bringing your garden gnome, Sam, inside because “Sam didn’t like” the mushrooms being pulled up. That fixation feels odd for a second-grader. Lately, he’s quieter, staring out the window during lessons, sketching mushroom circles on his desk. At recess, he just huddles with a small group of friends, whispering like they’re in their own world, apart from the other kids. What’s most unsettling is how Timmy talks to that gnome like it’s listening. It’s unnerving the rest of the class—and, honestly, me too.
I’m worried this might signal more than just imaginative play, especially given recent trouble in Volunteer Park. His schoolwork is still solid, but I’d like to discuss this with you in person. Can we set a time to meet soon?
—Ms. Evelyn Porter, 2nd Grade Teacher
V. Description: Printed news clipping, dated March 8, 2024, Seattle Times, page A1, submitted to King County Sheriff’s Office, collected from public records on March 18, 2024, Volunteer Park Incident Investigation.
Disturbing Discovery in Volunteer Park Escalates Road Dispute
Seattle, WA—A grim scene greeted early joggers in Volunteer Park yesterday: a stray cat found dead, strung up in a tree with twine tied in such small knots one would have thought they had to have been made by child’s hands. Scrawled in the dirt below: "LEAVE FAIRYLAND ALONE!" The chilling message follows protests and tire-slashing vandalism earlier this week tied to Apex Corporation’s project. Police are probing claims of sabotage, with foreman Jim Kessler calling it "a sick escalation"—a stark shift from his earlier dismissal that "not everyone lives in a fairyland." Local activist Sage Rivers said, "I don’t condone violence, but that message speaks to a real loss—they’re tearing up our park, uprooting old trees, and ruining habitats for a road nobody needs." Authorities urge calm as the dispute turns darker.
VI. Description: Printed classified ad, dated March 10, 2024, Seattle Times, page C4, submitted to King County Sheriff’s Office, collected from public records on March 18, 2024, Volunteer Park Incident Investigation.
Missing: Five Garden Gnomes—Stolen?
Lost from my home at 789 Oakwood Ln: 5 small garden gnomes, brightly painted, moved from the yard sometime yesterday. Not valuable—just keepsakes from my late grandmother. If you took them, no questions asked, I’ll forgive you. Please return them. Check your yards, trash bins, or trees—maybe spotted as odd shapes around the neighborhood. They can be good at hiding. Contact M. Finch, reward offered.
VII. Description: Printed news clipping, dated March 14, 2024, Seattle Times, page A3, submitted to King County Sheriff’s Office, collected from public records on March 18, 2024, Volunteer Park Incident Investigation.
Volunteer Park Roadwork Resumes, Mysteries Persist
Seattle, WA—Apex Corporation pushed forward with its Park Drive expansion in Volunteer Park yesterday, resuming work after a week of bizarre disruptions—slashed tires, a dead cat strung up, and an unsettling encounter that left former foreman Jim Kessler rattled. New foreman Sarah Nguyen took charge, promising completion by May. "We’re back on track," Nguyen said, hailing the progress. "The road’s happening, whatever the trouble was." When asked about Kessler, who has taken leave for personal reasons, she offered little comment.
Local kids aren’t so sure. Seven-year-old Timmy Reed stood with friends Joey Carter and Lila Brooks near the site. He held up a tiny, red gnome’s hat he’d reclaimed near the water tower. "Mr. Kessler did something to Sam," he said, voice shaking, "and now they’re tearing out our mushroom circle." Carter added, "They can’t take everything!" Police remain stumped, with no arrests despite reports of small shadows and odd scrawled messages in the dirt. Residents mourn lost trees near the water tower, but with no new incidents, police have no leads on the disruptions.
VIII. Description: Printed news clipping, dated April 1, 2024, Seattle Times, page B1, submitted to King County Sheriff’s Office, collected from public records on April 2, 2024, Volunteer Park Incident Investigation.
Dog Uncovers Buried Gnomes Near Volunteer Park
Seattle, WA—A stray dog was caught chewing on five painted garden gnomes it unearthed from a shallow pit near Volunteer Park’s eastern edge last night. Resident M. Finch, 62, identified them as his "stolen" keepsakes, reported missing March 10. "Someone must have buried them," Finch admitted, visibly shaken. "thought they’d stay down." Police noted the figures were warm, some of their tiny stone fingers worn. "Almost like they tried to scratch their way out—guess they didn’t like the dirt nap," one officer joked to chuckles from the squad. No charges filed. Finch refused further comment, retreating indoors with the chewed up gnomes in tow. The bizarre discovery caps weeks of unrest tied to the Park Drive expansion, leaving residents puzzled but relieved at the project’s completion.
IX. Description: Typed clinical notes, dated April 5, 2024, excerpt from Dr. Alan Marwood, MD, Seattle Psychiatric Associates, submitted to King County Sheriff’s Office, collected from medical records on April 6, 2024, Volunteer Park Incident Investigation.
Patient: James Kessler, 41—Evaluation Summary
Former Apex Corp. foreman James Kessler, 41, presented today after a leave of absence and job termination. He reports an incident on March 12 near Volunteer Park, claiming a half-dozen small "gnomes" ambushed him in the dark. Armed with a shovel, he says he fought them off, struck each one unconscious, and buried them in a wooded lot. He ties this to prior site disruptions—slashed tires, a dead cat—and insists it’s why he left the project. Symptoms since include anxiety and sleeplessness, with vivid recall of the "gnomes." Diagnosis: Acute stress disorder, likely from workplace pressure. I suspect he encountered vandals, possibly linked to the five gnomes reported missing just two days prior, and built a stress-induced story. Patient claims it’s real, showing little insight. Ordered 72-hour hold; recommend ongoing care.
—Dr. Alan Marwood, MD
X. Description: Handwritten school assignment, dated April 8, 2024, by Timmy Reed, Age 7, single sheet of lined paper, submitted by Ms. Evelyn Porter (Lincoln Elementary School, 2nd Grade) to King County Sheriff’s Office, collected from classroom on April 9, 2024, Volunteer Park Incident Investigation.
Sam’s Own Fairy Circle
I saw the machines last week. The fairy circle by the water tower is gone. The mean men won, but they didn’t get our gnome! I found Sam shaking and hiding under the front porch yesterday. He had a chewed off arm and kept mumbling about his brothers… and a dog? He even found a new blue hat, slobbery with bite marks, but at least it’s big enough to cover his bald head!
Mom felt bad so she made us a new mushroom grove in the backyard. Our own little fairy circle. Now Sam watches over it so fiercely that I can’t get him to stay inside anymore. Yep, Ms. Porter, Sam’s the real Mushroom Guardian! I’m kinda worried, though. He’s changed. Quieter now, like he’s waiting for his brothers to wake up again.
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
What a creative way to tell an awesome story -- well done! Can't wait to read more!
Reply
I had fun building this odd little world. Appreciate you taking a moment to let me know! (Maybe I'll have to think about what else these Mushroom Guardians might get up to in the future??)
Reply
A dark and whimsical piece! It's like a fairy tale gone awry, and I'm left wondering if those gnomes really were just garden ornaments. You've certainly made me think twice about what lurks beneath the surface!
Reply
“Fairy tale gone awry”... he he. Now making me side-eye my own garden! Really appreciate you reading and tossing out such a thoughtful take, keeps the gears turning for me.
Reply
Thank you for sharing!
Reply
What a great twist on a traditional mystery! I loved how the story unfolded from so many different sources.
Reply
Thanks for reading and digging the twist—I really enjoyed playing with all those different voices to piece the mystery together! (It's funny how Reedsy prompts ACTUALLY make you stretch your writing muscles at times!) Glad to hear you liked how it unfolded, and I appreciate you taking the time to drop a comment.
Reply
Ha! Cool story. Reminded me of an interesting story I read in the newspaper when I lived up in Marin County. Someone went around one night and stole the garden gnomes of 20+ front lawns. Their owners were unhappy but obviously its not the sort of thing that police will launch a full investigation into. Over time, interest in the mystery and the anger over it faded.
Happy Ending. About a month later every one of the gnomes was returned with a brand new, beautiful paint job right to where it came from. Love that story. Chaos doesn't have to be a bad thing.
Reply
Thanks so much for reading and sharing that wild Marin County gnome tale. I love that the gnomes got a happy, colorful ending there, and it’s cool to think a little mischief can turn into something unexpected.
Reply
I love the way you put the numbered descriptions before each piece of text. Giving the context. It works really well. A very imaginative way of telling a very imaginative story!
Reply
Appreciate that—glad the descriptions clicked for you! It was fun to write something so out there.
Reply
This is great. I read your bio, and I am fully supportive of you easing off the full-on sci-fi (because I never understand that), into something a little more relatable on planet earth. Do both, of course, but I like this departure!
In the UK, maybe twenty years ago, someone stole a gnome from a garden somewhere in the Midlands. The owner was bereft and pretty furious. Then, she started to get postcards, from all over the world, and each one featured her gnome, whose face was slowly darkening into a full-on sun tan!
There were pictures of him in front of the Golden Gate Bridge, the Eiffel Tower, well .. you name it! Eventually he was returned, and she never found out who took him!
Reply
That UK gnome tale is wild—seems like these little guys are fated to get snatched and sent on globe-trotting adventures, I’ve heard whispers of that kind of mischief before. But the tan darkening his face? That’s such a quirky detail I’d never heard of, and now I’m imagining Sam sneaking off for a sunburn by the Eiffel Tower. Love that you shared this, it’s too fun not to grin about!
Also: Thanks for checking out my bio and backing this Earth-bound turn. Sci-fi/Fantasy has always been my pull, but I’m really enjoying leaning into grounded stuff lately—realistic kid dynamics (I am a retired public school teacher), and actual places like Volunteer Park—and it’s great to hear it connected with you. Appreciate you rooting for both paths; it keeps me eager to weave them together.
Reply
Yes, the best stories are grounded in reality whilst acknowledging the weirdness. Fairy tales are always rooted in the real world.
Reply
Very inventive way of framing the story! Not to mention that I'm still chuckling at the lines, "Check your yards, trash bins, or trees—maybe spotted as odd shapes around the neighborhood. They can be good at hiding."
I do believe M. Finch is in trouble once his damaged and dismembered gnomes finalize their plans to reunite with Sam, the Mushroom Guardian. The perfect backdrop for a horror flick!
Reply
Really appreciate you checking out my story and enjoying the framing. Those M. Finch lines were fun to sneak in. The idea of the gnomes plotting revenge does feel like a horror flick waiting to happen, and now you’ve got me imagining their next move...
Reply