Drama Sad Speculative

The memory lives on the third floor of the county courthouse. The air in that hallway hangs heavy, a mix of chemical disinfectant and the weary friction of cheap shoes on linoleum. My client, Leo Ramirez —a kid whose only crime was being in the wrong car—was fed to the system, sentenced to five years on a stacked charge I couldn't unravel. I watched the prosecutor, Henderson, retreat, his ill-fitting suit creased on a frame slumped in the particular exhaustion of a man who ruins lives as a matter of clerical routine.

"Henderson," I called out.

He turned, his eyes already distant, on the next file. "Counselor?"

"He was a good kid. He needed a chance."

Henderson released a sigh of pure friction, adjusting his cracked leather briefcase. The words he spoke were gravelly, worn smooth. "A hundred more Leos are waiting, counselor. My job isn't giving chances, it's clearing cases." He tapped the briefcase. "He's just a file. My job is to close files."

He disappeared. The squeak of his shoes was a faint, receding rhythm. Indifference. Leo's mother wilted against the wall, her sobs muffled and hopeless. In the sudden quiet, the words escaped me, a fierce, foolish whisper aimed at the empty air.

"I swear I will never be that. I will never believe a person can be just a file."

***

The memory of the diagnosis is sterile and beige. The air in the specialist's office smelled of antiseptic, and the paper on the exam table crinkled under my five-year-old son. Ben was doodling, blissfully unaware as the doctor spoke in calm, measured tones. The words he used were alien. "Chronic condition," he said. "Lifelong management."

My mind snapped into focus, building a case against this new, invisible defendant. Fear was a luxury. The public defender in me took over.

"Okay," I said, my voice sharp. "What’s the protocol? We’ll do whatever it takes."

The doctor nodded, a sad understanding in his eyes. "We'll start him on this," he said, scribbling a prescription. "It's the gold standard, but I have to warn you, insurance pre-authorizations can be a difficult fight."

And there it was. The floor dropped out. The enemy wasn't a disease; it was a system of paperwork and endless costs. It was Henderson's world in a different building. I looked at Ben, who was now trying to draw a superhero, and a cold dread settled deep beneath my resolve. This fight wasn't going to be about my will. It was going to be about my resources.

***

Eight years later, my kitchen table groans under the weight of different files. One, a letter from the insurance company, its dense paragraphs boiling down to a single, polite word: "denied." The other, a bill from my son Ben’s rheumatologist. The number at the bottom contains a comma.

Ben sleeps in the next room. I track the faint, wheezing sound of his breath like a seismologist monitoring a fault line. His autoimmune disorder rages as a silent, cellular storm, and the cost of calming it is that number. Principles don't synthesize medication. A parent's only real principle is their child's survival, and all others are luxuries. This wasn't a choice. It was an equation where the only variable I could change was my income.

***

I sat in the waiting area outside Marcus Thorne's office, an antechamber to the belly of the beast. The air tasted of wood polish and ambition, and it was hard to draw a full breath. A mahogany clock on the wall measured my betrayal in loud, judgmental ticks. I looked at the polished door, pictured Henderson walking out of it, and acid climbed the back of my throat.

I was on the wrong side of the door. The urge to stand, to bolt and never look back, was a physical force. But then my fingers found the crisp, folded edge of Ben's latest bill in my coat pocket. I pulled out my phone and stared at a picture of him, his small face breaking into a gap-toothed grin. The specter of Henderson dissolved. The equation solidified.

"Ms. Sharma?" a secretary called. I stood, the performance rehearsed for three straight nights ready.

Thorne didn't look up from my resume. "You've spent your entire career fighting this office, Counselor. Why the change of heart?"

This was it. The first, necessary lie. "I haven't changed my heart," I said, calibrating each word into a cool instrument of conviction. "I've changed my strategy. I fought from the outside and saw the same weaknesses exploited. I can be more effective from within the system."

He finally looked up, his eyes sharp and analytical. I didn't flinch. I held his gaze, selling him a version of myself he wanted to buy: a battle-hardened convert, not a desperate mother. I offered him the weaknesses of my former tribe. The price was a piece of my past. The prize was Ben's future.

"Effective," he repeated, a smile creeping across his face. "I like that."

***

My first day at the District Attorney's office felt like a willing infiltration. The stiff, sober blazer I wore was a costume for a part I had to learn. Thorne guided me to a desk already burdened with a leaning tower of manila folders. "Welcome," he said with a politician's warmth. "The name of the game here is dispositions. Efficiency is its own form of justice." *I’m not joining them,* I told myself. *I’m using them.*

For a few weeks, I tried. I took a complex assault case the others had dismissed. I spent a weekend in the law library digging through precedents, fueled by stale coffee and the fading echo of my old self. I found a novel argument—a way to show the human story behind the police report.

On Monday, I presented my twenty-page brief to Thorne. My chest tightened with a sensation I hadn't known in years—not anxiety, but a clean, sharp pulse of purpose.

He scanned the first page, then the last, and set it down. "This is beautiful work. A real legal treatise." He paused, his gaze flat. "It's also completely inefficient. While you were building this monument, ten other files gathered dust. This is an assembly line. Your job is to work the line and do your part of the whole."

He pushed the brief back toward me. A chill leached the warmth from my face. He wasn't wrong. My meticulous work had created a bottleneck. In practice, my idealism proved a liability.

I didn't give up. Not at first. I found a loophole to get a young man into a diversion program, and for a day, the old pulse returned. The cost, I later calculated, was fast-tracking three other possession cases with standard, harsh plea deals. I rationalized it as battlefield triage. Then, in a case review meeting, I heard the other prosecutors using their cold jargon—"perp," "vic"—and I tried to interject with the human details. They met me with polite, blank stares. I realized that to be heard in that room, I had to speak their language. The next time I spoke, the word "perp" felt alien in my mouth, but it earned a nod from Thorne. The tower of files on my desk never shrank. It became a monument to my own inefficiency, a physical weight pressing down on me each morning.

A week later, I opened a file for a shoplifter, a mother who stole diapers and formula. My old instincts flared. The search of her bag smelled questionable, a clear violation. A gift for any decent public defender.

I looked at the clock. Thorne's words echoed. The mountain of files grew. I saw Ben’s face. I had tried my way, and it failed. Now, I had to try his. It was a simple cost-benefit analysis: a minor, defensible charge for her versus a stable, productive day for me. With a sigh of pure, pragmatic fatigue, I stamped the intake form and added it to the pile for arraignment.

***

The transition, after that, grew easier. I learned the language. "Perps," not "defendants." "Dispositions." "Verdicts." My annoyance became my compass. I faced a young public defender in court, a woman burning with the same fire I once had, and a spike of irritation, hot and familiar, pierced my calm. Her passion wasn't a virtue. It was an obstacle. I saw the impatience on the judge's face and recognized it as my own. Henderson hadn’t been evil. He had just been pragmatic.

That night, the office was a tomb, and I was its last living occupant under the hum of the overheads. The last file in my tray belonged to a Daniel Kerwin, nineteen years old. A non-violent B&E, his second offense. He faced a mandatory minimum that would swallow his youth whole.

And there it was, on page three. The search warrant, approved based on uncorroborated evidence. A fatal flaw. A get-out-of-jail-free card. The overworked PD had missed it.

Thorne had stopped by an hour ago. "Clear this last one, Anya," he'd said, "and we can finalize that promotion." The promotion. The insurance that came with it. Ben would be safe.

This wasn’t a choice. It was the final, elegant proof of an equation. On one side: Daniel Kerwin, a name on a page. On the other: Ben. The numbers were clear. You save your own.

I pick up The Stamp. The plastic handle feels cool and solid in my palm. This is not a failure of justice; it is a triage of reality. The thud of the stamp on the paper wasn't a tragedy. In the sudden quiet of my mind, it felt like a solution. The frantic noise ceased. Replaced by a cold, clean calm.

I aligned the file's edges with a robotic precision that leaves no room for error and placed it in the outgoing tray. I emptied my cold coffee mug and gathered my coat.

As I switched off the lamp, I caught my reflection in the dark window. For a split second, I didn’t see myself. I saw Henderson's tired, pragmatic eyes and the slight, cynical curve of his mouth. The specter is gone, not because I defeated it, but because I have absorbed it. I see a woman who understands the world for what it is now. A survivor.

My first thought as I walk out of the silent office is a simple, logistical one. I have to remember to call the pharmacy in the morning about Ben's refill.

The end.

Posted Sep 09, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

3 likes 1 comment

Collette Night
08:36 Sep 17, 2025

Great story!! I love your use of similes and metaphors, like this one: Ben sleeps in the next room. I track the faint, wheezing sound of his breath like a seismologist monitoring a fault line.

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.