Submitted to: Contest #302

A Tale of Miscommunication

Written in response to: "Center your story around a mix-up that leads to huge (or unexpected) consequences."

Romance

Emma found a sanctuary in her local gym in the heart of the bustling city. It was a place where she could escape the stressors of her job and focus on her well-being. She had been so proud of herself. She managed to stick to her New Year resolution for once to regularly go to the gym. At first, she found it awkward being here. After a few weeks, she felt that she belonged. The gym becomes her happy place.

One evening, after finishing her workout, she noticed a charming man lifting weights nearby. His name was David, and they started a conversation that flowed effortlessly. They shared a few laughs and exchanged numbers before they parted ways. She felt giddily excitement building up inside her. She could not believe she actually had some hot guy's number. David was the only person she noticed at the gym.

The connection seemed so natural at this stage in her life. She was over with relationships. A track record of trashy boyfriends who destroyed her self-esteem. She does not need a man in her life. No, she just focuses on her fitness routine and her career.

Over the next few days, Emma and gym David began texting frequently. Their messages were light-hearted and gradually became more flirtatious. Emma looked forward to their conversations, her heart fluttering with anticipation each time her phone buzzed.

However, in her excitement, Emma made a crucial mistake. She had another David in her life—her coworker David. Without realizing it, she had started sending flirty messages to her coworker instead of gym David. Coworker David was puzzled but intrigued by the sudden shift in their professional relationship. Though he found the messages amusing, he did not question them and responded in kind.

They rarely talked face-to-face at work, but she spent hours talking to him without knowing Emma. She thought coworker David was friendly but did not consider him anything more than a coworker. They rarely did anything outside of work, but they often worked on different projects.

She had some bad experiences dating coworkers, and she was determined never to make that mistake again. She left her last job due to a messy breakup with a coworker. She vowed that she would spend a whole year single. I texted David that she would break that vow in three months.

But she enjoyed texting David. The flirtation seemed so natural. She found the one. After kissing lots of frogs, she finally found her prince. Was this story being said in the vows? I am excited when people ask how we met. I have a beautiful love story that she can tell her children and grandchildren.

Emma remained blissfully unaware of her error until the day she and gym David had planned to meet for coffee. She arrived early at the quaint café, her nerves tingling with excitement. As the minutes ticked by, she glanced around, expecting to see the familiar face of gym David walking through the door.

To her shock and dismay, coworker David entered the café, looking equally bemused. The realization hit Emma like a tidal wave. She had been texting the wrong David all along. Her face flushed with embarrassment as she stammered an explanation to coworker David, who could not help but laugh at the mix-up.

At first, she thought she could slip past, but all hopes were dashed when he waved at her. He smiled wide. She forced herself to swallow her disappointment and join him at the table. He even brought her a flower, which was so sweet. He looked excited to see her. She would feel bad if she just ghosted him.

Then, a few things she found odd suddenly made sense. For example, he knew her favourite chocolate bar was Crunchie. He brought her one during a snack break at work. She did not ask for one. He even commented that he bought her favourite because he knew she was having a bad day. No one in the office knew that. But looking through the text, it suddenly made sense.

Despite the awkward start, the two Davids' paths had inadvertently crossed in a way that brought unexpected laughter and understanding. Emma apologized profusely to both men, and they all shared a light-hearted conversation over coffee.

In the end, Emma and gym David sorted out the confusion and continued to get to know each other. At the same time, coworker David became a good-natured confidant who would never let her forget the memorable mix-up. The experience taught Emma the importance of double-checking her contacts, but it also gifted her with two unique friendships that enriched her life in unexpected ways.

Luckily for Emma, she managed to get a transfer to another team. She continued to talk to her former coworker David, who quickly became her boyfriend. She could not believe the love of her life was someone who quickly dismissed her. Sometimes, she helped but pinched for herself. Her life is now perfect. David is the man of her dreams.

David was the prince among the frogs. She finally has a beautiful love story of her own. She has a funny tale about how they met. She shows her future children and grandchildren that true love exists. It was fate that caused them to cross paths.

She occasionally saw Gym David, but she quickly found out how sleazy he was. When she first saw him, she was desperate for male attention—attention she would take for anyone. Now, she sees him flirting with other women at the gym. She rolls her eyes and thanks her lucky stars that she no longer has an interest in him.

She found she had dodged a bullet. The last thing she needed was to have another frog in her life. I heard a horror story from a girl who went to the gym. Who actually texted back. That he was sleazy and sent her dick pic. So, the universe pushed in the right direction. Emma is forever grateful for that.

Posted May 14, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

9 likes 0 comments

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.