Submitted to: Contest #293

A Man Died on the Train Today

Written in response to: "Set your entire story in a car, train, or plane."

Fiction

A man died on the train today. I have never wanted to see a dead body, or to ease the passing of someone so close to the angels. I know how to do CPR, but I am wary of performing such an intimate and selfless act in the service of another.


He was in the opposite aisle, one seat down and facing me. These are the people you study the most on a train, because to observe someone directly opposite you is so boldly confrontational. I have seen him before because we both favour the same carriage, although it’s ridiculous, because they’re all alike.


I suffer the pulse of anxiety whenever this train pulls up at the station. I want carriage F, but the odds on F wheezing to a stop directly in front of me are, much like roulette, statistically small. So I have to make a run for it and hope that I am at the front of the queue for the door. Myself and the dead man used to exchange self-deprecating nods at our pointless foible, and occasionally passed a ‘good morning’ or two by way of breaking the ice. 


This morning he was with a woman I assumed to be his wife. She was disappointing. Perhaps she was pretty once, but her wrinkled rouge, lacquer and gravid jowls spoke, most pathetically, of a woman gone to seed. When she was settling herself by the window, filling the carriage with sweated cheap perfume, he passed a glance at me before looking away. I understand. I am very attractive whilst the wife is not. She is probably the jealous type, and has every reason to be. Nothing has happened between myself and her husband, but I think we would both be amenable if the opportunity presented.


I don’t look out the window so much any more. The view rarely changes. The same old socks flap on the sagging lines. Small patches of what’s left of the countryside reveal no meteor strikes or abandoned horses in need of rescue. 


I was reading a book. With my head down, my eyes were free to glance at the man and his wife. They appeared to be celebrating something, although he was ill at ease, loosening his tie and patting the sweat from his brow. I believe he worked in advertising. Probably going up to London to collect an award for penning the last word in spreadable butter. 


It was the male trolley-dolly who once told me that all trains go up to London, regardless of the direction of travel. It is an old railway custom in honour of the capital. So we are travelling southwards but going up. Up to the big smoke. 


The male trolley-dolly entered our carriage just past Tamworth. I can’t like him for some reason. His pronounced Adam’s apple makes me queasy and he is always in a good mood, singing in falsetto like a Vatican choir eunuch. I bet he goes home and beats his wife. 


But I will have a drink, thank you very much. I order two of those little bottles of wine that come with a plastic beaker. I like drinking on the train. The dead man liked it too, between taking swigs from his hip flask. I suppose he gets that from watching Mad Men. He ordered a can of Stella and the wife had white wine. Of course she did. 


He did not look well, which is understandable given what was about to happen and how much he appeared to be drinking of late. In fact, he was not quite the eye-catcher he was just a few months ago. Congestive heart failure would be my guess. Very ageing, I think. 


We were half an hour off London when it happened. At first, his face went a cherry red, as though all the blood in his body had rushed upwards, like the train. He made ghastly, panicked noises while his wife flapped and whimpered by his side. I thought I should do the sensible thing and call out for a doctor, but it would appear that even they work from home these days, for none came. 


I was going to pull the cord but the eunuch stopped me because the paramedics would not be able to access the train, so we had to endure his death throes while discoloured socks still flapped on sagging lines, and the buildings got bigger, marching towards their denouement, as the man marched towards his. 


When the paramedics came aboard at the next station, we were made to stay seated while they hauled him onto the gangway and worked away with increasing desperation. It’s disconcerting to have a dead man’s polished shoe banging against your ankles. By this time, his wife had settled into a stupor of shock. She sat, almost dispassionately, drinking the white wine before facing towards the back of the carriage and asking the hesitant eunuch for more. I suspected that before long there would be a loud, keening wail when they eventually had to give up and pronounce him dead. I wasn’t wrong. All her suspended breath came out in a primordial bellow of unrestrained frenzy.


He was body-bagged and manhandled onto a stretcher. The wife followed, unsteady on her feet. It must be curious to wake up married and excited and for it to end like this. 


I watched her move off with her husband’s body. People on the concourse were respectful. One man even doffed his baseball cap, a habit which was once so common but is now touching in its rarity. Her face was now completely white, and the effect of lipstick and rouge against the garish backdrop leant her the look of a ventriloquists’s doll. 


She caught me gazing at her and she stopped, looking puzzled, as if she recognised me. She came up to the window and slammed her palm against the glass, mouthing some obscenity at me. I cannot imagine why. 


And then we had to endure the police, taking down names and addresses. We would all be contacted, they said, although it is hard to know how a commuter can contribute anything illuminating about a middle-aged man having a heart attack on a train. I was even asked if I’d known the man, and when I denied it, they gave me a curious look. No doubt it will come up in the phone conversation they have with me later. 


I haven’t done anything wrong. Yes, I know where he lives and where he works. I know quite a lot about him, but they don’t need to know that. Just some old broad’s word against mine that I’ve been standing outside their house for some months now. I shall just deny it. They don’t have a doorcam, and I wear a precautionary wig. 


I moved carriages when the train finally rolled out. I am tired of F. The dead man has tainted it by association.


There is a man in the opposite aisle, one seat down and facing me. He acknowledges me with a brief smile and gets back to his phone. The smile on my face stays longer. At Euston, he lets me exit first. He smells of something woodsy. The man checks his watch and walks away, late and in a hurry. 


Since I now have nothing better to do, I follow him. 

Posted Mar 07, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

37 likes 38 comments

Jen Mengarelli
19:27 Mar 21, 2025

Love it! Beautiful twist.

Reply

Iris Silverman
16:11 Mar 20, 2025

I felt like I got to know the narrator while reading this story, which is really a nod to your ability to create characters with such depth in a small period of time. OMG, the ending was so surprising, and I loved it.
You sort of hinted to the narrator's curiosity throughout the story with such subtly that the reader just begins to suspect slightly that something is off. Awesome job

Reply

Rebecca Hurst
16:45 Mar 20, 2025

Thank you, Iris! That's really kind, and I really appreciate it.

Reply

Harry Stuart
12:56 Mar 20, 2025

My pick for the week, Rebecca. It's beautifully written with a harshness that resonates...lingers... and the clever twist at the end provides a satisfying conclusion. Although, I do worry for her next "victim." You write with such a clipped energy; the reader can feel the vast emptiness. Always enjoy your work!

Reply

Rebecca Hurst
13:57 Mar 20, 2025

That's really good of you, Harry. Yes, I think she's going to escalate ...

I alway enjoy your work too!

Reply

Dennis C
18:02 Mar 18, 2025

The way you wove the narrator’s detachment with those sharp, cutting observations hits hard. Great work building that creeping unease.

Reply

Rebecca Hurst
18:11 Mar 18, 2025

Thank you, Dennis. I really appreciate the compliment!

Reply

Hannah Lynn
17:29 Mar 17, 2025

Oh boy, that was soo good! I feel slightly nervous for the newbie in the opposite aisle.

Reply

Rebecca Hurst
17:41 Mar 17, 2025

So you should, Hannah. He's in a whole heap of trouble! Thank for reading and commenting!

Reply

Ashley Mitchell
17:00 Mar 17, 2025

The slow reveal on this was brilliant. Well done!

Reply

Sandra Moody
23:51 Mar 16, 2025

Just sooo good. Loved the flapping socks and comparison with "denouement" sentence. Great piece all round.

Reply

Rebecca Hurst
07:39 Mar 17, 2025

Thank you, Sandra, for reading and commenting. It is so much appreciated!

Reply

Jan Keifer
14:12 Mar 16, 2025

Oh My God. Fatal Attraction. LOL I loved it.

Reply

Rebecca Hurst
14:15 Mar 16, 2025

I'm glad you liked it, Jan! Thanks for reading it !

Reply

Kim Olson
13:16 Mar 16, 2025

I enjoyed your story very much. It drew me right in. The twist at the end was great also!

Reply

Rebecca Hurst
13:18 Mar 16, 2025

Thank you, Kim. I always appreciate your comments. I look forward to reading yours!

Reply

Helen A Howard
10:39 Mar 16, 2025

Throughly enjoyable and well depicted. You got the all important ending right too. You wasn’t expecting it. Well done.

Reply

Rebecca Hurst
10:45 Mar 16, 2025

Thanks, Helen! It's funny, (but you'll understand) - that when you write a story, you already have the ending fixed in your head. I am delighted, for that reason, that yourself and others have commented that the ending took them by surprise!

Thanks, as ever, Helen. It's always appreciated.

Reply

Helen A Howard
10:54 Mar 16, 2025

It probably wouldn’t work if there wasn’t some form of ending in a writer’s mind, though that might change as the story progresses.

Reply

Kendal Wilson
00:20 Mar 16, 2025

I thoroughly enjoyed this. It was engaging reading just as a recount of events of a man dying on a train, but the twist made it so much more satisfying. Excellent work!

Reply

Maisie Sutton
05:03 Mar 11, 2025

I really enjoyed this, and thought the twist was so masterfully woven in. It snuck up on me, which makes for a satisfying read.

Reply

Rebecca Hurst
09:08 Mar 11, 2025

Thank you, Maisie. I appreciate that!

Reply

Frankie Shattock
23:41 Mar 10, 2025

I think this is a really good story Rebecca. I loved your descriptions of the characters (especially the man with his probable congestive heart failure, and his wife who looks like a ventriloquist's dummy). I didn't see final few paragraphs coming :-) I enjoyed this a lot.

Reply

Rebecca Hurst
09:02 Mar 11, 2025

Thanks, Frankie! I really appreciate your comment, and I'm glad you enjoyed reading it!

Reply

Keba Ghardt
18:50 Mar 10, 2025

Great use of 'the dead man' as an identifier, and the twist hits like a ton of bricks. The structured environment is first at odds with the seemingly random event, then pales in comparison to how much engineering has gone into those extracurricular activities. Very satisfying ending

Reply

Rebecca Hurst
19:22 Mar 10, 2025

Thank you, Keba, for that very thoughtful critique. I really do appreciate it!

Reply

17:23 Mar 10, 2025

Ohhh...! I love this! Love the dry sense of humour... the line "I thought I should do the sensible thing and call out for a doctor, but it would appear that even they work from home these days, for none came. " particularly stood out to me - but there was so much good stuff in here, A cynical tone that resonates with me and really enjoyed reading this!

Reply

Rebecca Hurst
18:02 Mar 10, 2025

Thank you, Penelope. I really appreciate that, and I'm glad you liked it!

Reply

James Moore
19:17 Mar 09, 2025

Very good work, I'm not sure if it was intended, but it struck me as a bit of a comedy. Great twist, well written. 🙂

Reply

Rebecca Hurst
19:58 Mar 09, 2025

Everything's a bit of a comedy with me, James ! Thanks for liking it and for commenting!

Reply

Sandra Moody
05:43 Mar 09, 2025

Another wonderful read!

Reply

Rebecca Hurst
09:28 Mar 09, 2025

Thank you, Sandra. I really appreciate that! (It's nice to do a short one every now and then)!

Reply

Alexis Araneta
14:09 Mar 08, 2025

Rebecca, incredible story, as usual. The things that happen on trains (That's why I'm going with a train in mine, as well. That and, well, I'm a bit of a railway nerd. Hahaha!) Lovely work !

Reply

Rebecca Hurst
15:14 Mar 08, 2025

I love trains, too - although they're getting too expensive! Yes, it was the only prompt that resonated with me, and then I wondered what could happen. Since it's very unlikely that any character of mine would fall in love (ha!), I was left with no option but a dead body!!

Thanks, as ever!

Reply

Alexis Araneta
21:13 Mar 08, 2025

So I've heard. National Rail is ludicrous sometimes. 😂

Reply

Mary Bendickson
21:35 Mar 07, 2025

Totally innocently.

Reply

Rebecca Hurst
22:48 Mar 07, 2025

Ha! Thanks for reading, Mary.

Reply

Mary Bendickson
23:21 Mar 07, 2025

Thanks for liking 'Patrick...'

Reply

RBE | Illustrated Short Stories | 2024-06

Bring your short stories to life

Fuse character, story, and conflict with tools in Reedsy Studio. All for free.