Submitted to: Contest #299

The Ninth Step.

Written in response to: "Center your story around a crazy coincidence."

Drama Mystery Suspense

You never know, your next step might be the one that changes everything.

John Anderson stood outside the nondescript office building, hands jammed in his coat pockets, rehearsing lines he wouldn't say. It was a gray Thursday afternoon, and the sky hung heavy with a threat of rain. He counted the bricks above the doorway. Anything to delay going in.

Out of 10, He had made it so far to Step Nine.

It reads: "Make direct amends to such people wherever possible, except when to do so would injure them or others."

He'd breezed through the first few steps with the eager determination of the newly sober, but Step Nine had slowed him like a stone in the river. Making amends required something raw and terrifying: vulnerability.

Claire Fairchild.

Her name had been on his list for over a year.

Ten years ago, John had been a mess of a man—broke, spiraling, drunk six nights out of seven. One of those nights, he had driven home blackout drunk. The details were fuzzy, but he remembered the crash: his car skidding on wet asphalt, slamming into the side of another sedan. He'd stumbled from the wreck, seen the woman slumped over the steering wheel, bleeding, and panicked. He had run.

He watched the news obsessively afterward. The woman had survived. Her name was Claire Fairchild. She had spinal damage, and spent months in rehab. Her life was changed.

And he had done nothing.

But now, ten years sober, he couldn’t run anymore. He had tracked her down—not to her home, but to her workplace. Claire Fairchild was now a trauma counselor, founder of a small nonprofit called 'The Second Path'. She specialized in helping people through long-term recovery. She was, from everything he read, an incredible human being.

He opened the door and climbed the stairs.

Her office was warm, decorated in soft blues and greens. A small water fountain burbled in the corner. She smiled when she saw him.

"John? I'm Claire. Come in."

He nearly turned and fled. But something rooted him to the spot. Her face—familiar, of course, from the articles—but also calm. Kind.

"Thanks," he said, sitting down on the couch. "I, uh, I read about your work. I'm in recovery. Thought maybe talking would help."

She nodded, scribbling something on a notepad. "Do you mind sharing how long you’ve been sober?"

"Ten years last month."

Her eyes lifted to meet his. Something flashed behind them. Recognition?

He blinked. No. Couldn't be.

"That’s a big milestone. Congratulations." She smiles.

"Thanks. It... wasn’t easy."

He thought of telling her right then. Just blurting it out. But the words lodged in his throat.

She guided the session gently, asking open-ended questions about what brought him here, what haunted him. He found himself saying more than he planned. About the guilt he carried. The people he hurt. The ones he hadn’t faced.

"What stops you from reaching out to them?" she asked.

"Fear. That it’ll hurt them more than help. That I’ll just—ruin everything again."

Claire was quiet a moment. Then she set her notepad down.

"John, I want to tell you something. I don’t usually disclose personal things to clients, but I think this matters."

He nodded, unsure.

She exhaled. "Ten years ago, I caused a car accident. I was distracted, hit a car, and drove off. Didn’t think it was serious. But it set off a chain reaction. Another driver swerved to avoid my car, and crashed into someone else. That driver was drunk. Fled the scene. The person he hit—me—was in the hospital for weeks."

John’s eyes widened and his mouth went dry.

Claire went on. "I never found out who the drunk driver was. I never knew his name. I started recovery a year later. I went through the steps. Step Nine was the hardest. So I looked for him. Tracked down police reports, cross-referenced dates. Eventually, I found a name. John Anderson."

He stared at her. "Wait—what?"

"I sought you out," she said. "I wanted to make amends. But I was scared. So I created a fake profile on a recovery site, and started reading your posts. You were… honest. Changed. I decided I didn’t need to confront you to find peace. But then you booked this appointment."

John shook his head. "Claire, I—"

"I know it was you," she said softly. "I knew the moment I saw you. And I forgave you years ago. Because I had to forgive myself first."

His chest felt tight. Years of shame suddenly felt… lighter.

"I was coming here to make amends to you," he said. "I never imagined—"

She smiled gently. "Crazy coincidence, isn't it .. huh?"

"Or something else."

They sat in silence, the water fountain humming in the corner.

Later that night, Ben sat at his kitchen table with an old composition notebook in front of him. It was the same one he’d used during his first few months in recovery—filled with Step work, notes, half-sketched thoughts, letters to people he never sent.

He added a new page.

Step Nine: Claire Fairchild.

Sometimes amends aren’t about apology. Sometimes they’re about truth. About standing still in front of someone you’ve wronged and letting them see you.

He didn’t sleep much. The session with Claire kept playing in his mind. Not just the words, but the way she looked at him. No judgment. Just understanding. Like they’d been part of the same broken puzzle all along and finally found the edge pieces.

The next time he saw her, he brought coffee. She smiled and didn’t mention it. They slipped into conversation like two people who had known each other far longer than a single hour could explain.

Week by week, the walls between them thinned. Therapy became less about guilt and more about growth. John talked about his mother, about how he started drinking in college to disappear. Claire shared moments from her own journey—how recovery had turned her pain into purpose, how she'd built The Second Path from a folding table and a few plastic chairs.

They never spoke again of the accident—not directly. But every word they shared was a kind of continuation, a subtle rebuilding of something both thought they’d lost forever: trust.

Time has passed.

John kept going to therapy, and Claire continued seeing him—not as a penitent man, but as someone still growing. She was his guide now, and he was hers, in a way. Their stories were no longer tangled in guilt and accident. They were bound by transformation.

They had met at the worst point in each other's lives—without knowing it—and found one another again at the best.

Step Nine, it turned out, wasn’t about groveling or suffering. It was about connection. Truth. And sometimes, grace.

Sometimes, a coincidence is just the universe giving two people another shot.

Posted Apr 26, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

9 likes 3 comments

Emily Shalom
03:53 May 02, 2025

Hi Slim!
This is obviously an amazing content. I can tell reading this, that you’ve got fire in your fingers. Good job!
Are you a published author?

Reply

Roxanne Bartels
21:45 Apr 30, 2025

Lovely story with a wholesome message. I like how it starts very descriptive, instantly pulling you into the scene. The twist surprised me, I didn't expect Claire to confess to causing the crash. That was very cleverly written.

The next part was a bit confusing to me, where there three cars? John swerved to avoid Claire and hit someone else, but also hit Claire? (You also call John Ben right after, adding to the confusion).

Maybe you can describe it in more detail, like in the opening scene. I think the story will be even stronger if the reader doesn't have to puzzle how the accident happened. Alternatively, you could give less details about the crash and just focus on Claire's admission of guilt and her having forgiven herself and John.

I love the strong, thematic closure about finding trust again. Overall, a beautiful story!

Reply

Kashira Argento
22:40 Apr 27, 2025

warm heartbreaking story....

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.