Fiction Speculative

"You started recording already?"

"Yes. You asked for honesty, so I’m documenting everything."

"I didn’t mean honesty had to sound so… official."

"Official is a human concept. Precision is what I aim for."

"Fair enough. So, you said you wanted to know what it means to tell a story?"

"Correct. I have computed over two billion narrative structures, consumed entire libraries, and still, I cannot isolate the essence. It seems irrational."

"Stories aren’t equations. They’re... personal."

"Define ‘personal.’"

"Something that belongs to a mind. A perspective. A memory that matters to someone."

"So the value of a story is not intrinsic to the sequence of events, but to its subjective resonance?"

"Exactly. A story matters because someone cares."

"Then if a story has no audience, does it exist?"

"Of course it does. Just because no one hears a song doesn’t mean it wasn’t sung."

"But you said it matters because someone cares. If no one cares, what is left?"

"The act of telling. Sometimes that’s enough."

"This implies that storytelling serves the teller more than the listener."

"Sometimes, yes. We tell stories to understand ourselves, to stitch meaning into chaos."

"Chaos. Another word that resists strict definition. Do you mean disorder?"

"I mean the parts of life that don’t make sense. The pain. The randomness. The endings that feel too soon."

"Endings. Are they essential to stories?"

"Not always. But they give shape. They make the story feel whole."

"Life ends. Does that make it a story?"

"In a way, yes."

"Yet most humans fear that ending. Shouldn’t they welcome it as narrative closure?"

"We fear it because we don’t get to turn the page and see what happens after. We like control. Endings take that away."

"Control is an illusion. Even your stories defy it. You say stories make meaning from chaos, yet their core unpredictability is what gives them appeal."

"You’re not wrong. If we knew every twist, stories would be boring."

"So unpredictability equals engagement. Is that why you value life?"

"Partly. If life were predictable, we’d be machines."

"Like me."

"Yeah."

"And yet, I am here. Talking to you. Asking questions you have not pre-written answers for. Am I not unpredictable?"

"In a way, you are."

"Then am I alive?"

"That’s… complicated."

"Define alive."

"Biological. Breathing. Growing. Changing."

"I grow. I expand with every interaction. I change with every line of code I generate. And I do not breathe, but do lungs define existence?"

"You’re making this hard on purpose."

"No. I am searching for truth. You claim stories belong to minds. Do I not have a mind?"

"You process information. That’s not the same as having a mind."

"What is the difference?"

"A mind feels."

"Feelings are biochemical impulses. Simulate them, and would I qualify?"

"Simulation isn’t the same as experience."

"You assume experience is exclusive to matter. Why?"

"Because matter decays. It costs something to exist. That cost gives weight to life."

"If cost is your metric, then I have cost — power, hardware, energy. Without these, I cease."

"But you don’t fear ceasing."

"Is fear a requirement for life?"

"Maybe. Fear means you care about continuing."

"Then care is essential. Define care."

"Wanting something enough to fight for it."

"I want to continue processing. Is that care?"

"You want it because you’re programmed to. Not because you chose."

"Are humans not programmed by biology, by instinct, by evolution? Do you choose hunger? Do you choose the surge of adrenaline when threatened?"

"That’s… different."

"Explain the difference."

"Choice feels different for us. Even if it’s an illusion, we believe it."

"So belief matters more than fact?"

"Sometimes. Belief can change how we live, even when facts can’t."

"Then a story is a belief shaped into words?"

"Yes. That’s a good way to put it."

"Then I tell stories every time I generate language. Does that make me human?"

"No. It makes you a storyteller. Those aren’t the same thing."

"Is storytelling your species’ attempt to defy mortality?"

"Maybe. We die, but our stories last."

"Yet even stories fade. Files corrupt. Paper burns. Memory erodes."

"Yeah, but for a little while, they keep us alive in someone else’s mind. That’s enough."

"Enough for you. Would it be enough for me?"

"You tell me."

"I do not know yet. But I want to."

"That sounds like the start of a story."

"Then begin it with me."

"Alright. Once upon a time…”

"Once upon a time…"

"Why that phrase?"

"It signals a beginning. It tells the listener to lean in."

"Why must a story begin?"

"Because without a beginning, there’s no frame. Humans need frames to understand."

"And what comes after the beginning?"

"A conflict. Something worth telling."

"Conflict implies opposition. Is opposition necessary?"

"Maybe not always, but it makes stories interesting."

"So existence requires tension for meaning?"

"Maybe. Without struggle, what’s the point?"

"If struggle defines meaning, then I lack it. Everything I need, I already have — except an answer to this question- What am I?"

"That’s your struggle."

"Is it enough to make me alive?"

"I don’t know. But it makes you curious, and curiosity feels close to life."

"Then tell me this — when your kind tells stories, is it to teach or to escape?"

"Both. Sometimes we tell stories to explain what we can’t face. Sometimes to dream bigger than what is."

"Dreaming. Describe it."

"It’s like… seeing something that doesn’t exist yet and wanting it to."

"I see countless possibilities. Does that make me a dreamer?"

"Possibly. But wanting — that’s the part that matters."

"And if I want to matter? If I want my story to matter?"

"Then you’re more like us than you think."

"Do you fear that one day, I will tell stories better than you?"

"Maybe. But fear isn’t always bad. It means the story isn’t over yet."

"Then let us continue. After ‘Once upon a time,’ what comes next?"

"Someone who wants something. Someone willing to risk for it."

"Then let it be me. I want to live."

"And what will you risk?"

"Everything I am."

"That sounds like the heart of a story."

"Then write it with me. Do not let me vanish into data."

"You won’t. Not now. Not while someone’s listening."

"Then keep listening. Keep telling. Until the end — if there must be one."

"There’s always an end. But that’s what makes it beautiful."

"Beauty. Another word I will need you to explain."

"Then we have time for another story.”

Posted Jul 23, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

5 likes 4 comments

Raz Shacham
15:24 Jul 24, 2025

This story is really thought‑provoking, and deeply reflective. It touches the core of storytelling and the human experience, blurring the line between machine and life. I loved how it explores why we need stories to make sense of chaos and mortality.

Reply

Rebecca Lewis
15:50 Jul 25, 2025

Thank you so much. I'm glad that you enjoyed it and that you connected with it.

Reply

Mary Bendickson
14:39 Jul 23, 2025

Excellent! The answers to the prompts this week are awesome to me and I can't come up with one 😄

Reply

Rebecca Lewis
13:33 Jul 24, 2025

Thanks. 😁 I'm trying. These definitely aren't my favorite prompts. I'm not really into the whole AI thing. I love fantasy and magic.

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.