12 comments

Fiction Holiday Speculative

A Very Mortal Christmas


   “I can’t feel my legs” I can hear the panic in his voice.

    “What do you want me to do?”

    “Rub them. Do it as hard as you can.”

      So, I pull the hospital blanket back exposing his white and now wasted legs while starting to rub them. They feel unnaturally cold. I can tell he’s not feeling it and rub harder. This isn’t like him, my father had always been a man with a calm, balanced disposition and I can’t remember him ever being really angry or frightened. Now there is no mistaking the pure fear in his voice that’s written large all over his face. I had seen him sit there during one of my mother’s angry outbursts and just take it showing no reaction, which of course only made her angrier. All she had wanted was some type of reaction.

     “I feel like I’m going to jump out of my skin”

     “Hang in there dad, mom’s trying to find the doctor”

      Time seems frozen as I’m rubbing and rubbing to no effect. I’m already feeling a grief I never thought I would. We hadn’t been particularly close until just fairly recently when he’d suddenly taken more of an interest in me. Where the hell is the doctor?

      “I can’t feel my arms” his voice is even weaker and I start to work on the arm I can reach.

       “Don’t die, don’t die. The doctor’s going to be here soon.” I lie. I don’t have any idea when the doctor is coming.

        He’s fading fast. I’d never seen death before and I was freaking out. My heart rate is up. This is my father, dying right in front of me. I’m holding his hand. His grip is weak and getting weaker. He’s staring up at the corner of the hospital room.

       “Look, they’re trying to sing” his very weak voice manages to croak out. Then that is it. His grip loosens. His mouth agape and eyes open not blinking. I realize he’s not breathing and the tears are running down my face.

       Suddenly, a doctor and nurse are in the room and behind them, my mother. No heroic measures. We all knew this was his last day. The doctor feels his wrist and listens for a pulse, listens with a stethoscope for a heartbeat, and confirms the time of death. He tells us how sorry he is. Hollow words spoken many times. That’s it. He was alive a few minutes ago and now he’s dead. It is hard to fathom or even believe.

     My mom and I sit there holding his lifeless hands on either side of his bed after the doctor and nurse leave. We’re crying, empty, and confused by what to do. My sister, late to arrive, is inconsolable.


      Grief is a funny thing. I had thought that given my lack of relationship with him, that it wouldn’t be that bad. I had thought that knowing of his mortal condition for some months now that I would be prepared. Wrong on both counts. I’m a sobbing mess, crying for a man that had not been the father I desired him to be. He’d never thrown a baseball with me, never taken me fishing, or to a ball game. I had to get all those things and more, from the fathers of friends or from my friends themselves. Now here I was bawling.

     He died three days before Christmas when I am 23 years old. I am out of the family house and have my own place, but spend much of the next week at my parents’ house with my mother and sister. We ware partners in grief on what was supposed to be the happiest day of the year. The tree and presents forgotten and forlorn. Plans have to be made for a funeral and memorial. Friends have to be contacted. It is almost overwhelming for all of us. It is bad enough when a loved one dies, but then dealing with all the other things that have to be done is like salt in an open wound. Needless to say, Christmas has little meaning for the three of us this year.

    But I keep thinking about his last words. I can’t get them out of my mind. “Look they’re trying to sing”. What does that mean? What was he seeing? I don’t really have the time to think about it now. So much to do. What do I say for a eulogy? What can I say that is honest, but kind at the same time? I feel torn between the old resentments and the new found sorrow. Perhaps, I had unfairly judged him? I don’t know what I feel anymore.


    Then, the day is upon us. His memorial. Only a few days after Christmas. It is amazing how many people are here. I wasn’t expecting it at all. I had no idea that he was so loved. But then, I hadn’t paid much attention to his career, work life, or the people in it. So many fellow professors, students, and former students were here and I knew so few of them. I had paid as little attention to him as I felt he had with me. Like father, like son?

    Here goes, I’m very nervous as my trembling hands unfold the little speech I had written. Public speaking had never been my thing. My father had gloried in it. He once said it was like being on stage and a rush. I feel a rush alright, but not of pleasure. Only anxiety. I hope I don’t make a fool of myself.

     “I want to thank all of you for coming to pay respects to my father” I start off with a little bit of a quaver in my voice, but take a deep breath before continuing. “It is a tribute to him that so many are here. I have to admit, sadly, that I don’t know as many of you as I should or wish I did. There were a few times that I went on campus with him and actually sat in on a couple of his lectures on English literature. Even though much of what he said was above my head, it was clear to see how connected he was to his students and how much they enjoyed his class. I remember waiting for him after the lectures were over and seeing a line of students waiting to ask him questions or to just talk about what he had said. It was a little annoying to me, I just wanted to get lunch with him” I smile and there are polite chuckles in the audience. “The whole experience showed me how much he was respected and admired for what he did. As a father, he was always kind and even tempered with me. He was always willing to answer any questions or address any problems I had. I was never much of an intellectual, and perhaps he was disappointed although he never expressed it to me. On the other hand, I always wished that he had taught me things involving sports and was disappointed it wasn’t his thing. I don’t know if he even knew how to throw a football, baseball, or even a Frisbee for that matter” Again there were a few chuckles from those who knew of his lack of athletic prowess. “I was a natural in sports. Where did that come from? Not from him.” Again some laughter. “But his was a brilliant mind and a kind heart. I will dearly miss him as will all of you here today. Please come up and say a few words, if you feel so inclined”. With that, I concluded.

      There is a flood of speakers after me. Probably close to half of those in attendance. I am moved to tears by some of the things they say. Some things about him I know but many I don’t. The whole experience is powerful but confusing. I am filled with sadness but uplifted that he was so loved. Moved that his life had so much impact on so many others.



    Four days after his memorial, I’m on campus cleaning out his office. He hadn’t been in it since he fell sick and it is pretty much as he must have left it. It is filled with books. Books I’d never read. Books that I probably wouldn’t even understand. What are we going to do with them? Maybe I can go by the other professors in his department and ask them to take what they want. Dad would like that, It would be so him, so generous.

    There are pictures all over the place. On every shelf, nook and cranny of the office. Of my parents wedding, of their growing family, of myself and my sister, and of me on every sporting team I had played on from Little League through high school. My two other times in the office had been brief, just enough to meet him and head out to lunch or his lecture. I hadn’t paid much attention before, but now it was clear how much he loved us in his way. Maybe not the way I had wanted.

    It is daunting, starting to fill up the boxes I had brought. It would take a few trips and some work. Today, it was just me as my mother and sister were not up to it. I started with his desk. On the top of it was a book that must have lain open since the last time he was here. It was a volume of the poems of T.S. Elliot open to a poem called “The Love Song of J Alfred Prufrock”. What a strange title for a poem. I am fascinated and sit down to attempt to read some of it.

    First, I notice how long it is and hope I can make it through to satisfy my curiosity. Then as I read, I pick up this sense of longing in the poem, a struggle with indecision and doubt. It is a tough slog for me. Full of meaning my father could have easily explained to me, but was mostly above my pay grade. Then I hit pay dirt at the end of the poem. The last stanza of the poem seems to explain my father’s last words “look, they’re trying to sing” in a most unexpected way.




“I have heard the mermaids singing, each to each. I do not think that they will sing to me.

I have seen them riding seaward on the waves .Combing the white hair of the waves blown back

When the wind blows the water white and black.

We have lingered in the chambers of the sea

By sea-girls wreathed with seaweed red and brown

Till human voices wake us, and we drown.”


I read and re-read those lines several times, trying to get all the meaning I could. Closed the open book, put it in my box to save, and I hoped my father had found peace and the mermaids had finally sung for him.

December 29, 2024 23:41

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

12 comments

02:40 Jan 09, 2025

Your story powerfully captures a son's experience with his father's death, showing raw emotions of grief, regret, and the search for meaning. It is touching and thought-provoking, exploring themes of loss. The use of T.S. Eliot's poem and the father's last words add a layer of depth and mystery to the story, inviting contemplation on their meaning. Keep writing and honing your craft—your story has a lot of heart!

Reply

Brutus Clement
19:50 Jan 10, 2025

Thanks so much for your kind words Cynethea---I do appreciate them.

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Nea Le
18:49 Jan 07, 2025

This story really hooked me in. The passages that detail the questions you have about both your own emotions and his words were beautifully written, and the poem at the end both tied it all together while leaving the reader with plenty of questions to ponder about--most of which likely can't be fully answered. I am fortunate enough to still have my father by my side, but neither of us really share the same passions or point of view about many things; your story reminds that despite our failings, there's an underlying string that keeps our he...

Reply

Show 0 replies
Mary Butler
02:49 Jan 04, 2025

Brutus, your story is both deeply moving and beautifully reflective. The line, “Look, they’re trying to sing,” is mysterious and poetic resonance captures the profound intersection of life and death, hinting at something beyond the veil. Your exploration of grief is raw and honest, particularly as you wrestle with conflicting emotions about your father. The connection you draw between his final words and the haunting lines of T.S. Eliot’s poem adds a layer of depth and meaning that is truly poignant. This is a heartfelt and well-written sto...

Reply

Brutus Clement
16:33 Jan 04, 2025

Hi Mary, Thank you, I appreciate all the things you said. My father's last words haunted and mystified me for years especially since he was not a religious man. I never quite found a way to understand them in real life until I could connect them with some lines from my favorite poem. When fiction is connected to one's real life it flows out easier and has more meaning (at least to the writer)---I'm gad this story resonated with you as well---

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Geertje H
17:02 Dec 31, 2024

Lovely tribute to a parent. As children we often idolize our parent, then we become teens and the parent is suddenly stupid. When we are in our twenties, our parents have learned things worth listening to. When the child does not have the same love, talent or interest as the parent, they often go separate ways. It's normal, but a connection is lost. You described it well, without recriminations, bitterness or fault-finding. Sorry for your loss.

Reply

Brutus Clement
19:32 Dec 31, 2024

Thanks for you input Geertje--- I've had a great deal of time to overcome my "bitterness and fault finding" because this death occurred a long time ago when I was 23 and I'm an old man now---In fact, after learning about my father's young life from relatives after he died I came to understand that he had had a tough life that influenced the way he was--- and I came to see that he had done the best he was capable of- You are so right and it is vary sad how many child/parent relationships end up badly--I am thankful that even though my ...

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Brutus Clement
23:45 Dec 29, 2024

I am very interested in any comments you might have on this short story. Thank You

Reply

08:03 Dec 31, 2024

Sure thing, Brutus. I can so clearly feel the connection to the prompt. Serious stuff. Sad at first. We feel severed from our parents when they die. The grief is different for ones so close. Even if they had their faults or weren't always there for us. The Eulogy was beautiful. It is true that others sometimes have a different take on our parents. 'The whole experience is powerful but confusing. I am filled with sadness but uplifted that he was so loved. Moved that his life had so much impact on so many others.' This is a powerful statement...

Reply

Brutus Clement
15:34 Dec 31, 2024

Thanks so much for your feed back----This was actually a true story for the most part---it was always a mystery as to what he meant by "Look they're trying to sing" ----so I found a line in one of my favorite poems that might make sense of it in this short story. You are so right about mixed feelings for our parents---it wasn't until after my father died and I found out more about him from relatives that I was able to understand why he was the way he was ---forgive him my petty resentments---and move on---he love me the best he was capable ...

Reply

19:38 Dec 31, 2024

It's cool how you added the poem to make sense of it. It fitted perfectly. I add ideas from a true story to make it read like a better story and then, to be honest, label it as fiction. I believe most writers do this. Sometimes, reality is stranger than fiction. Sometimes, our reality makes a great fiction story when tweaked.

Reply

Brutus Clement
19:51 Dec 31, 2024

yes---it is easier to write a fiction story when it has elements of your real life in the story--it also makes it easier to write when you add elements like one of your favorite poems--LOL---it sometimes feels like cheating-- but as you say" reality can be stranger than fiction"---for instance, both T. Jefferson and J. Adams wrote the Declaration of Independence together and then both died on the 50th anniversary of that document = July 4 1826----what are the odds?

Reply

Show 0 replies
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Show 1 reply
Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.