Mystery

The night was alive with the whispers of wind slithering through the cracks of the old Victorian house. Though it had long been abandoned, the town of Black Hollow never dared demolish it. Superstition kept the wreckage standing, its bones creaking in the moonlight. Among the scattered relics of a forgotten past, one object remained untouched by time: a grand piano, its polished surface dulled but not broken, its keys yellowed but intact. It was known as the Dead Piano.

Legends swirled like mist around it. Some said it was cursed, others claimed it was haunted by the restless soul of its last owner. No one had played it in decades, and no one wished to. It had earned its name because, according to folklore, it had played one final song the night its owner, the once-renowned pianist Victor Halem, had died. A song no one had composed, a song that had echoed through the town like a requiem.

A young woman named Eleanor Finch didn’t believe in ghosts. She was a historian, a scholar who sought truth, not phantoms. When she first heard about the Halem house, she saw it as an opportunity. A chance to uncover the reality behind the myths and to write the definitive account of the Dead Piano.

She arrived in Black Hollow just before dusk, renting a room at the only inn in town. The locals avoided her gaze when she asked for directions. They whispered among themselves, their voices hushed and wary, as if speaking too loudly might awaken something unseen. A few cast her looks of pity, others of fear.

The innkeeper, an older woman with cloudy eyes, only whispered, “Stay away from that house, dear. Let the dead rest.”

Eleanor hesitated, noting the genuine concern in the woman’s voice, but she had come too far to turn back. “It’s just a house,” she replied gently, but the woman shook her head.

“No, child,” she murmured. “It’s not.”

Eleanor thanked her and left anyway.

The house stood on the outskirts, hidden beneath the embrace of twisted trees. Its structure was failing, its walls peeling like sunburnt skin, but the piano inside was pristine. A contradiction. A mystery waiting to be unraveled.

Its windows, gaping and cracked, reflected the dying light like watchful eyes. The porch sagged, its once-grand columns now leaning as if the house itself were exhausted by the weight of time. Vines choked the façade, creeping through the splintered wood and curling around the broken shutters like skeletal fingers. A rusted iron gate, bent and forgotten, groaned against the wind.

Beyond the threshold, the air hung heavy with the scent of damp wood and mold. The grand staircase, though still standing, had lost its dignity, its steps warped and bowed. Paint flaked from the walls, revealing ghostly imprints of wallpaper patterns long faded. Fragments of shattered chandeliers lay among the dust, their crystals dull and lifeless. The remnants of forgotten furniture huddled in the corners, draped in sheets that billowed like shrouds in the cold draft.

And yet, at the heart of it all, untouched by ruin, sat the piano.

She stepped inside cautiously, her lantern’s light throwing long shadows. Dust floated in the air, disturbed by her presence. The air was thick with a scent of decay and something else—something bitter and old.

And then she saw it.

The Dead Piano.

It sat at the heart of the grand hall, untouched by the rot that had consumed the rest of the house. Its lacquered surface gleamed faintly in the dim light, betraying no signs of age or decay. The elaborate carvings along its edges, delicate ivy leaves and curling vines, remained sharp and intact, as if the hands that had shaped them had only just finished their work. Her fingers itched to touch the keys, but a chill ran up her spine. The silence around it was oppressive, thick and expectant, as though the house itself was holding its breath. The stories clawed at the edges of her rational mind, whispering warnings she refused to heed.

Still, she was not afraid.

She set down her bag and lit more lanterns, illuminating the room. She opened her notebook, ready to record her observations. The wood was still rich, the carvings of ivy along its edges detailed and untouched. She ran a hand along the lid, and the temperature beneath her palm felt...wrong. Too cold. Too smooth.

But it was just a piano. An instrument. Nothing more.

She lifted the lid and revealed the keys. Ivory and ebony, waiting, silent. With bated breath, she pressed one down.

A single note rang out, pure and crisp. It should have comforted her, should have proven that it was nothing more than an object of wood and wire.

But then, another note played.

And she hadn’t touched a key.

Eleanor’s heart slammed against her ribs. Her breath turned shallow. The sound that followed was not music, but something close—a hesitant, fractured melody. She stepped back, her lantern flickering. The piano played on, its notes forming a tune that she had never heard but somehow recognized, a song that whispered of loss and longing, of pain and regret.

She wanted to move, to run, but she couldn’t. Her hands trembled as she reached for her notebook again, trying to steady herself with logic.

“This is a trick,” she whispered to herself. “Some old mechanism, some fault in the strings.”

But deep down, she knew better.

The melody shifted, growing darker, more urgent. Shadows stretched across the room, curling like fingers reaching for her. Eleanor staggered back. The air thickened, the temperature plummeting. And then, the music stopped.

A silence more suffocating than the sound that had preceded it.

And then, a whisper.

“Play it.”

Eleanor whirled around, her lantern swinging wildly, but there was no one there. Just dust and decay, the piano and its lingering echoes.

The voice had been soft, familiar, yet not quite human.

She should have left. Every instinct screamed at her to run, to abandon her research and flee back to the warmth of the inn.

But she didn’t.

Instead, she sat before the Dead Piano and placed her fingers on the keys. They were cold, too cold. But she played.

The first notes were shaky, hesitant, but the piano responded eagerly, filling in the gaps where her memory failed. The song came to life beneath her hands, a melody both foreign and intimate. It guided her, led her, consumed her.

And then, she saw him.

Victor Halem.

He stood in the corner, his figure transparent, his eyes hollow. He watched her with something like relief, something like sorrow. She couldn’t move, couldn’t breathe. The music bound them, wove them together in that decaying house.

She understood then.

The piano wasn’t cursed. It wasn’t haunted. It was mourning.

Victor Halem had died unfinished. His final composition had never been completed, his masterpiece left abandoned, a ghost in itself. And the piano had waited. Waited for someone to finish what he could not.

Tears streamed down Eleanor’s face as she played. The notes came easier now, the hesitation gone. The melody soared, a lament and a triumph. And with the final chord, the house sighed.

The air grew warm. The shadows receded. And Victor Halem smiled before fading into the dust.

The Dead Piano had been silent for so long. But now, it was at peace.

And so was she.

Posted Mar 15, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

1 like 2 comments

Victoria West
20:52 Mar 15, 2025

This is a great story. It was a nice twist at the end to have the piano not be haunted and malevolent, and instead having owner wanting to finish his piece.

Reply

Vera N
13:44 Mar 17, 2025

That's a great answer. Not everything that's sinister stays that way. Reminds me of the saying about face value.

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.