🏆 Contest #294 Winner!

Fiction

"I've said too much," Jack muttered, watching the maître d's smile fade like a dimmer switch. The restaurant fell silent, conversations halting as heads swiveled in his direction. Jack tugged at his waiter's collar. "Occupational hazard of being British. We're supposed to communicate exclusively through weather observations and apologizing."

The woman at table seven stared, her Botoxed forehead struggling to register offense.

"Mr. Harmon, a word." Marcel, the maître d', beckoned him toward the kitchen with a manicured finger.

Jack followed, shoulders hunched. He'd only commented that the woman reminded him of Diana Rigg from "The Avengers," unaware that "you look like you could kill a man with your thighs" wasn't universally considered flattering.

The kitchen doors swung shut with a pneumatic hiss that sounded like the collective sigh of relief from the dining room. The sound triggered an instant, visceral response—a tightening in Jack's chest. Thirty-two years of doors closing behind him, each reducing his world a little more.

"Jack, what did we discuss about customer interactions?" Marcel's French-accented voice dripped with the particular condescension reserved for speaking to children and convicted felons. "Brief, professional, invisible."

"I was aiming for charming." Jack scratched the back of his neck. "Landed somewhere closer to 'potential lawsuit,' did I?"

"Given your situation, we've been quite accommodating, wouldn't you say?" Marcel's eyes flicked to the small scar above Jack's eyebrow—the only visible reminder of the violence that had sent him away.

There it was again. Your situation. The delicate phrasing that reminded Jack of his status without explicitly mentioning it. Ex-con. Institutionalized. Damaged goods.

"Right," Jack said, the old prison reflex kicking in. Compliance was survival. "I'll retreat to my natural habitat among the dirty dishes."

"Excellent. And Jack? Your daughter called." Marcel's tone softened slightly. "Something about needing you this evening."

Jack's stomach dropped. Emma never called him at work unless something was wrong.

Three hours later, Jack stood outside the Royal London Hospital, gathering courage. He hadn't seen Emma in nearly a month—not since their explosive argument when she'd accused him of being more comfortable in prison than in her life. The worst part had been his inability to deny it.

Emma lay pale against hospital-white sheets, her pregnant belly a mountain beneath the blanket.

"Dad." Her voice caught, surprise and something softer in her tone.

"They told me you were here." Jack hovered awkwardly. "Is everything...?"

"The baby's pressing on the cord. His heart rate drops with contractions." Emma fiddled with her IV line. "They're talking C-section if it doesn't improve. Which means..."

"Ruby," Jack finished, naming his granddaughter. "Who's looking after her?"

"Lisa can't get her until six. I need you to pick her up from school."

Jack felt panic rising. He'd only met Ruby twice since his release. The silent, solemn-eyed child had regarded him with the wariness of a small animal encountering a predator.

"Em, I don't know if—" Jack ran his hand through his salt-and-pepper hair. "The last time I looked after a child, Teletubbies were considered cutting-edge entertainment."

"Dad, please." Emma's voice cracked. "There's nobody else."

The unspoken truth hung between them—after her mother's death and his incarceration, Emma had grown up with little family. Now, with her partner gone too—vanished back to Spain when Ruby was still a baby—their fractured family tree had few branches to lean on.

"Of course I'll get her." His daughter needed him. "How hard can it be? Children are just small humans who haven't yet learned to hide their contempt for me."

Emma's relief was palpable. "Her school knows you're coming. She takes medication with dinner for anxiety." She squeezed his hand. "And Dad? Don't let her watch the news. Not after last time."

Jack nodded, not asking what "last time" meant. Another gap in his knowledge, another reminder of all he'd missed.

St. Catherine's Primary looked nothing like Jack's childhood schools—all bright colors and posters proclaiming "Every Child Is A Star!" How differently might his life have turned out, he wondered, if he'd been told that instead of learning that mistakes earned beatings?

"Mr. Harmon?" A young teacher approached, leading a small figure. "This is Ruby. Ruby, your grandfather is here."

Ruby, aged ten but small for her years, regarded Jack with dark, serious eyes. She wore a navy uniform with a cardigan that was slightly too big. Around her neck hung a tablet device Jack would later learn was a communication aid she never used.

"Hello, Ruby." Jack crouched awkwardly, knees protesting. "Your mum's going to be in hospital for a bit, so you're stuck with me until Lisa comes. I promise I've improved since my last babysitting stint in 1986."

Ruby didn't respond but didn't pull away when Jack carefully took her small hand.

On the bus home, Ruby produced a notebook, writing in precise handwriting: Is Mum really okay?

"She's being well looked after," Jack said. "The doctors are keeping a close eye on her and the baby."

Ruby considered this, then wrote: They said that about Grandma too. Then she died.

The simple statement hit Jack like a physical blow. He hadn't known Emma's mother had died in hospital—another gap in the vast terrain of his daughter's life.

"This is different," Jack said. "Your mum is young and healthy."

Ruby's dark eyes studied him, then she wrote: Did you have to go to hospital when you were in prison?

Jack felt the blood drain from his face. "Who told you that?"

I heard Mum and Lisa talking. Lisa said we shouldn't leave valuables out. Mum said you're not a thief, you're a murderer.

"Yes," he admitted after a pause. "I did something wrong when I was young. Very young and very stupid, which often go together."

Did you kill someone?

The directness of the question, delivered in a child's neat handwriting, hit him like a punch to the gut.

"Yes," he said finally. "It was an accident, but that doesn't make it right. A man died because I was angry and showing off. I've paid for it—thirty-two years' worth—and I'm trying to be better now."

Ruby absorbed this with unsettling calmness, then wrote: I'm hungry. Mum makes pasta with butter and cheese. Not the green pasta.

By the time Ruby was fed and medicated, Jack had discovered something unexpected: this silent child fascinated him. Every careful gesture revealed a mind working overtime to navigate a world that refused to meet her halfway.

"She's had a rough time," Lisa whispered when she arrived to collect Ruby. "After what happened at her last school..."

"What happened?"

"Some older children took her communication device. Recorded horrible things with it. Put it online." Lisa crossed her arms. "That's when she stopped using it completely."

Jack's hands curled into fists, the old rage surging up like bile. He carefully packed it away—a skill learned through decades of institutional control.

As Lisa prepared to leave, Ruby approached Jack, notebook extended: You're not what I expected.

Before he could respond, she offered her hand for a high-five—a gesture so unexpectedly normal it took his breath away.

That night, Jack's phone buzzed with a text from Emma: "She liked you. Said you weren't as scary as she thought. High praise from Ruby."

He smiled in the darkness. Not scary. It wasn't much, but it was a beginning.

The kitchen doors of Le Petit Jardin swung open as Jack plunged his hands into soapy water.

"Jack." Marcel appeared. "Telephone. Your daughter."

"Emma? What's wrong?"

"Lisa's got food poisoning. She can't take Ruby. Can you pick her up from school?"

Jack glanced at the mountain of dishes. "I'm working until four."

"Please, Dad. I'm trapped here, and Ruby—"

"I'll sort something out."

Marcel raised an eyebrow as Jack hung up. "Problem?"

"My granddaughter needs looking after."

To Jack's surprise, Marcel nodded. "Take the afternoon. Children are more important than dishes, no?"

At Victoria Park, Ruby methodically fed the ducks, movements precise and thoughtful.

"You'll be a big sister soon," Jack said. "That'll be exciting, yeah?"

Ruby wrote quickly: Will you go away again?

The question pierced him. "No. No, I won't."

Promise? The word was underlined twice.

"I promise, Ruby. I'm staying right here."

She studied him with eyes far older than her years, then nodded once—accepting his vow with surprising gravity.

An elderly woman on a bench smiled at Jack. "Your granddaughter?"

"Yes," Jack said, the word still strange in his mouth.

"The quiet ones are often deep thinkers. Storing it all up for later."

Jack watched Ruby navigate the climbing frame with unexpected grace. "Maybe you're right."

Over ice cream, Jack found himself filling the silence with carefully edited stories about Emma as a child.

Ruby wrote: You talk a lot.

"Too much?"

No. I like it. Most people stop talking when I don't answer.

For the first time since his release, Jack wasn't thinking about prison or all he'd lost. He was simply present, pointing out squirrels and cloud shapes to a child who noticed everything and said nothing.

Emma looked paler each day, dark circles beneath her eyes. "How was she?"

"Good. We fed ducks. Had ice cream." Jack perched awkwardly in the visitor's chair. "She's remarkable, Em."

Emma's eyes filled. "I know. I'm trying my best, but it's hard. With everything she's been through, and now this—" she gestured to the monitors. "I feel like I'm failing her."

"You're not," Jack said with unexpected firmness. "She's loved and looked after. That's more than many kids get."

"The doctors say I could be here for weeks. Lisa can't manage Ruby that long with her work schedule."

"I'll help. Whatever you need."

Emma's relief was visible. "Thank you. And Dad? Lisa said Ruby seemed different tonight. More... present. Whatever you did today, it was good for her."

Jack felt a strange warmth spread through his chest—pride, he realized. An unfamiliar sensation.

Two weeks passed in a blur of new routines. Jack worked mornings, collected Ruby after school, and became unexpectedly adept at helping with homework.

Ruby's trust emerged in subtle increments—a sleeve tug instead of writing, sitting closer during nature documentaries, once even falling asleep against his shoulder in the car.

Jack changed too. He stood straighter. Made awkward but genuine small talk with other parents. Started to feel the prison posture melting from his shoulders.

"Jack," Marcel called him aside one Tuesday. "You seem more... settled lately. Starting next week, you'll train as a server again."

Jack nodded, swallowing his irritation at having his humanity reduced to a rehabilitation checklist.

That afternoon, Jack's phone rang—Emma's number.

"Dad?" Her voice was high with panic. "Emergency C-section. Baby's heart rate dropping—"

"I'm on my way."

"No! Stay with Ruby. Lisa's coming here. Ruby can't be alone when she finds out—"

Jack turned to find Ruby watching him, fear already written across her face.

"That was your mum," he said gently. "The doctors need to help get the baby out early."

Ruby's hand trembled as she wrote: Is Mum going to die?

"No, sweetheart. She's in the best place."

My other grandma died in hospital.

Ruby's face crumpled, tears welling. Jack felt utterly helpless—what did he know about comforting a child?

But somehow his arms opened, and Ruby walked into them. He held her as she cried silently against his chest.

"It's okay to be scared," he murmured. "I'm scared too. But we'll be brave together."

When the call finally came two hours later, Jack answered with Ruby pressed against his side.

"It's a boy," Lisa said. "Seven pounds even. Emma's going to be fine."

Ruby sagged with relief, then wrote: What's his name?

"Thomas," Lisa told him. "Thomas Jack Harmon."

Jack's throat tightened. "She used my name?"

"Middle name. I think it's an olive branch."

That night, as Jack prepared to leave, Ruby suddenly activated her communication device. The flat, electronic voice stated simply:

"Thank you for staying."

The next morning at the hospital, Ruby extended a tentative finger toward her new brother, which Thomas promptly grasped. Her face transformed with wonder.

Carefully, Jack cradled his grandson, marveling at how little a new life weighed. Thomas blinked up with unfocused eyes, and Jack felt something crack open inside his chest—a warmth he'd walled off decades ago.

Ruby tugged his sleeve, her notebook held up: He has your eyes.

Jack looked at the baby, then at Ruby, then at Emma. The family resemblance flowed through them all—the same dark eyes, the same stubborn set to the jaw.

"Maybe we could do this more often," Jack suggested later in the hospital canteen. "Even after your mum comes home."

Ruby wrote: I'd like that.

They were gathering their things when Jack bumped into a woman, causing her to spill her coffee.

"I'm so sorry," he exclaimed, grabbing napkins.

The woman looked up, irritated, then her expression changed. "Jack? Jack Harmon?"

Jack froze. Sarah Mitchell, a court clerk from his trial. She'd shown him small kindnesses during that terrible time.

"Sarah," he managed. "It's been—"

"Thirty-two years," she finished, eyes flickering to Ruby.

"My granddaughter," Jack explained quickly.

Ruby reached for her notebook and showed it to Sarah: My grandad is a good person now.

As they walked away, Jack felt heat rising in his face. "You didn't need to say that."

Ruby wrote firmly: It's true.

Jack wasn't sure it was, not entirely. But perhaps it could be, someday.

As they stepped outside, Ruby slipped her hand into his—a silent vote of confidence.

"I've said too much," Jack murmured, thinking of all the missteps he'd made, all the times his words had entangled him in complications. But looking down at Ruby's upturned face, he realized that perhaps, for once, he'd said just enough.

Posted Mar 21, 2025
Share:

You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.

20 likes 135 comments

John Rutherford
14:46 Mar 28, 2025

Congratulations

Reply

Alex Marmalade
17:00 Mar 29, 2025

Hi John,

Thank you for the congratulations! 😊

It means a lot to receive these kind words of support. Writing "Unspoken Orders" was a journey in itself - exploring how Jack and Ruby could find connection despite their different communication challenges.

There's something special about sharing stories and having them resonate with readers. It transforms the solitary act of writing into something shared and meaningful. ✨

I appreciate you taking a moment to reach out!

Reply

21:43 Mar 28, 2025

Well done!! I absolutely loved the fact that one character said too much, when the other couldn't say anything at all!!
Congratulations!!
I loved the character of Jack... and how his relationship with Ruby gently and slowly progressed...
I did wonder though, if Emma's partner left her when Ruby was a baby, then where did Thomas come from??

Reply

Alex Marmalade
16:28 Mar 29, 2025

Hi Amanda,

Thank you for that thoughtful reading! 😊 I love that you picked up on that contrast between Jack and Ruby - one struggling with saying too much, the other unable to speak at all. Those opposing communication styles created such an interesting dynamic to explore.

You've spotted something interesting about the timeline! Emma's previous partner (Ruby's father) left when Ruby was small. Thomas has a different father - Emma's more recent partner who isn't explicitly mentioned in the story. I wanted to focus tightly on the Jack/Ruby relationship, so some family details remained in the background.

I'm really drawn to writing about these complicated, messy family structures that reflect real life - where relationships evolve, people come and go, but new connections form in unexpected ways. ✨

Thank you for engaging so thoughtfully with the story and these characters. It's questions like yours that make me see my own work through fresh eyes! 💫

Reply

16:43 Mar 29, 2025

No problem!! Glad it was helpful

Reply

K Spiers
20:28 Mar 29, 2025

I love a good redemption story, thank you for providing that.

This line made me laugh out loud-
unaware that "you look like you could kill a man with your thighs" wasn't universally considered flattering.
Thanks for that too.

Reply

Alex Marmalade
17:19 Mar 30, 2025

Hi K,

Thank you for that wonderful feedback! 😊 It means so much to hear which specific lines connected with you.

That particular line about Diana Rigg was one of those moments where Jack just took over the page. I could see him so clearly - genuinely believing he was paying a compliment while everyone else in the restaurant froze in horror. Those moments of social disconnect were both heartbreaking and humorous to write.

I've always been drawn to redemption stories too. There's something profoundly hopeful about watching someone find their way back from the margins, especially when that journey comes through unexpected connections. Jack needed Ruby as much as she needed him, though neither of them realized it at first. ✨

Thank you for taking the time to share your reaction - knowing which moments resonated with you is incredibly valuable!

Reply

18:21 Mar 28, 2025

What a lovely story- I really enjoyed it. Very uplifting and full of details that shed light on the difficulties of Jack's life, without giving us too much of the visceral aspects. Loved the opening- both funny and revealing. Congrats!

Reply

Alex Marmalade
16:40 Mar 29, 2025

Hi Anne,

Thank you for such a thoughtful response! 😊 I'm particularly touched that you noticed the balance I was trying to strike with Jack's backstory.

Finding that line between acknowledging the weight of his past without letting it overwhelm the present moment was one of the most challenging aspects of writing this piece. How do you honor the depth of someone's pain while still leaving room for their redemption?

I'm glad the humor in the opening worked for you! Those moments of awkward social fumbling felt so true to Jack's character - someone trying to navigate a world that moved on without him, where even the simplest interactions feel like navigating a minefield. 💫

There's something fascinating about characters who are out of step with the world around them, isn't there? The way they notice things others miss because nothing feels automatic or expected.

Thank you for taking the time to share such specific observations about the story. It means the world to know these details resonated with you. ✨

Reply

Alexis Araneta
17:21 Mar 28, 2025

'Occupational hazard of being British. We're supposed to communicate exclusively through weather observations and apologising.' - I almost spat out my water there. Hahahaha!

I loved how incredibly detailed this story is. Well-deserved win!

Reply

Alex Marmalade
16:43 Mar 29, 2025

Hi Alexis,

Oh, you caught me in one of those moments where Jack just took over and said what he wanted! 😂 Nothing quite like writing a line and then laughing at your own character's observation.

There's something about that particularly British form of social awkwardness that felt so right for Jack - a man already struggling to navigate social cues after decades of institutionalization, now also battling with cultural expectations about proper small talk!

I find those small cultural details often reveal the most about characters - the specific ways we fumble through our interactions, the particular shields we use to protect ourselves. For Jack, humor became both his defense mechanism and his way of reaching out.

Thank you for sharing that moment of connection! There's something magical about knowing exactly which line made someone laugh. ✨

Reply

Ashlee Osborn
02:09 May 18, 2025

Very discriptive:)

Reply

Efa Wiliam
08:45 May 16, 2025

Loved this. Totally hooked from the start.

Reply

Alex Marmalade
11:02 May 24, 2025

Thank you, Efa—that means a lot. ⚡

Hooking someone from the start feels like catching lightning in a bottle, so I’m really glad it landed with you. I loved writing this one—and shared a bit more of the behind-the-scenes process over on Substack too, for anyone curious. ✍️🐚

Appreciate you reading and taking the time to say so. 🙏

Reply

Olivia Kingree
09:41 May 02, 2025

Really good, made me wait to find out what happens

Reply

Alex Marmalade
20:06 May 02, 2025

Hi Olivia,

Thank you for taking the time to read and comment! 😊 I'm glad the story held your interest - creating that sense of wanting to know what happens next is something I really strive for.

Jack and Ruby's journey had its own rhythm that seemed to unfold naturally as I wrote. Sometimes the characters just take over and show you where the story needs to go.

I've recently started a Substack where I explore what happens beyond the 3,000-word boundaries of these stories. If you're curious about Jack and Ruby's continuing journey, you might find it there. ✨

I appreciate your kind words and support!

Reply

Alex Marmalade
23:10 May 05, 2025

Thanks for sitting with it, Olivia. That kind of attention means a lot.
Wrote a little thing on the Substack the other day about *waiting*—how it’s a quiet kind of trust between writer and reader.
Appreciate you lending me that trust 🙏✨

Reply

Ken Cartisano
01:14 May 02, 2025

Excellent.

Reply

Zahraa Assaad
23:08 Apr 26, 2025

This is really well written. I'm amazed how you can write all that in such a small amount of words. Congrats on winning.

Reply

Elena Balaguer
10:58 Apr 25, 2025

Such a heartfelt and warm story, utterly enjoyable. Descriptions and conversations were so vivid, it was like the scenes were unfolding before me. Bravo!

Reply

Sierra Roberts
17:44 Apr 18, 2025

This story was amazing

Reply

13:10 Apr 17, 2025

Nice story deserves the winning prize, can you like my post in profile.

Reply

Brenda Adams
22:34 Apr 13, 2025

Great read! You did a fantastic job, I really like the natural habitat part alot too.

Reply

Julia Solstice
02:35 Apr 13, 2025

This was so fun and I was so emotionally attached to the characters!! I would honestly read a full length book ab this story, it was really great and I wish there was more time for you to develop the characters :)

Reply

Alex Marmalade
21:47 Apr 13, 2025

Hi Julia,

Oh, what a wonderful thing to say! 😊 The idea that you'd want to spend more time with Jack and Ruby truly makes my day.

I didn't expect Jack and Ruby to become so real when I started writing them. By the end, saying goodbye felt like parting with old friends - you know the feeling? There's that hope you'll see each other again somehow.

You've actually touched on something I've been turning over in my mind. I think it was Neil Gaiman who said a short story is often like the last chapter of a novel you don't have to write. In my case, it's often the first chapter of a story I hope to continue exploring.

I just launched a Substack newsletter yesterday where I share behind-the-scenes glimpses of characters and stories from the week, along with responses to reader questions. I hope it becomes a space where these story worlds can continue growing, especially for characters like Jack and Ruby who feel like they have more to say.

Thank you for such encouraging feedback! It's readers like you who make me want to keep following these characters wherever they lead. ✨

Reply

Aaliyah Grace
16:34 Apr 12, 2025

Wow! Great job, you deserved it!

Reply

Alex Marmalade
21:48 Apr 13, 2025

Hi Aaliyah,

Thank you so much for those kind words! 😊 Your enthusiasm means a lot to me.

It's always a wonderful surprise when a story connects with readers. Jack and Ruby's journey felt special to write - watching their relationship develop through all those small, significant moments.

I appreciate you taking the time to read and share your thoughts! ✨

Reply

Aaliyah Grace
21:43 Apr 26, 2025

Yw, 😊🫶

Reply

Bruce Pearson
07:04 Apr 12, 2025

Loved it. Thank you

Reply

Alex Marmalade
22:05 Apr 13, 2025

Hi Bruce,

Thank you for those simple, heartfelt words! 😊 Sometimes the most straightforward feedback carries the most genuine appreciation.

I'm touched that the story resonated with you. Jack and Ruby's journey was a special one to explore - those small, meaningful connections that gradually build into something transformative.

I appreciate you taking the time to read and share your thoughts! ✨

Reply

Stevie Burges
10:20 Apr 10, 2025

Aw that was lovely - I almost cried in a public place!! Good story and well written. Thanks for sharing.

Reply

Alex Marmalade
22:01 Apr 10, 2025

Hi Stevie,

Thank you for that wonderful reaction! 😊 If I think too much about you almost crying in public, I might start as well!

There's something about those quiet moments of connection between Jack and Ruby that seemed to write themselves. Sometimes the characters just take over and show you where the heart of the story truly lies.

I'm deeply moved by your comment and feel honored that you shared that with me. It's encouraging to know these stories are finding good people to give them a place to stay in their hearts. ✨

Reply

Micaela Casanova
22:17 Apr 08, 2025

I really like this story, it was really well written, and I like the inclusion of a character who can't communicate the way most due.

Reply

Alex Marmalade
22:19 Apr 10, 2025

Hi Micaela,

Thank you for your thoughtful comment! 😊 I'm particularly touched that you appreciated Ruby's character.

I've always been fascinated by the different ways people communicate when conventional speech isn't an option. Ruby's silence doesn't mean she has nothing to say - quite the opposite. Sometimes those who communicate differently see things the rest of us miss.

Writing their relationship was about finding that space where two people create their own language of understanding. Jack and Ruby both struggle to be heard in their own ways, which creates this unexpected bridge between them. ✨

Thank you for taking the time to read and share your thoughts!

Reply

Rebecca Buchanan
20:36 Apr 07, 2025

awesome story of second chances

Reply

Reedsy | Default — Editors with Marker | 2024-05

Bring your publishing dreams to life

The world's best editors, designers, and marketers are on Reedsy. Come meet them.