3 am, the dead of night. My chest hurts.
The familiar sounds barely register. The gentle hum of the ceiling fan. The more intrusive knocks and pings from the refrigerator, the measured flub when another minute is counted off by the old clock. The distorted whine from an eighteen-wheeler speeding down I-74, the futile protest from a dog awakened from its sleep, an owl calling for a mate. Then all is quiet again except for the muffled thumps from the washing machine.
I am staring at several innocent looking items spread before me. The small balled-up wrapper from a Jolly Rancher. A crumpled cocktail napkin from the Brush-off Bar, the ink slightly smeared but the number still legible. A dogeared ticket stub from the multiplex out on the ring road. A comb with a few teeth missing. A handkerchief with a smear of lipstick.
I have never bought Jolly Ranchers, have never heard of the Brush-off Bar. Have not seen a movie in months and don’t wear lipstick. Part of me is sorry I decided to do a load of laundry when I couldn’t sleep. Part of me is angry at him.
Though 3 am is prime real estate for flights of fancy, I try not to jump to conclusions.
I crunch the crumpled candy wrapper. It is probable that someone offered him the candy. I flick it to the side. The old comb follows. I pick up the napkin, turn it over and over between my fingers. It’s possible that someone else visited the Brush-off, but who stuffs a used cocktail napkin in their pocket, just in case? It’s possible he lent his handkerchief to a woman who needed to blot her lipstick, but who? But why would he have gone to a movie without me?
The longer I sit there, the tighter my chest feels, the clearer the scenario forms in my head.
Work would have been draining, as usual. Gerry would have urged Peter to come and have a drink, unwind. “Don’t bring your shit home to the missus,” would have been his argument. I can picture them sitting at the bar, elbows propped on the smooth surface, the place would have been quiet that late in the afternoon. Two women might have walked in and occupied a few stools further on.
Once shoptalk had been exhausted, Gerry would have told a joke or two including the women and the bartender and whoever else was there, or the ladies might have opened the conversation. The phone number, hastily scribbled by one of the women on the damp napkin, could have been pressed in Peter’s hand before he left to come home, or maybe she left first. She might have kissed his cheek, laughing merrily at the smear of lipstick she left behind. On his way home Peter might have remembered I was out of town, visiting my mother. He could have stopped and called the number, maybe he’d cancelled the call before she answered and gone to the movie by himself. But what if she had answered …
Or.
Remembering that I was at Mom’s, he could have gone for a drink. He would have sat at the bar, nursing his beer. A woman might have already been there or walked in a little later. Peter is not the type to strike up a conversation but always willing to chat if someone approaches him. So, she would have started, he might have bought her a drink. Something sweet and sticky. Maybe they had a bite to eat. Right there at the bar? Appetizers to share, why not? She’d have scribbled her phone number on the napkin.
But I can’t fit the movie into this scenario.
Wait, I was I gone two nights, wasn’t I? Did he go to the movie one of those and to the Brush-off the other night? Did he ever call the number?
A small convoy of trucks screeches down I-74, wakening the dog. The washer has started the spin cycle. My thoughts whirl through my head.
He loves me, doesn’t he? I trust him, then why do I doubt? Has he changed or is it me? What is different about us? Yes, we’re busy with our work. No, that’s not it. We don’t touch anymore, haven’t gone anywhere, or even picked a movie together in months, or longer. We talk but don’t say anything, do we? When was the last time I told him that I love him? When was the last time I heard him say it?
I sigh and look at the items again. What am I missing? What am I looking for? I rub fist over my chest.
We met at a party. Carla had dragged me there. I had felt out of place, self-conscious, shy, I had stayed on the fringes.
“Wanna dance?” He hadn’t looked at me, not really. His eyes had skirted over my face and looked away. “Okay.” The next song was a slow dance. He had held me carefully, as if I were breakable.
Before the week was out, he had come to the bookstore where I worked. Carla told me he had asked many people before he asked her.
“Hi, remember me?” We were both shy, awkward, introverted. Yet we were married within the year. That was seven years ago. Is he bored with me? What can I do? What should I do? I’ve never flirted, don’t know how to be coy or cute. I don’t know how to tell him that I feel insecure. That I miss him.
The washer lets me know that the spin cycle is finished. In the basement I transfers the wet clothes to the dryer. I have a few hours before Peter wakes up. A few hours to decide whether I will ask him which movie he saw last week.
When I reach the top of the stairs, I see Peter, sleep tousled, drool caked at the corners of his mouth, pj pants riding low on his hips, staring at the coffee table.
“Woke up. You weren’t there.” His voice is groggy. “What’s this?” He nods toward the table.
“Found it in your pants pocket.” I can’t make myself look at him. Don’t want to see guilt in his eyes.
“Oh, babe. Ger and I went to the Brush-off for a drink, that night you went to see mom. This is his new cell number. His two-year-old tried to flush his other one down the toilet.” His hand is rubbing my back.
He picks up the movie stub. “Afterwards I went to see that horror flick, the one you said you didn’t want to see.”
He points to the hanky. “That’s raspberry jam. Jo in dispatch brought doughnuts on Thursday.” He chuckles. “I had jam dribbling down my chin, apparently.” His hand rests lightly on my shoulder.
“I thought …” My throat is tight.
He waits patiently for me to finish my thought.
“… It’s been so long since we, you know … And we don’t talk anymore, I thought …” I shrug.
Peter sighs, his hand slides down my arm, his fingers lace through mine. We stare at the innocent items on the table.
“I love you, Pat. I don’t say it all the time, but don’t ever doubt that, okay? Remember when we met?”
I look at him and nod. “You were all I saw. You’re still all I see. Okay?”
I finally find what I had been looking for all night. My breath, inhale, exhale.
I tug on Peter’s hand. “Let’s go to bed.”
You must sign up or log in to submit a comment.
38 comments
Loved it. Very subtle!
Reply
Thanks, Diana. Since my forte is not in the subtle realm, your comment feels extra good. :-)
Reply
Finally catching up. Yes this is ...relatable.......... The 3am overthinking... or the overthinking in general... the dreaming up of the scenarios.......the insecurity..... in my case....when i came across things like this....the suspicions were sadly real. the explanations were also convincing and believable. i hope Gerry is being honest! Great stuff Trudy, this gets right to the heart of a very real, very regular situation and set of circumstances.
Reply
Thanks, Derrick (you should have seen what AI thought about it, LOL)
Reply
I enjoyed the sort of 'ping-pong match' being played in your main character's mind. I think a good number of us have had this heart-stopping moment in our lives where a partner may inject a feeling of doubt, causing us to spiral without clarity.
Reply
Thanks, B. And the middle of the night is the best, or worst time to do that. :-)
Reply
Towards the middle, I was almost ready to give up, as the overthinking dragged a bit too much, for my liking. But then again, I would have awakened him and set up a fight right then, at 3am, so it is just me :)
Reply
LOL. We are all different. That's half the fun. Thanks, Kashira.
Reply
And so the spin cycle ends. The 3am whirl of the mind. Enjoyed.
Reply
Thanks, Carol. Glad you liked it. The witching hour might not be the best time to empty pockets. :-)
Reply
What a beautifully intimate and relatable piece! The late-night anxiety and overthinking are captured so perfectly, creating a vulnerable and realistic moment. The gradual build-up of tension, as the small, seemingly insignificant items are pieced together, is so well done. The conclusion, with Peter’s simple yet reassuring explanations, is both touching and satisfying. It’s a wonderful reminder of how easy it is for doubt to creep in when communication fades. Absolutely stunning work!
Reply
Thank you so much, Anna. I'm thrilled you liked it. And yes, the middle of the night should be used for sleeping, not jumping to conclusions (unless you work 3rd shift, of course. :-)
Reply
Aw, I loved this. As a chronic over-thinker, I relate so much to this narrator lol
Reply
:-) Totally got you! Thank you, LC
Reply
An evocative dtory. You set the scene vividly. I like that it turnes out well but is she kidding herself? I await the sequel :-)
Reply
I so love an optimist. :-) Thank you, Jim,
Reply
Aw. So happy her imagined scenarios weren't true. In life it pays to listen to the reasonable explanations. Not as a naive way to blindly accept the innocent excuses. I believe if someone is actually telling porkies there are telltale signs. She looks at him and I believe he looked back (Innocent). By the time the hanky is washed the jam will wash away. Lipstick is harder to remove. Time will tell. I believe he's innocent. All those surrounding nighttime noises. So realistic.
Reply
Thanks, Kaitlyn. It's hard not to jump to conclusions in the middle of the night, is it? And yes, I've been up and about at 3am, more times than I'd care to, and that's it sounds like. :-)
Reply
Nice Trudy, total thumbs up with a smooth ending and a very nice ride. thanks for sharing I am sending it on!
Reply
Oh, bless you, Dena. You just made my day. (won't sleep for the rest of the week.) :-) :-):-)
Reply
Ah, so beautiful love story 🥰
Reply
Gracias, :-) It doesn't always take flower words, does it?
Reply
Right... it just seemed real; I liked it a lot.
Reply
As the mind wanders...I'm so glad it turned out well for the happy couple! You are a master at building up suspense and having the reader along for the journey. Well done.
Reply
Aww, thank you, Linda. It was one of those things that grew out of a sleepless night. I'm glad you enjoyed it.
Reply
The way you capture 3am thought processes in the writing style here is fantastic, added so much voice and authenticity
Reply
Thank you, Martha. It's amazing where your thoughts go at 3am. (which is when this was written) :-) I'm glad you liked it. Thanks for reading.
Reply
I usually write horror stories in the middle of the night. Nice work
Reply
LOL Sometimes doing the laundry is a horror story. Thanks, Darvico
Reply
Oh, boy! I've been there. Wondered, imagined, on the odd occasion fantasized. We're better off not doing the laundry then, are we?
Reply
No. LOL It's better to sleep. If only
Reply
Great to see a happy ending, loved the different imagined scenarios!
Reply
Thanks, James! The middle of the night is NOT the time to second guess where we are. I'm glad you like it.
Reply
As usual, beautifully descriptive, Trudy. That build up to what had been missing was so well-established too. Lovely work !
Reply
Thank you, Alexis, it was a long night. LOL Was I too obvious in the build-up?
Reply
Outstanding descriptions of the sensory details and setting made it so I could feel, hear, and see what the main character experienced and thought. The inner narrative of the main character was riveting. We readers can relate to times we have considered puzzling evidence about something and wondered what it meant. Then we find out our guesses were way off. So much better to go to the source and get the truth. Expertly done story with skillful writing style. Glad I got to read this!
Reply
Thank you so much, Kristi. Your thoughtful feedback makes my day. :-) The middle of the night is always a tricky time to try and puzzle out a problem.
Reply
<removed by user>
Reply